Jump to content
Twins Daily
  • Create Account

DataNerd

Verified Member
  • Posts

    275
  • Joined

  • Last visited

DataNerd's Achievements

  1. While Lowe is the best guy, I think he fits the team worse than the next 3. He and Lee both struggle against LHP, he's the oldest, and he would cost us a pick and maybe the most $.
  2. I know it's not your list, but how is Chisolm 17 and Torres 18? In the last 3 years, Jazz's worst year was 3.5 fWAR while Gleybar's best was 2.5. I'd put Jazz in the tier with Arraez/Sato and would be very happy if he was their only major hitter signing.
  3. The twins gave up a 27 yr old hitter who we were hoping could return to how good he was in 2023 for a 27 yr old pitcher we are hoping can return to how good he was in 2023.
  4. LAD had already done this, so 99% sure he won't be pitching more than 2IP in a game this year.
  5. Burger was listed as a non-tender candidate on a MLB show, and some TEX fans don't want him tendered, so it's probably a fair swap. Larnach has more defensive versatility and is probably the better player, but 2 years of Burger (next year will be questionable tender decision) vs 1 for Larnach
  6. We would be getting something pretty good for Ryan, potentially a good 1B or top RP.
  7. 2 year deals aren't a huge risk. Even if he disappoints this year, he'd still be a decent option for a 5th SP as a bounce back bet. Years are way riskier than AAV
  8. Would be shocked if nobody was a taker, He ranked 41st/279 hitters with 200PA against RHP in wRC+ last year, that's not a guy that you can find in the bargain bin.
  9. I don't think this ends up happening. There will also be teams needing to cut, so the simple solution is the teams cutting trade bad players to the teams that need to add salary and give them prospects in return. You would also have a FA class where the LAD/NYY of the world aren't signing any of the top guys. Also, in most floor systems you don't actually get penalized for being under the floor, the contracts just auto-scale up to meet the floor (a team that spends 80M against a floor of 160M would pay someone with a 5M contract 10M).
  10. For those 2, I think it's mostly about the money, but the idea of the Twins competing next year isn't insane. 4 teams the past 30 years had a worse record than us and won the WS the next year. The 22 Rangers and 12 Red Sox won under 70 games and then won it all the next year. We lose nothing critical, add Gray and have Jenkins/Culpepper who are both ROY candidates. It's not the reason they are signing, but I think they are going to sell the team post-lockout and having a competitive team will be slightly more appetizing for a buyer.
  11. 1: Wow. 2: If nothing else happens with the rotation, not sure that I like this move. Currently would have Abel/Prielipp both out, even without Ober. Feel like 1 of Lopez/Ryan/Kremer is getting traded and Ober DFA'd or traded for peanuts.
  12. You don't save much money, and the only way you end up actually saving money is by replacing him with a C who is probably worse. They clearly don't believe Jackson is the guy (getting DFA'd late last year), and Caratini was worth 1.0 WAR as a C last year (he was a bit better hitting as C than otherwise so this is a bit optimistic). There are not 60 guys who are capable of being a not-horrible hitter who can actually play C.
  13. The 5-year range drags that down a bit, including his 86 wRC+ season when he was 25, but I agree with the overall point. If he can repeat his offense last year for a full-year at 1B, he's a 3 WAR guy. Not a ton of upside, and there are a lot of ifs needed to get there, which is why if someone wants to give him 4 years at >60M I'm fine letting him walk.
  14. Steamer currently has Holmes projected for 1.6 fWAR, while Kremer is at 1.4, Prielipp 1.3. Signing him for his age 34,35, and probably 36 seasons when he's never been an amazing pitcher seems like the type of deal that often blows up immediately and then you are stuck with a guy who isn't good, and he doesn't really make our rotation nearly enough better for the cost.
  15. If you ignore money, this is easily correct. Pick ~30 is a bit over 3+ expected WAR, ~75 is 1.6. I don't think you can ignore money though, and if we have the choice of Jeffers or Arraez/Chisolm + Pick, I'm easily taking the 2B+Pick. Also could let Jeffers go, sign Lowe and we end up gaining pick 30 but losing 50 for a free 20 spots (1 WAR).
×
×
  • Create New...