TopGunn#22
Old-Timey Member-
Posts
2,551 -
Joined
-
Last visited
-
Days Won
5
Content Type
Profiles
Minnesota Twins News, Rumors & Analysis
Minnesota Twins Videos
2026 Minnesota Twins Top Prospect Rankings
2022 Minnesota Twins Draft Picks & Signing Bonuses
Minnesota Twins Trade & Free Agent Rumors
Minnesota Twins Fan Guides & Resources
2023 Minnesota Twins Draft Picks & Signing Bonuses
2024 Minnesota Twins Draft Picks & Signing Bonuses
2025 Minnesota Twins Draft Picks & Signing Bonuses
2026 Minnesota Twins Draft Picks & Signing Bonuses
Forums
Blogs
Events
Store
Downloads
Gallery
Everything posted by TopGunn#22
-
I don't think there's a single guy who posts on here that thinks the Pohlad's are great owners and that the guys we've employed in our FO post Andy McPhail have been tremendous. We are all sick to death of the Pohlad family and even more frustrated by the collection FO misfits they've employed. But I prefer to be happy about Jeffers coming back for the 2027 even if they ended up paying him a ridiculous $23 million (it's not my money). Jeffers fills the biggest hole and it's a short term-one season investment. I seriously doubt the Twins sign him to a 3-year contract because Vahn Lackey will be starting behind the plate for the Twins to open the 2028 season. As a fan I really hope the Pohlad's over spend at least a little bit more than they had anticipated due to the VAST overpay for Jeffers, but I will admit, I don't have high expectations they will. They need a 1B. They could stand to add TWO bullpen arms that would be difference makers, not just "flyers." And there is still a LOT that needs to be done with this roster. It would be nice to get some talent back for Ober, Kremer, Lewis, Larnach and maybe even Caratini, Martin and Wallner. But at this point I'd settle for addition by subtraction. These guys are not the future and none of them are difference makers. So sweep them out the door and hand the baton to other players. I'm even open to trading Joe Ryan if it's the right kind of deal. Unfortunately, we've been conditioned to have low expectations for what this franchise can do. Stack the Twins up with the Vikings, T-Wolves and Wild and they are SO CLEARLY the WORST run sports team in Minnesota that it is arduous being a Twins fan. But, I AM a Twins fan, and I will always have hope. Even when it seems irrational.
-
This development is quite a surprise. I have to admit, with Scott Boras as his agent, this is the last outcome I would have expected. I've never thought Jeffers was an "elite" catcher. $23 million is what an elite catcher would be worth. Now I'll put that negativity aside. This is great news!!! The Twins have now filled a HUGE hole behind the plate, a position that is crucial for any baseball team's success. His defense is so/so, but he was, and should continue to be, excellent at challenging pitches, which is more important now than pitch framing.. Jeffers also fits in right in the middle of the lineup, which should lengthen our batting order. And this is a one-year contract. Jeffers is gambling on himself, and the Twins took the proper gamble on protecting themselves with high draft pick compensation should he have elected to sign elsewhere. In no way is this a "Loss." This is a big win with only one year of enhanced compensation. For 2027 this is a big WIN !! Now, Tom Pohlad almost has to treat this as a separate budget category, like the Carlos Correa $10 million compensation. This is a BIG step toward the Twins contending in the winnable A.L. Central in 2027. Tom Pohlad and Jeremy Zoll still need to fill 1B. Signing Ty France would be an excellent move. They still need to hunt for possible "Diamonds in the Rough" like Jordan Lawler, Tristan Casas and bullpen arms. They can help mitigate the money paid to Jeffers by shedding payroll on guys like Ober, Larnach, Lewis, Kremer and maybe even Joe Ryan, depending on what a Ryan trade would bring back. And finally, if the season is going well and Jeffers is having a good year, they can keep him for the whole season and look at 2028 and beyond once he becomes an unrestricted FA. Or they could trade him for a haul at the deadline if Vahn Lackey is pounding on the door for a promotion. They could also trade Caratini in a salary dump to help pay for some of Jeffers $23 million if they choose. This entire scenario gives the Twins FO flexibility and retains a solid player at a desperately needed position. There is certainly some risk in paying Jeffers $23 million for the 2027 season. I would never have expected it. But I choose to focus on the positive. The Twins retained a core player needed to contend for the A.L. Central, at a position that is crucial. Jeffers must have told Scott Boras that he likes it in Minnesota, and what could be the harm in making $23 million for one season and staying where he likes it. The Twins and Ryan Jeffers were BOTH big winners last night.
-
Someone, someplace mentioned how thin the Padres rotation is. I'd like to add the Giants to that list. Two players I really have my eye on from the Giants are 27 year old Casey Schmidt and 27 year old RP Randy Rodriguez. Schmidt had a bit of a breakout last year while playing 1B, 2B, 3B, and LF. he even played 7 games at SS. He's a solid RH bat who hit 21 HR's in only 387 AB's. He only walked 11 times, so a little more patience would help, but he's a solid RH bat who had a .784 OPS last year with defensive versatility. Rodriguez has a heck of an arm. He missed 2026 after having Tommy John surgery, but he's healthy now. In 2025 he had a 1.78 ERA and struck out 67 in 51 innings. I'm sure the Giants would like to discuss Joe Ryan. I'd start with those 2 guys and maybe offer Larnach as well. I wonder how the Baseball Trade Values would rate a trade like that? But Schmidt at 1B would help the lineup and Rodriguez could be our next Closer.
- 29 replies
-
- jhoan duran
- louis varland
- (and 5 more)
-
I agree tony&rodney, I also would like to see some articles that get SPECIFIC regarding trades. Sometimes spending money is acquiring a player in a trade who COSTS. This is what teams acquiring Joe Ryan from the Twins would be doing. It is generally assumed that the Twins should trade Joe Ryan, not because he tends to fall apart in the 2nd half of a season, but because of what he will COST, either through an arbitration award or what he could command on the open market. Other teams have these issues as well. There are plenty of players that could be acquired via trades that would cost "talent" and maybe some additional cash, if the player the Twins were trading for has a better track record than the player/players we are trading away. This is my fundamental problem with the Pohlad family and their FO people post Andy McPhail. We don't hear them say we intend to KEEP Joe Ryan and that we are working on an extension. We hear constant trade speculation due to his future COST. We've also heard Zoll say he would like to add more "power" to the Twins lineup. But we're still waiting on an article that discusses possible targets and includes specific hypothetical trades. For example: The Red Sox acted quickly and signed Jake Bauers for 4 years, $58 million. That's a contract the Twins should have been able to match or better. Maybe Bauers would never have considered the Twins. We'll never know. But that opens up a possible trade for the Twins. The Red Sox now have Jake Bauers, Wilson Contreras and Curtis Mead all able to play 1B (Mead will probably be their 3B). This leaves Tristan Casas, a once promising young power hitter without a spot on the Red Sox. He hasn't played since May of 2025 but he's healthy now and headed to Winter Ball to get AB's. He's still just 26 years old and is a possible non-tender candidate. He's also projected to earn only $1.6-$1.7 million in 2027. Who else is out there that fits this profile TD?? I'm not suggesting Casas will be a future superstar. But in 2023, he did finish 3rd in ROY voting. He hit 24 HR's and posted an .856 OPS. In 2024, injuries limited him to 212 AB's but he still hit 13 HR's and posted an .800 OPS. He's got power. There is no debating that. Signing Ty France and platooning him with Casas or just using Casas as a DH against RH pitching would add depth and power to the lineup. And the cost would be LOW. What other prospects could be pried from the Red Sox? I've lost track of who their top guys are since we failed to close the Ryan trade for Arias and Tolle. The Red Sox top 3 pitchers (Crochet, Tolle and Suarez) are all Left-Handed. Might they still be interested in Joe Ryan? Or possibly Ober or Kremer? The Twins should be extremely active in the trade market this off season. Tom Pohlad has stated the salary out lay will be increased. I want to see specific trades and or signings that restructures the Twins roster and increases payroll to $150 million. Why tread water at $130-$135 million. The goal is to compete. The bar is quite low in the A.L. Central.
-
I could see the Twins looking to add a SP this off season. Someone who would be controllable for at least 2-3 years. But in FA, you always have to over-pay for SP's (and even many RP's). I'd rather see the Twins TRADE for someone who would be affordable, and with untapped upside. One thing I'm hoping the Twins do is trade some dead weight. The Padres LF's are 27 year old Dustin Harris (no power-bats Left) and 28 year old Samad Taylor (bats Right. no track record to speak of). I would trade them Trevor Larnach for either their #2 catcher-Luis Campusano 28 y/o, decent bat, middling defender or their #3 catcher, former KC Royal Freddy Fermin, 31 y/o. Outstanding defensive catcher, so/so bat. I'll take Fermin and the benefit shedding Larnach's salary and adding Fermin for $2.6 million. A roughly $4 million dollar savings. The Padres NEED a LF and with Ethan Salas now the #1 catcher, need to shed either Campusano or Fermin. I'm also finding a way to shed Royce Lewis and Bailey Ober. I don't have any trade ideas for either at this moment but Ober would save $7 million and Lewis about $5 million. Coupled with a Larnach for Fermin trade and I'm about $16 million better off without factoring in who I get back and how much they cost for Lewis and Ober. I'll take whatever that savings is and sign Ty France. I'd give him either 2 years $32 million or 3 years $48 million. 1B solved with a solid RH bat and a Gold Glove. I'm not opposed to seeing the Twins use Zebby Matthews as a RP to begin 2027. I still have high hopes for Matthews as a SP, but using in him in the BP to begin 2027 does NOT close the book on his SP viability. Jim Perry, Tommy Hall, Johan Santana, Francisco Liriano and Griffin Jax are all examples. With that in mind, I'm not opposed to trading Joe Ryan should a suitable deal present itself. The Twins will never get a better offer than the Red Sox had last winter, but proven SP is a premium and Ryan has been an All Star. Some moves have already been made. It always has frustrated me that the Twins "wait the market out" strategy. They never identify a player they want and make an aggressive play. Would they have been willing to pay Jake Bauers more than the Red Sox?? I guess we will never know.
-
Ryan Jeffers and the $50 Million Question
TopGunn#22 replied to Cody Christie's topic in Twins Daily Front Page News
The math is fairly easy for the Twins on this one. Offer him 4-years and $50 million. At his age, and the fact that he's never caught 100 games in a season, I don't want to over pay for him, especially since we've got young catchers that will be knocking on the door soon. It is unlikely the Twins will out bid any of the catcher needy teams Jeffers could end up with. It's just not something the Twins have ever historically done. The Yankees and Cubs are much more likely to bet on signing Jeffers if we were betting our house mortgage on a deal. I don't want to actively capitulate to losing Jeffers. I'm just not committing $17 million dollars a year for 3 years. $12.5 million is more to my liking. And the Twins better be ready to pivot quickly for a defense first catcher at a much better price. I'd rather spend a little more money on Ty France to shore up 1B defense and offense at a position we don't have a highly thought of prospect ready to step in. France would provide more offense than Jeffers (at least the last couple years indicate that) at a position of equal need of upgrading. But the $50 million dollar offer assures the Twins of that end of round #1 compensatory pick, which could provide an exciting pitching prospect who falls that we could pay over-slot to secure. -
The Twins have a nice mix of veterans and promising young arms to front a solid starting rotation for 2027. While I think Lopez, Ryan and Bradley will be pretty good, what could make the Twins rotation a real force are the young arms...Prielipp, Abel and Matthews. Health is always an issue, for every major league team. Just look at all the talent the Dodgers have in their rotation, yet guys like Snell and Glasgow are always on the shelf a couple times each season. Guys like Prielipp, Abel and Matthews should now be ready. One of Kremer and Ober should be traded for an area of need. Packaging one of them with Lewis or Larnach and maybe even Wallner could bring a bullpen arm or even a catcher that could supplant Caratini. And there is still some minor league depth to enhance a trade package. I also wouldn't be averse to acquiring a SP with a solid track record and consistent health to provide further depth. Young guys like Prielipp, Matthews and Abel may need a break or two as well as Lopez and Ryan coming off injury. A 6 man rotation could be a smart move. 2027, to me, is a year to turn to the young SP's and give them run. I wouldn't be at all disappointed to see both Ober and Kremer moved in trades. Send the young guns a message that we have confidence in them, and that they are going to be counted on this season. The bar to compete in the A.L. Central is fairly low. We have 6 guys in Lopez, Ryan, Bradley, Prielipp, Abel and Matthews and possibly a 7th if one is signed or acquired in a trade. Keep the best arms up. I don't see a need for Matthews or Abel to "prove themselves" in St. Paul. I've seen their stuff. It's plenty good enough. They need to improve their command, but it's time to send them the message "you guys are ready, go do your thing."
-
I always appreciate the effort and thought that someone puts in an article, and Cody's targets are interesting. I just don't think Langeliers and Burleson are realistic targets. However, I DO agree that the Twins have minor league depth and a couple of major league arms (Ober, Kremer) who could be mixed in to sweeten a trade. Lewis and Larnach are also sweeteners. But the point of an article like this is to lay out HOW you would go about acquiring Player "A" or Player "B." You almost have to use something like BBTV's to approximate a trade, whether it's Major League rated talent or Minor League rated talent. Otherwise, everything is just a pipe-dream. Once they made you pay for BBTV's I stopped using it. So my knowledge of a players supposed "value" is not on par to suggest what would at least be nominally fair for a trade.
- 57 replies
-
- bryan abreu
- royce lewis
- (and 5 more)
-
I agree Patzky !! Why would we pay Crawford $10 million per year for 2 years when we could just sign Ty France to fill a position of need?? With Culpepper looking serviceable at SS and Marek Houston highly probable to join the Twins sometime in 2027, there is no need to sign Crawford. Certainly not at $20 million for 2 years. I'd rather spend that on a solid BP arm and Ty France.
-
This is why the qualifying offer was a no-brainer for the Twins. As a one-year bridge to Lackey, $23 million is steep but doable because it's just a one year commitment. But I think the estimates for the ultimate contract Jeffers gets are LOW. The Yankees alone will assure this. They want to keep Ben Rice as a DH/1B. That was clear after this last season's trade deadline. So this likely means the Twins are looking at an end of round #1 compensatory pick. I say "well played" by the Twins FO. I would use that pick on the highest ceiling possible pitching arm available. The suggestion of Carson Kelly as a fall back position when Jeffers inevitably signs with the Yankees is excellent. The quote from Falvey about small market teams needing to lean on defense and pitching is shocking, since in his era the Twins never prioritized defense. Look at what we DID, not what Falvey SAYS. We played Brooks Lee far too many innings at SS before the obvious lack of athleticism necessitated a move to 3B. We played Larnach and Wallner in the corner OF positions with the idea that Buxton's speed and range would forgive all sins. That didn't work either. We tried to get a better glove at SS with Correa, but his being consistently injured messed that up. Sadly, that was predictable with his being turned away by the Giants and Mets. And if the Twins are truly committed to improving defensively, Carson Kelly is a much better defensive catcher than Jeffers and while not the equal with the bat, will not be automatic out-Christian Vasquez either, at a fraction of the cost to retain Jeffers. At that point, I go hunting for Randy Arozarena. He'd be a great RH OF bat who could provide a consistent presence, especially if Jenkins and E-Rod have injury issues during the season.
-
What I glean from the projected salaries for Jeffers tells me at worst...the Twins are going to get a comp pick at the end of round #1 (meaning the contract Jeffers signs will surpass $50 million in total). It also means that teams like the Yankees and Cubs will probably out spend us. Scott Boras does not give hometown discounts. So I think Ryan Jeffers is as good as gone. The logic why we should fight to bring him back as stated by several posters is sound. I just don't see the Twins winning a bidding war for Jeffers. So this leaves the Twins with a BIG NEED to have a PLAN for how they are going to fill this hole at Catcher. The Twins must realize that Caratini should be the back up. Who are the potential Catchers the Twins could make a trade for that could be counted on to be their #1 Catcher for 2 years (2027 & 2028)? The "plan" should be to bring in a guy that shoulders the bulk of the load and who sometime in 2028 steps back to make way for Vahn Lackey. This allows the Twins to trade Caratini either before the 2027 season begins or at the deadline, and then either way, just be done with Caratini well before the 2028 season. By that time Lackey will be in place and possibly Tait as well. Tinney will be a 1B who could play Catcher in a pinch, kind of like Ben Rice for the Yankees. So eventually, we need to see a list provided by the writers at TD of Catchers who could be acquired in a trade this off season. Teel, Davis, Quero, Susac, Campusano. A deep dive on these possible targets and what a trade for each of them could possibly look like.
-
The Twins are not constructed at this time to benefit from a "Full Time DH." Last year with Bell worked, but he WAS signed to be a 1B and occasional DH. Finally using him as a "Full Time DH" was, as Riverbrian so aptly put it..."done out of necessity." Buxton may well need to DH a lot coming out of Spring Training depending on his recovery from surgery. Keaschall will probably work very hard on OF defense this winter but at this time, he will not be the equal of Jenkins, E-Rod or Roden in the OF. Keaschall will probably be the full time leadoff hitter in the 2027 Twins lineup, so if Buxton opens the season on the IL or becomes the full time DH for the first month of the season, Keaschall will be getting AB's either as a DH or 3rd/4th OF, Keaschall WILL be at the top of the order. As a switch hitter who was fairly good from both sides of the plate, Bell was solid as a DH. Kind of like a Reggie Smith/Ken Singleton vibe without the OF defense of Smith. But the best outlook for Twins has multiple players cycling through the DH spot once Buxton is healthy enough to play the OF 4 times a week.
- 39 replies
-
- byron buxton
- josh bell
-
(and 1 more)
Tagged with:
-
Kody Clemens Can Hold Down First Base
TopGunn#22 replied to Cody Pirkl's topic in Twins Daily Front Page News
Clemens has proven himself to be a capable player. He's a better Utility guy than Castro ever was and he has greater defensive versatility. I'm O.K. adding a RH option at 1B to be used in a platoon with Clemens. Goldschmidt and Mountcastle fill that role. Ty France would be a better signing He would be a more regular 1B hitting against RH pitchers as well as LHP's with Clemens playing 1B against specific LHP's to give France a day off. I would prefer the Ty France route and just play Clemens at 2B the majority of the time and sit Clemens against LHP. I expect Marek Houston to rise to the challenge at AAA St. Paul and starting about June 1st, to be in the conversation for a call up. It very well could take until July 1st, but the longer range plan would be to have Lee-3B, Houston-SS, Culpepper-2B and then a Ty France/Cody Clemens 1B. That would be pretty darn good IF defense. With Jenkins and E-Rod replacing the Larnach/Wallner spots, and incremental improvement from Keaschall, (and Buxton of course) the overall, IF/OF defense would improve quite a bit. I don't think you can minimize what Marek Houston will bring to the overall defensive improvement of the Twins. Jazz Chisholm is not the answer. Brandon Lowe will be too expensive. I think Gleybor Torrez is slipping defensively. Ty France would cement Clemens at 2B for the first 2 or 3 months of the season with occasional starts at 1B against a tough RHP. And it leaves the door open for a Marek Houston promotion that will be a difference maker.- 33 replies
-
- kody clemens
- royce lewis
-
(and 1 more)
Tagged with:
-
The ceiling for Debarge is as a Utility Infielder. He's got the Glove. While I'm encouraged by the swing adjustment, teams don't always send their best to the AFL anymore. The offense will always be a question and the strikeout rate is an issue. But if you're looking for a utility infielder with a great glove and speed...? Then Debarge has a chance to be that guy. He's got to prove himself at AA and then at AAA. That's at least 2-3 years from today.
-
If I'm being sensible, I can't see the Twins going for Bednar, no matter how much Shelton loves him due to the draft compensation and the fact that as good as he was, the Yankees will NOT let him leave. Morejon also requires draft compensation and is not a Closer. Guys like Iglesias and maybe Ryan Helsley with the Orioles would be good targets. Maybe even Kenley Jansen, who while no where near as dominant as he once once has a proven track record of closing games. I agree that having Hoffman as the set up guy that could close when needed is the best role for him. I like Gomez in the 7th inning. Now, if I'm being just a bit NOT sensible, I look at the track record of Iglesias and I say $15-$17 million for a one-year contract makes perfect sense. Especially if the plan (assuming the Twins actually HAVE a plan) is to entertain offers on Joe Ryan but keep him unless a team makes an offer too good to turn down. With a starting rotation of Ryan, Lopez, Bradley, Prielipp and Abel, a BP anchored by Iglesias and Hoffman is very close to the Duran/Jax years. The Braves may let Iglesias walk because they have a bevy of younger RP's ready and Robert Suarez, 2 years younger than Iglesias at 35 was challenging for the Closer role last year already. So if I'm being completely non-sensical, and I consider the stellar track record of Iglesias, maybe I'm the only team that offers him a 2-year contract for $10 million annually. Maybe $12 million annually. The Twins may need to do something like that to set them apart from all the one-year offers Iglesias will get. I refuse to let the star-crossed signing of Addison reed deter me from this plan. Reed was never on the level of a guy like Iglesias. The Twins need to focus on improving the team, not dwell on the failures of the past.
-
I want the Twins to continue with Prielipp as a SP. But I envision Rojas as a Tommy Hall kind of Swing-Man. A guy who can pitch 2 innings, maybe 3 if he's efficient, and give you a spot start on occasion. That's how the Twins used Tommy Hall in 1969-1970 and he was very good in that role. Rojas has great stuff but really needs to become more consistent with his command. I'd like him on the MLB roster and logging about 80-90 innings as a long reliever/spot SP. With Ryan/Lopez/Bradley/Abel and Prielipp as the top 5 and Matthews and Dean Kremer there is depth. Ober should be traded. Festa might finally surprise us and stay healthy. Matthews is also a guy who is a RH version of Rojas. Both of them could be long relief/spot starts to give the Twins bullpen and rotation some flexibility. Trading Joe Ryan would need to bring a SP back or an affordable FA SP addition. But I think the Twins hang onto Ryan and possibly deal him at the deadline if we are not contending.
- 23 replies
-
- kris bubic
- sean newcomb
-
(and 4 more)
Tagged with:
-
I agree it was a no-brainer to offer Jeffers, and what the heck, it's just a one-year contract. There is almost no risk to offering. Catcher is a big issue for 2027, even if Caratini DOES bounce back to a degree, which I think he will. But Tom Pohlad needs to put his money where his mouth has been and get the Twins closer to what may become a negotiated "salary floor" even if that concept isn't applied until 2028. The Twins will either have Jeffers for a 2027 bridge year for Lackey, or they will receive some sort of draft compensation. I think the idea of offering Jeffers 3-years, $45 million or 3-years and $50 million is also a good idea. An offer like that could push the Yankees or Cubs to make an offer that easily clears $50 million and that pushes the Twins draft compensation to end of 1st round. Having Jeffers around for 3 more years is not necessarily a BAD option. I would pursue RP options that do not include Bednar and Morejon. There are other good options that would not take a draft pick away from the Twins.
-
Offering Jeffers the qualifying offer was the easy and logical first step. If he accepts, it's a sizable investment, but only for one season, and as others have pointed out, if there is an extended lockout, the Twins will see that $23 million dollar figure diminish as the lockout drags on. If he accepts, the Twins have solidified their catching position for at least whatever baseball gets played in 2027. That, and improved health of the SP staff and impact improvement from rookies like Jenkins, Culpepper, E-Rod and eventually Marek Houston gives the Twins an encouraging chance to be very competitive in the A.L. Central. Jeffers may not be a good pitch framer, but who cares? With the ABS system, Jeffers IS a very effective pitch challenger. To me, that's far more important than a skill that is by and large useless going forward. Having Jeffers for 2027 plugs their biggest hole for 2027. I wouldn't offer him longer than a 2-year deal, which is why he and Boras will probably decline and sign a contract for greater than $50 million with the Yankees. If Jeffers refuses, I think it's quite likely that the Twins get a high comp pick at the end of round #1. The draft is always a crap-shoot, but I'll take that extra pick that high in the draft anytime. This also gives Tom and Jeremy at least theoretically, another $23 million to improve the current roster, either by signing free agents, or making a trade that takes on some salary.
-
With 5 of our top 20 prospects catchers I wonder if the Twins would be willing to include one of their young catchers in a trade to acquire an MLB catcher? I wouldn't deal Lackey or Tinney, but I might consider one of Tait, Diaw or Jimenez in a package. I've got to believe there are several MLB teams who aren't satisfied with the catching talent in their minor leagues and would have interest.
-
The Twins’ Greatest Players: Pioneers & Unicorns
TopGunn#22 replied to Cody Christie's topic in Twins Daily Front Page News
Great points Teflon !! I'm really enjoying these articles. Everyone remembers Killebrew, Carew, Oliva and Puckett. This series digs a little deeper and remembers certain players for specific reasons and how they helped make the Twins an entertaining and good baseball team. Allison and Pascual were home grown, having moved with the Senators franchise to Minnesota. The Twins got Tovar from the Reds for LHP Gerry Arrigo in a trade the Twins clearly won. Tovar (nicknamed "Pepe" by his teammates) was always one of my favorite Twins. Battey was acquired along with Don Mincher in a trade with the White Sox for slugger Roy Sievers. The Twins needed a catcher and had an abundance of RH hitting sluggers (Killebrew, Allison) so they dealt Sievers for a future All Star and GG catcher and LH power hitter in Mincher. Another good trade made by the ballclub. The off season is upon us and labor strife awaits. I wonder what trades the Twins could make that could help us contend in 2027.- 7 replies
-
- bob allison
- cesar tovar
-
(and 2 more)
Tagged with:
-
It's really too bad the Twins couldn't complete the Larnach for Abreu trade at the trade deadline, but if I was the Astros owner, I wouldn't have just vetoed the trade, I'd have fired the FO for even considering it. It would have been a steal for the Twins. MeleMouth makes a good point. A deeper dive on Abreu would be helpful. But I just gotta say, this kid has been lights out for 5 consecutive years. The Twins would still have had to wrestle for him in FA for next season even if we had succeeded in acquiring him, but I think he's an excellent target. He's always walked more guys than you would like. But he generally throws about 70 innings a season and strikes out about 90. That's pretty good. Chembry's suggestion of Evan Phillips is also good. So it comes down to cost Spotrac estimates Abreu (30 years old) to cost around $10-$11 million per year for 2-3 years. Phillips (32 years old) is estimated to get $9 to $10 million per year, probably a maximum of only 2 years. I guess I'd rather invest in the slightly younger Abreu but either would be a NICE addition. One of the reasons the Twins dismantled a pretty good BP was COST. Duran and Jax were in line for some healthy raises. Duran should have been extended if the Twins REALLY thought they were going to be contenders. Jax wanted to be a SP and he did a pretty credible job for the Rays. Would it have been better to just keep Duran and Jax? Probably. But the Twins are going to have to spend some serious money to bring in an Abreu and a Vesia or Minter. At least we got Taj Bradley for Jax (good trade) and Abel and Tait for Duran.
-
jmlease, I think you missed the point I was trying to make, which is probably on me for not explaining it well enough. When a team hits 307 HR's, no one would expect them to lead the league in SB's or even be middle of the pack. But that first season with Rocco set a tone and philosophy that the Twins would just out slug other teams. With power such a sought after commodity, and expensive as well, it was never a sustainable model. I don't disagree with the points you made, in fact I agree. Guys like Kepler, Polanco and Rosario could have run more, but how that would have improved a team that struck out a lot is questionable. But year after year, the Twins just didn't add any players who were capable of supplying speed or even a higher level of defense to their lineup or bench. And even after the rule changes to enhance and encourage the running game were instituted, Rocco was extremely slow to react. Willi Castro kind of lit the fire somewhat in the 2nd half of 2023 but the Twins under Rocco just generally ignored the SB. We never added a player like David Hamilton or Chandler Simpson who could pressure a team in late game situations as a pinch runner. The Brewers employ David Hamilton at 3B. A generally accepted "power" position. Would the Twins, under Rocco, ever play a 3B with a .650 OPS and 4 HR's but 30 SB's at 3B? Probably not. When Cesar Tovar joined the Twins he played 70 games at 3B in 1967 and 78 in 1968. Killebrew was primarily playing 1B with a little Rich Reese here and there. I don't know what kind of manager Rocco was in the minor leagues. But as a major league manager, he didn't believe in the running game. If the Twins weren't drafting or developing speed as you say, that's on the FO for sure, but was Rocco requesting some speed and defense guys be included in drafting and developing or had he bought into the 3 run HR or a strikeout and 2 men LOB philosophy? The game has changed a little from 2019 and Rocco will probably get another chance to manage somewhere. It will be interesting to see how Rocco approaches his lineup. I'm willing to give him the benefit of the doubt, but my gut tells me speed will not be a priority to him.
-
I've often remarked on TD that as fun as the 2019 season was for the Twins it totally messed up their philosophy going forward and certainly damaged Rocco as a manager from the end of that season onward. How else can you explain Rocco being completely unwilling to steal a base, even after the rules were changed to improve the success of base stealing? The Twins in the post Andy McPhail era have never demonstrated an off season or trade deadline "plan." They never seemed to identify a specific need and strategy to fill that need, whether it be a FA or a trade. Nelson Cruz was a late spring training addition. He wasn't somebody the Twins identified early, prioritized, and then went out and got. Can anyone name the best trade deadline deal the Twins made in the Mauer-Morneau-Santana-Nathan-Hunter era? A trade for an impact player to help the Twins win a playoff series? Remember, that star-studded team never even won a single playoff game. The ability of the Brewers, Rays and Cleveland to trade established, star level players for prospects and develop those prospects (rinse and repeat) is what has really separated them from the Twins. The example of Ryan Jeffers and Joe Ryan not being traded at the most advantageous time is as good as it gets for a comparison. I had mentioned in a previous post a couple days ago that the value in "trading" is that you get to identify and acquire a specific player or players that fill obvious weaknesses on your ball club. When you draft, it's all about projectability. When you trade, projectability is part of the equation, but the strengths a player has that you've identified your team needing have manifested themselves more clearly. I don't see Jeremy Zoll as any kind of improvement in what the Twins have had for the last 20-25 years. Until the Pohlad family finally sells and new owners re-hire a completely different front office I don't trust the Twins to make the right kind of trades to reconfigure this roster into a contender. I think with future talent like Jenkins, Lackey, Houston. Culpepper, and current guys like Keaschall and Lee there is a chance they could be good. Bradley, Abel, Prielipp, Zebby and others need to stay healthy and take big steps forward as well. But teams like the Brewers, Rays and Cleveland are just better at trading than the Twins are at this time.
-
The 3 pitchers suggested were excellent. I would have included Mick Abel as well because while his health is the 1 thing that has held him back, he has tantalized with his stuff. As we approach the off season, I'm O.K. with Ryan, Lopez and Taj Bradley as #1-#3 but I'm also interested in seeing what a Joe Ryan trade could bring back. In other words, I wouldn't be opposed to those three at the top, but I think 2027 should be a year devoted to young talent, so I'm also not opposed to a Joe Ryan trade if the return is good. For both Zebby and Rojas, I don't think they need to be completely defined at this point. A mix of starting AND relieving for both would be O.K. with me. Depending on what we would get back in talent with various trades, we may have other arms that would be in the mix. The hope is that the new pitching coach can improve the command of guys like Matthews and Rojas and just make them better pitchers in general.
- 21 replies
-
- zebby matthews
- kendry rojas
-
(and 1 more)
Tagged with:

