Austin Martin's Incredible Start Has Disappeared in the Rearview Mirror

[Sam Caulder]

Image courtesy of © Mark J. Rebilas-Imagn Images

What a wild ride the 2026 season has been so far for Austin Martin. For about the first month and a half of the season, it looked like the Twins had unlocked the type of player they envisioned when they acquired him. Martin wasn't hitting for power, but that was never really the expectation. Instead, he was doing what he's always done best: putting the ball in play, controlling the strike zone, and finding ways to get on base.

Through May 14, Martin was hitting .333 with an absurd .454 on-base percentage. He was actually walking more often than he was striking out, and he owned a fantastic 155 wRC+. For a player whose game has always revolved around contact skills and plate discipline, those numbers were incredibly encouraging. He looked like one of the best hit-for-contact bats in baseball for that stretch, and it finally felt like everything was coming together.

And then it wasn’t. Since May 15, Martin has gone from one of the Twins' most productive hitters to someone who has been generating, quite frankly, unplayable offensive production. During that stretch, he's hitting just .157 with a .236 on-base percentage. And when you compare those two halves of his year to date, the differences are pretty staggering. His strikeout rate has jumped from 13.8% to 22.0%. His walk rate has been cut by more than half, dropping from 16.9% down to just 7.1%. His wRC+ has cratered, falling from 155 to just 40. And perhaps the most eye-opening number of all is his OPS, which has literally been cut in half. He went from an outstanding .882 OPS through May 14 to just .454 since then. That's an enormous swing in production over a relatively short period.

The current version of Austin Martin simply isn't playable offensively. Martin has never been someone who impacts the baseball consistently enough to survive long stretches without getting on base. His offensive value has always come from elite bat-to-ball skills, drawing walks, and putting pressure on defenses. When those things disappear, there just isn't much left offensively.

So what can the Twins actually do? Should Martin be optioned to Triple-A? Is he truly nothing more than a short-side platoon player? Those are fair questions to ask, especially if this slump continues. Even if Minnesota were to move him back into more of a platoon role against left-handed pitching, he'd still need to produce more than he has recently. Overall, Martin is hitting .268 against lefties this season, which is a perfectly respectable number by itself. But considering that average was sitting around .300 just a month ago, even that split has started trending in the wrong direction.

The Twins also have another option if they decide they need to press the reset button. I do think the minor league route has to at least be on the table. It's probably not the likeliest outcome, nor is it the preferred one, but Martin still has a minor-league option remaining. If the organization reaches a point where they feel everyday at-bats in Triple-A would benefit him more than sporadic major-league playing time, they have the flexibility to make that move.

If that were to happen, the Twins wouldn't exactly be left scrambling for another right-handed outfielder. Gabriel Gonzalez has already been shuffled around a bit this season and could be an easy right-handed replacement if Martin were optioned. Gonzalez has also been swinging the bat much better over the past month, making him a legitimate alternative should Minnesota decide to make a roster change. That's certainly something worth keeping an eye on if Martin's struggles continue.

At the same time, nothing drastic needs to happen right this second. Martin isn't being forced into everyday playing time, and there's still a very real chance that this is simply a month-long cold stretch during what could end up being a solid season. Baseball seasons are long, and players go through stretches like this all the time. But eventually, there does come a point where you can't continue giving someone at-bats if they aren't hitting.

That's the balancing act the Twins are going to have to navigate over the next few weeks, because Martin is an extremely talented hitter when he's right. We already saw exactly what he's capable of during the season's first month and a half, when he looked like one of the better contact hitters in the American League. Now, the Twins just have to figure out whether that version of Martin is still in there, or whether a brief stint in Triple-A is the best way to help him find it again.

View full article

[HeresWaldo]

Martin is a perfectly usable bench piece and I have no problem with them having given him a shot at a bigger role when there weren't better options available and he was playing well, but I don't think his decline is at all surprising. March/April OPS was .899 but his BABIP .373 and his ISO was only .109. An .899 OPS driven by lucky singles and hustle doubles was never going to be sustainable, so the fact he fell off isn't at all surprising. 

I still like him as a platoon bench bat / utility player / pinch runner, but it's not surprising he didn't work out as a regular given this offensive profile and limited defensive value outside corner outfield spots. I suspect this is probably where Keashall ends up as well for much the same reasons, although hopefully he can offer a bit more value in right/right matchups. 

[thelanges5]

I’m glad they’ve given Martin the playing time so that we could learn some things about him.

He’s played a better defense in the outfield than I thought he would.

He’s over exposed as an everyday player. .780 OPS vs LHP; .587 OPS vs RHP

Not as good on the base paths as one would think given his speed.

He can be a useful platoon bat, defensive sub. 

One of Martin or Fedko should go down to bring Roden up, IMO

[LA Vikes Fan]

Agree with all of this, but I think you have to let this play out a little longer. You expect younger players to have peaks and valleys in their first full season. Having said that, Martin had a very high peak last two months of 2025 and the first month and 1/2 2026, and has had an incredibly deep valley until about a week ago. In the last seven games, he's had 16 ABs and is hitting .313/.353/.313, with only 1 strike out but only 1 walk. I think what really happened is that pitchers have realized that even if they throw him a mistake, he's not going to hurt them too badly. A middle middle fastball might get hit for a double but not a homerun, and most other hittable pitches are singles. If I am pitching to him I go ahead and challenge him, particularly if no one is on base. That's going to limit his ability to walk, which limits his OBP, and limits his value. Still, he is getting better again so I would let this play out a little longer. Keep in mind he is the second demotion from the outfield, Fedko goes before he goes since Fedko has shown to date that he cannot hit major league pitching.

I think the timing is dependent on when and if Jeffers is coming back and how long we intend to keep him when he does before he is traded. Fedko is still on the roster give us someone to easily demote when Jeffers is activated. Jackson is out of options and will not survive waivers given how many catching injuries there have been and how desperate teams are for passable backup catchers. Sandy Leon had an MLB job for a month for goodness sakes. We want to keep Jackson to be the backup catcher once Jeffers is traded. I do think it's a fair question whether we should demote Martin in favor of Alan Roden. I suspect the team is waiting until they have a better read on when Jeffers will be ready and on whether we have any significant injuries before the ASB that would create an opportunity for Roden. 

My view would be DFA Gray, move Kreider to the full time SS spot, and call up Roden to play RF against RH pitching and CF every day Buxton sits. Fedko almost never plays until Jeffers comes back and then he is demoted to AAA. By then, hopefully we have some read on whether Roden is ready and can contribute and at what level, which then makes it easier to know what to do with Martin. Martin can be anything from a a guy who takes the old James Outman pinch runner/defensive replacement role, to that with a little more occasional OF start and pinch-hitting duties, to a short side platoon player, to a guy you make a longer run commitment to to work through his slump. Yes, then we don't really have a backup SS other than Lee but he was as good at SS as Gray is now so that really isn't a downgrade. What about Wallner you say? He comes up if and only if Bell is gone. Wallner is a DH who occasionally plays in the field. That role is currently taken.

[Linus]

His greatest offensive skill is drawing walks. Pitchers are simply making him swing the bat and it doesn’t look good. I’m a little surprised it took this long. 

[mickster]

Fedko will go after the NY series and Roden can come up.   Martin may be the one moving down when Jeffers is ready

[Blyleven2011]

Really enjoyed watching him in that month and a half ...

Yes , yes he really is not that same player who started the season hot ...

What is the cause , anything is possible  , pitchers made adjustments  OR  and it’s my opinion that when he was switched to the rightfield position his hitting suffered immediately ....

Could be just a coincidence but something disrupted his hitting ...

[RpR]

19 minutes ago, Blyleven2011 said:

Really enjoyed watching him in that month and a half ...

Yes , yes he really is not that same player who started the season hot ...

What is the cause , anything is possible  , pitchers made adjustments  OR  and it’s my opinion that when he was switched to the rightfield position his hitting suffered immediately ....

Could be just a coincidence but something disrupted his hitting ...

Could be another Jose Miranda, BUT, Miranda was hit by a pitch that probably ruined his career, whereas, Martin could just be another Julien who cannot adjust to the other teams changing how they pitch him.

[ashbury]

A player is never as good as he seems when he's going well, and never as bad as he seems when things are down.

In his first 24 games (72 plate appearances) Martin's OPS was .995.  His batting average on balls in play was .415.

Since then in 53 games (185 PA) his OPS has been .549 but his BABIP has been only .258.

.300 has been a good rule of thumb for BABIP for a long time, but more precisely it's been more like .290 across the majors lately (.289 this season so far).

I never call BABIP "luck."  You put the ball in play and sometimes the fielders catch it and sometimes they don't but in every case the players are trying their best so it's nothing like rolling dice or dealing cards.  Some batters maintain a high BABIP throughout their careers (Joe Mauer's was .341), likewise some pitchers can keep it low (Kershaw .275)  so I consider it a certain sort of skill that is measurable.  But it can represent an ebb and flow to the game until the sample size is large enough to stabilize.  

So for the season as a whole Martin's OPS is .664 and it's built on a BABIP of .295. which doesn't look too far outside the norms.  BABIP has been an up and down factor in our perceptions of him all along the way this season, but overall it's at a level you might expect to remain stable now, though his prior two partial seasons had a BABIP more like .320 so maybe he's still got some upward movement coming to him.  But his season numbers are probably about who he is at the present time.  He could improve in ways outside of BABIP (cutting down Ks, raising BBs or HRs), but is getting kind of old for that kind of expectation.  He is who he is by now.

[CRF]

He's just fine as a backup. No way is he an every day player. 

[NYCTK]

His bat is exactly what we thought it was going to be two seasons ago. The only surprise with Martin was that he was able to prove himself a competent outfielder, enough so that he can be counted on to cover CF for a few innings. 

 

[BillyBallLives]

And thus, the verdict is finally in on the Berrios trade.

Another swing and a miss.

Btw, SWR was placed on Waivers by Tor. He cleared and is stuck in Buffalo now. Not even on the 40 man roster. 
 

[stringer bell]

I think I might have been tge biggest Martin fan on this site, but tge numbers are the numbers. He’s become a good defensive corner outfielder, with good speed and contact skills. He hasn’t hit well enough to garner full-time playing time and his value on the bases hasn’t been substantial despite the aforementioned good speed.

A pretty good 13th position player on a good team? Maybe, but not someone to build around or invest at-bats. Martin is good in left and right and hasn’t played an inning of infield this year, so I wouldn’t classify him as versatile.