Twins 5, White Sox 3: The Twins Experience Wins a Shocker in Chicago

[Steven Trefz]

Image courtesy of © Kamil Krzaczynski-Imagn Images

Box Score
SP: Joe Ryan 7.2 IP, 5 H, 2 ER, 0 BB, 9 K (98 pitches, 77 strikes (79%))
Home Runs: N/A
Top 3 WPA: Brooks Lee (0.29), Luke Keaschall (0.24), Kody Clemens & Taylor Rogers (0.14)

Win Probability Chart (via FanGraphs) 

On Memorial Day afternoon, the Twins discovered that the White Sox are a solid baseball team. Joe Ryan got the call to face the South Side Mashers on Tuesday, in hopes of inching his squad back toward the .500 mark, while Chicago sent young righty Sean Burke out to keep the Twinkies in their third place.

PItchers Dominate, but Twins Break Through
The first three innings started where Monday night's game left off, with pitchers dominating the game and no hits to be found. Burke had failed to finish five full innings in each of his last three starts, so his success appeared to be fool's gold. In the top of the fourth, the Twins mined two runs on three straight hits. First, Trevor Larnach put a ball in play to right, and Rikuu Nishida couldn't come up with the diving catch in his second career start in right field. Larnach took the double on his stat sheet, and he quickly scampered home when Kody Clemens laced a slump-breaker off the right-field line for a rolling triple to put the Twins up 1-0.

With Clemens at third and nobody out, Austin Martin looked to keep Burke and the White Sox on the ropes. He laced a single up the middle to make it 2-0. What happened next didn't appear to be a game-wrecker at the time, but it would loom large as the pitching duel continued. Martin attempted to steal second base with offensive wet blanket Victor Caratini at the plate. Drew Romo threw a perfect strike to second to nab Martin, and the Twins didn't taste the bases again against Burke.

The Experience Dominates Early and Often
Joe Ryan took this early lead and immediately faced a test in the bottom of the fourth. Colson Montgomery and Chase Meidroth hit a couple of two-out singles to put Ryan on the ropes. Ryan swept out perennial Twins pest and phonics experiment Andrew Benintendi by inducing a harmless grounder to get his squad back into the dugout. 

Burke found his groove again, and took care of the Twins in order in the fifth, sixth, and seventh innings. When the White Sox took on Ryan in the bottom of the seventh, they again made some noise with two outs. A single off second base by Benintendi and a questionable hit by pitch to the light-hitting Tristan Peters got Ryan ranting and raving and throwing his glove around. Caratini went to the mound, settled down his ace, and the duo struck out Romo to again keep the zeros coming.

But the Murakami Experience is Inevitable
Derek Shelton let Ryan take the hill in the eighth with 88 pitches already thrown, with the top of the order (and power) looming. Nishida immediately put Twins Territory on edge with a leadoff single. While he danced the night away off first, Ryan managed to come back to strike out Sam Antonacci for his ninth of the night. American League-leading home run phenom Munetaka Murakami stepped to the plate, and this time, Ryan's attempt to sweep away the threat landed far out in the right field seats for Murakami's 19th of the year. Ryan pitched at a remarkable 76% strike rate, but it was just one too many.

Once the sadness settled in, Ryan managed to get one more out before Shelton brought in Anthony Banda to face the lefty Montgomery. Banda immediately gave up a blast to the wall... but not over it. With the go-ahead run now at second base, Banda faced Meidroth with everything on the line. Meidroth beat out a grounder to Luke Keaschall, but luckily, the umpires took the initiative to examine the play more closely because the Twins were all out of challenges. The call was overturned, and we headed to the ninth all square at 2-2.

Who Will Enjoy How This Experience Ends?
Brooks Lee got himself on first base to start the ninth by hustling out an infield hit. Josh Bell came in to replace Larnach against the lefty Sean Newcomb. That was a poor decision, as Bell grounded into a double play via the usual 5-4-1-Slide Rule review route, as Lee slid wildly past second base, wiping out the fact that Bell beat out the relay.

Banda stayed in to start the ninth, and Will Venable took charge by pinch-hitting Randal Grichuk for Benintendi. Banda made that move look foolish with a strikeout. Venable came out yet again to pinch-hit Derek Hill for Peters, and Shelton countered by bringing in the roller coaster that is the Andrew Morris save experience. Morris got the final two outs on quality plays from Keaschall, and bonus baseball would decide tonight's experience.

Clemens started out the 10th as the Twins' placed runner, and Martin struck out on a highly questionable check swing to leave him right there. This placed the pressure on the previously mentioned Caratini, who kept the offensive offense narrative going with a strikeout of his own. Shelton went to the Orlando Arcia experience for a pinch-hit in this crucial moment, with the White Sox's big guns waiting at the bottom of the inning. Arcia delivered with a hit, but Nishida made Ramon Borrego look foolish, as he threw out Clemens by a mile at the plate.

Unlike Shelton, Venable switched out his zombie runner for a faster option in Luisangel Acuña. Taylor Rogers had no margin for error with Nishida at the plate. While his throw home might have saved the top of the inning, Nishida foul bunted himself on out of the bottom of the 10th. Antonacci bounced a ball off of Rogers' leg, but Arcia held it in the infield to put runners at the corners for Murakami. This had to be how the experience ends right? Wrong! Rogers swept away Murakami on a grounder to Bell, who tagged Antonacci somewhere near Lake Michigan for a double play! Or, if you believe the actual call, he lined out to Bell who then doubled up Antonacci. Either way, the Taylor Rogers Experience sends us to the 11th!

Every Experience Needs to End
The game's goofy vibe rolled right on into the top of the 11th and off of third baseman Miguel Vargas's leg for a Keaschall leadoff single. This advanced new Manfred Man Ryan Kreidler to third base, and brought up the much-maligned James Outman for a potential hero moment. Outman, predictably, struck out instead, and it was left up to Byron Buxton to break the seal that had paralyzed the Twins' side of the scoreboard since the fourth inning. On a 3-1 pitch, home plate umpire Adam Beck called strike two, but Buxton challenged—and won a walk to load the bases. The newest man of the hour was Lee. New pitcher Tyler Davis got Lee to foul off two straight fastballs. Davis then slowed things down a bit, and Lee sped them back up with a bases-clearing double!!!

The Twins left Lee on the bases, and Yoendrys Gómez allowed the Sox's automatic runner to score in the bottom half of the frame to add some angst to the evening once again. But once a Grichuk grounder found its way from Kreidler's arm to Bell's glove, Twins Territory could exhale and soak in the experience in victorious style.

What’s Next?
The Twins look to keep the momentum rolling against Chicago in the third game of the four-game series. Twins rookie Connor Prielipp (1-2, 4.03 ERA) will make his first start on the South Side, and will face rising ace righty Davis Martin (7-1, 2.04 ERA). On paper, this looks like another big blast-or-bust kind of evening, First pitch is scheduled for 6:40 pm CDT.

Postgame Interviews

 

Bullpen Usage Spreadsheet

	FRI	SAT	SUN	MON	TUE	TOT
Gómez	13	0	22	0	18	53
Rojas	0	45	0	0	0	45
Morris	0	32	0	0	8	40
Rogers	0	6	13	0	16	35
Woods Richardson	0	0	0	35	0	35
Banda	14	0	10	0	10	34
Adams	29	0	1	0	0	30
Orze	14	0	10	0	0	24

 

View full article

[GopherMike]

The Twins pitching staff went 11 innings and didn't walk a single batter. Props. 

[Parfigliano]

11 minutes ago, GopherMike said:

The Twins pitching staff went 11 innings and didn't walk a single batter. Props. 

Great pitching again.

[Peter]

Joe Ryan/bullpen/brooks Lee 🔥🔥🔥💪💪💪way to dig deep and get huge huge huge win💪💪💪🔥🔥🔥

[soyouresayingtheresachance]

Nice win. 

A couple base running blunders, but in the end, did enough to get the W.

Great night for the pitching staff. No walks. Really nice start for Ryan. I'd have preferred to see him finish up the 8th but its just because 8 innings looks better on the box score than 7 2/3 😂

[tarheeltwinsfan]

Accurate and dryly funny  summary of an unusual game. Thanks Steven.

[Permanent Twins Fan]

A couple of things about this game: 

A. Rikku Nishida is a bit annoying, but he does have a great arm. 

B. Luke Keaschall had a great defensive game. He had three great plays

C. Inteference calls seem to be showing up more lately. First, the Royce Lewis defensive interference call, and now the sliding inteference on Brooks Lee. I didn't like either of those calls even though they were likely the right call. It seems a bit nitpicky

D. Great game from Ryan. He and Bradley are a legimiate 1-2 duo on a playoff team. It would be fun to get this Twins rotation with Ryan, Bradley, Ober, and a healthy Abel in the playoffs. With a few additions to the bullpen, we could make a run.

E. Go Twins!!!! 

[Blyleven2011]

Nice to break the 7 game losing streak to the Sox  ...

Nice win in extra innings , Whew  ...

Pitching on both sides was tough , twins prevailed and won with Lee the hero in the eleventh clearing the bases ...

Outmans 4 strikeouts , his offense , need i say more  , OK  , it's BAD ...

[DocBauer]

It's really tough when the SP doesn't win after pitching to well. But that's baseball. Despite 1 run allowed, the pen did their job.

I remain frustrated with those disappointed in Lee. Even when drafted, he was regarded as a "competent" SS who would probably move to 2B or 3B. His "competent" SS glove has now been moved to 3B, where it belongs. And he was supposed to be some "hitting machine" that he hasn't been yet. 

Last season, 2025, he was a ROOKIE save for 22 AB in 2024. But so many seem to believe he's been around forever and has TONS of experience and should be a STUD already. It's just RIDICULOUS how Lee has been perceived so far.

He's still adjusting to ML pitching, and who he is as a hitter.  So far, his power is looking better than expected. He may not be the HITTER  we expected. He may have more power than expected. And I think we should be excited that we're seeing a maturation of his bat.

 

[1985Fan]

Great pitching once again. The BP is coming around now, so there is hope for those guys as well. I thought Taylor Roger’s showed his veteran mettle. I was impressed with his outing and Gomez keeps pitching well under pressure. No one saw that coming. 
I can't see how Lee was called for interference. When he rolled over 2nd base, the throw was already on its way, so it didn’t affect the throw or play at all. Poor call on that one. 

[Parfigliano]

6 minutes ago, 1985Fan said:

Great pitching once again. The BP is coming around now, so there is hope for those guys as well. I thought Taylor Roger’s showed his veteran mettle. I was impressed with his outing and Gomez keeps pitching well under pressure. No one saw that coming. 
I can't see how Lee was called for interference. When he rolled over 2nd base, the throw was already on its way, so it didn’t affect the throw or play at all. Poor call on that one. 

Dumb rule.

[UK Twin]

Joe Ryan doing Joe Ryan things is to be expected. Didn't mind the call for him to pitch the 8th with a fairly low pitch count and going well. BP stood up and delivered. Gomez looks a decent pick up and both Banda and Rogers have settled in after rough starts to the season. Brooks Lee is clutch with the bases loaded! Great swing on an 0-2 count. Caratini is a mess at the plate right now. Give Jackson more game time.

[UK Twin]

2 hours ago, DocBauer said:

It's really tough when the SP doesn't win after pitching to well. But that's baseball. Despite 1 run allowed, the pen did their job.

I remain frustrated with those disappointed in Lee. Even when drafted, he was regarded as a "competent" SS who would probably move to 2B or 3B. His "competent" SS glove has now been moved to 3B, where it belongs. And he was supposed to be some "hitting machine" that he hasn't been yet. 

Last season, 2025, he was a ROOKIE save for 22 AB in 2024. But so many seem to believe he's been around forever and has TONS of experience and should be a STUD already. It's just RIDICULOUS how Lee has been perceived so far.

He's still adjusting to ML pitching, and who he is as a hitter.  So far, his power is looking better than expected. He may not be the HITTER  we expected. He may have more power than expected. And I think we should be excited that we're seeing a maturation of his bat.

 

1 unearned run don't forget. That came in extra's with the runner starting on 2nd and that run didn't matter with a 3 run lead.

[Jack207]

So much fun watching this team play! Outman and Caratini look overmatched against average pitching.

[LewFordLives]

7 hours ago, Blyleven2011 said:

 

Outmans 4 strikeouts , his offense , need i say more  , OK  , it's BAD ...

And yet if you suggest releasing him certain people on these message boards will jump all over you and claim there's no one to replace him with.

Call up Gonzalez, Wallner, Mendez, Fedko.... anybody. Have Martin play center for days where Buxton can't go. A team that has trouble scoring runs cannot keep Outman on the roster.

[MinnInPa]

24 minutes ago, Jack207 said:

So much fun watching this team play! Outman and Caratini look overmatched against average pitching.

OUTman  should be out of baseball

[UK Twin]

17 minutes ago, LewFordLives said:

And yet if you suggest releasing him certain people on these message boards will jump all over you and claim there's no one to replace him with.

Call up Gonzalez, Wallner, Mendez, Fedko.... anybody. Have Martin play center for days where Buxton can't go. A team that has trouble scoring runs cannot keep Outman on the roster.

We're inconsistent but we don't have much trouble scoring runs - we're second in the AL in runs scored!

[mikelink45]

With Outman and Caratini playing it seems like the Twins are winning with a lineup of seven batters instead of nine. .179 and .167 - what am I missing. Maybe we are stuck with Caratini at catcher, but come on - Outman is -0.3 WAR.  43 OPS+.  Can't we be creative with Gonzales, Rojas, Fedko, or Mendes? 

Caratini matches Outman with a -0.3 WAR. and nearly matches him with a 47 OPS+ and we have him signed for next year too.

And this leads to Josh Bell -0.7 WAR. 73 OPS+  Replace him with Lewis and move on. 

[Bangkok Twins Fan]

9 hours ago, tarheeltwinsfan said:

Accurate and dryly funny  summary of an unusual game. Thanks Steven.

I agree. I think I enjoyed Steven's summary even more than the game!

[Bangkok Twins Fan]

16 minutes ago, UK Twin said:

We're inconsistent but we don't have much trouble scoring runs - we're second in the AL in runs scored!

That seems like a crazy, almost unbelievable stat ... but I'll take it!

[Bangkok Twins Fan]

8 hours ago, DocBauer said:

He may not be the HITTER  we expected. He may have more power than expected. And I think we should be excited that we're seeing a maturation of his bat.

Lee's development as a hitter has certainly been one of the brighter aspects of this season so far for the Twins.

[Dman]

8 hours ago, 1985Fan said:

I can't see how Lee was called for interference. When he rolled over 2nd base, the throw was already on its way, so it didn’t affect the throw or play at all. Poor call on that one. 

I would agree he didn't affect the play in the end.  The rule was put in place to protect players from getting spiked or knee's taken out on the throw from second when players knew they had no chance to be safe.  I think it is a good rule in that regard.  Lee knew he was out and had no chance to be safe at second yet he slide aggressively into second. So much so that he did go past second base and into the knee's of the thrower.  While the contact was minimal I think they want to discourage that type of uncontrolled play into second to protect players vulnerable after the throw.  I don't think making the rule apply only if the player is injured is the "right" message. 

I'm old school and used to the aggressive slides, but I get that protecting players on a throw from a guy who has no chance to be safe at second makes some sense to keep players from getting injured for no good reason. 

[JD-TWINS]

58 minutes ago, UK Twin said:

We're inconsistent but we don't have much trouble scoring runs - we're second in the AL in runs scored!

They had one run through NINE innings on Monday and two runs through TEN innings on Tuesday. ……… They have won 3 games when they scored 3 or less through 55 games……. they have lost 16 of those games.

(That’s not a “bullpen issue”)

So they have scored 3 or less in 19 of 55 games …….. 35% of the time.

Have 6 or more runs in a dozen games 9-10-11 -11 -13 in five of them. Scoring runs is great! CONSISTENTLY getting 4 runs will lead to Wins.

 

[JD-TWINS]

1 hour ago, Bangkok Twins Fan said:

Lee's development as a hitter has certainly been one of the brighter aspects of this season so far for the Twins.

.462 BA with RISP ……. agreed, Lee’s ability to contribute at the plate with some really big hits mixed in is a nice step forward!

[Nshore]

As others have said, Lee has become great in the clutch.  He has defensive limitations, but the 2 hitters I want up there with the game on the line are Lee or Martin.

[JD-TWINS]

So, Team had the intestinal fortitude (sense) to Option Lewis and Wallner with obvious positive results on MLB Club, to date.

James Outman can’t bunt - struck out 4 times on Tuesday night - is hitting .165ish. Kreidler can play similar OF defense …… he doesn’t hit LH, but Outman doesn’t hit RH pitching either…….so Team needs to make a move. Need a 13th bat - I don’t care who it is from AAA, there HAS TO BE a better option in St Paul!

Already living on the edge with Gray & Kreidler at the plate for weeks ……… can’t imagine they continue to perform……… sure hope so. Arcia won’t continue to hit .533 but it seems obvious that with his start at AAA and a handful of games back in the Show, he’s turned a page at the plate!!

My point is the Team needs guys that can potentially contribute - nobody thinks any positive thoughts when James Outman comes to the plate.

[hitterscount]

2 hours ago, LewFordLives said:

And yet if you suggest releasing him certain people on these message boards will jump all over you and claim there's no one to replace him with.

Call up Gonzalez, Wallner, Mendez, Fedko.... anybody. Have Martin play center for days where Buxton can't go. A team that has trouble scoring runs cannot keep Outman on the roster.

You had me until Wallner was thrown into the mix....at least Outman can field, other than that he's pretty much an automatic out.

[saviking]

So, is it just me or do the Twins bats go quite everytime Ryan pitches, especially the first 6 innings making it impossible for Ryan to win games. 

[JD-TWINS]

2 hours ago, mikelink45 said:

With Outman and Caratini playing it seems like the Twins are winning with a lineup of seven batters instead of nine. .179 and .167 - what am I missing. Maybe we are stuck with Caratini at catcher, but come on - Outman is -0.3 WAR.  43 OPS+.  Can't we be creative with Gonzales, Rojas, Fedko, or Mendes? 

Caratini matches Outman with a -0.3 WAR. and nearly matches him with a 47 OPS+ and we have him signed for next year too.

And this leads to Josh Bell -0.7 WAR. 73 OPS+  Replace him with Lewis and move on. 

It took for Matt Wallner to get to -1.3 for a couple weeks to get demoted & Outman can play OF. I agree, a change would be welcomed but until a lefty OF bat steps up in St Paul, we’ll have to live with James.

[Mike Sixel]

Four or five automatic outs with Outman batting.... How many plays can only he make and not Martin or Fedko or Kriedler in a game? It's less than four....