Jump to content
Twins Daily
  • Create Account

Recommended Posts

Posted

In a surprising development, news broke Tuesday that Ryan Jeffers had decided to accept the qualifying offer extended to him by the Minnesota Twins. Jeffers will return to Minnesota for the 2027 season on a one-year, $23.15-million contract, giving the Twins their starting catcher for another season and keeping one of their most productive offensive players in the fold.

While there is plenty to discuss about Jeffers's decision and what it means for the Twins moving forward, his return also creates another interesting question for the front office. With Jeffers back behind the plate, should the Twins start looking for a trade partner for backup catcher Victor Caratini?

When the Twins signed Caratini to a two-year, $14-million contract last offseason, the plan seemed straightforward. Caratini would serve as Jeffers's backup in 2026 before taking over as the starting catcher in 2027, when Jeffers was expected to depart in free agency. The contract was also structured to backload the money, with Caratini earning $4 million in 2026 before accounting for a $10-million commitment in 2027, including his $3.5 million buyout on a 2028 option. He was coming off back-to-back seasons of above-average offensive production and offered the Twins a switch-hitting catcher who could provide some stability behind the plate. Unfortunately, his first season in Minnesota did not go according to plan.

Caratini posted a 78 OPS+, one of the worst offensive seasons of his career, and things got even worse down the stretch. He recorded a .461 OPS in the second half. Defensively, he struggled to control the running game, finishing with a -6 Caught Stealing Above Average, tied for the second-worst mark in the league. (Jeffers finished with the same mark.)

Despite those struggles, Caratini was still expected to have a prominent role in Minnesota next season. With Jeffers assumed to be headed for free agency, the Twins couldn't realistically afford to move on from Caratini, as well. Doing so would have left them without a catcher on their major-league roster, forcing the front office to find two new players to fill the position. Caratini might not have been an ideal starting option, but keeping him around gave the Twins much-needed stability.

With Jeffers accepting the qualifying offer and returning for 2027, that situation has changed. The Twins suddenly have their starting catcher back, making Caratini's $10-million commitment much harder to justify. There are three reasons why the Twins should explore finding a trade partner for the veteran catcher.

First, the financial commitment at catcher is untenable. Between Jeffers's $23.15 million qualifying offer and Caratini's $10 million commitment for 2027, the Twins are currently allocating $33.15 million to the position. For a team that operated with a payroll of approximately $110 million last season, that represents nearly 30% of its entire payroll. While all indications are that the payroll will increase from the embarrassingly low number the Twins operated with in 2026, $33.15 million is still an enormous investment in two players at the same position, particularly when one is coming off a disappointing season and would be relegated to a backup role.

The Twins have plenty of other needs to address this offseason, particularly when it comes to improving their bullpen and adding some additional offensive firepower. Finding a way to move Caratini's contract would give the front office another $10 million to work with. If the Twins could turn that money into a legitimate late-inning reliever or a meaningful upgrade to their lineup depth, that would provide considerably more value than paying Caratini $10 million to serve as Jeffers' backup.

Second, the Twins have enough organizational catching depth to find a less expensive alternative. The original purpose of the two-year contract was to give Minnesota a veteran who could transition into the starting role once Jeffers departed. With Jeffers now back, that need has disappeared. Instead, the Twins can look internally for someone to fill the backup role. They have some intriguing catching depth in the organization, including Noah Cardenas, Khadim Diaw and Vahn Lackey, the third overall pick in the 2026 MLB Draft.

Obviously, none of those players should be expected to immediately replace Jeffers as the everyday catcher. However, the Twins don't need another everyday catcher. Assuming Jeffers stays healthy, he should handle about two-thirds of the team's games behind the plate, leaving around 50 to 60 starts for a backup. That is a much easier role to fill internally than trying to find someone capable of handling a full season as the starting catcher. If the Twins aren't confident any of their internal options are ready to start the season, there are always veteran catchers available on minor-league contracts who could fill the role until someone proves ready. (It's only fair to note, though, that Jeffers has never caught more than 88 games in a season, so it would be wise to plan on 65 or 70 games going to whoever inherits the role. That's probably the right number to plan to fill behind any given catcher, understanding the injury risk at the position, but Jeffers certainly isn't someone you can count on more than an average backstop.)

Lackey is particularly interesting because he has the potential to become the next standout catcher in Minnesota's organization. While he won't be ready to take over a significant role immediately, there is a possibility he could work his way into the picture during the second half of the season. Keeping Caratini around could create an unnecessary obstacle for Lackey to break into the major leagues, something we saw last year, when an overcrowded outfield delayed the debut of Walker Jenkins.

Finally, Jeffers's decision to return to Minnesota could actually increase Caratini's trade value. While Caratini might not have much value coming off his disappointing season, the supply of available catchers in free agency just got smaller. With Jeffers no longer available, teams looking for help behind the plate have fewer options, creating more interest in a veteran like Caratini. He might not be coming off a season that inspires much confidence, but he does have a track record of above-average offensive production and could appeal to a team looking for an experienced catcher.

Before Jeffers accepted his qualifying offer, he was one of the more attractive catchers in free agency. Now that he's off the market, the top remaining options are Carson Kelly and Tyler Stephenson. Both could be upgrades for teams looking for a starting catcher, but neither comes without questions. After those two, the options become considerably less exciting. Austin Hedges, Kyle Higashioka and James McCann are among the other veteran catchers available.

The Twins shouldn't expect to receive a significant prospect return for Caratini, especially with the money remaining on his contract. However, they don't need to get anything for him, directly. If they could find a team willing to take on the money, that would be a meaningful victory. Even if the Twins have to eat a portion of the contract to get a deal done, the opportunity to redirect some of that money toward another roster need is worth exploring.

Jeffers accepting the qualifying offer was a welcome development, but it also creates an opportunity for the front office to rethink its plans at catcher. Caratini was a reasonable investment when the expectation was that Jeffers would be leaving Minnesota. Now that Jeffers is back, the veteran catcher feels like an unwise use of resources.

Between the financial commitment, the organizational depth behind Jeffers and the limited options available on the free-agent market, the Twins should at least explore what they could get for Caratini. There's no guarantee they'll find a taker, but freeing up even a portion of his contract could make a meaningful difference in how they approach the rest of the offseason.


What do you think? Should the Twins prioritize trading Victor Caratini now that Ryan Jeffers is returning, or would you prefer to keep the veteran catcher around as insurance behind the plate? Leave a comment below and start the conversation!

Image courtesy of Jesse Johnson-Imagn Images

View full article

Posted
6 minutes ago, thelanges5 said:

Doubt they can dump the entire $10m.  Even if they pay down 1/2 that gives back some $$ to use on a better bat or LH reliever. They should absolutely be calling 29 other teams today. 

It would give them enough money to sign Gary Sanchez or one of the other backup catcher options. 
 

They have to find someone to take the whole contract or they will receive no benefit.

Posted

I'm not sure the needle of trading Caratini and signing a competent backup to Jeffers is worth threading.

I'm working under the assumption that the Twins will have to eat at least $4M of Caratini's 2027 owed money. If they can get out from under all of it, then you absolutely do it, but that doesn't seem realistic.

So, if the Twins have to eat $4M, that means they save $6M. Great. But then they still need to sign a backup catcher. And probably a backup, that you don't totally mind being pushed into a bigger role at times if inevitable catcher injuries happen. How much is that going to cost? $3M at least, right? So now you're netting out a savings of $3M. 

All that maneuvering just doesn't seem worth it to save $3M. Are there scenarios that it WOULD be worth it? Sure. But even though I really wish Caratini wasn't under contract, I'd still rather dance with that devil that I know.

Now... If we snagged Campusano from San Diego (2M in arb and 2 years of team control), then I'd eat as much money as necessary to move on from Caratini.

Posted

Don't understand the Caratini hate or the rush to get rid of him.

Jeffers can be counted on to catch maybe half the games and he looked like he wore down as they played him more frequently later in the year, so somebody else needs to catch the other half. Caratini was a fine defensive catcher last year. If he's dumped, a replacement would need to come from outside the organization.

There are no internal candidates. You mentioned Cardenas, but he's Sandy Leon light, available just in case of emergency. Diaw could be up in 2027, depending on how his defense improves between now and season opening, but as of now nobody would want to see Diaw catching in MLB. And bringing Lackey to the majors in 2027 would mean that he went through the minors two years faster than Adley Rutschmann, a better talent, which seems rash and a good way to damage his development.

If you think there's a reasonable replacement who can catch and hit as well as Caratini who is available for less money, then, sure, get that player and dump Caratini. If not, look elsewhere for improving the team.

Posted

I'm not against moving Caratini. It makes sense to try and do so. But unless someone is desperate for a veteran behind the plate, nobody is going to take him with a $10M commitment. So the Twins have to pay down at least half, I'd guess, which means we eat $5M but save $5M. 

But hold on, we need to sign someone for about $2M minimum to be our #2 catcher. So best case scenario, we save around $3M to be spent elsewhere. 

I'll take the $3M to be spent elsewhere, but IF they can move Caratini, it's not going to be for some $10M financial windfall. 

Posted

At the moment, Caratini does not appear to be blocking anyone. The critical question though is how much cash is the theoretical production difference between Caratini and Diaw or Cardenas worth?

Asked another way: would you rather have a) Caratini and his production for 1/3 of the games plus the insurance if Jeffers gets hurt for $10MM or Diaw/Cardenas for those games at $1MM plus two decent FA RPs (assuming we can get the whole $10MM back)?

The decision cannot be made without knowing how much is truly available and how all in the Twins are in ‘27.

For example, if the budget is $160MM you keep Caratini.

If the budget is less, would you rather have Lewis, Larnach and/or Ober over Caratini?  Probably not.  So maybe JZ starts with those three.

Caratini may or may not get traded.  But that decision likely has not been made yet and will depend on other factors. 

Posted

Is Caratini expendable? Not really. there's nobody in the system that can step in & be a tandem catcher. My only hope is that Cardenas can step up & be a 3rd catcher. Can he be substituted outside the system? The answer to that is yes. Caratini is on the long list of FA bad deals. Can you find someone who will take over his salary, in trade? I doubt it, unless they are willing to eat a good chunk of it, but you never know. It's worth a try. We can find more economical & better options. Will trading Caratini really affect the salary bind? I don't think so.

Posted
11 minutes ago, Nashvilletwin said:

If the budget is less, would you rather have Lewis, Larnach and/or Ober over Caratini?  Probably not.  So maybe JZ starts with those three.

The gap between Caratini and the people behind him on the depth chart is muuuch greater than the gap between Lewis, Larnach, and Ober and the people behind them.

It's too bad the Twins traded Daniel Susac last year when they drafted him in the Rule V. He's a perfect backup catcher: great defense, OK hitting, salary under $1M. He helped San Francisco decide to move on from Bailey. But in true Twins fashion, they preferred a big power, poor defense complex league catcher instead.

Posted

You don't save much money, and the only way you end up actually saving money is by replacing him with a C who is probably worse.  They clearly don't believe Jackson is the guy (getting DFA'd late last year), and Caratini was worth 1.0 WAR as a C last year (he was a bit better hitting as C than otherwise so this is a bit optimistic).

There are not 60 guys who are capable of being a not-horrible hitter who can actually play C.

Posted

Caratini was exactly who he has been for most of his career - a capable, non starting average catcher who has the ability/tendency to "get hot" 1x a season, which is what he did LY. Giving him starting duties behind the plate or at 1B is not the strength and whether we were forced into it due to injury or Bell's inability to be anything more than a statue at 1B, the Twins overextended his usage.

Caratini has traditionally been his "best" playing about 25% less than he did. Entering Y10, the regression was alarming, but again he was overextended. However, a $10MM backup who is average at best behind the plate is an expensive price to pay. Hopefully they'll find a taker, but the Twins would have to eat a minimum of 35% of the contract potentially (or you have to attach a low level "prospect", which they won't do). It would be completely different if he was an elite defensive backstop, which he is not. Falvey missed on the signing, I would be thankful he doesn't have 2 years left. Even if they eat $3MM and sign someone like Jackson for $1MM, the potential $6MM in savings would allow them to sign someone along the lines of Minter. 

Posted
6 minutes ago, DataNerd said:

You don't save much money, and the only way you end up actually saving money is by replacing him with a C who is probably worse.  They clearly don't believe Jackson is the guy (getting DFA'd late last year), and Caratini was worth 1.0 WAR as a C last year (he was a bit better hitting as C than otherwise so this is a bit optimistic).

There are not 60 guys who are capable of being a not-horrible hitter who can actually play C.

There may be some backup C's at lower salaries who may be available for the right trade, such as Jimmy Crooks, Freddy Fermin, Drew Millas, and Henry Davis, but the prospects required to acquire them could actually be worth MORE than the prospect you would get for Caratini, unless the Twins are willing to eat a good deal of his salary, in which case the savings could go way down, and they would really be rolling the dice about whether they will be as good as Caratini.

That said, I'd be OK if they traded Caratini and acquired Fermin or Davis for a marginal loss of prospect value and little payroll savings, to get better defense, but people will be really unhappy with their hitting and such a swap is easier said than done.

Maybe JZ can talk PIT into a 1:1 swap of Caratini for Davis.

Posted

Caratini is expendable from our cheap seat view, but it is pretty clear that Shelton likes him.  He played Caratini almost constantly when Jeffers was hurt, even though Alex Jackson was molding on the bench.

There will be less expensive backup catcher options available, but I'll wager Shelton is going to lobby to keep Caratini (and probably will use him a lot).

Posted

Let's not forget one of the claimed virtues of signing Caratini last year: his versatility at being able to play a couple of positions. Versatility was a high value of the Twins during the Falvey era. And just like all other versatile players, Caratini is a jack of all trades, master of none - although he may be decent at catching. Hopefully, that stubborn misconception of Twins management went out the door with Falvey, along with

  • valuing power over contact and defense,
  • pinch hitting in the third or fourth inning to maintain a platoon advantage,
  • believing that if you built a bullpen once you can do it again easy-peasy,
  • thinking you have some magical health formula that will prevent pitchers who were injured elsewhere from getting injured with the Twins, and
  • thinking you have some magical hitting formula that makes you think that hitters who have struggled elsewhere for a few years will again be good with the Twins.
Posted

Caratini is worth somewhere close to his contract. The issue is he's not actually expendable just because the Twins are way overpaying Jeffers.

The Twins still need 2 catchers on opening day, even if you think Lackey or Tinney will be ready mid year. Jeffers won't start more than 100ish games, even with an abnormal workload.

Posted
2 hours ago, MeleMouth said:

Don't understand the Caratini hate or the rush to get rid of him.

Jeffers can be counted on to catch maybe half the games and he looked like he wore down as they played him more frequently later in the year, so somebody else needs to catch the other half. Caratini was a fine defensive catcher last year. If he's dumped, a replacement would need to come from outside the organization.

There are no internal candidates. You mentioned Cardenas, but he's Sandy Leon light, available just in case of emergency. Diaw could be up in 2027, depending on how his defense improves between now and season opening, but as of now nobody would want to see Diaw catching in MLB. And bringing Lackey to the majors in 2027 would mean that he went through the minors two years faster than Adley Rutschmann, a better talent, which seems rash and a good way to damage his development.

If you think there's a reasonable replacement who can catch and hit as well as Caratini who is available for less money, then, sure, get that player and dump Caratini. If not, look elsewhere for improving the team.

Both Jeffers and Caratini had difficulty with holding runners, both were pretty adept at using the challenge system in 2026. (Will be different this year.) 

 

Perhaps the reason is that our pitching staff does a lousy job of holding runners on base. 

Posted

Do you really believe the Twins can trade Caratini without retaining a large chunk of his salary, probably closer to more than two-thirds than the amounts discussed? 

Second question, who is going to be the backup?  The names mentioned are barely acceptable as the emergency third catcher to come up and sit on the bench should Jeffers or Caratini be injured.  None of them are remotely capable of being a backup who plays even a quarter of the games on a team who wants to contend.  

After those two questions are answered, it is easy to understand why Caratini will be with the Twins in 2027.

Posted

2 other thoughts

1) Jeffers and the family may really love Minnesota. It's not always about chasing the money and uprooting your family.

2) The market may not have materialized for any number of reasons. If teams hypothetically weren't willing to give Jeffers something like a 4/$60MM (an easy $15MM #), but the belief is he could get a Vasquez type 3/$30 in '28, he's economically foolish not to take the QO. If those numbers are even in the ballpark, over 4 years his AAV is over $13MM. If you're betting on yourself, it's a no brainer for him to take it. 

Posted
39 minutes ago, Patzky said:

Both Jeffers and Caratini had difficulty with holding runners,... 

Perhaps the reason is that our pitching staff does a lousy job of holding runners on base. 

The Toronto Blue Jays gave up the most stolen bases in the majors last season, 145.  That's less than one stolen base per game.  The Mets gave up the fewest, 69.  Our Twins were closer to worst than best, but the difference between them and the best was still about half a base per game.

Meanwhile the Reds were the worst in the majors at giving up walks, 688, while the Rays were stingiest at 409.  That's an extra baserunner and a half per game, worst to best.

Base hits ranged from 1635 (Rockies) down to 1159 (Dodgers), almost 3 extra baserunners between those extremes.

The room for improvement in other areas makes SB prevention a minor priority in my book.  The numbers don't say anybody is running wild, anywhere in the majors.  Sure, you want to be the best, but the payoff there is really small.

Posted
2 hours ago, DocBauer said:

I'm not against moving Caratini. It makes sense to try and do so. But unless someone is desperate for a veteran behind the plate, nobody is going to take him with a $10M commitment. So the Twins have to pay down at least half, I'd guess, which means we eat $5M but save $5M. 

But hold on, we need to sign someone for about $2M minimum to be our #2 catcher. So best case scenario, we save around $3M to be spent elsewhere. 

I'll take the $3M to be spent elsewhere, but IF they can move Caratini, it's not going to be for some $10M financial windfall. 

Blaming Spider-Man GIF

Posted
4 hours ago, DJL44 said:

It would give them enough money to sign Gary Sanchez or one of the other backup catcher options. 
 

They have to find someone to take the whole contract or they will receive no benefit.

This comment made me think...Hey a guy I will always think of as a Yankee actually got a ring. Congratz Gary!

If they have to pay it down to make a trade happen, I just don't see the value in it. I could be wrong, but I don't think the catching situation was the problem last season. 1st half the BP and defense cost them way too many games. 2nd half the offence was a dumpster fire and the whole pitching staff seem to run out of gas.

Reallocating maybe 5 mil elsewhere. I'd roll with the two we have.

Posted

The underlying premise of the article appears to be focused on money. Does Caratini take up too much of the roster budget? The answer is almost entirely tied to an unknown. What is the budget.

The roster sits at around $142-149M according to whatever sources one chooses. If the budget is to rest at the TD Blueprint of $135M, the Twins have some pruning to do and finding a home for Caratini, even if it means paying up to half his contract, is on the table. That changes entirely if the final resting number for the payroll sits at $175M or a little bit higher. The numbers can be the clue to what happens next.

If people are more focused on switching out Caratini for someone else because they perceive that ol' Victor is not productive enough, that requires a different set of moves. In that case the Twins are closing on two transactions at virtually the same time. One sends Caratini somewhere and the Twins eat a portion of his contract, say $4M. Two, the Twins acquire a catcher to back up Jeffers, focusing primarily on defense. There are catchers to add in that case. I think Henry Davis can be acquired for a small price. San Diego would likely agree to a swap of Freddy Fermin for Dean Kremer and something else (Wallner, Martin, Larnach). 

Is it money or the player? Do you keep Victor if money is not a criteria? Do you want a different back up catcher?

Posted

I still think Caratini will be better than he showed last year.  From 2023-26 his OPS+ ran 98 - 111 - 102 - 77 so a bounce back to average is very plausible. The thing about him is he does go through stretches where he's a good hitter, and most of the names proposed to replace him do not. I think his ABS skills are more important than framing skills, and some of that baserunning fault lies with pitchers.  If the new pitching coach can convince anyone to keep an eye on first that could get better too.  There are much biggest fish to fry than who the backup catcher is, so Vic will do just fine.

Posted
44 minutes ago, Cris E said:

I still think Caratini will be better than he showed last year.  From 2023-26 his OPS+ ran 98 - 111 - 102 - 77 so a bounce back to average is very plausible. The thing about him is he does go through stretches where he's a good hitter, and most of the names proposed to replace him do not. I think his ABS skills are more important than framing skills, and some of that baserunning fault lies with pitchers.  If the new pitching coach can convince anyone to keep an eye on first that could get better too.  There are much biggest fish to fry than who the backup catcher is, so Vic will do just fine.

The first thing I noticed about Caratini is that he seemed like a professional. 

His hitting results were less than what would be predicted based on how he hit the ball. Interestingly, his K/W rates, exit velocity, barrel and hard hit rates were similar to what he did in 2019, when he had a wRC+ of 106. That isn't a prediction, because other stats can be found that show he was trending down last year, but the main point is that odds are that he will be a better hitter in 2027 than he was in 2026.

Also, and I've posted this before: many defensive stats show that Caratini was a slightly above-median defensive catcher in 2026. That doesn't make him elite, but it makes him fine. It would be great to have elite and sure, you can find things where he's below average, but that's looking at a tree instead of the forest, which shows that overall he was fine.

Posted
6 hours ago, MeleMouth said:

There may be some backup C's at lower salaries who may be available for the right trade, such as Jimmy Crooks, Freddy Fermin, Drew Millas, and Henry Davis, but the prospects required to acquire them could actually be worth MORE than the prospect you would get for Caratini, unless the Twins are willing to eat a good deal of his salary, in which case the savings could go way down, and they would really be rolling the dice about whether they will be as good as Caratini.

That said, I'd be OK if they traded Caratini and acquired Fermin or Davis for a marginal loss of prospect value and little payroll savings, to get better defense, but people will be really unhappy with their hitting and such a swap is easier said than done.

Maybe JZ can talk PIT into a 1:1 swap of Caratini for Davis.

I like the idea of Henry Davis as well. Don’t know what it would take but there is some upside that makes this more than run of the mill backup scenario. 

Posted
10 minutes ago, Linus said:

I like the idea of Henry Davis as well. Don’t know what it would take but there is some upside that makes this more than run of the mill backup scenario. 

"Hello Mr. Pittsburgh GM, you need better offense. How would you like a catcher with better offense than your defense-first backup?" 

Posted

Well, the question of money seems to have been answered. There is money.

The second question remains - Do the Twins belieive they need a different or better backup catcher than Victor Caratini? If the answer is yes, Freddy Fermin may be a good acquisition. Kremer-Fermin likely works. The Twins would need to trade Caratini first though. 

I think the Twins keep Victor, but we shall see.

Create an account or sign in to comment

You need to be a member in order to leave a comment

Create an account

Sign up for a new account in our community. It's easy!

Register a new account

Sign in

Already have an account? Sign in here.

Sign In Now
The Twins Daily Caretaker Fund
The Twins Daily Caretaker Fund

You all care about this site. The next step is caring for it. We’re asking you to caretake this site so it can remain the premier Twins community on the internet.

×
×
  • Create New...