Jump to content
Twins Daily
  • Create Account

Recommended Posts

Posted

By 4:00 Minnesota time on Friday, we will find out which Twins players have been tendered a contract for the 2027 season. Nine Twins are arbitration-eligible, and there are a couple of fairly difficult decisions that may need to be made. 

Reading opinion articles at Twins Daily and other sites, there is some thought that the Twins could just non-tender infielder Royce Lewis. MLB Trade Rumors projected Lewis to receive $5.1 million in 2027, his third of four years of arbitration-eligibility. 

There is no way around it. 2026 was a very disappointing for Royce Lewis. The low point, most likely, was being optioned to St. Paul with no timeline for a comeback. In mid-May, his batting average was hovering around .160. At-bats were difficult to watch. So many check swings and lack of balance. As we know, he went to the Saints and played in 13 games. He hit .340/.417/.868 (1.285) with four doubles, eight homers and 19 RBI. He turned 27 while playing for St. Paul. A day later, he returned to the Twins and James Outman was DFAd. In 94 games after his return, he hit .245/.295/.409 (.704) with 21 doubles, 12 homers and 44 RBI. 

Overall, he played in 125 games with the Twins in 2026. He hit .227/.287/.380 (.667) with 24 doubles, 15 home runs and 16 RBI. He was worth 0.9 bWAR and 0.5 fWAR. It was hit career-high in games played. He generally was healthy most of the season. In 2025, he had hit .237/.283/.388 (.671) with 18 doubles, 13 homers and 12 stolen bases in 106 games. The 667 and .671 OPS were 15% and 14% below league average, respectively. 

Players within the 25 MLB hitters just ahead and 25 immediately following Lewis's .667 OPS in 2026 (minimum 350 PA) include Dansby Swanson (.694), Christian Yelich (.692), Matt Chapman (.692), Jose Ramirez (.688), Vlad Guerrero (.687), Xander Bogaerts (.676), Trea Turner (.675), Cal Raleigh (.664), Salvador Perez (.656), Austin Riley (.654), Dalton Varsho (.637), and Jarren Duran (.627). This group includes a few veterans who may be approaching the end of their career. Several of these players had injuries. Researchers will be researching for years what happened to Guerrero in 2026. But another thing you'll notice is that most of these guys still provide strong defense at their respective positions. Lewis certainly wouldn't qualify as Gold Glove caliber and moved from third base to first base when he returned from the minor leagues.  

So yes, I can see that it was disappointing season. I know I could go more and add flames to the fire, but I'm not going to do that. Many already have written such things. When it comes to the stats, I won't put up too much of an argument. When people start throwing out personal issues they may have, or talk about him being hurt, or getting upset at quotes that he has made, then I'll roll my eyes and disagree. 

Riding with Royce 

So yeah, I'm going another direction than most with Royce Lewis. I'm betting on Lewis by offering a long-term contract with options. Think about what a long-term deal with Lewis would have looked like if he had signed something after his 2023 season when he hit .309 (.921) with 15 homers and 52 RBI in 58 games. He would have received a deal of at least eight years and probably $80-100 million. 

This long-term deal idea will be much smaller than that. It will consider his struggles the last couple of years, but it also acknowledges his talent and upside and power potential that we do see from time to time throughout the season. It is a fairly short deal, with a reasonable base salary and some incentives similar to those included in Byron Buxton's contract signed in November 2021, just weeks before the last owners' lockout. (Reminder: Buxton signed a seven-year, $100 million contract in which he got $9 million for his final arbitration season and then six years with a base salary of $15 million. It then included incentives that were based on playing time (plate appearances) and performance MVP voting.) 

Here is what my offer looks like: 
Primary Offer
Signing Bonus: $1 million
2027 (age 28): $5 million 
2028 (age 29): $7.5 million
2029 (age 30): $7.5 million. 
Summary: The offer begins as a three-year, $22 million deal with a $1 million buyout (with a mutual option).

Twins Club Option 
Option A: If the Twins Decline their Option: Buyout: $1 million.
Option B: If the Twins Accept their Option: 
2030 (age 31): $15 million
2031 (age 32): $15 million
Summary: After the three seasons, the Twins can choose to pick up a two-year, $30 million option. If things don't go as well, the Twins can decline the two-year option and pay Lewis a $1 million buyout. Along with getting the $1 million buyout, Lewis will have an option to stay with the Twins. 

Player Option 
If the Twins Decline their Option: Lewis receives the $1 million Buyout and has an option of his own.
Option A: Lewis accepts the one-year
2030 (age 31): $5 million 
Summary: Lewis may be an All Star in 2028 and 2029, but the Twins could still decline the two-year option for 2030 and 2031 and give Lewis the $1 million buyout. Instead of becoming a free agent coming off those two All Star seasons, Lewis could be so happy to have had all this time with the Twins and love the fans and his teammates so much that he wants to stay for one year at $8 million. OK, that scenario may not play out. More likely, 

The Incentives
Plate Appearances: $250,000 for reaching 500, 525, 550, 575, 600, and 625 plate appearances. (annual maximum = $1.5 million)         

Achievements: $4 million for MVP, $3.5 million for second in MVP voting, $3.0 million for third, $2.5 million for fourth, $2.5 million for fifth, and $1.5 million. Obviously, he could only get one of those bonuses per year. In addition, he would earn $1 million for each Silver Slugger and Gold Glove award he wins.)

You will notice these are the same incentives found in Byron Buxton's contract, though generally about half the dollar amount. 

The Contract Summary

Guaranteed: 3 years, $21 million.
Maximum 2027-2029 incentives: up to $7.5 million per year. 
Guaranteed 2027-2029 maximum of 3 years, $43.5 million. 

If Twins exercise the Club option, he would make $29 million for 2030 and 2031. plus, up to $7.5 million per year in incentives. 
Five year guaranteed/option salary total: $50 million before incentives.

If Twins decline option, the Twins would pay him a $1 million buyout. Lewis would have the ability to choose a one year, $8 million deal for 2030. In that scenario, he would make four years and $30 million (assuming that he'd accept the one-year deal and didn't earn much in incentives). 

Why Lewis and Even Boras Might Consider This Deal? 

Both are smart, logical thinkers who have to know that the luster and shine of his draft and prospect status have faded. They can't look at his stats the last three seasons and think of a 10-figure contract. He's already turned 27, so it's likely that a contract for eight of more years is very unlikely. With two seasons of arbitration remaining, is it more likely that he breaks out, or what might the odds be that two years from now, he's looking at minor-league offers with spring training invites? Lewis and Boras can say, MLB Trade Rumors projects you at $5.1 million. Right now, that's the only guaranteed money that you have (assuming the Twins tender the deal). With my proposal idea (or structure), there is $21 million in guaranteed money with incentives that can nearly double that number and an option that if picked up would then guarantee another $30 million and still have those same incentives. I might argue that it'd be silly if Lewis and Boras didn't strongly consider this type of deal. Even the $5 million isn't guaranteed if time is missed due to the impending owners' lockout. 

Why Lewis and Boras Might Not Consider This Deal?

You don't hire Scott Boras as an agent if you don't want to maximize your potential earnings. Maximizing the compensation would mean giving Lewis the chance to earn a bunch more money in his fourth and final arbitration-eligible offseason in a year. he can do that by putting up numbers in 2027. Maybe he does enough to warrant $10 million in 2028, and then he has another huge season in 2028 and becomes a 29-year-old free agent coming off of two strong years. That could make him $50-80 million, or at least something similar to what Ryan Jeffers could have received in free agency without the Qualifying Offer albatross. Or the Twins could offer that Qualifying Offer to Lewis. By then it's $25 million for that year. Now he will have made $40 million over these same three years and then can enter free agency as a 30-year-old. Frankly, it is up to Royce Lewis. He has to find a way to adjust at the plate and become more consistent. He can't have another sub-.300 OBP or sub .700 OPS. He has to find a defensive position that works for him. Maybe that's second base. I'd personally just put him at first base and play him every day that he can. I'd have Joe Mauer and Justin Morneau work with him all spring training and maybe even in-season.. 

Why the Twins Would Consider Making This Deal?

First, they would have some cost certainty. Second, this organization made him the #1 overall pick a decade ago. They've invested a lot of time and money to him, beyond his original signing bonus. If they are hanging on to any belief in what Lewis can be, post ACL surgeries, then this type of minimal short-term extension will show that to Lewis. As for the incentives, like with Buxton, if Lewis reaches those incentives they will be thrilled to pay the bonus dollars. If you believe that 1.0 WAR is worth $8-10 million. According to FanGraphs, Lewis has been "worth" $21.4 million over the past three seasons when he accumulated a total of 2.6 fWAR. If he's just worth what FanGraphs says he's been worth the last three seasons over the next three seasons, it will be disappointing. If he is the 2.3 fWAR player that he was in about a half a season in 2023, he'd justify the contract with one season. That's not unrealistic.  

Why the Twins Might Not Consider Making This Deal? 

I mean, they have a pretty solid analytics department that can look at the stats. The stats scream "Go year-to-year" at this point. Trading him now isn't ideal as you'd be trading so low. 


What do you think? First, should the Twins tender Lewis a 2027 contract this afternoon? Should they non-tender him? Should they tender him a contract in hopes of getting a suitable return for him in a trade? Or do they talk to him, trust him, work with him and believe in him long term?


Other Twins who are Arbitration-Eligible

Will the Twins tender 2027 contracts to the following arbitration-eligible Twins players? Here they are shown with their projected 2027 contracts. I'll throw my two cents in on each player. 

Joe Ryan ($9.6 million): Easy choice. Pick it up. Also, don't be afraid to see just how much trade value he might have. this offseason, with doubts about the 2027 season
Bailey Ober ($6.9 million): He's been so solid, and such a team guy since he's been in the big leagues. Utmost respect for him doing as much as he has done while struggling to hit 90 the last couple of years. Explore trades all day, right to the last month. But definitely a non-tender candidate. 
Dean Kremer ($6.5 Million): I miss Jhomardo Reyes, but I was wrong about Kremer. He came over from Baltimore and pitched quite well most of his Twins starts. Sits more around 92-94 and seems like a thinking person's pitcher. 
Trevor Larnach ($6.3 million): Was putting up a very solid 2026 season until wrist injuries shut him down and he recently had surgery. Solid player, but the reality is it's a number game, and with the likes of Alan Roden, Walker Jenkins, Emmanuel Rodriguez, Hendry Mendez, the Twins have good left-handed outfield options. They also have Byron Buxton, Austin Martin, Luke Keaschall and Gabriel Gonzalez. Look to trade all day, but is a non-tender is possible.
Cole Sands ($1.3 million): Tremendous out of the Twins bullpen in 2025 .2026 was filled with injuries for Sands. More difficult decision, especially as it appears a few starters may be pushed to the bullpen. 
Tommy Nance ($1.2 million): came to the Twins ahead of the 2026 trade deadline. Easy tender. 
 

Image courtesy of Jesse Johnson-Imagn Images via Reuters Connect

View full article

Posted

Below this paragraph is what I wrote on a board related to Lewis recently. I too have changed my mind. Call it a crappy hunch, but I could see Lewis being somewhat humbled by his 2026 campaign and adopting some different approaches.

Lewis is on a minimal contract. He wasn't really good at third base but he was ok. He managed to pick up first base better than expected and was particularly good at scooping poor throws even as he struggled with the nuances of where to line up on relays or occasionally wandering too far off the bag on grounders to the second baseman. At the dish, Lewis has worn out his welcome with many because of his addiction to the low outside pitches, which he obstinately attempts to pull. The other side of the coin is that Lewis is not someone with high K rates, he can run a little bit, and the ball still comes off his bat in a sweet fashion. In various iterations of a roster, often I have dumped Lewis from the team. That has changed. 

I'm now more inclined to hold him unless he returns real value. The only way Lewis returns value is if he is packaged with another player like Ryan. I don't see a good trade for Ryan so this leaves Royce at 1B if the Twins can bring in Brandon Lowe or 2B if the Twins choose to sign Ty France. Lewis will be a better defender than Clemens after he gets the repetitions he needs to learn the position because he is more athletic.

While I never previously bought into the hype for Royce Lewis because I saw only an undisciplined player, I now see a rehabbing guy who may come into 2027 with his legs back to what can be his 100% health going forward. I also think he will finally adopt the approaches his coaches have brought to him about punishing those middle and middle high outside pitches to right field while laying off the outside worm borers. It could happen but I could be stone cold wrong too.

Posted

All very interesting.  But the key question remains: where does Lewis play?

He’s clearly not a good enough hitter to be the starting 1B or 2B on a team that has emphatically announced through its actions that they intend to compete vigorously in ‘27.  To slot Lewis in either of those positions hoping for some sort of miraculous turnaround would be self defeating.

Moreover, what particular skill set does Lewis have that would warrant keeping him as a utility player, particularly under the contract terms suggested?  Speed, defensive ace, bat - to - ball skills, etc.? He’s not a standout in any area per se.

And, to be honest, is he really a huge culture/glue guy?   Hmmm.

The entire #1 pick rationale is water under the bridge as well.  Besides, the effort to justify that decision was has been made under a different regime and era. There’s a new sheriff and vibe in town now.

With no place to play and new management in place, Lewis should welcome the opportunity for a new start elsewhere as opposed to just hanging on here struggling for innings with the failed top pick mantle hanging over his head.

Posted

I've seen enough. He's a #1 overall pick who has talent but cannot get his head around MLB pitching. He's had more than enough time to do so. I guess we could hang onto him in a backup role, but I definitely wouldn't be throwing a long term contract at him.

Posted

You know, as you lay it out, I don't actually mind it too much. It's definitely a team-friendly deal no matter which way you spin it/slice it. I mean, worst we're out is about $23million over 3 years, which isn't all that bad considering he'd still be bargain pricing. It isn't too much different than we're paying him (or expected to pay him) going forward. 

And the best part is that if he doesn't pan out, I'm sure there is a team that needs a body or a backup 1B/2B/3B/Util guy and Lewis would be a decent one of those. He isn't horrible on defense regardless of where you put him, he is backup material bat, and he has a contagious smile in the clubhouse. 

Posted

Seth's article is honestly just detached from reality, I'm not sure Boras himself would be so aggressively positive about a guy half a step from permanently falling out of the Bigs. 

Lewis' chase, swing and miss issues are severe and there is no indication of progress or any other reason to think he can significantly improve in that regard. 

As a first baseman, the offensive baseline is high, and Lewis would need dramatic improvement just to be average -- to be better than that is an incredible reach. 

The Twins can't be run based on sentimentality. Bringing back Lewis at all is questionable but obviously nothing like Seth's idea here is even remotely on the table. 

 

Posted

Um, no. 

If the plan with Lewis is to basically tie him with Clemens and offer a flexible platoon at either 1B or 2B, I'm OK with that. That's 9 million for what should be an effective platoon with some athleticism. 

But a multi year deal for Royce Lewis? No. That'd be deserving of an instant firing. 

Posted

It (potentially) will be interesting if they choose to shop him to see what other teams opinions are of Lewis. Is he a stubborn, head case, and malcontent or he just needs a full healthy season or change of scenery? Any potential offers for Lewis will be really interesting. 

 

Posted

I’m in. But I think you need to give Royce a single position to focus on.  Minimize the different things he has to focus on.  Contrary to past proclamation, he does do slumps so keeping it simple should help.  
 

I think he is athletic enough still to play second.   Give hIm the role in Spring Training. 

Posted

Boy, I don't know. I'd love for it to work out with Royce, but he's been a bad hitter for 2 1/2 seasons now. During that time he might put together a hot streak that lasts a few weeks (at most), but it's always cancelled out by a dreadful run where he looks unplayable. 

He was so bad last season he got demoted. Sure, he came right back up and had one of his hot stretches, but he was one of the prime examples why the Twins stumbled into oblivion down the stretch last season. How is he going to solve his issues at the plate where he's guessing at every pitch, flailing at pitches 2 feet outside the zone, and looking completely lost? Where's the evidence that he goes up to the plate with a real plan?

I think his defense at 1B could be quite good, and he was passable at 2B as well, but none of that matters if he's going to put up another 85 OPS+. Because that's just not good enough for a team with any kind of ambition, and he's not a 23 year old prospect any longer. He also doesn't have the health excuse to lean on; he was healthy in 2026 and still couldn't hit at league average. He's clearly lost some of the supreme athleticism that made him an elite prospect...and it's doubtful that ever comes back. I question whether he can survive as a hitter without it at the MLB level.

Posted

The comments here mirror what has been written about Lewis since he arrived in one way in that people have strong opinions on what Lewis is like and his worth. Previously, Lewis was a darling who had the best positive attitude and was certain to be a superstar. Hordes of comments were made about signing him to a long term lucrative contract. My how far Lewis has fallen in the eyes of some fans. 

He is still in a group of people, behind Buxton and Keaschall, in terms of speed. His defense is still reasonable and he is improving in that skill area. Lewis can be the other half of Kody Clemens too. The salary is not out of line. My main beef with Lewis is his low on base percentage. 

I'm fine with the Twins trading Lewis and will not think it a mistake if he is not tendered a contract. I would keep him until there is a better alternative already in place.

I can see why folks are opposed to a long term contract. The primary offer proposed by Seth is low by baseball standards and because Lewis initially banked a substantial signing bonus, it is hard to know if he would find that palatable. I'm year to year on Royce. He can be replaced via free agent, trade, or advancing prospects.

Posted

Lewis has not produced offensively, is not great defensively, and (by seemingly all accounts) doesn't seem to "get it". The tools are there, it just is not falling into place for whatever reason.

Guys like this are prime change-of-scenery candidates. I can easily see the Twins moving on from him and just as easily see him producing somewhere else.

IMO, I am not sure what else the Twins can do here to make him viable. Rewarding all of the wrong things with a long term deal does not seem like a great decision.

Posted

I have always respected your opinion, Seth; which confirms my hunch also on Royce Lewis. I've always been a big fan of Royce Lewis. I'm not a big fan of how the Twins have handled their young players, that plus how media like to come down on Lewis on everything he says & twists it around, which caused him to flounder & I felt for a time that Lewis was disgruntle with the whole TC experience & trading him was probably the route to go.

But recently I've felt that he really wants to stay & work hard. Because he has been injured so often, he's been out of shape; IMO, he has figured it out but ran out of gas at the end. He has a lot of talent, character & his endurance will return, therefore deserves to be offered a contract. Seth, you have emboldened me to agree with you that we even try to extend him. #1 Boras allowing Jeffers to accept an QO (maybe he'll let Lewis accept an extension). #2 he wants to stay; #3 it motivates Lewis to become better believing in Twins trust & the Twins comes out on top.

I'm afraid there'll be a lot of push back on your article because many don't have the insight that you have. But I thoroughly enjoyed it. Keep up the good work!

Posted

The definition of insanity is doing the same thing over and over and expecting different results.  

24   WAR .7  OPS .747

25   WAR .6  OPS .671

26  WAR  .9  OPS .667

Total at bats over this 3 year period is 1237.   Lewis 2nd half stats were worse than his 1st half stats in 26 so it doesn't look like Lewis was able to create long last effect of any changes he made in the minors. At least with Larnach in a heavy platoon he has an OPS average of .740.  Kyler Murray and Lewis to be feel very similar in different sports.  They both have flashes of brillance,  but doing the routine on offense is a struggle.   We try to pull everything,  meaning anything hit to the right side is hit weakly because we aren't being patient and driving hit.  When he came back he had 2 solid hits to right field.  I said maybe he is figuring it out,  this was during his hot stretch.  Some articles came out saying he should continue to pull,  and thats what he did the remainder of the year.   SO 130 times.  Show me he recognizes or the team recognizes what to change with him.  Even in this article there is no suggestion.  Its stating he could get better because you compared him to a bunch of players who played terrible last year but have historically been good players.  Other than a flash on the scene 2023 for Lewis,  we have seen squat from him in 3 years and nothing under the hood is improving.  EV is down.  OPPO is decreasing.  In 2023 at his peak he was hitting opposite field 21%. Its now down to 13.3%.  

Posted

Very interesting, Seth.  Expect it is highly unlikely to happen, but surprises seem common of late.

I have been in the tender camp for some time as I would like to see his having at least another half year to allow his potential to finally come through.  So count me on the tender side of the ledger.

Posted

I'd love to see Lewis rebound, but there just isn't evidence to expect it to be coming anymore. There are signs it could happen, and I think he has the talent to make it happen, but not everybody can get past the mental aspects of the game.

Posted
14 minutes ago, LakesideChilly said:

It's hard not to root for a guy who's always positive and smiling.

But for some reason that just strikes me as phony. Trying too hard to be Mr. Twins Community. Maybe I'm too cynical but it's just seems so self-serving and not genuine.

Posted
1 hour ago, MackMan said:

You know, as you lay it out, I don't actually mind it too much. It's definitely a team-friendly deal no matter which way you spin it/slice it. I mean, worst we're out is about $23million over 3 years, which isn't all that bad considering he'd still be bargain pricing. It isn't too much different than we're paying him (or expected to pay him) going forward. 

And the best part is that if he doesn't pan out, I'm sure there is a team that needs a body or a backup 1B/2B/3B/Util guy and Lewis would be a decent one of those. He isn't horrible on defense regardless of where you put him, he is backup material bat, and he has a contagious smile in the clubhouse. 

I agree with this sentiment, and that last comment about the clubhouse, is the real reason I think he is an important part of the team.  He is the one you see greeting other players first after a score or a great at bat.  I think he's a club house asset for sure.

 

Posted

I like this concept and appreciate the thought and detail that went into it.  If the Twins are really on a spending spree it would be malpractice to not spend some of it on smart extensions for some young players. 

I wouldn't do it with Lewis though, he doesn't have a position, has significant limitations, and there just isn't enough upside to make it worthwhile.  Culpepper, Bradley, and Jenkins would be my list for this offseason.  Jenkins would be the biggest risk given his injury history.  The other 2 I'd do in a heartbeat.

Posted

Again, the questions remains: where does Lewis play on the ‘27 Twins?

He has done nothing, zippo, to have earned the starting 1B role.  You can’t sign Jeffers and Gray and then roll Lewis out at 1B.  That makes zero sense.

Assuming we add a starting right side of the infield starter, the only reasonable solution/role for Lewis is that he is the back up utility infielder for 1B, 2B, and 3B.  Does he have the requisite skill base for $5MM to fulfill that role?  Probably, more or less.  Is that a role he would embrace?  Not sure.

But if the Twins and Lewis are ok with that role at that price, and it does not impede signing a starting 1B/2B or stud southpaw reliever, then go for it.  Hey, the team also retains the option value on a Lewis turnaround,  even if it is small.

Posted

We will know more tomorrow than we know today …

everyone loved grand slam Lewis , everyone wonders what happened to him  …

your opinion isn’t unpopular , many still awaits for some kind of potential …

Who can you blame , Lewis himself , coaching , WHO … 

Can you blame the owners for making it a business and the players losing the focus on themselves for the love of the game , can you count on 1 hand , players that really have that feeling ….

maybe right now the whole Milwaukee team does as they just won the World Series and are celebrating until the 2027 season starts 

i personally see a few things with Lewis ,  discipline at the plate at recognizing pitches , shorten that swing some , he’s not a rookie anymore , he shouldn’t be so aggressive and another is the muscle he added , how did he obtain it , did he over do it and lose his flexibility , that can happen if you add to much muscle and not the right way …

1 more season for Lewis , how about larnauch fate today , tender or non tender ???  …

 

if its a lengthy lockout I sure hope these players are smart enough to invest in themselves and go for help and a fresh voice on how to improve their talent , it wouldn’t hurt … 

DRIVELINE COMES TO MIND , there are other

Posted
1 hour ago, StiltedGopher said:

I’m in. But I think you need to give Royce a single position to focus on.  Minimize the different things he has to focus on.  Contrary to past proclamation, he does do slumps so keeping it simple should help.  
 

I think he is athletic enough still to play second.   Give hIm the role in Spring Training. 

I think the flexibility is good.  1B is fine just needs the work Clemens has actually said that he prefers 2B.  Have him focus on 1B.  

Posted

"When people start throwing out personal issues they may have, or talk about him being hurt, or getting upset at quotes that he has made, then I'll roll my eyes and disagree. "

Yes, but there's no denying he's said some pretty alarming things.  I just don't see how you can ignore some of that stuff, especially when it appears to affect his game.  Look I'm not knocking him personally on that stuff, but it's definitely an issue for him and it IS impacting his ability to hit and probably some of his decisions while fielding.   

All that said, why on earth would the Twins sign him to a long-term deal?  Hope that giving him millions of dollars will transform him into a passable 1st baseman?  If anything it will reward his production so far and to me that's insane logic.  Fans here are always talking about how we need to DFA this player or DFA that player because their WAR is not good, etc.  Why does Lewis get the royal treatment?  Is it simply because he's a bust #1 pick, or because it's personal, and some fans and the writer have latched onto him emotionally (honest question)?  We've all seen the results the last 3 season, he's atrocious, and I'd argue his defense isn't that great either. Let him go, he's not a good player.

I'd MUCH RATHER roll with Cody Clemens at 1st base than Lewis.  I'm sorry, but the ridiculous strikeouts and on base percentage are brutal.  And why on earth would Zoll even consider pushing him back to 2nd base?  That seems insane considering the Twins have Marek Houston knocking on the door to take over short, and Culpepper certainly could slide over to 2nd.   

Look I'm not opposed to keeping Lewis on as a bench warmer and utility guy, if the Twins aren't quite ready to cut him loose for now, but absolutely NO LONG-TERM DEAL.  Perhaps Shelton can finally get Lewis to open his eyes and realize this is not AAA pitching he's facing anymore.  He needs to do his homework and study the tapes in between games and LEARN what opposing pitchers are likely to throw, instead of just trotting out to the batter's box every game with only a thought and a prayer, swinging away like a mad man. 

Until he dedicates himself to truly learning how to be a smarter hitter, I'm out.  He has the power but has a deplorable eye at the plate.  And I disagree that this is a Twins development issue (shifting the blame to the organization), I think it's a Royce Lewis issue.

Posted
31 minutes ago, Pykkman said:

He was demoted to AAA last year and didn’t perform when he returned. And now you wanna offer him a long-term contract? Doesn’t pass the smell test.

Lewis raked when he returned. He was hitting at an All Star level for a lot of the year, but at the end of the season, he started just flailing away. Expanded the strike zone and just took absolute hacks.

Posted
18 minutes ago, laloesch said:

...I'd MUCH RATHER roll with Cody Clemens at 1st base than Lewis.  I'm sorry, but the ridiculous strikeouts and on base percentage are brutal.  And why on earth would Zoll even consider pushing him back to 2nd base?...

Kody Clemens

Also, Clemens technically has a worse career K rate and OBP than Lewis so I think you might not be that objective there. Clemens' value comes from the power. That's all he brings to the plate at all. Just power, but at least it's something. 

Create an account or sign in to comment

You need to be a member in order to leave a comment

Create an account

Sign up for a new account in our community. It's easy!

Register a new account

Sign in

Already have an account? Sign in here.

Sign In Now
The Twins Daily Caretaker Fund
The Twins Daily Caretaker Fund

You all care about this site. The next step is caring for it. We’re asking you to caretake this site so it can remain the premier Twins community on the internet.

×
×
  • Create New...