Jump to content
Twins Daily
  • Create Account

TL

Verified Member
  • Posts

    193
  • Joined

  • Last visited

Recent Profile Visitors

The recent visitors block is disabled and is not being shown to other users.

TL's Achievements

  1. Not against trading him for a very good prospect return, but: Caratini and Jackson have done well in his absence, but they are not Ryan Jeffers. Twins are in contention and to they could really use him if they want to make a playoff run (that is the goal, right?). If the return isn’t great, then you end up with a fringe major leaguer like a Ryan Gallagher. I’d suggest keeping Jeffers for a playoff run could have bigger long-term benefits to the psyche of the team (and fans) than having another Ryan Gallagher in AA. Making playoffs, or even a legit playoff run, could increase revenue and result in higher payroll next year (no laughing). There are no bad 1 year contracts, even at 23MM; and if he declines then you get a decent prospect anyway through the comp pick.
  2. Comp A picks last 5 years. 2022 and 2023 look pretty good considering MLB draft is a crapshoot. Too early to tell on most recent 2 years. Of course I’d prefer a player who has demonstrated ability in the minors already, but then again I’d also prefer keeping Jeffers for the stretch.
  3. At least 1/3 of comp A picks end up on a top 100 list or its fringes at some point. You’d probably end up with a Charlie Soto type. But McGonigle was a comp pick too so…
  4. Maybe, maybe not. But then we get Jeffers for a pennant chase and a borderline top 100 prospect (which seems to be all anybody thinks he’s worth anyway). I’m fine with that.
  5. To me trading Larnach and Martin for bullpen help makes the most sense. Larnach has been great but I really think one or two of Roden/Jenkins/Emma will equal his contribution given their far superior defense and comparable on-base skills, even if early in their careers they don’t quite equal his offensive production. Martin would perhaps need to be pared with a lower level minor leaguer in a trade but he plays a good OF and still has some potential - and Keaschall/Clemens make him unnecessary.
  6. I think this is the right way to think about it. If someone gives up a top 50 prospect, take it. Otherwise get the comp pick or one more year at a bit of an overpay. We may even need to overpay to get to a salary floor.
  7. Caratini’s play definitely makes trading Jeffers more palatable for both this and next year. Someone pointed out to me 6 weeks ago that the QO is 23MM, and that is at the top or above what any catcher makes. I’d still consider it if the trade offers aren’t acceptable given it is only 1 year and Jeffers may prefer a long term deal anyway, so we’d get a comp pick. On the other hand, if he takes the QO we miss out on flipping him for prospects; and 30MM for the C position is rich for this club. I expect it is a moot point given the Yankees dire need for catching.
  8. This would be a way to accelerate the future while still trying to contend. Trade Larnach and Bell (and Wallner, Gray, Martin or a 2nd tier minors prospect if it helps bring anything back in a deal) for bullpen help. And Jeffers for a top pitching prospect at least. Bring up Culpepper, Jenkins, Roden and Emma (when healed up) and trust they can replace what was lost. May not quite get you there with the bats, but with the improved defense and bullpen they may be better overall.
  9. Agree with pretty much everything here. Jeffers is really the only guy you “have” to trade or you get nothing in return. Fine on waiting on Ryan until the offseason unless they are blown away with an offer. But I think you need to target highest upside you can for Jeffers and not water it down by insisting on an established reliever as a secondary piece that may net you a lesser headliner.
  10. Monitoring/managing Prellip’s status and workload must be keeping Zoll and Shelton up at night. He’s looking like a front line guy for several years and they’ll be kicking themselves in hindsight if he gets over ~140 and then gets injured (again). I’d be thinking long-term with him, which you can tell they are by pushing back starts here and there… just a tough situation but obviously super positive development.
  11. They get Jeffers and Ober back in a few weeks and Culpepper should get promoted soon (and maybe Jenkins?). If Buxton can avoid a long term IL stint and the starting pitching continues to develop like it has been this team can stay in contention. Just maybe Rojas, Abel, CJ Culpepper and Preillip find themselves in the pen and it becomes a strength later in the year. (Both Preillip and Abel are still long term starters, but used out of pen to manage injury risk later this year). Too far fetched? Downside is Jeffers likely walks for nothing if you go for it this year so they may need to deal him anyway while still trying to contend.
  12. Kreidler can take the utility spot, but I would not call it “super” if you include a productive bat in that equation. No utility man the Twins have gotten in my memory (including Escobar or Castro) have hit like Clemens has this year while being able to play what appears to be an above average CF along with the right side of the infield. I love having Kreidler for his SS play and ability to also play the OF, but not instead of Clemens. Those two make Martin and any other 4th outfield very expendable.
  13. I think it’s fair to say Emerson has the consensus highest upside but also more risk given age and competition. I’ve read he is clearly ahead of where Roch was as a HS senior. That would be a helluva consolation prize. I’d take that swing if opportunity presented but doubt he gets by Rays.
  14. I think we'd find the Twins are not any different than other teams in that regard. It's typically infielders who are questionable to stick up the middle that get moved around. By way of example, Marek Houston has only played SS while Jesus Made is being moved all over the infield to increase "flexibility" (i.e., he may not be a SS). Twins fans have also been complaining about management not trying their outfielders at first base. You'd think they would do that if their first priority was making everyone a utility player.
×
×
  • Create New...