Jump to content
Twins Daily
  • Create Account

Recommended Posts

Posted

The Minnesota Twins extended a qualifying offer to catcher Ryan Jeffers, giving him the opportunity to return on a one-year, $23.15-million contract. As expected, Jeffers plans to decline that offer, according to Bobby Nightengale of the Minnesota Star Tribune. He enters the offseason as the top catcher available, putting him in a strong position to secure a multi-year contract.

Minnesota remains interested in bringing Jeffers back, but there's another factor complicating those efforts. Because Jeffers received a qualifying offer, the Twins would receive draft pick compensation if he signs with another organization. That compensation could become a significant part of the team's offseason strategy, especially for a lower-payroll team looking to add young talent through the draft.

The biggest number to watch is $50 million. Where Jeffers lands financially will determine when Minnesota receives its compensatory selection. While the Twins would certainly welcome a reunion, they also have to consider the value of the draft pick they could receive if he signs elsewhere.

If Jeffers Signs for More Than $50 Million

If Jeffers secures a contract worth more than $50 million, the Twins will receive a compensatory selection after the first round of the MLB Draft. Its associated slot value could reach approximately $3 million to $3.5 million. That represents a meaningful opportunity for the Twins to add another talented prospect without surrendering any additional assets.

For a franchise that needs to continue developing young talent, a pick in this range can provide flexibility. Minnesota could use the selection on a promising high school or college player, adding another potential contributor to its farm system.

A contract exceeding $50 million would essentially give the Twins a better return for losing one of their established major-league players. Jeffers deserves to maximize his earning potential, but Minnesota would benefit from seeing him reach that financial threshold, too. Since they're likely to receive a competitive-balance pick in Round A (after the compensatory picks but before the start of the second round), if Jeffers signs for at least $50 million, the Twins will probably have three picks in the top 40 next July—an enviable position that would let them move money around and build a stronger class than their first pick's position would imply.

If Jeffers Signs for Less Than $50 Million

The alternative is considerably less appealing for Minnesota. If Jeffers signs a contract worth less than $50 million, the Twins won't receive their compensatory selection until after Competitive Balance Round B. That pushes the selection much deeper into the draft and reduces its overall financial value.

The difference between the two potential selections is substantial. Instead of receiving a pick with a slot value potentially reaching $3 million to $3.5 million, Minnesota would be looking at a selection worth approximately $1 million to $1.5 million, and they'd have about 40 fewer players from whom to choose.

That is still an opportunity to add another prospect, but it represents a significant drop in draft capital. The difference could determine whether Minnesota has access to a higher-end prospect or needs to take a different approach when selecting a player.

This's why the $50 million threshold matters so much. Jeffers signing for $49 million instead of $51 million could create a dramatically different outcome for the Twins. Many national outlets have estimated that he will receive a three- or four-year deal with a range from $45-$75 million. FanGraphs and The Athletic have him earning under the $50 million threshold, while ESPN and MLB Trade Rumors have him hitting the over. 

What It Means for the Twins

There are several possible outcomes for Minnesota as Jeffers navigates free agency. The best-case scenario is a reunion on a reasonable multi-year contract. In fact, Minnesota could try and set the market for Jeffers by offering him $50 million on a three-year deal. The Twins know what he brings behind the plate and offensively, and retaining an established starting catcher would provide some stability at an important position.

However, if Jeffers receives a contract that pushes beyond $50 million, Minnesota would at least receive a valuable draft selection in return for his departure. That could help replenish a farm system that needs additional high-end talent.

The least favorable outcome would be losing Jeffers for a contract below $50 million and receiving the lower compensatory selection. Minnesota would lose its starting catcher while collecting considerably less draft capital than it could have received. The Twins have expressed interest in keeping Jeffers, but they also need to be realistic about the financial commitment required. If another organization is willing to give him a substantial multi-year contract, Minnesota might have to let him walk. If they go at least far enough to ensure that he clears $50 million if he signs elsewhere, they'll have done themselves a $2-million favor.


Should the Twins offer Jeffers a contract for more than $50 million? What’s your prediction for what he will receive in free agency? Leave a comment and start the discussion.

Image courtesy of © Matt Krohn-Imagn Images

View full article

Posted

I would be surprised if the Teins wallet gets opened this off season.  I hope they do as they need a lot of help.  I think the Front Office will use the lock out or suspected lock out as an excuse to do little.  The past 2 trade deadlines they traded veterans one year and prospects the next produce little or nothing in the standings.

Please surprise me Front Office.

 

Posted
1 hour ago, DJL44 said:

If he signs somewhere else for less than $50M then he took a discount to leave. The Twins can easily offer 4 years and $50M.

Other than Jim Bowden, whose 2/$15.5M is so far off it doesn’t even meet the QO, has anyone projected less than $15M as an AAV?

I don’t think 4/$50M works as an enforcer deal. Unless a team is committed to a fourth year, it’s easy to stay under with a 3/$48M. It’s hardly a risk for Jeffers to bet on himself to get a $2M deal as a 33-year-old.

If even $15M is legit as an AAV, that means having to go to 4/$60M if you want to consider four years.

If you want to only go three years, you have to go to 3/$51M. I think that’s much more viable as an enforcer offer. If you are stuck on not giving a $17M AAV, consider 3/$48M with a $2M team option on a fourth year.

But in any case, I don’t think someone going to $50M is going to a problem. 

Posted
16 minutes ago, Riverbrian said:

You'd have to offer 3/50M to force someone over to sign him. There is value in the draft compensation so maybe... 3/50 over 3/45 could be justified. 

RB types faster. I’m more verbose.

Posted

It's not going to be 4yr/$50 million.  3/$50 for sure.  I'm ok with a 4-year commitment.  But I don't think it means he has to be a full-time catcher for four years.  All assuming enough good health:

In 2027 he catches say 110 games.  DH for 25ish.  Caratini catches 50.

In 2028 he catches 90 and start to transition him to 1B.  Maybe he plays 50 games there and Lackey catches the other 70.

In 2029 Jeffers catches 50.  Plays 1B around 80-90.  Lackey catches 110.

In 2030 Jeffers is your everyday 1B.  Lackey catches 110.  Hopefully Tait catches 50.  

Posted
18 minutes ago, HerbieFan said:

It's not going to be 4yr/$50 million.  3/$50 for sure.  I'm ok with a 4-year commitment.  But I don't think it means he has to be a full-time catcher for four years.  All assuming enough good health:

In 2027 he catches say 110 games.  DH for 25ish.  Caratini catches 50.

In 2028 he catches 90 and start to transition him to 1B.  Maybe he plays 50 games there and Lackey catches the other 70.

In 2029 Jeffers catches 50.  Plays 1B around 80-90.  Lackey catches 110.

In 2030 Jeffers is your everyday 1B.  Lackey catches 110.  Hopefully Tait catches 50.  

He's never caught more than 88 games in a season. Not likely to increase that as he ages.

Posted

If that all worked out I think people would be pleased. 

Things to consider: Jeffers has yet to catch 90 games in a season. Jeffers has never played first base. The Twins have indicated a desire to improve their defense. The Twins seem to be moving towards using the DH as a rotating spot. Naturally, the Twins have said one thing and often done something else, so no surprise if the team backs off on a desire for better defense.

Posted
3 hours ago, DJL44 said:

If he signs somewhere else for less than $50M then he took a discount to leave. The Twins can easily offer 4 years and $50M.

3 years and 49.9 million offers a higher net present day value.  The Twins should offer a 4 year 56-60 million.  This gives a solid value to Jeffers and a definite bar to pass to sign him.  

Posted
2 minutes ago, tony&rodney said:

If that all worked out I think people would be pleased. 

Things to consider: Jeffers has yet to catch 90 games in a season. Jeffers has never played first base. The Twins have indicated a desire to improve their defense. The Twins seem to be moving towards using the DH as a rotating spot. Naturally, the Twins have said one thing and often done something else, so no surprise if the team backs off on a desire for better defense.

The Twins could put Larnarch at DH for 90 ges next year with Buxton getting 30 -40 games there as well and that still leaves 32-42 games for others.  10-20 games at DH for Jeffers + 90-100 games C and 5 at 1B to try out 1B.  

Posted
4 minutes ago, Brandon said:

3 years and 49.9 million offers a higher net present day value.  The Twins should offer a 4 year 56-60 million.  This gives a solid value to Jeffers and a definite bar to pass to sign him.  

Are you wanting to see the Twins sign Jeffers or have another team pay more money?

Posted

I'm an over-pay to retain the best free agent catcher guy. While I'd disagree with those that don't want to pay for his services, I can understand if they have other players they want to spend the money on.

But, I hope that most of us would be on the same page in that, the Comp draft pick carries next to no weight in the decision.

Posted
2 hours ago, IndianaTwin said:

I don’t think 4/$50M works as an enforcer deal. Unless a team is committed to a fourth year, it’s easy to stay under with a 3/$48M. It’s hardly a risk for Jeffers to bet on himself to get a $2M deal as a 33-year-old.

4/$54 works. $6M is no guarantee in four seasons.

Posted
18 minutes ago, tony&rodney said:

If that all worked out I think people would be pleased. 

Things to consider: Jeffers has yet to catch 90 games in a season. Jeffers has never played first base. The Twins have indicated a desire to improve their defense. The Twins seem to be moving towards using the DH as a rotating spot. Naturally, the Twins have said one thing and often done something else, so no surprise if the team backs off on a desire for better defense.

Jeffers is only averaging 97 games a season, total, over the last 6 years. He has always had an availability problem. That won't get better in the coming years.

Posted
8 minutes ago, tony&rodney said:

Are you wanting to see the Twins sign Jeffers or have another team pay more money?

I think the Twins will need to pay more to sign him.  I was just commenting on the post where they are saying the Twins should offer a 4 year 50 million to ensure that if he signs elsewhere he gets a higher dollar amount thus ensuring the draft pick after.the first round.  I said it needs to be higher on a 4 year deal in case of a higher AAV on a 3 year deal but under 50 million and losing the pick after the first round.  

Then I responded to another post about rotating DH and how Jeffers could get his time in with Larnarch getting a bunch of games at DH next season.  

That is all.  I think a 4 year 68 million is the minimum to sign him.  But I don't have the answers just a guess 

Posted
7 minutes ago, SE23 said:

Jeffers is only averaging 97 games a season, total, over the last 6 years. He has always had an availability problem. That won't get better in the coming years.

For contrast, Luis Arraez is averaging 145 games per season over the same span.

Posted

The negotiations with Jeffers start at 3 years 50 mil. You offer that to ensure it is not possible for him to sign elsewhere for under. 16.67 AAV is very fair for him, and only 3 years would be great for the Twins as they wait for Lackey. To me, its a no doubter and someone should be fired if it isn't at least offered. If someone goes more years or AAV I would love that draft pick

Posted

I’m sure the reason we haven’t heard any news yet is because Zoll’s Outlook was down and then he got stranded in Las Vegas. He better not be waiting for the market to come to him or there will be nothing left.

Posted

Like many have said, Twins offer has to start at 3 for $50MM. To do otherwise is like giving away a top ~100ish prospect AND letting him walk (if he signs for < $50).

And it’s not as easy as saying you’d use that money elsewhere. On a relative basis you’re not going to get a catcher that hits better than him. So the choice is between using that money to sign the best hitting catcher on the market or a middle of the pack hitting first baseman (which you could sign even if you do bring back Jeffers).

Posted
8 hours ago, SE23 said:

He's never caught more than 88 games in a season. Not likely to increase that as he ages.

The number he caught in 2025 and before was a strategic decision they made to strictly alternate catchers. It wasn’t a durability issue that kept him to 88 or less. 

in 2026, he caught 80 games while spending 45 games on the IL because of a hamate bone injury, which is not a durability-related issue. Were not for an errant pitch, he would easily have caught more than 88. While on the active roster, he was essentially playing two of three games, which puts him into the 105-110 game range.

The progression Herbie lays out isn’t at all unreasonable. Probably any team who signs him is planning for 110 games or so for at least a couple years. If anything, the regression is too quick. It’s very reasonable to expect more than 90 games as a 31 year old. Shucks, even Vázquez caught that many as a 32 year old, again limited as a strategic decision, not by durability concerns. 

Separately, I think we should pump the brakes on the expectations for Lackey. He’s only played 10 games at High A so far. To think he’s going to get any substantial time in 2028 doesn’t seem likely. Cup of coffee perhaps, but even that would require aggressive movement. 

Posted

The math is fairly easy for the Twins on this one.  Offer him 4-years and $50 million.  At his age, and the fact that he's never caught 100 games in a season, I don't want to over pay for him, especially since we've got young catchers that will be knocking on the door soon.

It is unlikely the Twins will out bid any of the catcher needy teams Jeffers could end up with. It's just not something the Twins have ever historically done.  The Yankees and Cubs are much more likely to bet on signing Jeffers if we were betting our house mortgage on a deal.

I don't want to actively capitulate to losing Jeffers.  I'm just not committing $17 million dollars a year for 3 years.  $12.5 million is more to my liking.  And the Twins better be ready to pivot quickly for a defense first catcher at a much better price.  I'd rather spend a little more money on Ty France to shore up 1B defense and offense at a position we don't have a highly thought of prospect ready to step in.  

France would provide more offense than Jeffers (at least the last couple years indicate that) at a position of equal need of upgrading.  But the $50 million dollar offer assures the Twins of that end of round #1 compensatory pick, which could provide an exciting pitching prospect who falls that we could pay over-slot to secure.  

Create an account or sign in to comment

You need to be a member in order to leave a comment

Create an account

Sign up for a new account in our community. It's easy!

Register a new account

Sign in

Already have an account? Sign in here.

Sign In Now
The Twins Daily Caretaker Fund
The Twins Daily Caretaker Fund

You all care about this site. The next step is caring for it. We’re asking you to caretake this site so it can remain the premier Twins community on the internet.

×
×
  • Create New...