LyleCole
Verified Member-
Posts
274 -
Joined
-
Last visited
Content Type
Profiles
Minnesota Twins News, Rumors & Analysis
Minnesota Twins Videos
2026 Minnesota Twins Top Prospect Rankings
2022 Minnesota Twins Draft Picks & Signing Bonuses
Minnesota Twins Trade & Free Agent Rumors
Minnesota Twins Fan Guides & Resources
2023 Minnesota Twins Draft Picks & Signing Bonuses
2024 Minnesota Twins Draft Picks & Signing Bonuses
2025 Minnesota Twins Draft Picks & Signing Bonuses
2026 Minnesota Twins Draft Picks & Signing Bonuses
Forums
Blogs
Events
Store
Downloads
Gallery
Everything posted by LyleCole
-
Counting Lopez as a starter and Prielipp as a quality starter is really beyond an optimistic take. Lopez only pitched 75 innings in 2025 before he went down with elbow problems that kept him out the entire 2026 season. (I know everyone here knows this). The probability of a pitcher returning from this type of injury with anywhere near the effectiveness they once showed is very limited. Prielipp had some very good starts in 2026 (so did Zebby Matthews) but he was not consistent and his 4.87 ERA is a solid measure of that inconsistency. Based on his pitch quality (positive) and his injury history (negative) I would move him to be a late inning reliever. No matter what, as a starter there is always going to be a pitch and inning count on him so why not move him where he can produce the most. I hope Lopez can make a come back. It would be good luck that the Twins really deserve. I hope Joe Ryan can put together a full quality season and that Sonny Gray still has several years in him. If we have a rotation of Gray-Ryan-Lopez-Bradley-Kremer that is a very good starting rotation. Add quality arms of Matthews and Prielipp to the bullpen. If we can get a qualtiy year as a closer from Jeff Hoffman, and maybe more consistentcy from Gomez and Morris, that is a decent bullpen. If we can resign AJ Minter it would be a very decent bullpen.
- 26 replies
-
- sonny gray
- zebby matthews
-
(and 2 more)
Tagged with:
-
Huge hole? Well signing Sonny Gray changes some of the calculus for sure. But basically the hole is just a handful of meaningless games. Gray might stabilize the rotation giving it a true #1 - 3 in Gray-Ryan-Bradley (with the great fear Bradley regresses). But there are still more, and expensive moves that need to be done (and overpaying Jeffers with the QO does not help that).
-
No, this is a stupid. They could have not offered the QO and just signed him to a market rate contract if they . The compensation they would have protected with the QO simply was not worth paying Jeffers almost $10 million more than his market rate. If Jeffers has a decent year then he preserves his market value and the Twins just wasted the money. Even worse, this is a huge bubble on the Twins payroll budget way out of line with Jeffers value. It can impact other moves they may plan to make and took that signing decision completely out of their hands. No matter what the Twins ownership states, they will be on a strict budget and at least one reasonable (for the Twins HUGGGGGE) potential free agent signing is probably not possible. Lastly, the Twins need to stop this concept of "stop gap" and "needs". The team is not at a competitive level to have those concepts. The fact is, the MOST FAVORABLE outcome for the Twins is that they will dramatically overpay him for the 2027 season, Jeffers will have a season that will maintain his market rate value in the next offseason, and then sign a multi-year deal with another team with the Twins not able to make the QO again. The worse outcome is that he is hurt and misses even more games than he did in 2026. Again, if they wanted to retain Ryan Jeffers they should not have offered the QO and instead made the best free agent offer to him they could. Then, instead of worrying about "stop gap", they would have a guy locked in for 3-4 years that could become a complementary player once our younger prospects get their growing pains out of the way.
-
Ryan Jeffers and the $50 Million Question
LyleCole replied to Cody Christie's topic in Twins Daily Front Page News
This decision is not a micro one. It is a macro, in that deciding to resign Ryan Jeffers (ignore what hte terms of the contract are) should be dependent upon what other moves the Twins plan to make and how much money they are willing to expand their payroll. If Jeffers is really the only guy they would consider signing, then just let him walk. Ryan Jeffers is just bringing back the same level team. Then, unless you can find a trade partner for Caratini, the catching duo for 2027 should be Caratini and Kadim Diaw. But if they plan on bringing in several more free agents to $10+ million market rate contracts then they need to sign Jeffers. The decision needs to be made with a complete understanding of the free agent environment and understanding the fact the Twins are not a premium free agent destination. Unrealistic expectations on our ability to sign quality free agents cannot be entertained. But, go one way or the other. Either fully commit to a much higher budget or rebuild. Playing the middle, low budget but not a rebuild, just gives more low end mediocrity. -
And how has that worked out for this team?
- 100 replies
-
- walker jenkins
- alan roden
-
(and 2 more)
Tagged with:
-
If it is a matter of keeping Buxton and sending Jenkins back to the minors, then we should not keep Buxton.
- 100 replies
-
- walker jenkins
- alan roden
-
(and 2 more)
Tagged with:
-
I would say no. Instead, with a rebuilding team I would leave the DH spot open so that I can at least begin the season rotating some of the hitters into the lineup, with Keaschall getting the most appearances at DH. Perhaps, as the season unfolds, the positional situation solidifies and a DH only type develops out of that. But until you get a good long look at Rodriguez, Jenkens, Mendez, Roden, and Gonzales do not slot a guy like Josh Bell to the DH.
- 39 replies
-
- byron buxton
- josh bell
-
(and 1 more)
Tagged with:
-
Usually salary caps are structured so you cannot offer contracts like the 4/75 you propose.
- 19 replies
-
- carlos correa
- sonny gray
-
(and 4 more)
Tagged with:
-
Over the long run, the salary cap might help teams like Minnesota compete. But, the cities with huge local revenues also are the cities that have the highest level of outside sports income opportunities. So $30 million in New York or LA is always going to be much more valuable than $30 million in Minneapolis. And, over the short and near term, the huge jump in salary floor could really kill teams like Minnesota because they will simply get locked into bad contracts where they had to overpay to get free agents to sign here. And this could hit the team right when we really should be rebuilding with very cheap young talent like Jenkens, Culpepper, and Lackey.
- 19 replies
-
- carlos correa
- sonny gray
-
(and 4 more)
Tagged with:
-
LyleCole’s 2027 Payroll Blueprint: Prospect Rebuild
LyleCole replied to LyleCole's topic in Minnesota Twins Talk
Sure there is. We have 4+ young outfielders who have made their tours through the minor leagues: Jenkins, Rodriguez, Mendes, and Roden. They need ABs. This team is not going to be good in 2027 so why keep Buxton in their way? -
LyleCole’s 2027 Payroll Blueprint: Prospect Rebuild
LyleCole replied to LyleCole's topic in Minnesota Twins Talk
IT is rebuild time. The only player that is traded is Buxton. Perhaps some of the prospects/players he brings back would be on this rebuilding roster. What I would hope is that Culpepper, Jenkins, Rodriguez, Houston, all gain solid experience in 2027 to build on 2028. There is enough of a cadre of pitching (Ryan is still tentatively on this roster unless a team makes a solid offer), with Hoffman and resigning MInter to carry over into 2028 to start to compete. Then, because of the massive savings this budget develops, they can build around that core to fill in the gaps. This is the only realistic approach. -
C: Victor Caratini ($7.00M) 1B: Royce Lewis ($5.10M) 2B: Luke Keaschall ($1.00M) 3B: Brooks Lee ($1.00M) SS: Kaelen Culpepper ($1.00M) LF: Emmanuel Rodriguez ($1M) CF: Walker Jenkins ($1M) RF: Hendrys Mendez ($1.00M) DH: Kody Clemens ($3.60M) 4th OF: Alan Roden ($1.00M) Utility: Marek Houston ($1.00M) Utility: Gabe Gonzales ($1.00M) Backup C: Khadim Diaw ($1M) POS: Add Dead Money Here ($0.00M) SP1: Pablo Lopez ($21.50M) SP2: Joe Ryan ($9.60M) SP3: Dean Kremer ($6.50M) SP4: Zebby Matthews ($1M) SP5: Taj Bradley ($4.50M) RP: Jeff Hoffman ($7.25M) RP: AJ Minter ($7M) RP: Tommy Nance ($1.20M) RP: Cole Sands ($1.30M) RP: Kody Funderburk ($1.00M) RP: Connor Prielipp ($1.00M) RP: Andrew Morris ($1.00M) RP: Marco Raya ($1.00M) POS: Add Dead Money Here ($0.00M) Payroll is 33.67% under budget
-
C: Victor Caratini ($7.00M) 1B: Royce Lewis ($5.10M) 2B: Luke Keaschall ($1.00M) 3B: Brooks Lee ($1.00M) SS: Kaelen Culpepper ($1.00M) LF: Trevor Larnach ($6.30M) CF: Byron Buxton ($15.00M) RF: Walker Jenkins ($1.00M) DH: Kody Clemens ($3.60M) 4th OF: Emmanuel Rodriguez ($1.00M) Utility: Austin Martin ($1.00M) Utility: Ryan Kreidler ($1.00M) Backup C: Alex Jackson ($2.00M) POS: Add Dead Money Here ($0.00M) SP1: Pablo Lopez ($21.50M) SP2: Joe Ryan ($9.60M) SP3: Dean Kremer ($6.50M) SP4: Bailey Ober ($6.90M) SP5: Taj Bradley ($4.50M) RP: Jeff Hoffman ($7.25M) RP: Anthony Banda ($2.30M) RP: Tommy Nance ($1.20M) RP: Cole Sands ($1.30M) RP: Kody Funderburk ($1.00M) RP: Travis Adams ($1.00M) RP: Andrew Morris ($1.00M) RP: Zebby Matthews ($1.00M) POS: Add Dead Money Here ($0.00M) Payroll is 17.74% under budget
-
I did not express an opinion on public subsidies of sports franchises. However, since you brought the point up the value that the public gets from the money they invest in these stadiums is pennies on the dollar. You can use the Warehouse District as an example, but for the most part this is just shifting investment from one area of the city to the another that benefits new investors and hurts previous investors. One easy way to view this is to think about a new "convention center". Proponents of such venues point to the massive revenues such an investment will yield, but usually these projections fall short because the incremental revenues created by the new building are small compared to the revenues that already existed. I do not oppose public investment in infrastructure that is based on a realistic return on those dollars. I also believe the city-county-state receive some value in the architectural value of these buildings. But the $1 billion plus they have invested on the Vikings stadium cannot come close to paying for the investment.
-
Yeah. Normally I am all for ownership and profits. That is how innovations and high paying jobs are created. Without the incentives for capital formation our lifestyles would not be much greater than that of Medieval times, hand to mouth subsistence living. But high level professional sports ownership is different because the franchise is limited. There are only 30 major league baseball teams. These corporations trade at multiples to cash flow that are very high because not every billionaire gets to own one no matter how much they want to. So there should be an obligation to the fans/customers of these special types of business, which are also, btw, heavily subsidized by local governments, to create a product that maximizes the fans value. The Pohlads have never done this. Nor did the Griffiths. The fact is, Minnesota is not a sports friendly environment. Our local revenues are minimal (see all of the problems getting the local sports broadcasting done for the region). And although the market size is not small, it is the 15th largest television market in the United States, the value is just not there. And I think our local ownership of all of the sports franchises reflects this. It even carries into college level athletics. One of the pieces of evidence I present in support of this thesis is look at the states in the US that have only one D1 FBS basketball and football teams. Minnesota is by far the largest. Minnesota has 80% more population than Iowa, yet Iowa fields 2 D1 football teams. Minnesota has 700k more people than Alabama, yet that state has 6 D1 FBS football teams.
-
I would not offer a QO to Jeffers. It would be a disaster if he accepted the QO and the return of a compensatory draft pick isn't enough to take the risk. Instead, as I have said many times, the Twins need to decide if they want to be a real major league baseball franchise or just some rinky dink operation. If they decide on the former, then what their approach with Jeffers should be is to offer him a competitive offer and get him to stay in MN. If they decide the later, then just let him walk. The idea that they "get nothing" in that case, and if they decide on the latter, not trading him at the trade deadline was another in a string of huge mistakes.
-
3 Bold Predictions for Minnesota Twins’ Offseason
LyleCole replied to Cody Christie's topic in Twins Daily Front Page News
65 years of history. 125 years if you want to include the full Washington Senators franchise.- 53 replies
-
- royce lewis
- ownership
-
(and 1 more)
Tagged with:
-
3 Bold Predictions for Minnesota Twins’ Offseason
LyleCole replied to Cody Christie's topic in Twins Daily Front Page News
I would not put that past the Twins....- 53 replies
-
- royce lewis
- ownership
-
(and 1 more)
Tagged with:
-
3 Bold Predictions for Minnesota Twins’ Offseason
LyleCole replied to Cody Christie's topic in Twins Daily Front Page News
Here is my bold prediction: The Twins will do everything exactly the same as they have done that last 15 years. 1. They will address the bullpen exactly the same old way. They will add 2-3 arms like Anthony Banda and Taylor Rodgers, spending a maximum of $2 million on them and total budget under $6 million. 2. They will find a couple of 30 plus year old guys that are mediocre at best and sign them to a 2 year deal that has a year two buyout, all for under $15 million. 3. They will not be bold in promoting any other prospects who did not come up in 2026, and might even send Emmanual Rodriguez back to AAA for more seasoning. Oh, they will talk the talk about building up the team, but in the end their caution and cheapness will prevail, and they will produce similar results as 2026, and many of the years before.- 53 replies
-
- royce lewis
- ownership
-
(and 1 more)
Tagged with:
-
Who Was the Least Valuable Player on the 2026 Twins?
LyleCole replied to Nick Nelson's topic in Twins Daily Front Page News
The Twins could have eliminated many of them. Why break Spring Training with Outman on your roster? Tristan Gray, same question. The Twins have been very reluctant to move their prospects to their major league roster. I am not sure if it is a case of them feeling that the guys are "not ready" or whatever, but the fact is, they seldom arrive at the MLB level "ready". But there can never be "perfection" except in the case of some of the top level prospects, and even they usually need some seasoning at the MLB level. But, most likely, in 2027, (if they do not resign Jeffers) the Twins will have a throw away backup catcher behind Caratini (two candidates for worse player) rather than give a guy like Diaw an opportunity to develop at the major league level. Add in a couple of low level backup positonal guys and bargain basement relievers, those will be your candidates for Least Valuable player in 2027. It is almost set in stone. If I ran the team, I would have Diaw as my starting catcher, play him some in the OF, and even 1B. Develop that professional hitter with defensive flexibility. If he does worst than 0.0 WAR we are actually ahead of the game because then we know. Not all prospects work out. Not all prospects can come close to their success in the minors. When you are rebuilding, the sooner you find out that information, the better.- 62 replies
-
- simeon woods richardson
- matt wallner
-
(and 2 more)
Tagged with:
-
Again, I think the word crisis is an overstatement but what you present is basically impossible. For the Twins to become anywhere competitive they have only four real choices for roster development: 1. Internal player development ; 2. Prospects acquired by trading (potential) high cost veterans ; 3. Minor free agent signings and ; 4. Minor trades. There isn't a major free agent signing that is coming down the pike, and one reason for that is even if ownership was willing to spend that kind of money there are few high end free agents that want to come to the franchise in Minnesota. And your last statement is a lame argument. Of course, no one knows for certain if the 2028 staff will be better or worse. When you are dealing with decisions that involve the future there is uncertainty. HOWEVER, the lack of certainty does not mean you ignore objective probabilities, and the probability of the 2028 starting rotation being better than the 2026 one is very low. Why? Almost the PROJECTED starting rotation would be the same, with the likely exception of Joe Ryan. When evaluating the projected 2028 rotation one easy way of thinking of how it will place the Twins relative to the best teams in major league baseball is to look at the 1-2-3-4-5 type status of the rotation. Taj Bradley had a pretty good first full season as a starter, but as a #1 starter is he on the level of the existing competitive teams? The answer is almost certainly no. Then their other guys are at least "one rotation spot lower than what a competitive staff would have them i.e. our 2nd-3rd starter would be a 4th starter on a high end roation. Our 4th starter, the 5th. And the balance of the rotation would probably not be part of any real competitive teams rotation. And, as I have pointed out, are there really any high end prospects that follow up those guys? Maybe Riley Quick? But he struggled to find the plate this season. I think Rojas has some potential, maybe the highest of any of the pitchers with rookie status still intact, but the Twins cannot seem to finalize a development path for him. Their organization seems to not really be able to develop young high school arms (Dasan Hill, Charlie Soto) and is filled with mid-level college arms that they cannot get over the AA hurdle. And, we have not even come close to addressing the bullpen.
- 81 replies
-
- taj bradley
- connor prielipp
- (and 6 more)
-
You are counting on high upside for everybody and no injuries, and even those hopes cannot fill the entire pitching roster. And based on the actual evidence we have seen, while you can put out a rotation with Abel, Matthews, and Prielipp plus Bradley and some #5 starter, that really isn't a good enough rotation to be a real contender. That rotation isn't as good as our current rotation.
- 81 replies
-
- taj bradley
- connor prielipp
- (and 6 more)
-
While the word "crisis" is poorly chosen, the Twins have a serious lack of talent in their pitching pipeline. I have pointed this out several times when I have posited that the Twins should have entered rebuilding mode before the 2026 season, trading Ryan and Buxton to improve the quality and depth of their pitching prospects. What the Twins have is a significant imbalance between the maturation of their positional prospects (Jenkins, Culpepper, Rodriguez, Houston, Lackey, and others) and their pitching prospects. The most likely result of all of this will be a continuation of mediocre outcomes and a team that is not a true contender to win the World Series, or even a playoff series, or even a playoff game.
- 81 replies
-
- taj bradley
- connor prielipp
- (and 6 more)
-
If Johan is being disqualified because of the sexual that is completely unfair. The entire incident occurred in Fort Myers in the Renaissance community where Santana had a home. All of the real evidence indicated that this was consensual sex. I know people who live in the community and they stated that this was not the first time this woman has had these claims.
-
People can SAY anything. Of course he says he wants to stay in Minnesota. But, when confronted with a huge upgrade in teams and the chance to play in the World Series, he would forget everything he ever said. And if he didn't, then you have to wonder about his competitiveness level. So, in a way, you can believe him and not believe him simultaneously. "Byron we have a deal to trade you to teh LA Dodgers do you opt out of your no trade?" Split second later "Of course." But, Byron we have a deal to trade you to the Montreal Expos, do you reject that trade" is a much different proposition.
- 73 replies
-
- joe ryan
- bailey ober
-
(and 1 more)
Tagged with:

