Jump to content
Twins Daily
  • Create Account

Cody Schoenmann

Twins Daily Contributor
  • Posts

    788
  • Joined

  • Last visited

  • Days Won

    1

Cody Schoenmann last won the day on December 1 2025

Cody Schoenmann had the most liked content!

5 Followers

About Cody Schoenmann

  • Birthday 02/26/2000

Recent Profile Visitors

35,726 profile views

Cody Schoenmann's Achievements

Ft Myers Mighty Mussels

Ft Myers Mighty Mussels (6/14)

  • Dollar Dog Night
  • Gettin' Noticed Rare
  • Now Let's Talk About This Rare
  • Squatter
  • NICE

Recent Badges

1.7k

Reputation

  1. writing a speculative piece on the Twins pursuing let alone signing Tarik Skubal would be a waste of everyone’s time
  2. i think we undersell how valuable a 1.6 WAR starting pitcher is also, i would bet my mortgage that Holmes earns more than 2.0 WAR (i don't have a mortgage)
  3. Synopsized ever so eloquently by Twins Daily’s Matthew Trueblood in an article published Sunday morning, general manager Jeremy Zoll stated the team plans to bolster its bullpen primarily through "internal additions"—converting starting pitchers already on the 40-man roster into relievers. Trueblood mentioned Zebby Matthews as the favorite to undergo said conversion. David Festa, Kendry Rojas, and Mick Abel are candidates, too. Regardless of which erstwhile starter(s) convert(s), however, Zoll also signaled that the club prefers to invest in a free-agent starting pitcher this month, rather than a reliever (or relievers). Tarik Skubal is baseball’s top free agent, but obviously, Minnesota won’t sign him. Michael King, Trevor Rogers, and Freddy Peralta are frontline starters who will probably land in the upper echelon of what the club is comfortable spending. Still, I’d be shocked if the Twins signed any of them, even with spending restrictions less stringent than in seasons past. Kaima Taira is an intriguing NPB free agent with a fastball that can touch 100 miles per hour. Given that he primarily worked as a reliever for the Saitama Seibu Lions and is expected to earn a multi-year, eight-figure contract despite not yet having thrown an inning in the majors, however, Twins decision-makers would be wise to take a more risk-averse approach to signing a starting pitcher. Disqualifying Skubal, King, Rogers, Peralta, and Taira, the best free-agent starting pitcher the Twins could realistically sign before the lockout begins on December 2 is Clay Holmes. Converted from a starter to reliever and back into a starter after signing a three-year, $38-million contract (with an opt-out after the second season, which he exercised) with the New York Mets before the 2024 season, Holmes has been one of the more underrated starters in baseball the past two seasons, netting a 3.41 ERA, 3.87 FIP, and a 207-to-108 strikeout-to-walk ratio over a combined 264 innings pitched. Traded from the Mets to the Chicago Cubs at last season’s trade deadline, the 33-year-old struggled with his new club, posting a 4.25 ERA, 4.09 FIP, and a 16.2% strikeout rate over 48 2/3 innings with Chicago, far less impressive than the 2.39 ERA, 3.21 FIP, and 20.9% strikeout rate he posted over 52 2/3 innings with New York. The cause behind Holmes’s regression with Chicago was his walk rate spiking from 8.4% to 11.1%. Cubs pitching coaches also had him throw his cutter more, which proved to be a bad decision, as he surrendered a .799 OPS when throwing the pitch. Assuming Holmes’s next club will shift him back to throwing his sinker and sweeper a combined 70% of the time, there's a strong chance that the righty will again perform like a mid-rotation starter next season. According to FanGraphs's median crowdsourced projection, Holmes is projected to secure a three-year, $51-million deal, earning $17 million annually. There is, then, reason to believe he could be acquired on a two-year deal, with an annual salary around $18-20 million. Minnesota can afford that. With veteran starters Pablo López, Joe Ryan, Bailey Ober, and Dean Kremer set to become free agents after 2027, Twins decision-makers are further incentivized to sign Holmes to a multi-season deal, with him headlining the 2028 starting rotation alongside Taj Bradley and Connor Prielipp. Until then, Holmes could pitch alongside López, Ryan, Kremer, Bradley, and Prielipp next season, forming what could be one of the AL’s most formidable starting rotations. Zoll is wise to invest significant money in the starting rotation, rather than the bullpen. However, Minnesota needs to be smart about which pitcher they target. King, Rogers, Peralta, and Taira are higher-upside candidates, but Holmes is the perfect blend of affordability and skill that could bolster Minnesota’s rotation. Image courtesy of Mark J. Rebilas-Imagn Images View full article
  4. Synopsized ever so eloquently by Twins Daily’s Matthew Trueblood in an article published Sunday morning, general manager Jeremy Zoll stated the team plans to bolster its bullpen primarily through "internal additions"—converting starting pitchers already on the 40-man roster into relievers. Trueblood mentioned Zebby Matthews as the favorite to undergo said conversion. David Festa, Kendry Rojas, and Mick Abel are candidates, too. Regardless of which erstwhile starter(s) convert(s), however, Zoll also signaled that the club prefers to invest in a free-agent starting pitcher this month, rather than a reliever (or relievers). Tarik Skubal is baseball’s top free agent, but obviously, Minnesota won’t sign him. Michael King, Trevor Rogers, and Freddy Peralta are frontline starters who will probably land in the upper echelon of what the club is comfortable spending. Still, I’d be shocked if the Twins signed any of them, even with spending restrictions less stringent than in seasons past. Kaima Taira is an intriguing NPB free agent with a fastball that can touch 100 miles per hour. Given that he primarily worked as a reliever for the Saitama Seibu Lions and is expected to earn a multi-year, eight-figure contract despite not yet having thrown an inning in the majors, however, Twins decision-makers would be wise to take a more risk-averse approach to signing a starting pitcher. Disqualifying Skubal, King, Rogers, Peralta, and Taira, the best free-agent starting pitcher the Twins could realistically sign before the lockout begins on December 2 is Clay Holmes. Converted from a starter to reliever and back into a starter after signing a three-year, $38-million contract (with an opt-out after the second season, which he exercised) with the New York Mets before the 2024 season, Holmes has been one of the more underrated starters in baseball the past two seasons, netting a 3.41 ERA, 3.87 FIP, and a 207-to-108 strikeout-to-walk ratio over a combined 264 innings pitched. Traded from the Mets to the Chicago Cubs at last season’s trade deadline, the 33-year-old struggled with his new club, posting a 4.25 ERA, 4.09 FIP, and a 16.2% strikeout rate over 48 2/3 innings with Chicago, far less impressive than the 2.39 ERA, 3.21 FIP, and 20.9% strikeout rate he posted over 52 2/3 innings with New York. The cause behind Holmes’s regression with Chicago was his walk rate spiking from 8.4% to 11.1%. Cubs pitching coaches also had him throw his cutter more, which proved to be a bad decision, as he surrendered a .799 OPS when throwing the pitch. Assuming Holmes’s next club will shift him back to throwing his sinker and sweeper a combined 70% of the time, there's a strong chance that the righty will again perform like a mid-rotation starter next season. According to FanGraphs's median crowdsourced projection, Holmes is projected to secure a three-year, $51-million deal, earning $17 million annually. There is, then, reason to believe he could be acquired on a two-year deal, with an annual salary around $18-20 million. Minnesota can afford that. With veteran starters Pablo López, Joe Ryan, Bailey Ober, and Dean Kremer set to become free agents after 2027, Twins decision-makers are further incentivized to sign Holmes to a multi-season deal, with him headlining the 2028 starting rotation alongside Taj Bradley and Connor Prielipp. Until then, Holmes could pitch alongside López, Ryan, Kremer, Bradley, and Prielipp next season, forming what could be one of the AL’s most formidable starting rotations. Zoll is wise to invest significant money in the starting rotation, rather than the bullpen. However, Minnesota needs to be smart about which pitcher they target. King, Rogers, Peralta, and Taira are higher-upside candidates, but Holmes is the perfect blend of affordability and skill that could bolster Minnesota’s rotation.
  5. Jenkins had a 0 wRC+ over 25 PAs against LHP last season; small sample, but the Twins would be wise to shield him against lefties early next season. Martin would allow that.
  6. Twins could still benefit from a RHH cOF platoon bat. Against LHSP, they could have an outfield configuration of Martin, Buxton, and Keaschall; all plus hitters against lefties. Kreidler is a plus defender at 2B, 3B, and SS. He also had the same wRC+ as Lewis last season. There's really no benefit in rostering Lewis atp, especially if they acquire a 1B of Bauers's ilk.
  7. wishcasting C: Ryan Jeffers ($23.15M) 1B: Jake Bauers ($17.20M) 2B: Kody Clemens ($3.60M) 3B: Brooks Lee ($1.00M) SS: Kaelen Culpepper ($1.00M) LF: Alan Roden ($1.00M) CF: Walker Jenkins ($1.00M) RF: Luke Keaschall ($1.00M) DH: Byron Buxton ($15.00M) 4th OF: Emmanuel Rodriguez ($1.00M) Utility: Austin Martin ($1.00M) Utility: Ryan Kreidler ($1.00M) Backup C: Victor Caratini ($7.00M) POS: Add Dead Money Here ($0.00M) SP1: Pablo Lopez ($21.50M) SP2: Joe Ryan ($9.60M) SP3: Taj Bradley ($4.50M) SP4: Dean Kremer ($6.50M) SP5: Connor Prielipp ($1.00M) RP: Jeff Hoffman ($7.25M) RP: Bryan Abreu ($9.00M) RP: Sean Newcomb ($10.33M) RP: Andrew Morris ($1.00M) RP: Kody Funderburk ($1.00M) RP: Yoendrys Gomez ($1.00M) RP: Tommy Nance ($1.20M) RP: Mick Abel ($1.00M) POS: Add Dead Money Here ($0.00M) Payroll is 9.29% over budget
  8. From the Twins' perspective, the most important story of this past postseason was the heavy reliance on left-handed relievers capable of throwing multiple innings. Milwaukee’s Aaron Ashby’s epitomizes this trend, as he put up a 0.00 ERA, 1.38 FIP, and 33.3% strikeout rate over 18 innings pitched. Of his nine games, Ashby threw more than one inning in eight, twice tossing three innings in separate NLDS and NLCS appearances. The 28-year-old often threw multiple innings in the regular season, too, pitching more than one frame in 24 of his 75 outings. Milwaukee’s NLDS opponent (San Diego) deployed a similar approach, having star southpaw Adrián Morejón pitch two innings once against the Chicago Cubs in the NL Wild Card round and once against Milwaukee. San Diego often had Morejón operate in a multi-inning role during the regular season, too, alongside fellow plus lefty relievers Yuki Matsui and Wandy Peralta. The Los Angeles Dodgers used the same approach in both the postseason and the regular season with left-handed relievers Kris Bubic, Jack Dreyer, and Justin Wrobleski. The Chicago White Sox did the same with Hagen Smith and Sean Newcomb. The list goes on and on. Baseball’s smartest and most successful organizations all utilized their top left-handed relievers and swing men in multi-inning roles during the regular season and postseason. Why is that? The best lineups in baseball have a lot of left-handed hitters. Naturally, the best way to combat that is by rostering multiple left-handed pitchers who can pitch multiple innings—fighting platoon fire with platoon fire. As you know, one of Minnesota’s many areas of need this offseason will be its bullpen, which was a bottom-10 unit in the sport, according to Wins Above Replacement at FanGraphs (fWAR). As constructed, the Twins have one left-handed reliever who can throw multiple innings: Kody Funderburk. Funderburk is a serviceable major-league reliever who can toss multiple innings—don’t get me wrong—but he isn’t the headlining lefty reliever of a postseason-contending club. Perhaps Connor Prielipp could transition into the Ashby role and find much success. However, club decision-makers are highly incentivized to continue stretching the young southpaw out as a starter. That being the case, Minnesota would be wise to address this roster inefficiency via free agency this November, before the lockout begins on December 2. At first glance, the most obvious option would be re-signing A.J. Minter. The 33-year-old southpaw excelled with Minnesota after being acquired from the New York Mets on July 31, posting a 2.78 ERA, 4.91 FIP, and 22.3% strikeout rate over 22 2/3 innings pitched. The club could probably retain him on a one-year deal for around $8 million. Even if Minter returned, though, he would probably operate exclusively in a one-inning role. While he'd be a fine addition, he's no facsimile of Ashby. Aforementioned southpaws Morejón, Bubic, and Newcomb are free agents. Morejón was offered the $23.2 million qualifying offer from San Diego, which he could accept. Bubic, Newcomb, and other free-agent lefties like JoJo Romero, Brent Suter, or (to a lesser extent) Dietrich Enns could pitch multiple innings, however. There are plenty of options. To address this role meaningfully, the Twins would need to target a high-upside candidate such as Bubic, Newcomb, or Romero. Again, given how most of the offseason will be condensed into one month, Twins decision-makers will need to decide which multi-inning southpaw to invest in. The specific pitcher takes a back seat to the necessity for team decision-makers to proactively seek out and acquire a lefty reliever of this mold, capitalizing on one of the sport’s most understated advantages. It won't be easy, but it's necessary. Image courtesy of Kim Klement Neitzel-Imagn Images View full article
  9. From the Twins' perspective, the most important story of this past postseason was the heavy reliance on left-handed relievers capable of throwing multiple innings. Milwaukee’s Aaron Ashby’s epitomizes this trend, as he put up a 0.00 ERA, 1.38 FIP, and 33.3% strikeout rate over 18 innings pitched. Of his nine games, Ashby threw more than one inning in eight, twice tossing three innings in separate NLDS and NLCS appearances. The 28-year-old often threw multiple innings in the regular season, too, pitching more than one frame in 24 of his 75 outings. Milwaukee’s NLDS opponent (San Diego) deployed a similar approach, having star southpaw Adrián Morejón pitch two innings once against the Chicago Cubs in the NL Wild Card round and once against Milwaukee. San Diego often had Morejón operate in a multi-inning role during the regular season, too, alongside fellow plus lefty relievers Yuki Matsui and Wandy Peralta. The Los Angeles Dodgers used the same approach in both the postseason and the regular season with left-handed relievers Kris Bubic, Jack Dreyer, and Justin Wrobleski. The Chicago White Sox did the same with Hagen Smith and Sean Newcomb. The list goes on and on. Baseball’s smartest and most successful organizations all utilized their top left-handed relievers and swing men in multi-inning roles during the regular season and postseason. Why is that? The best lineups in baseball have a lot of left-handed hitters. Naturally, the best way to combat that is by rostering multiple left-handed pitchers who can pitch multiple innings—fighting platoon fire with platoon fire. As you know, one of Minnesota’s many areas of need this offseason will be its bullpen, which was a bottom-10 unit in the sport, according to Wins Above Replacement at FanGraphs (fWAR). As constructed, the Twins have one left-handed reliever who can throw multiple innings: Kody Funderburk. Funderburk is a serviceable major-league reliever who can toss multiple innings—don’t get me wrong—but he isn’t the headlining lefty reliever of a postseason-contending club. Perhaps Connor Prielipp could transition into the Ashby role and find much success. However, club decision-makers are highly incentivized to continue stretching the young southpaw out as a starter. That being the case, Minnesota would be wise to address this roster inefficiency via free agency this November, before the lockout begins on December 2. At first glance, the most obvious option would be re-signing A.J. Minter. The 33-year-old southpaw excelled with Minnesota after being acquired from the New York Mets on July 31, posting a 2.78 ERA, 4.91 FIP, and 22.3% strikeout rate over 22 2/3 innings pitched. The club could probably retain him on a one-year deal for around $8 million. Even if Minter returned, though, he would probably operate exclusively in a one-inning role. While he'd be a fine addition, he's no facsimile of Ashby. Aforementioned southpaws Morejón, Bubic, and Newcomb are free agents. Morejón was offered the $23.2 million qualifying offer from San Diego, which he could accept. Bubic, Newcomb, and other free-agent lefties like JoJo Romero, Brent Suter, or (to a lesser extent) Dietrich Enns could pitch multiple innings, however. There are plenty of options. To address this role meaningfully, the Twins would need to target a high-upside candidate such as Bubic, Newcomb, or Romero. Again, given how most of the offseason will be condensed into one month, Twins decision-makers will need to decide which multi-inning southpaw to invest in. The specific pitcher takes a back seat to the necessity for team decision-makers to proactively seek out and acquire a lefty reliever of this mold, capitalizing on one of the sport’s most understated advantages. It won't be easy, but it's necessary.
  10. Realistically, there's very little chance that Ryan Jeffers remains with the Minnesota Twins in 2027. The team will get to decide, shortly after the end of the World Series, whether to extend him the qualifying offer (worth just over $23 million for one year), but even if they do, he might well reject it and seek a multi-year deal elsewhere. The way the organization values and deploys catchers makes a big expenditure to keep Jeffers unlikely. Watching Jeffers leave will be a somber experience for Twins Territory. The second-round draft pick developed into one of baseball’s best offensive catchers. He has also become a beloved personality for fans and media. These plus traits are why the Twins could be priced out of a reunion with the 29-year-old. Immense optimism surrounds the position for the team in the long term, with top prospect Vahn Lackey succeeding Jeffers as the club’s backstop as soon as next summer. Still, the club will need to bridge the gap between the Jeffers and Lackey Eras early next season, leaving team decision-makers in a bind. Victor Caratini is the most obvious bridge. He's entering the second half of a two-year, $14-million deal signed last offseason. The 33-year-old hit .220/.312/.315 with seven home runs and a 79 wRC+ over 382 plate appearances in 2026. He was also a plus receiver behind the plate, sporting plus blocking and framing metrics, while netting 2.2 Runs Above Average on challenges. However, he was one of the weakest backstops in baseball against the running game, with an abysmal 2.04-second average pop time that led to six fewer runners being caught than expected. Jeffers was similarly atrocious at stopping runners. It often felt like basestealers could run freely against the Twins. (Indeed, only two teams allowed more steals, and no team caught a lower percentage of runners in the attempt.) This was one of Minnesota’s more glaring shortcomings last season, functioning as a significant hindrance to the club’s ability to suppress runs. Caratini has never been able to effectively suppress base-stealing efforts. There’s no reason to believe he will suddenly be able to in 2027. As noted earlier, he’s also an offensive liability, but given his plus receiving skills, knack for reversing balls into strikes, and (arguably most importantly) $7-million price tag, the switch-hitting veteran is all but guaranteed to be the club’s primary catcher next Opening Day. Caratini catching four or five days a week is not ideal, particularly if he hits at a rate like last season's. (But things could be worse. At least they’re not paying J.T. Realmuto $15 million next season, right?) As things stand, Caratini will soon be the only catcher on Minnesota’s 40-man roster. Alex Jackson is still with the organization and under team control next season, but only if they take the proactive step of putting him back on the 40-man by the end of this month. I’d be content with the club entering next season with Jackson as Caratini’s backup. He performed well at the plate in 2026, hitting .304/.342/.406 (good for a 112 wRC+) over 73 plate appearances. The 30-year-old also had one of the best pop times last season, resulting in him being far better at suppressing the run game than Jeffers and Caratini. Caratini is far better at receiving, framing, and challenging than Jackson is. In theory, the tandem could function as counterbalances for one another. The damage of Caratini’s inability to suppress base runners is mitigated by that being Jackson’s strength, and vice versa. Unfortunately, that’s not how the sport works, in practice. Starting Caratini only against teams who don't run isn't realistic, and the Twins don't have enough pitchers who can live with a lesser receiver to lean on Jackson more often. (Nor, in all likelihood, would Jackson hit as well in a more regular, exposed role.) Caratini’s and Jackson’s shortcomings will remain on display until Lackey (an elite all-around catcher) takes over the position full-time. They're a tolerable stopgap, but the team could still aim higher. The only desirable non-Jeffers impending free agent catchers are Carson Kelly and Tyler Stephenson. Kelly is a far better option, but he will likely demand a multi-year contract, similar to what Caratini got last season. Stephenson is a better hitter than Caratini and Jackson and might be available on a one-year deal, or at least a low-risk, high-reward two-year pact. However, he's arguably the worst defender of the four, diminishing the impact of his just-above-average bat. I wouldn’t be against Minnesota pairing Stephenson with Caratini. He or Kelly could come in on a two-year deal and be the bridge's bridge, as it were, working in tandem with Caratini for 2027 and alongside Lackey in 2028, when Caratini's contract is up. Austin Hedges, James McCann, and Kyle Higashioka are also likely to be available, but the Twins might as well roll with Jackson, if they're considering any of those options. Five years after being the No. 1 overall pick in the MLB Draft, Pirates catcher Henry Davis could be available via trade. Of course, he has a Derek Shelton connection, having played under him for three seasons in Pittsburgh. Davis has yet to meet expectations at the plate, generating a career 55 wRC+ over 958 plate appearances. In fact, 2026 was his first positive-fWAR season in the majors, generating 0.6. The driving factor in his progression was that the 27-year-old was one of the best defensive catchers in baseball, being a plus receiver and near-elite run game suppressor. (He was slightly below-average at challenging.) His polished defensive skills make him an interesting target who could benefit from a change of scenery. Under team control until the end of the 2029 season, Davis could also tandem with Lackey, solidifying the position for years to come. The Twins probably wouldn’t have to surrender much prospect capital to acquire Davis, given his lackluster performance at the plate. Pittsburgh appears set at the position long-term, with Rafael Flores Jr. and Endy Rodriguez. Between veteran options in Kelly, Stephenson, Hedges, McCann, and Higashioka or team-controlled trade candidates in Davis, Luis Torrens, Carlos Narváez, or Austin Wells (especially if Jeffers signs with the Yankees), there are plenty of external options Minnesota could acquire. The Twins would be wise to invest in a higher-upside partner for Caratini than Jackson. Twins Territory should prepare for Caratini to make the bulk of starts behind the plate until Lackey’s highly-anticipated arrival. Maybe the wait will make the payoff a bit sweeter. Image courtesy of Bruce Kluckhohn-Imagn Images View full article
  11. Realistically, there's very little chance that Ryan Jeffers remains with the Minnesota Twins in 2027. The team will get to decide, shortly after the end of the World Series, whether to extend him the qualifying offer (worth just over $23 million for one year), but even if they do, he might well reject it and seek a multi-year deal elsewhere. The way the organization values and deploys catchers makes a big expenditure to keep Jeffers unlikely. Watching Jeffers leave will be a somber experience for Twins Territory. The second-round draft pick developed into one of baseball’s best offensive catchers. He has also become a beloved personality for fans and media. These plus traits are why the Twins could be priced out of a reunion with the 29-year-old. Immense optimism surrounds the position for the team in the long term, with top prospect Vahn Lackey succeeding Jeffers as the club’s backstop as soon as next summer. Still, the club will need to bridge the gap between the Jeffers and Lackey Eras early next season, leaving team decision-makers in a bind. Victor Caratini is the most obvious bridge. He's entering the second half of a two-year, $14-million deal signed last offseason. The 33-year-old hit .220/.312/.315 with seven home runs and a 79 wRC+ over 382 plate appearances in 2026. He was also a plus receiver behind the plate, sporting plus blocking and framing metrics, while netting 2.2 Runs Above Average on challenges. However, he was one of the weakest backstops in baseball against the running game, with an abysmal 2.04-second average pop time that led to six fewer runners being caught than expected. Jeffers was similarly atrocious at stopping runners. It often felt like basestealers could run freely against the Twins. (Indeed, only two teams allowed more steals, and no team caught a lower percentage of runners in the attempt.) This was one of Minnesota’s more glaring shortcomings last season, functioning as a significant hindrance to the club’s ability to suppress runs. Caratini has never been able to effectively suppress base-stealing efforts. There’s no reason to believe he will suddenly be able to in 2027. As noted earlier, he’s also an offensive liability, but given his plus receiving skills, knack for reversing balls into strikes, and (arguably most importantly) $7-million price tag, the switch-hitting veteran is all but guaranteed to be the club’s primary catcher next Opening Day. Caratini catching four or five days a week is not ideal, particularly if he hits at a rate like last season's. (But things could be worse. At least they’re not paying J.T. Realmuto $15 million next season, right?) As things stand, Caratini will soon be the only catcher on Minnesota’s 40-man roster. Alex Jackson is still with the organization and under team control next season, but only if they take the proactive step of putting him back on the 40-man by the end of this month. I’d be content with the club entering next season with Jackson as Caratini’s backup. He performed well at the plate in 2026, hitting .304/.342/.406 (good for a 112 wRC+) over 73 plate appearances. The 30-year-old also had one of the best pop times last season, resulting in him being far better at suppressing the run game than Jeffers and Caratini. Caratini is far better at receiving, framing, and challenging than Jackson is. In theory, the tandem could function as counterbalances for one another. The damage of Caratini’s inability to suppress base runners is mitigated by that being Jackson’s strength, and vice versa. Unfortunately, that’s not how the sport works, in practice. Starting Caratini only against teams who don't run isn't realistic, and the Twins don't have enough pitchers who can live with a lesser receiver to lean on Jackson more often. (Nor, in all likelihood, would Jackson hit as well in a more regular, exposed role.) Caratini’s and Jackson’s shortcomings will remain on display until Lackey (an elite all-around catcher) takes over the position full-time. They're a tolerable stopgap, but the team could still aim higher. The only desirable non-Jeffers impending free agent catchers are Carson Kelly and Tyler Stephenson. Kelly is a far better option, but he will likely demand a multi-year contract, similar to what Caratini got last season. Stephenson is a better hitter than Caratini and Jackson and might be available on a one-year deal, or at least a low-risk, high-reward two-year pact. However, he's arguably the worst defender of the four, diminishing the impact of his just-above-average bat. I wouldn’t be against Minnesota pairing Stephenson with Caratini. He or Kelly could come in on a two-year deal and be the bridge's bridge, as it were, working in tandem with Caratini for 2027 and alongside Lackey in 2028, when Caratini's contract is up. Austin Hedges, James McCann, and Kyle Higashioka are also likely to be available, but the Twins might as well roll with Jackson, if they're considering any of those options. Five years after being the No. 1 overall pick in the MLB Draft, Pirates catcher Henry Davis could be available via trade. Of course, he has a Derek Shelton connection, having played under him for three seasons in Pittsburgh. Davis has yet to meet expectations at the plate, generating a career 55 wRC+ over 958 plate appearances. In fact, 2026 was his first positive-fWAR season in the majors, generating 0.6. The driving factor in his progression was that the 27-year-old was one of the best defensive catchers in baseball, being a plus receiver and near-elite run game suppressor. (He was slightly below-average at challenging.) His polished defensive skills make him an interesting target who could benefit from a change of scenery. Under team control until the end of the 2029 season, Davis could also tandem with Lackey, solidifying the position for years to come. The Twins probably wouldn’t have to surrender much prospect capital to acquire Davis, given his lackluster performance at the plate. Pittsburgh appears set at the position long-term, with Rafael Flores Jr. and Endy Rodriguez. Between veteran options in Kelly, Stephenson, Hedges, McCann, and Higashioka or team-controlled trade candidates in Davis, Luis Torrens, Carlos Narváez, or Austin Wells (especially if Jeffers signs with the Yankees), there are plenty of external options Minnesota could acquire. The Twins would be wise to invest in a higher-upside partner for Caratini than Jackson. Twins Territory should prepare for Caratini to make the bulk of starts behind the plate until Lackey’s highly-anticipated arrival. Maybe the wait will make the payoff a bit sweeter.
×
×
  • Create New...