The Twins Can't Keep Platooning Austin Martin... Can They?

[Sam Caulder]

Image courtesy of © Matt Blewett-Imagn Images

So far in 2026, Austin Martin has mostly been used as a true platoon option. He's started 14 of the team's first 22 games, but that's because the Twins have faced left-handed starters 13 times. Martin has only gotten the nod once in nine games against righties, and he's not in the lineup Tuesday against Mets righthander Nolan McLean.

Even with that limited role, you could easily argue Martin has been the Twins’ best hitter. At a certain point, when the production looks like this, it’s fair to start questioning whether that platoon-focused role still fits the player.

Entering Tuesday night, Martin is hitting .311 with a .484 on-base percentage, both of which lead the team. More importantly, he hasn’t just been quietly productive. He’s come through in big spots, consistently putting together quality at-bats when the lineup has needed it most. For a player who’s largely been penciled in based on matchups, he’s been far more impactful than that role would suggest.

Obviously, the huge caveat must be stated. Martin has had the platoon advantage in 45 of his 62 plate appearances, pushing 73%. That's a ratio more typical of a lefty batter being shielded from southpaws than of a righty; everyday right-handed batters enjoy the platoon edge more like 28% of the time. So far, though, Martin has held his own just fine when he's encountered righties, too. Is it time to let him prove himself against them in more playing time?

For his career, Martin is a .257 hitter against righties. On the surface, that number might not jump off the page. But when you zoom out and look at his full offensive profile, it becomes a lot more valuable than it initially appears. His career on-base percentage against right-handers sits at .343, driven largely by an advanced approach and a willingness to take pitches.

That approach has been on full display so far this season. Martin leads the Twins with 14 walks, and it’s not the result of a lucky stretch or a handful of passive at-bats. He’s been one of the most disciplined hitters in the league to start the year. His chase rate, whiff rate, and walk rate all sit in the 95th percentile or higher among major-league hitters, and his zone contact rate is up at 94%. That, too, is driven by having the platoon advantage most of the time. It's a lot easier to make good swing decisions when you can pick up the ball sooner, which is one of the crucial advantages for a batter facing an opposite-handed pitcher. Facing more righties would put more pressure on that approach, and with breaking balls moving away from him much more often (the other key to the platoon dynamic), his contact rate would surely fall, too.

Up to this point, his role has been pretty clearly defined. He’s been splitting time in left field with Trevor Larnach, with the decision largely dictated by the opposing starting pitcher. If it’s a right-hander on the mound, Larnach gets the nod. If it’s a lefty, Martin’s in the lineup. But what if that doesn’t need to be an either-or situation? There’s a case to be made that both bats should be in the lineup on a daily basis.

Coming into the season, Forest Lake native Matt Wallner was expected to handle right field on an everyday basis. His power is real, and when he’s right, it adds a different dimension to the lineup. But through the early part of 2026, it’s getting increasingly difficult to argue that he’s earned that role.

The swing-and-miss issues have been extreme. Wallner currently sits near the bottom of the league in both whiff rate and strikeout rate. He’s swinging through just under half of the pitches he offers at, and striking out in 42% of his plate appearances. That’s incredibly difficult to carry in a regular role. It, too, is colored by the distortion of the early season, because a whopping 38 of Wallner's 81 plate appearances have come against lefties. His track record is checkered enough, though, that the cold start still mutes any optimism about him.

Defensively, Wallner has been ghastly. He's slow, he takes bad routes, and he did this.

Taking Wallner out of the lineup more often and putting either Larnach or Martin in right field (with the other in left) would improve the team's defense, for certain, and it might be the best way to optimize their run production, too.

The Twins are in the middle of a four-game losing streak and about to start a week-long road trip. This is the kind of moment where small adjustments can make a real difference, and the lineup feels like an obvious place to start. Martin has shown that he deserves more than a platoon role. Wallner, at least for the time being, looks like someone in need of a reset.

That doesn’t mean Martin is going to step in and start launching balls into the seats every night; that’s not his game. What he will do is give the Twins competitive at-bats, work counts, get on base, and play solid defense in the outfield. You can put him near the top of the order and let him set the table, somewhere in the middle, or even drop him into the nine spot and essentially create a second leadoff hitter. But regardless, he lengthens the lineup and will challenge opposing pitchers.

At a certain point, roles have to adjust to production. Right now, Martin's production is making a pretty clear case. The platoon weirdness of this March and April muddies our evaluations, but to the extent that one is possible, it seems like Larnach and Martin should get more playing time, at Wallner's expense.

View full article

[thelanges5]

Probably shouldn’t platoon him, but he is not starting tonight against a righty.

[stringer bell]

I've been beating this drum for a while. The Twins need to know if Martin is part of their core or if he's a short-side platoon player. His offense has been great, his defense is improved and he's a fast runner. The speed hasn't translated into value on the bases or stolen bases. Part of that is stealing bases against left handers is a different game. I don't like Bell playing first that much, but with Bell at first and Larnach the DH, there is room against right handers for Martin.

[karcherd]

The argument isn't should he be playing over Wallner or Larnach,  It is Clemens that is keeping him on the bench.  It is hard to argue to keep Wallner in the lineup but there are enough AB's for Wallner, Martin, Larnach and ERod between the corner OF spots and DH.  A good manager could rotate them thru those spots and they all could play 4 to 5 times a week.  Yes it means Bell at 1B but that is what he was signed for.  And this would also mean no Outman.  But this team and I do not believe it is all Shelton's decision is fixated on matchups at the expense of putting your best team on the field.

[Doctor Gast]

I don't think putting Larnach in the OF because of defense or Martin in RF doesn't flies. 

With Martin against RHPs, he'll still get on base & his speed, will vastly improve his stolen base %,

[DJL44]

Martin should be in every day for his defense if nothing else. A plus Walk rate tends to narrow a platoon split.

[PDX Twin]

The best reason to let him play against right-handed pitchers is that it will get Wallner out of the lineup. The current version of Wallner is a black hole in the lineup and a disaster in right field.

[AlwaysinModeration]

Minor quibble, the Twins aren’t in the middle of a four-game losing streak.  They were at the tail end of a four-game losing streak, and now they are at the start of a winning streak of undetermined length.

[JD-TWINS]

1 hour ago, DJL44 said:

Martin should be in every day for his defense if nothing else. A plus Walk rate tends to narrow a platoon split.

Martin has 14 Walks & Larnach has 13 Walks

[JD-TWINS]

Martin .484 OBP ….. Larnach .468 OBP

Martin’s splits are almost identical v. LH or RH pitching ………. should figure out a way to get him in the starting line-up 80% of the time and see how that works over the next month.

Larnach’s splits are not advantageous (never have been), he should continue to be platooned v. RH pitching in Left - Right - DH.

The number of RH pitchers Team faces will steeply rise ……. there are 70-75% RH pitchers - starters v. Twins to date have been an INORDINATE amount of lefties.

Bell at 1B 60% of the time - Caratini at 1B 20% of the time …………this leaves a spot for Larnach to DH a bunch v. RH starters ……..allowing Martin to be more of a fixture in LF.

[RpR]

They can and they will unless some one gets hurt.

[soyouresayingtheresachance]

Martin should be starting in LF. Period. Buck in Center. Call up Eman from AAA to start in right, he can cover center on Bucks off days. Push Wallner to 5th outfielder/ occasional DH. 

[LA Vikes Fan]

Agreed. Martin should be playing at least 5 days a week. That may mean Bell has to play 1B, or Wallner or Clemons sits. So what? Play your best 9 regularly. Martin is easily one of our best 9, probably one of our best 5.

[dxpavelka]

As far as Martin goes, if it ain't broke, don't break it.  As far as Larnach / Wallner go, every plate appearance they get is one that Rodgriguez / Jenkins / Gonzalez don't get.  Which set of guys is going to lead you back to contention, the one that hasn't or the one that hasn't, YET?

 

[Bangkok Twins Fan]

When a batter like Martin is leading the team in both batting average and OBP it seems like you would want him in the lineup every single day, either in left field or as DH in a pinch. As JD-TWINS noted, his Lefty/Righty splits are about equal this season. Let the kid play more. 

 

 

[TJSweens]

10 hours ago, JD-TWINS said:

Martin has 14 Walks & Larnach has 13 Walks

And Wallner has 7 walks.

Martin Larnach have 18 combined strike outs. Wallner has 35. See where I'm going with this?

[nicksaviking]

I really can't stand the constant platooning. The Twins best lineups through history are the ones you could fairly accurately predict before the lineup cards were released. And honestly, watching my team was more fun then too.

The Twins think they've found a hack for putting the most competitive roster on the field, but they haven't. They found a hack for putting the most thrifty roster on the field. We don't need a player who has a .800 OPS, we just need two players who can put up a .750 OPS against each handed pitcher. Such an inefficient use of limited roster space.

Your best team is a lineup where seven or eight guys play EVERYDAY and against EVERY PITCHER and saving your bench players for late game substitutions and the occasional rest days.

[Peter Gravett]

One thing from Martin's minor league days is his willingness to take an HBP. The guy will do anything to get on base.

[Road trip]

Martin has had an unexpectedly good start, which brings him into the everyday player conversation.  But it's just a good 20 game stretch at this point.  His defense looks better, I guess, but he's probably at best an average outfielder because his arm is no bueno, and his routes are still an adventure at times.

Should he get some starts against right-handers?  Yes, I think so, if for no other reason than he will get mighty rusty soon as the tsunami of left-handed starting pitchers will inevitably end (it has to, right?).  Mixing him in a bit more while sitting Clemens/Larnach/Wallner is fine but odds are all three of those guys are going to be better hitters over the course of the season against right handers (maybe not Clemens... but the Twins seem to have no faith in Bell at 1B).

[jmlease1]

43 minutes ago, nicksaviking said:

I really can't stand the constant platooning. The Twins best lineups through history are the ones you could fairly accurately predict before the lineup cards were released. And honestly, watching my team was more fun then too.

The Twins think they've found a hack for putting the most competitive roster on the field, but they haven't. They found a hack for putting the most thrifty roster on the field. We don't need a player who has a .800 OPS, we just need two players who can put up a .750 OPS against each handed pitcher. Such an inefficient use of limited roster space.

Your best team is a lineup where seven or eight guys play EVERYDAY and against EVERY PITCHER and saving your bench players for late game substitutions and the occasional rest days.

Well, teams like the '91 Twins didn't have a lot of LH bats and if you think the Twins back then didn't platoon guys then I suggest you examine Mike Pagliarulo's splits from that season. Hrbek was the only LH bat to start basically every day, and he hit LHP pretty well over his career. late 2000's Twins had a lot more LH bats, but guys like Mauer & Morneau, while significantly worse against LHP could still handle it, and even someone like Span wasn't getting torched like our LH bats are right now. '87 Twins didn't have many LH bats, much like '91. It's a lot easier to just write in the same names every day when you're starting off with a bunch of righties. Bomba Squad? Well, that's the season Rosario was actually good against LH pitchers and so was Kepler. Outliers the both of them. How well did it work the rest of the time running Kepler out against LHP (hint: not so good).

I think the issue is less about increased playing time for Austin Martin and more about having more and better RH bats on the roster period. It's about having more good hitters on the roster, and fewer guys with serious limitations. Caratini has pretty neutral splits, but he's only a "good for a catcher" hitter. Bell has fairly neutral splits and rightly should play every day...but is a poor defender at 1B. Clemens, Larnach, and Wallner all really struggle against LHP and it's not likely to change. 

If you want to give more ABs to Martin over Wallner, who is definitely struggling at the plate period, you certainly can, I guess?

[Major League Ready]

17 hours ago, JD-TWINS said:

Martin .484 OBP ….. Larnach .468 OBP

Martin’s splits are almost identical v. LH or RH pitching ………. should figure out a way to get him in the starting line-up 80% of the time and see how that works over the next month.

Larnach’s splits are not advantageous (never have been), he should continue to be platooned v. RH pitching in Left - Right - DH.

The number of RH pitchers Team faces will steeply rise ……. there are 70-75% RH pitchers - starters v. Twins to date have been an INORDINATE amount of lefties.

Bell at 1B 60% of the time - Caratini at 1B 20% of the time …………this leaves a spot for Larnach to DH a bunch v. RH starters ……..allowing Martin to be more of a fixture in LF.

Martin's career OPS against LHP is 801, and .683 against RHP.  Are you looking at 2026 where he has only had 17 ABs against RHP?  I like Martin well enough and would be fine with giving him more opportunity in the short-term against RHP.  However, I sure hope Rodriguez and Jenkins perform significantly better than Martin against RHP.  Martin profiles as the ideal 4th OFer.

[nicksaviking]

2 hours ago, jmlease1 said:

Well, teams like the '91 Twins didn't have a lot of LH bats and if you think the Twins back then didn't platoon guys then I suggest you examine Mike Pagliarulo's splits from that season. Hrbek was the only LH bat to start basically every day, and he hit LHP pretty well over his career. late 2000's Twins had a lot more LH bats, but guys like Mauer & Morneau, while significantly worse against LHP could still handle it, and even someone like Span wasn't getting torched like our LH bats are right now. '87 Twins didn't have many LH bats, much like '91. It's a lot easier to just write in the same names every day when you're starting off with a bunch of righties. Bomba Squad? Well, that's the season Rosario was actually good against LH pitchers and so was Kepler. Outliers the both of them. How well did it work the rest of the time running Kepler out against LHP (hint: not so good).

I think the issue is less about increased playing time for Austin Martin and more about having more and better RH bats on the roster period. It's about having more good hitters on the roster, and fewer guys with serious limitations. Caratini has pretty neutral splits, but he's only a "good for a catcher" hitter. Bell has fairly neutral splits and rightly should play every day...but is a poor defender at 1B. Clemens, Larnach, and Wallner all really struggle against LHP and it's not likely to change. 

If you want to give more ABs to Martin over Wallner, who is definitely struggling at the plate period, you certainly can, I guess?

Pags and Leius were the only platoon players in 1991. Gardenhire's teams typically had a set lineup outside of one of the corner outfield positions. Same with Molitor and even the same with the Bomba Squad in Baldelli's first season. Then Covid and the utter decimation of the long-ball lineup and this organization completely changed course. And not for the better.

And Kepler absolutely COULD NOT hit left handed pitching his first three years. What changed? Almost certainly it was seeing all of that left handed pitching early in his career. The left handed hitters under Baldelli never got the opportunities Kepler got under Molitor. 

I'm advocating for the Twins to either let the young hitters get full opportunity against same handed pitching, or trade them and give someone else that opportunity. I don't care if it's Wallner or Martin (but, obviously Martin). Better yet, call up Emanuel Rodriguez. Or of course in the offseason, go for option B and actually pay good free agents. But this franchise isn't winning lately and it's because they are more focused on piecing together 'matchups' instead of putting together a roster of well rounded players. It's inefficient, it's clearly ineffective and most of all, it's boring as hell. 

[jmlease1]

5 minutes ago, nicksaviking said:

And Kepler absolutely COULD NOT hit left handed pitching his first three years. What changed? Almost certainly it was seeing all of that left handed pitching early in his career. The left handed hitters under Baldelli never got the opportunities Kepler got under Molitor. 

Well, Kepler was also bad at hitting LHP in 2020 & 2021, and only ok (by the standards of a lefty, really) in 2022 or 2025. He was good against LHP in 2018, 2019, 2023, and 2024...but was also still facing relatively small numbers.

[DJL44]

4 minutes ago, jmlease1 said:

Well, Kepler was also bad at hitting LHP in 2020 & 2021, and only ok (by the standards of a lefty, really) in 2022 or 2025. He was good against LHP in 2018, 2019, 2023, and 2024...but was also still facing relatively small numbers.

Kepler got the opportunity to play every day because his glove helped him add value even when there was a lefty starter on the mound.

[Patzky]

3 hours ago, Road trip said:

Martin has had an unexpectedly good start, which brings him into the everyday player conversation.  But it's just a good 20 game stretch at this point.  His defense looks better, I guess, but he's probably at best an average outfielder because his arm is no bueno, and his routes are still an adventure at times.

Should he get some starts against right-handers?  Yes, I think so, if for no other reason than he will get mighty rusty soon as the tsunami of left-handed starting pitchers will inevitably end (it has to, right?).  Mixing him in a bit more while sitting Clemens/Larnach/Wallner is fine but odds are all three of those guys are going to be better hitters over the course of the season against right handers (maybe not Clemens... but the Twins seem to have no faith in Bell at 1B).

So long as we keep playing the Rays Royals and Tigers, the lefties will keep on coming.

[Linus]

Oh they can and most likely will. Their obsession with gaining small advantages on the margins is contradictory with developing players. This is especially misguided on a club that isn’t going anywhere and needs guys to step up become good big leaguers. 

[RpR]

2 hours ago, Linus said:

Oh they can and most likely will. Their obsession with gaining small advantages on the margins is contradictory with developing players. 

Since when has MLB become AAA &1/2 ?

[Linus]

11 minutes ago, RpR said:

Since when has MLB become AAAA?

Troll on…

[RpR]

2 minutes ago, Linus said:

Troll on…

And leave such a thing just to you?

[Riverbrian]

I don't know what Shelton has planned once this run of left handed starters stabilizes. 

Right now... He might be feeding the left handed hitters to make up for the lack of playing time. 

Until it is stabilized with a run of right handed starters and Martin gets playing time against them... I will continue to fear that Martin was set up as a short side platoon and remains a short side platoon. 

Martin in a short side platoon role will develop a player that has limited value to the team. It will develop a player that will be easily booted off the roster when they decide to roster someone who they won't strip mine for parts. It will develop a player who has next to no trade value. 

I won't participate in subjective discussion on the what Austin's future ceiling or floor may or may not be. I don't know... the Twins front office doesn't know... Austin Martin doesn't know. 500 Professional AB's is still a work in progress.  

Everyone else can debate his future.

However... I will state unequivocally. There is one certain way to know for sure what he will become tomorrow.. You just strip mine him for parts today. There will be no long career for Austin Martin... it will be just the drops of juice you squeeze out of him today and then you toss him aside. 

I feel this way when they do it to young left handed hitters. It's triple when they do it to young right handed hitters. 

Screw the platoon. Go find young talent and get damn serious about their complete development. Quit sitting on them when they start to display it.

 

 

 

: