Jump to content
Twins Daily
  • Create Account

Recommended Posts

Posted

The Minnesota Twins are expected to move on from Trevor Larnach, according to Dan Hayes of The Athletic. The team is reportedly planning to non-tender the outfielder on Friday, which would make him a free agent once the transaction becomes official.

Larnach entered the offseason as an arbitration-eligible player, with MLB Trade Rumors projecting him to earn approximately $6.3 million in 2027. That figure is a significant commitment for a player whose role with Minnesota was becoming less certain. Rather than carry that salary into next season, the Twins appear ready to give Larnach an opportunity to find a new home.

 

There are several factors behind the expected decision, but Minnesota's changing outfield composition is one of the biggest. 

A Crowded Outfield Picture

The Twins have several young players pushing for opportunities at the major-league level. Byron Buxton remains an important part of the organization's plans, while Emmanuel Rodriguez, Walker Jenkins, and Luke Keaschall are all part of the team's future outfield picture.

Rodriguez presents an especially interesting roster situation because he is out of minor-league options. Minnesota cannot simply send him back to Triple-A without exposing him to waivers. That puts additional pressure on the organization to find a place for him on the big-league roster.

Jenkins is another important piece of the team's future. The highly regarded prospect is expected to factor into Minnesota's plans as he continues progressing toward a major-league opportunity. Keaschall also gives the organization another young option who can contribute in multiple areas.

Keeping Larnach would make it more difficult to distribute playing time among those players. The Twins need to determine which young players deserve opportunities, and maintaining an established veteran at a projected $6.3 million salary would limit some of that flexibility.

Production Comes With Some Questions

Larnach is coming off the best offensive season of his major-league career. He appeared in 122 games during 2026, hitting .269/.352/.436 with 13 home runs and a 120 OPS+. He was one of Minnesota's most productive hitters, providing a consistent offensive presence in a lineup that needed it.

However, there are reasons to question how much of that production would carry over into next season. Larnach was often shielded from left-handed starters, giving him more favorable matchups throughout the season. His numbers were solid, but they might look different if he were asked to handle an everyday role against pitchers from both sides. His .436 slugging percentage was a career high, but it still doesn't provide the type of power teams typically want from a corner outfielder.

There are also defensive limitations to consider. Larnach isn't an especially strong defensive outfielder, and his lack of speed limits his ability to contribute on the bases. Minnesota has talked about improving its athleticism and defensive versatility, and Larnach doesn't necessarily fit that direction.

Health has also been a concern. Larnach missed time late in the 2026 campaign with a wrist injury and is scheduled to undergo arthroscopic surgery during the offseason. While the procedure is considered relatively minor, it adds another variable to his availability heading into spring training.

Still, there is something uncomfortable about the optics of this decision. Larnach was a first-round pick in 2018, and he finally delivered the type of offensive season the organization had been waiting to see. Now, the Twins are reportedly prepared to let him walk without receiving anything in return. After watching him become one of the team's better hitters, Minnesota is essentially giving up on that investment.

The organization has also demonstrated that it was willing to move Larnach before reaching this point. At last season's trade deadline, the Twins reportedly agreed to send him to the Houston Astros in exchange for reliever Bryan Abreu. However, Houston's owner Jim Crane ultimately nixed the deal before it could be completed. That situation makes Friday's expected decision even more interesting. Minnesota once viewed Larnach as a potential trade piece capable of bringing back an established major-league reliever. Now, the organization appears ready to move on for nothing.

An Opportunity for a Fresh Start

There was a reasonable argument for keeping Larnach entering the offseason. He proved he could be a productive major-league hitter, and the Twins aren't exactly overflowing with established offensive talent. However, roster construction is about more than identifying the best individual players.

Minnesota needs to determine what its younger players can accomplish at the major-league level. Rodriguez needs a spot because he is out of options, Jenkins showed his high-ceiling after a slow start, and Keaschall was arguably the team’s best hitter in the second-half. Keeping Larnach would make it harder to create a clear path for those players.

Non-tendering Larnach doesn't mean he cannot be a productive major-league player. Another organization could see value in his ability to get on base and provide left-handed offense. At 29, he should have plenty of opportunities to continue his career elsewhere.

For Minnesota, this decision comes down to balancing recent production against salary, roster flexibility, and the organization's future plans. The Twins might have legitimate reasons for moving on, but watching a former first-round pick leave for nothing after his best major-league season is difficult to ignore.


Did the Twins make the correct decision with Larnach, or should they have found a way to keep him? Leave a comment and start the discussion.

 

Image courtesy of © Katie Stratman-Imagn Images

View full article

Posted

Another guy who's had more than his fair share of chances. Good move, although I would've tried harder to get something for him last year.

Posted
6 minutes ago, dberthia said:

Another guy who's had more than his fair share of chances. Good move.

But he's delivered.  The question is if MN has enough OF depth if Buxton gets hurt and either ERod or Walter start slow or get hurt. Then it's just the other rookie in CF, Keaschall and Roden starting and Martin and Clemens as the subs.  Seriously, go look at how Rodriquez and Jenkins started last year and tell me both are going to be great out of the gate and not get hurt.

Posted

Crowded outfield? Not sure what that has to do with Larnach since he's not an outfielder. Sure, he can technically stand in left field, but he doesn't have any business playing there outside of an emergency. I could see the Twins bringing him back on a $3-4MM deal as a DH.

I don't expect Larnach will generate a lot more than that on the open market unless a team actually looks at Larnach as a legitimate left field option. I could see Boston as a landing spot.

Posted

I expect you could not find a 10-year-old playing little league who didn't know that there wasn't a spot for Larnach on next year's team.  Unfortunately, that also meant every other GM also knew the Twins couldn't keep him.   So, when the Twins called regarding trading either Larnach or Ober, expect the response was what else to you want to give us for a middling level complex league player? 

Great seeing Zoll making the hard calls regarding both.  Unfortunately, they both have meant a lot to the Twins for many years and as people, will be missed. 

Also means the Twins will have another $12M+/- and two open roster spots.  Whether they are free agents or via trade, would love to see a good lefty reliever and another option on the right side of the infield.

Posted

I'm surprised they couldn't find a trade partner since he has a three year track record of above average production.  I mean Kansas City need OF bats, and we could use a DH.  Now Roden gets more guaranteed playing time.  

Posted
2 minutes ago, rdehring said:

I expect you could not find a 10-year-old playing little league who didn't know that there wasn't a spot for Larnach on next year's team.  Unfortunately, that also meant every other GM also knew the Twins couldn't keep him.   So, when the Twins called regarding trading either Larnach or Ober, expect the response was what else to you want to give us for a middling level complex league player? 

Great seeing Zoll making the hard calls regarding both.  Unfortunately, they both have meant a lot to the Twins for many years and as people, will be missed. 

You may want to keep other teams from signing them.  Ober, I am not as surprised with the loss of velocity.  But Larnarch was getting better.  A120+ OPS is pretty good.  He is a good 3/4 player against rhp. 

Posted
7 minutes ago, Brandon said:

I'm surprised they couldn't find a trade partner since he has a three year track record of above average production.  I mean Kansas City need OF bats, and we could use a DH.  Now Roden gets more guaranteed playing time.  

My guess is that other teams could see the writing on the wall with Minnesota's crowded outfield situation. They can wait until he is a free agent and sign him for less than he would have made in arbitration. 

Posted
16 minutes ago, Cody Christie said:

My guess is that other teams could see the writing on the wall with Minnesota's crowded outfield situation. They can wait until he is a free agent and sign him for less than he would have made in arbitration. 

I blame Jim Crane and the wrist surgery. 

Posted
34 minutes ago, TheLeviathan said:

Ugh, it's the right call but it compounds a wrong call that was already made to keep him last year.

Compounds?  How so?  At most it shines a bright light on the decision a year ago.

I think most of the posters here correctly inferred he had no meaningful trade value.  Tendering him meant keeping him; and this was confirmed at the trade deadline when a deal for a partial season of a good reliever fell through.  Sure, you could trade him for nothing, but that's not trade value.

But past is past, and if the FO tried again to swing a deal, even for a low-ranking prospect, and failed, then this is a good decision and I don't know quite what you mean.

Posted
49 minutes ago, Brandon said:

I'm surprised they couldn't find a trade partner since he has a three year track record of above average production.  

Other teams can read the stats and interpret the splits the same as we can.  Probably better.  There is a large gap between "above average at the plate if you play him only a certain way and ignore base running and defense" and "an asset toward a championship season." 

Teams don't trade for assets when they probably have someone already with similar skills.  The Twins don't want to keep someone they can't trade when they have someone already with similar skills and who costs less. 

It doesn't mean Larnach is a bad baseball player, exactly. Baseball's a business and sometimes the decisions turn on things that lie beneath the surface stats.

Posted
53 minutes ago, Brandon said:

I'm surprised they couldn't find a trade partner since he has a three year track record of above average production.  I mean Kansas City need OF bats, and we could use a DH.  Now Roden gets more guaranteed playing time.  

About 8-10 competitive teams could upgrade their LF/DH. It's surprising the Twins couldn't find a trade partner, even for an A/AA MIRP.

Maybe his wrist surgery chilled the market.

37 people currently on the 40-man.

Posted
6 minutes ago, MeleMouth said:

About 8-10 competitive teams could upgrade their LF/DH. It's surprising the Twins couldn't find a trade partner.

When faced with a paradox, it pays to examine underlying assumptions.

  • The Twins front office is competent
  • Larnach at his salary represents an upgrade for multiple teams

Folks here like to question the first of these assumptions, and imply the FO is giving away tradable assets.

I'm suggesting it's the latter assumption that needs to be reconsidered.

Posted
5 minutes ago, ashbury said:

When faced with a paradox, it pays to examine underlying assumptions.

  • The Twins front office is competent
  • Larnach at his salary represents an upgrade for multiple teams

Folks here like to question the first of these assumptions, and imply the FO is giving away tradable assets.

I'm suggesting it's the latter assumption that needs to be reconsidered.

I said Larnach's wrist surgery may have made teams skittish to take him on, perhaps, as you say, at his salary. How is that challenging an assumption of competence by the front office? (Not that they haven't done many other things that made them appear to be less competent than many other front offices.)

Posted

I think it's the right decision. Larnach hits RHP pretty well, but unfortunately that's really about all he does at this point. That ain't nothing, but when you really only contribute to one facet of the game you have to be really good at it (or be cheap and filling a smaller role).

If we had more RH hitters, more availability at DH, fewer LH prospects...maybe. But the opportunity cost of letting him fill the roster spot is more of the problem than the salary.

I wish him luck. His injury luck didn't help him here.

Posted
Just now, MeleMouth said:

About 8-10 competitive teams could upgrade their LF/DH. It's surprising the Twins couldn't find a trade partner.

What was said quite a bit in the Ober threads was that he's not enough of an upgrade at the arb price to want to lock in this soon.  Trevor's likely going to be out there at market value, and over time that price will slowly drift down until some team thinks he's worth it at that time. Desperate teams will move before those where he's only a mild upgrade. But the Twins were going to have to be dealing him this month at the arb price (or sign him to take a loss) and other teams preferred to wait.

Posted
Just now, Cris E said:

What was said quite a bit in the Ober threads was that he's not enough of an upgrade at the arb price to want to lock in this soon.  Trevor's likely going to be out there at market value, and over time that price will slowly drift down until some team thinks he's worth it at that time. Desperate teams will move before those where he's only a mild upgrade. But the Twins were going to have to be dealing him this month at the arb price (or sign him to take a loss) and other teams preferred to wait.

Makes sense. I accidentally hit "submit" too soon with my comment about Larnach and amended it quickly. With Larnach, $7M might have been OK to other teams if he were fully healthy, or at least worth sending an A/AA pitcher for, but the wrist surgery may have scared them off.

Posted

So much for taking on the risk of the “tender, then trade” approach.

Twins wanted no part of that with Larnach and Ober.  The team is not taking any chances of being stuck with a bad use of cash.

One more shoe left to drop?

Posted
2 minutes ago, MeleMouth said:

Makes sense. I accidentally hit "submit" too soon with my comment about Larnach and amended it quickly. With Larnach, $7M might have been OK to other teams if he were fully healthy, or at least worth sending an A/AA pitcher for, but the wrist surgery may have scared them off.

I may have ended up more responding to @ashbury more than you. But it all adds up to the same result that letting him go was the best option his market left open.

Posted
2 minutes ago, Cris E said:

I may have ended up more responding to @ashbury more than you. But it all adds up to the same result that letting him go was the best option his market left open.

Teams will be interested in Larnach. Assuming health, competitive teams with openings include ATL, CHW, DET, SEA, TOR, CHC, NYM, and PHI. At a lower price, several other teams will be interested.

Create an account or sign in to comment

You need to be a member in order to leave a comment

Create an account

Sign up for a new account in our community. It's easy!

Register a new account

Sign in

Already have an account? Sign in here.

Sign In Now
The Twins Daily Caretaker Fund
The Twins Daily Caretaker Fund

You all care about this site. The next step is caring for it. We’re asking you to caretake this site so it can remain the premier Twins community on the internet.

×
×
  • Create New...