Jump to content
Twins Daily
  • Create Account

Recommended Posts

Twins Daily Contributor
Posted

Royce Lewis entered last season with an opportunity to establish himself as a cornerstone of the Minnesota Twins’ infield. Instead, his year became a frustrating exercise in trying to find consistency. He appeared to fall out of favor with the organization, spent time in Triple-A, and struggled to regain his footing after returning to the big leagues. Now, the Twins might be considering another defensive change for Lewis heading into 2027.

For much of his major-league career, Lewis has been associated with third base. However, Brooks Lee’s emergence at the position has complicated that arrangement. Lee took over as Minnesota’s primary third baseman and performed well enough to become a Gold Glove finalist, even though he didn’t spend the entire season at the hot corner.

That development makes it increasingly difficult to envision Lewis simply reclaiming his previous position. The Twins also appeared to be moving toward a future where Lewis would see more time at first base. However, general manager Jeremy Zoll recently offered another possibility that could reshape the infield.

Second Base Could Be an Option

During his comments about Minnesota’s roster plans, Zoll left the door open for Lewis to become a regular second baseman. The organization experimented with moving Lewis around the right side of the infield last season, but the transition didn’t happen under ideal circumstances.

Lewis received limited preparation at Triple-A St. Paul before attempting to handle those responsibilities in the majors. Learning a new position while trying to get his offensive production back on track created additional challenges.

“It was a little bit clunky last year doing the right side of the infield on the fly in a very brief amount of time in St. Paul before trying to do it at the Major League level,” Zoll said. “If [Lewis] gets more time at second base, that’s probably somewhere that could really suit him over the medium term. But it was hard to fully accomplish on the fly there. His athleticism allows all those possibilities to present themselves in a way that whatever best suits the team is probably the right answer.”

That comment suggests Minnesota hasn’t completely settled on where Lewis belongs defensively. Second base could provide an opportunity to keep his athleticism on the field without forcing him into a position where the organization already has an established option. It also creates some interesting possibilities elsewhere on the roster.

How Does the Rest of the Infield Fit?

If Lewis becomes the primary second baseman, Kody Clemens could shift into a larger role at first base. Clemens has demonstrated the ability to move around the diamond, making him a potential utility option rather than someone locked into one position.

That flexibility could also give Minnesota more freedom when addressing its first-base situation. The Twins could pursue an impact bat at the position while using Clemens in a supporting role across multiple spots.

Lee’s defensive emergence at third base also gives the organization another reason to explore alternatives for Lewis. Lee has earned an opportunity to continue developing at the position after becoming a Gold Glove finalist. Moving him elsewhere just to accommodate Lewis would be difficult to justify based on their respective defensive performances.

Lewis still has plenty to offer Minnesota. His athleticism provides defensive flexibility, and his offensive potential makes finding a consistent place for him in the lineup important. The challenge is figuring out how to maximize those abilities without disrupting other parts of the roster.

The Twins have several decisions to make before Opening Day, and Lewis’ defensive assignment could influence multiple offseason moves. First base, second base, and even a utility role remain possibilities.

After a season in which Lewis struggled to find his place in Minnesota, the organization appears willing to give him another opportunity to establish himself somewhere new. Second base might not have been the expected destination, but Zoll’s comments indicate it deserves serious consideration.


Does Lewis fit at second base? Should the Twins move on from Lewis? Leave a comment and start the discussion. 

 

 

Image courtesy of Jeffrey Becker-Imagn Images

View full article

Posted

I've wondered for a year or two if this was the long-term move.  He came up as a SS so playing in the middle infield isn't exactly new...he clearly can pick up a ground ball.  I think(?) he's still athletic enough to have the required range to play 2B.  He clearly has the arm strength, which doesn't require a ton, to play 2B.  His offensive profile isn't nearly good enough for 1B.  But it would be a lot closer to good enough for second.  I hope they pick this lane and stick to it.  Perhaps having one defensive home would help him unlock a measure of the offensive potential we've seen in the past.  If it doesn't, it'd be easy to move on from him.

Posted
6 minutes ago, HerbieFan said:

I've wondered for a year or two if this was the long-term move.  He came up as a SS so playing in the middle infield isn't exactly new...he clearly can pick up a ground ball.  I think(?) he's still athletic enough to have the required range to play 2B.  He clearly has the arm strength, which doesn't require a ton, to play 2B.  His offensive profile isn't nearly good enough for 1B.  But it would be a lot closer to good enough for second.  I hope they pick this lane and stick to it.  Perhaps having one defensive home would help him unlock a measure of the offensive potential we've seen in the past.  If it doesn't, it'd be easy to move on from him.

The issue is he's not good enough to have earned one defensive home. Only stars and sure bet starters have one set position with the fringe required to fill in as needed. 

 

Posted

Clemens is a solid 2B and would project as a 2-3 WAR starter there, and Clemens is pre-arb. Can Lewis be reasonably projected as better than that?

The Twins are probably going to implement a new position where all the players go in motion and jog all over the field randomly to add more positional versatility.

Posted

This sounds like a terrible idea for someone with a history of knee reconstruction surgeries like Lewis has. One hard slide could wipe out his career. This reminds me of the failed experient with the Japanese player Tsuyoshi  Nishioka who playeed SS & was then moved to 2B and had his leg broken by a Yankee slider. Then he was relegated to the minors until he got so fed up that he quit his contract and went back to Japan despite having a guaranteed contract. IMO 2B would be a risky move for Lewis & I'm not sure that he would make a good 2B. I would much rather see the Twins try to sign Arraez. 

Posted
21 minutes ago, bean5302 said:

The Twins are probably going to implement a new position where all the players go in motion and jog all over the field randomly to add more positional versatility.

Maybe they’ll hire Brian Flores to create defensive schemes to confuse the batter.

Posted
1 minute ago, DJL44 said:

Trade him to a team that needs a third baseman. There are several of them.

No one needs one that bad.  

It's better just to non-tender him if you want to get rid of him. He's not bringing back anything valuable in a trade. 

All of Ober, Kremer, Lewis, and Larnach are essentially due a fair market salary in arbitration so it's either retain them or drop them. 

Posted

Bad idea.   Very bad idea.

1. He’s simply not a good enough hitter to be a starter at any position.

2. He doesn’t have any special skill set (speed, OBP, defensive wizardry, etc.) that would make him a good candidate for a bench position.

3. He’s starting to get expensive.

4. His presence could block innings and ABs from a player who could be part of the core starting in ‘28.

5. In no way does he move the dial in terms of competing in ‘27.

Let’s just rip the band aid off and say adios to Lewis.  Use his roster spot and cash to improve the current and future team.

Posted

I agree with most of the comments. BUT, Zoll's take on this sounds like a we're making the square peg fit into that round hole whether we like it or not. Maybe that will work, plan?

I don't see them cutting him. .01% chance of it. Same for Ober/Larnach/Kremer. Johan Duran came from a trade for a player similar to any of those 4. After the new CBA some or all will have new teams.

Posted
1 hour ago, sun said:

This sounds like a terrible idea for someone with a history of knee reconstruction surgeries like Lewis has. One hard slide could wipe out his career. This reminds me of the failed experient with the Japanese player Tsuyoshi  Nishioka who playeed SS & was then moved to 2B and had his leg broken by a Yankee slider. Then he was relegated to the minors until he got so fed up that he quit his contract and went back to Japan despite having a guaranteed contract. IMO 2B would be a risky move for Lewis & I'm not sure that he would make a good 2B. I would much rather see the Twins try to sign Arraez. 

The recent rule changes have basically eliminated this issue.

Posted
1 hour ago, sun said:

This sounds like a terrible idea for someone with a history of knee reconstruction surgeries like Lewis has. One hard slide could wipe out his career. This reminds me of the failed experient with the Japanese player Tsuyoshi  Nishioka who playeed SS & was then moved to 2B and had his leg broken by a Yankee slider. Then he was relegated to the minors until he got so fed up that he quit his contract and went back to Japan despite having a guaranteed contract. IMO 2B would be a risky move for Lewis & I'm not sure that he would make a good 2B. I would much rather see the Twins try to sign Arraez. 

This has to be one of the most needless mean spirited posts I've seen in a while.

Nishioka came in and was hated by Gardenhire from day 1. Nick Swisher made a slide that would have gotten him suspended today, and the guy was then relegated to the minors where he toiled away with no hope of ever making it back. Despite this, he kept working at it as his marriage fell apart, and instead of sticking around and milking out out his contract like other MLB players have always done, he publicly apologized for his poor play, allowed the Twins to tear up the contract, release him and return to Japan. Could Nishioka have made it? Unlikely, but all he did was give 100%, accept being relegated to the minors while trying to improve, sacrifice his reputation, marriage, guaranteed paycheck to try.

When it comes to Lewis, did you miss where he played 3B? You think standing at a different position on the field means his knees will buckle? 

Seriously. Eat a Snickers.

Posted

My proposal for second base ......... Bailey Ober and a solid milb prospect for Casey Schmitt as it would be good for both teams. Schmitt a solid 2B defensively, a RH bat with .271/.301/.741 slash last year (will need to work on plate discipline away from Giant's free-swing mentality to improve that OBP), and arb controllable for 3 years.  Clemens serves as primary 1B with Gabriel Gonzalez getting some reps vs lefties.

Move Lewis, Wallner and Larnach for what the market will bear.......RPs and/or milb lottery tix accepted. This leaves payroll in a good place to add a free agent SP and/or RP.

 

Posted

My how far Lewis has fallen in the esteem of some folks here on Twins Daily. Three years ago I suggested that the Twins needed to reconsider their direction and make attempts at reconfiguring their roster. My focus was to improve the rotation and defense. The three players I wanted to move in transactions were Matt Wallner, Eddie Julien, and Royce Lewis. Those three carried outsized values at that time as shown by BaseballTradeValues.com. I was ripped vociferously for my comments. Since then I have mellowed on Lewis.

Lewis is on a minimal contract. He wasn't really good at third base but he was ok. He managed to pick up first base better than expected and was particularly good at scooping poor throws even as he struggled with the nuances of where to line up on relays or occasionally wandering too far off the bag on grounders to the second baseman. At the dish, Lewis has worn out his welcome with many because of his addiction to the low outside pitches, which he obstinately attempts to pull. The other side of the coin is that Lewis is not someone with high K rates, he can run a little bit, and the ball still comes off his bat in a sweet fashion. In various iterations of a roster, often I have dumped Lewis from the team. That has changed. 

I'm now more inclined to hold him unless he returns real value. The only way Lewis returns value is if he is packaged with another player like Ryan. I don't see a good trade for Ryan so this leaves Royce at 1B if the Twins can bring in Brandon Lowe or 2B if the Twins choose to sign Ty France. Lewis will be a better defender than Clemens after he gets the repetitions he needs to learn the position because he is more athletic.

While I never previously bought into the hype for Royce Lewis because I saw only an undisciplined player, I now see a rehabbing guy who may come into 2027 with his legs back to what can be his 100% health going forward. I also think he will finally adopt the approaches his coaches have brought to him about punishing those middle and middle high outside pitches to right field while laying off the outside worm borers. It could happen but I could be stone cold wrong too.

Posted

How much more will the Twins spend on position players after the Jeffers transaction and Gray signing? I would expect that they might try to trade Larnach, Caratini plus a pitcher or two to reduce the payroll enough to sign a reliever or two, but filling the gaps at first and second would have to either save money or be neutral.

Keeping Lewis and giving him a chance at second with some prep time would seem to be a higher possibility now.

I think there absolutely has to be a Plan B (probably involving Kody Clemens) but I have hope that Lewis can help the current club. 

Posted

I'll just repeat what was written yesterday. The Twins can do whatever they want. Will they? 

Today we saw the Twins take another big step. Can they do something else? Yes, they can. Will they?

I don't think it has been possible to make sense of the moves in the past ten years and mostly we just remain baseball fans. It is what we do best. 

People made predictions on $125M, $135M, $150M, $160M, and $170M. Round and round and round we go and where it stops .... nobody knows.

Posted

JZ's talk about moving Royce Lewis to second is more likely a message to Lewis than to fans, despite how it's been portrayed, but Lewis at second sounds scary. Second basemen get injured a lot and Lewis already gets injured a lot. A key requirement of second basemen is making bang-bang plays, but Lewis struggled to do that at the easier position of first base.

Posted

Before any of this matters Royce has to hit. If he hits next year like he did this past year he will simply be released. I think the Twins hitting philosophy of trying to get everything in the air to the pull side has hurt Royce. If I’m Royce I would call Molly and ask for a complete rehab of swing and approach. 

Posted
8 minutes ago, Linus said:

Before any of this matters Royce has to hit. If he hits next year like he did this past year he will simply be released. I think the Twins hitting philosophy of trying to get everything in the air to the pull side has hurt Royce. If I’m Royce I would call Molly and ask for a complete rehab of swing and approach. 

Paul loved the first pitch and he always tried to yank it into the corner or seats. After that Molly was hitting the pitch anywhere and off and running. What a player. Molitor is the #11 all time hits leader in MLB history.

Posted
1 minute ago, IndianaTwin said:

We'll find out Friday, but the Zoll quote doesn't sound like someone about to be non-tendered. 

Lewis to the Pirates for Henry Davis and Levi Sterling

Posted
6 hours ago, bean5302 said:

Clemens is a solid 2B and would project as a 2-3 WAR starter there, and Clemens is pre-arb. Can Lewis be reasonably projected as better than that?

The Twins are probably going to implement a new position where all the players go in motion and jog all over the field randomly to add more positional versatility.

Except he's not a good defensive 2B. Clemens has -4 defensive runs saved (DRS) and -4 outs above average (OAA) at 2B. Simply put, he stinks at 2B. 

On the other hand, he has a +1 OAA and a +3 DRS rating at 1B. Simply put, Clemens is an above average fielding 1B.

Best defensive alignment is for Clemens to play 1B and to get a better defensive 2B. Is that Lewis? Who knows.  

Posted
5 hours ago, BSLinPA said:

My proposal for second base ......... Bailey Ober and a solid milb prospect for Casey Schmitt as it would be good for both teams. Schmitt a solid 2B defensively, a RH bat with .271/.301/.741 slash last year (will need to work on plate discipline away from Giant's free-swing mentality to improve that OBP), and arb controllable for 3 years.  Clemens serves as primary 1B with Gabriel Gonzalez getting some reps vs lefties.

Move Lewis, Wallner and Larnach for what the market will bear.......RPs and/or milb lottery tix accepted. This leaves payroll in a good place to add a free agent SP and/or RP.

 

Sounds good but I doubt Ober and a prospect will get it done unless its a pretty darn good prospect. How about Ober and ERod for Schmitt and a Solid AA guy? Substitute GG or Quick for ERod? Maybe Ober and Roden plus a 15-30 prospect currently in A or AA? 

Posted
7 hours ago, Nashvilletwin said:

Bad idea.   Very bad idea.

1. He’s simply not a good enough hitter to be a starter at any position.

Exactly. Finding him a regular slot on defense would only make sense if he could hit consistently. DFA him and move on.

I’ve also come around to the idea of a reunion with Luis Arraez to play second and lead off, with Keaschall as DH, batting second. And no I don’t care that he doesn’t fit the power-hitter DH profile—he gets on base and is able to create some excitement out there.

Posted

Talk about rearranging the deck chairs! This is getting ridiculous. 

Clemens gets moved to 2B when Keaschall moves off of it. He gives the Twins one of the better power/offensive 2B in the league. Is he great defensively? No. But he's OK, and will probably get better the more he plays there. Eventually he moves to a daily play utility role when Houston is ready. But again, power and offense at 2B better than most. 

After 2 1/2 years of poor, below average offense, the consensus is Lewis needs to be replaced. An 85 OPS + doesn't work for a "starter"  unless you're a hell of a glove man. That isn't Lewis. The Twins need better. So the option is to move Clemens back to 1B and put Lewis at 2B? You haven't improved anything! You've just moved a bad offensive player to a different position. 

Get a 1B of any decent quality and keep Clemens at 2B. That's an improvement. Move Clemens to 1B and add a decent, quality 2B who can provide a better than 100 + OPS...though I'd take that about now...and you've made an improvement. 

Just moving Lewis to 2B changes nothing. 

I believe Lewis and the Twins need to part company for the good of both sides. But if they insist on keeping him, use him as a 3 position backup. If he actually turns a corner and starts to hit, then he earns more playing time. 

I'm not even a Lewis hater. In fact, I've rooted like hell for him ans offered up excuses/reasons for some of his issues. But just giving him a different starting position doesn't fix or improve anything. 

Create an account or sign in to comment

You need to be a member in order to leave a comment

Create an account

Sign up for a new account in our community. It's easy!

Register a new account

Sign in

Already have an account? Sign in here.

Sign In Now
The Twins Daily Caretaker Fund
The Twins Daily Caretaker Fund

You all care about this site. The next step is caring for it. We’re asking you to caretake this site so it can remain the premier Twins community on the internet.

×
×
  • Create New...