Jump to content
Twins Daily
  • Create Account

Recommended Posts

Posted
7 hours ago, SE23 said:

Jeffers is only averaging 97 games a season, total, over the last 6 years. He has always had an availability problem. That won't get better in the coming years.

97 games a season is really important to point out. It's important. However. Availability doesn't appear to be an issue. Hamate bone last year. Broken thumb in 2022, A concussion in the who cares moments of September 2025. 

Jeffers has a typical catcher utilization problem.

He also has a we spent 10 million on Caratini, Vazquez and Sanchez problem. 

 

 

 

Posted

What the Twins get does not affect what a team gives up to sign Jeffers. Second highest pick, 5th highest pick and a million in international money might be too steep of price for a short term player for those who pay the CBT

Posted

I don't care about the draft pick. It's nice and all, but the odds are it doesn't produce a player even close to what Jeffers provides.

In the end, I don't think we need to worry about that $50 million benchmark. I think he will get much more than that. I would do 3 yrs / $50 million in a heartbeat if I were the Twins, but even that might not get it done. 

Posted
10 hours ago, HerbieFan said:

It's not going to be 4yr/$50 million.  3/$50 for sure.  I'm ok with a 4-year commitment.  But I don't think it means he has to be a full-time catcher for four years.  All assuming enough good health:

In 2027 he catches say 110 games.  DH for 25ish.  Caratini catches 50.

In 2028 he catches 90 and start to transition him to 1B.  Maybe he plays 50 games there and Lackey catches the other 70.

In 2029 Jeffers catches 50.  Plays 1B around 80-90.  Lackey catches 110.

In 2030 Jeffers is your everyday 1B.  Lackey catches 110.  Hopefully Tait catches 50.  

The solid bat and the transition to 1st are key if the offer is 4 year. Go $50 with a descending base and increasing incentives based on the hit tool.

Posted
2 minutes ago, Peter Gravett said:

The solid bat and the transition to 1st are key if the offer is 4 year. Go $50 with a descending base and increasing incentives

Never front load a contract 

Posted
28 minutes ago, LewFordLives said:

I don't care about the draft pick. It's nice and all, but the odds are it doesn't produce a player even close to what Jeffers provides.

In the end, I don't think we need to worry about that $50 million benchmark. I think he will get much more than that. I would do 3 yrs / $50 million in a heartbeat if I were the Twins, but even that might not get it done. 

If you ignore money, this is easily correct.  Pick ~30 is a bit over 3+ expected WAR, ~75 is 1.6.  I don't think you can ignore money though, and if we have the choice of Jeffers or Arraez/Chisolm + Pick, I'm easily taking the 2B+Pick.  Also could let Jeffers go, sign Lowe and we end up gaining pick 30 but losing 50 for a free 20 spots (1 WAR).

Posted
11 hours ago, HerbieFan said:

 

In 2030 Jeffers is your everyday 1B.  Lackey catches 110.  Hopefully Tait catches 50.  

Jeffers' OPS over the past 5 years is 42nd among 1B.  By wRC+ he'd be 36th.  Playing him at 1B ensures subpar offense from a premium offensive position.  

For DH, his OPS would be 39th and his wRC+ would rank 35th.  His bat doesn't play there either.

People have to stop pretending that Jeffers is some offensive masher.  His only offensive value is at catcher.  He is not good enough to play elsewhere.  If anyone plans to move him to 1B or DH they are saying "let's be bad offensively at 1B or DH in order to overpay for Jeffers."  Makes no sense.  

Posted

Jeffers is a career "better than average" hitter who is going to be signing for his age 31+ seasons in a physically demanding position. I don't know why people on this site keep inflating Jeffers' value. He's a 2.0 WAR 600 PA 1B. He's a 2.0 WAR 400 PA catcher. He's a 1.5 WAR 600 PA DH.

He's a solid guy for your team if he's under fair market value. He's not a guy who is going to provide a significant lift to making or advancing in the playoffs. It doesn't matter if the Twins sign him. I'd probably prefer if the team spent the money elsewhere and traded for a catcher.

Posted
2 hours ago, DJL44 said:

Joe Ryan is averaging 27 games played over the same span. 

I thought this was a funny comment.

Ryan faced as many as 689 batters in a season and Arraez topped out at 675 PA. So one can always find a way to compare players. Still I'm sure you would not seriously make a real comparison of Luis Arraez to Joe Ryan.

Posted
1 hour ago, Woof Bronzer said:

Jeffers' OPS over the past 5 years is 42nd among 1B.  By wRC+ he'd be 36th.  Playing him at 1B ensures subpar offense from a premium offensive position.  

For DH, his OPS would be 39th and his wRC+ would rank 35th.  His bat doesn't play there either.

People have to stop pretending that Jeffers is some offensive masher.  His only offensive value is at catcher.  He is not good enough to play elsewhere.  If anyone plans to move him to 1B or DH they are saying "let's be bad offensively at 1B or DH in order to overpay for Jeffers."  Makes no sense.  

The 5-year range drags that down a bit, including his 86 wRC+ season when he was 25, but I agree with the overall point.  If he can repeat his offense last year for a full-year at 1B, he's a 3 WAR guy.  Not a ton of upside, and there are a lot of ifs needed to get there, which is why if someone wants to give him 4 years at >60M I'm fine letting him walk.

Posted
16 minutes ago, tony&rodney said:

Still I'm sure you would not seriously make a real comparison of Luis Arraez to Joe Ryan

I wouldn’t seriously compare playing time for a catcher and a second baseman either. 96 games played for a catcher is perfectly normal just like 30 games played for a starting pitcher is within expectations.

Posted
14 hours ago, tony&rodney said:

A Jeffers post. It's about time.

Gotta give Twins Daily credit: There must be at least half a dozen of them since the season ended saying pretty much the same things, but in a different order or with different emphasis. That’s not easy to do!

Posted

The Twins have already stated they plan to spend money this year. I have been having a discussion with @Woof Bronzer who is essentially arguing the same point as @bean5302.   Yes we need to have some players that out perform contracts on a WAR to salary basis,  but when the team makes free agent signings you need to hit on them and be productive.  Getting 1.5 to 3 WAR per a year for Jeffers over 3 years would be fantastic out of the catcher position while we wait for some elite players to show up.  The other is this free agent class is atrocious.  There will be overpays all over the place in my opinion, including Jeffers.   I am fine with just getting a comp pick, but I would also be ok with be aggressive with signing him and going after another QO player as well.  We will see what direction the Twins go.  I would gather most of salary increases will come primarily through trades.    

Posted
16 hours ago, IndianaTwin said:

Other than Jim Bowden, whose 2/$15.5M is so far off it doesn’t even meet the QO, has anyone projected less than $15M as an AAV?

I don’t think 4/$50M works as an enforcer deal. Unless a team is committed to a fourth year, it’s easy to stay under with a 3/$48M. It’s hardly a risk for Jeffers to bet on himself to get a $2M deal as a 33-year-old.

If even $15M is legit as an AAV, that means having to go to 4/$60M if you want to consider four years.

If you want to only go three years, you have to go to 3/$51M. I think that’s much more viable as an enforcer offer. If you are stuck on not giving a $17M AAV, consider 3/$48M with a $2M team option on a fourth year.

But in any case, I don’t think someone going to $50M is going to a problem. 

Jim Bowden is so much fun to have around.  A couple weeks back he threw out that 2/$15.5m and then over the weekend he says the Yankees are out on Jeffers because his price is too high. Love that guy!

I'd do a 3/$50 with an option year at $15m with a fat buyout that means we either keep him (so the contract turns out to be 4/65m) or let him walk (and it's 3/55 or 3/60.) Heck, throw in an optout after year two, why not? 

Once he's signed you try trading Caratini and keep Jackson.  I'm not sure you get anything for Caratini, but as long as you clear payroll you can count on Tait as your #3 and maybe get an emergency cup of coffee if there's another injury. If he's not ready it may be a coffee enema, but it didn't kill Wyneger, exactly. 

Posted

This decision is not a micro one.  It is a macro, in that deciding to resign Ryan Jeffers (ignore what hte terms of the contract are) should be dependent upon what other moves the Twins plan to make and how much money they are willing to expand their payroll.

If Jeffers is really the only guy they would consider signing, then just let him walk.  Ryan Jeffers is just bringing back the same level team.   Then, unless you can find a trade partner for Caratini, the catching duo for 2027 should be Caratini and Kadim Diaw.

But if they plan on bringing in several more free agents to $10+ million market rate contracts then they need to sign Jeffers.

The decision needs to be made with a complete understanding of the free agent environment and understanding the fact the  Twins are not a premium free agent destination.  Unrealistic expectations on our ability to sign quality free agents cannot be entertained.

But, go one way or the other.  Either fully commit to a much higher budget or rebuild.   Playing the middle, low budget but not a rebuild, just gives more low end mediocrity.

Posted

Getting hung up on baseline to $50MM as floor to make other teams spend more to get better comp pick, isn’t the factor. Twins offer $50MM over 3 years, won’t be the same as a Yankees, Red Sox offer of let’s say $45MM over 3 years for example. What Jeffers and Boras team will look at is the bigger picture of team competitiveness vs Twins. Perennial teams and playoffs is a major factor and Twins haven’t proven they are investing to be playoff caliber year over year. Yes other factors come into play for all teams, injuries being the biggest one.
 

Twins operating philosophy is very poor on roster management, free agent and money spend along with trade manufacturing. Do we trust zoll and others to make good moves need to be made, and stop with one year dumpster diving as the norm. Yes, salary spend increases need to happen, but will they spend it in the right areas. The Caratini spend after the Vázquez sever over spend is prime example. 
 

I would be very surprised if Twins win out with pursuit of Jeffers for long term plan of success base on the fact that front office don’t seem to have a plan. 

Posted
12 minutes ago, Cris E said:

Jim Bowden is so much fun to have around.  A couple weeks back he threw out that 2/$15.5m and then over the weekend he says the Yankees are out on Jeffers because his price is too high. Love that guy!

I'd do a 3/$50 with an option year at $15m with a fat buyout that means we either keep him (so the contract turns out to be 4/65m) or let him walk (and it's 3/55 or 3/60.) Heck, throw in an optout after year two, why not? 

Once he's signed you try trading Caratini and keep Jackson.  I'm not sure you get anything for Caratini, but as long as you clear payroll you can count on Tait as your #3 and maybe get an emergency cup of coffee if there's another injury. If he's not ready it may be a coffee enema, but it didn't kill Wyneger, exactly. 

That's great on Bowden. 

I've seen a few people mention Jackson as part of a "trade Caratini" scenario, but I don't think they have rights to him anymore. They released him to clear up a 40-man roster.

They could re-sign him, but if they are doing that, they can also cast the net broader in finding a backup. 

Posted

Jeffers is the best slugging catcher available. Most teams would agree with that statement. 

Jeffers is the best catcher available? There would be wide disagreement on that statement.

Do the Twins have a plan? Am I the only person who struggles to guess what the Twins will do? The past tells me they just roll it over and keeping making these crazy sayings publicly about expecting to be a playoff team in 2027.  

 

Posted
5 minutes ago, tony&rodney said:

Jeffers is the best slugging catcher available. Most teams would agree with that statement. 

Jeffers is the best catcher available? There would be wide disagreement on that statement.

Do the Twins have a plan? Am I the only person who struggles to guess what the Twins will do? The past tells me they just roll it over and keeping making these crazy sayings publicly about expecting to be a playoff team in 2027.  

 

He is the best hitting free agent catcher available.  And he is the best free agent catcher available as well. Seriously, Stevenson doesn't hit as well and has at least the same defensive questions and injury history. Kelly might be a little better than him, but he's also 32.  There's really not wide disagreement on this. If you want to pretend that you can just point at a rostered player and declare him "available" I guess there could be a wider discussion, but that would mean that the first statement isn't true either because Langoliers or Goodman are both pretty solid hitting catchers that might be available.

As far as The Plan goes, no one knows their team's Plan. Plans are not published ahead of time. It's why you can't lay out The Plan for any other team.   In fact it's likely that the (lower case) plan is to see how the Jeffers thing plays out and then see either what money is left or what catchers are left and proceed from there, hopefully before December 1. 

 

Posted
3 minutes ago, Cris E said:

He is the best hitting free agent catcher available.  And he is the best free agent catcher available as well. Seriously, Stevenson doesn't hit as well and has at least the same defensive questions and injury history...

 

Free Agent vs. Available by any means are two different things.

Posted
16 minutes ago, bean5302 said:

Free Agent vs. Available by any means are two different things.

Right, but then you don't split the assertion that Jeffers is not the best catcher but he is the best slugging catcher.  Either both are true or you are pretending that there aren't other catchers with better power, and Langoliers and Goodman are both clearly in that discussion and "available". 

Posted
20 hours ago, DJL44 said:

If he signs somewhere else for less than $50M then he took a discount to leave. The Twins can easily offer 4 years and $50M.

As much as I like Jeffers, we do not need him for four years.  Two max, before we get at least 2 if not 3 very good to exceptional starting Catchers graduating to the biggs.  If we sign Jeffers, then sign him to two years max, because he will be hard to trade in 2029 when he will be 32 years old.  He's in his prime right now, let him go to the NYYs or someplace, and if he getys 4 years then great, we will get the better comp pick

Posted
17 hours ago, HerbieFan said:

It's not going to be 4yr/$50 million.  3/$50 for sure.  I'm ok with a 4-year commitment.  But I don't think it means he has to be a full-time catcher for four years.  All assuming enough good health:

In 2027 he catches say 110 games.  DH for 25ish.  Caratini catches 50.

In 2028 he catches 90 and start to transition him to 1B.  Maybe he plays 50 games there and Lackey catches the other 70.

In 2029 Jeffers catches 50.  Plays 1B around 80-90.  Lackey catches 110.

In 2030 Jeffers is your everyday 1B.  Lackey catches 110.  Hopefully Tait catches 50.  

I am not sure that I want to wait until 28 to see him at 1B....and how good will he be at 1B?  Or is he just an expensive, and probably declining DH in 2030?  That's a tough pill to swallow.  I like Jeffers, but he doesn't fit beyond 2 years.

Posted
9 hours ago, TL said:

Like many have said, Twins offer has to start at 3 for $50MM. To do otherwise is like giving away a top ~100ish prospect AND letting him walk (if he signs for < $50).

And it’s not as easy as saying you’d use that money elsewhere. On a relative basis you’re not going to get a catcher that hits better than him. So the choice is between using that money to sign the best hitting catcher on the market or a middle of the pack hitting first baseman (which you could sign even if you do bring back Jeffers).

I can very quickly name two catchers that will hit better than Jeffers;  Vahn Lackey and and Carson Tinney....

Posted
7 hours ago, LewFordLives said:

I don't care about the draft pick. It's nice and all, but the odds are it doesn't produce a player even close to what Jeffers provides.

In the end, I don't think we need to worry about that $50 million benchmark. I think he will get much more than that. I would do 3 yrs / $50 million in a heartbeat if I were the Twins, but even that might not get it done. 

I am not so sure you can say that.  If we get the $50 million draft pick, it will give us a selection somewhere in the 35-40 range.  If Jeffers signs for less than $50 mill, we get a pick in the 70-80 range.  Jeffers was picked #59 in 2018.

But, remember, we have 3-4 very good to exceptional catchers working their way through the minors, so we do NOT need Jeffers for 3 years...and moving him to 1B may not be an easy fix.  He is in his prime now.  Let someone else overpay for him....

Posted

Does anyone think the Yankees are actually going to keep Jeffers for 4 years? Signing him to a 4 year contract decreases the luxury tax value of each year. They’ll be looking to unload year 4 in 2029 and will be willing to eat salary to make it happen.

Create an account or sign in to comment

You need to be a member in order to leave a comment

Create an account

Sign up for a new account in our community. It's easy!

Register a new account

Sign in

Already have an account? Sign in here.

Sign In Now
The Twins Daily Caretaker Fund
The Twins Daily Caretaker Fund

You all care about this site. The next step is caring for it. We’re asking you to caretake this site so it can remain the premier Twins community on the internet.

×
×
  • Create New...