Luke Keaschall is the New Luis Arraez, and Maybe That's Ok

[Cody Christie]

Image courtesy of © Daniel Kucin Jr.-Imagn Images

When Luke Keaschall arrived in Fort Myers this spring, expectations bordered on unreasonable. After an impressive debut and years of strong minor-league production, many believed Keaschall was ready to become a foundational piece of Minnesota's lineup. There were legitimate arguments that he should open the season as the Twins' leadoff hitter. Some even projected him as the club's second-best offensive player, behind Byron Buxton.

Instead, the first month of the season was a reminder that development is rarely linear. Keaschall struggled out of the gate, his defense remained a work in progress, and questions started to emerge about whether he was ready for an everyday role. A few months later, however, the conversation shifted dramatically. He still isn't producing the power numbers many hoped to see, but he is beginning to look like something else.

Maybe Luke Keaschall isn't becoming the next star slugger. Maybe he's becoming the next Luis Arraez. And that might be perfectly fine.

Early Season Sophomore Slump

Keaschall's April numbers painted an ugly picture. In 90 plate appearances, he hit .217/.267/.275 with four doubles and one home run. Perhaps even more concerning was his approach. He struck out 21 times while drawing only eight walks, a significant departure from the disciplined offensive profile that had made him such an intriguing prospect.

The struggles became impossible to ignore. At the plate, Keaschall looked caught between being aggressive and trying to work counts. He increased his bat speed this year, but that initially caused more problems than it solved. In the field, his below-average defense at second base continued to create questions about his long-term fit. When a player isn't providing defensive value and isn't producing offensively, roster spot discussions naturally follow.

There were legitimate reasons to wonder if a reset at Triple-A might be necessary. Instead, the Twins stuck with him. That patience is beginning to pay off.

Keaschall is Officially Fixed

Since May 1, Keaschall has looked like an entirely different hitter. Across 164 plate appearances, he owns a .288/.390/.381 slash line, with eight doubles, one triple, and one home run. More importantly, the underlying plate discipline metrics have returned to the levels that made him successful throughout his climb through the minors.

During that stretch, he has drawn 20 walks while striking out only 23 times. The trend has become even more noticeable recently. Over his last 11 games, Keaschall owns a .930 OPS, fueled by an outstanding .457 on-base percentage. He's walked seven times while striking out only six times during that span.

The Twins' offense has finally started to find consistency over the last couple of weeks, and Keaschall has become an important part of that resurgence. Every lineup benefits from hitters who can extend innings, force opposing pitchers to throw extra pitches, and consistently find ways to reach base. Keaschall is doing all of those things right now.

Keaschall Won't Hit for Power

As encouraging as the recent turnaround has been, it has also clarified exactly what kind of hitter Keaschall is likely to become. Power probably won't be a major part of the equation. His average exit velocity of 84.7 mph ranks in the 4th percentile league-wide. He also sits in the 18th percentile or lower in xSLG, Barrel%, and Hard-Hit%.

Those numbers aren't flukes. Much of the issue stems from his 69.2 mph bat speed. Even when Keaschall makes quality contact, he simply doesn't generate the same raw force as many of the league's premier power hitters. He squares the ball up fairly well, but his hardest contact comes when he's hitting to the center of the diamond on a line, rather than when he pulls and/or backspins the ball.

The result is a unique offensive profile. Instead of launching balls into the seats, Keaschall produces line drives and hard-hit singles. With a 28.7 feet-per-second sprint speed, he has enough athleticism to turn some of those balls into doubles and create pressure on opposing defenses. It may not be flashy, but it can still be productive.

The Luis Arraez Connection

The comparison to Arraez becomes increasingly difficult to ignore. Throughout his career, Arraez has built value almost entirely through elite contact skills, good plate discipline, and an ability to reach base. Home runs were never a significant part of his game, but his offensive profile worked because he consistently put the baseball in play and rarely gave away at-bats.

Keaschall appears to be following a similar blueprint. The encouraging part is that many of the foundational skills are already present. His chase, whiff and strikeout rates all rank in the 83rd percentile or better this season. Those numbers suggest that the early-season swing-and-miss issues were more of a temporary slump than a permanent concern, and that he will find ways to draw walks even though pitchers don't fear him.

Like Arraez, Keaschall's success will depend on maintaining elite bat control and strike-zone awareness. If he starts chasing pitches or allowing strikeouts to creep back into his game, the lack of power becomes a much bigger problem. But if he continues controlling the strike zone the way he has since May, there is a path to becoming an extremely valuable offensive contributor.

Keaschall is unlikely to replicate Arraez's batting titles. Arraez routinely posted strikeout rates below 10% and possessed perhaps the most advanced contact skills in baseball. Keaschall's game includes more walks, more athleticism, and more speed on the bases. The comparison is less about identical production and more about the path to offensive value.

Arraez showed that players do not need 25-home run power to contribute to wins. They need to get on base, create scoring opportunities, and consistently put pressure on opposing pitchers and defenses. Keaschall is beginning to demonstrate that he can do exactly that.

The version of Keaschall many envisioned this spring may never fully materialize. He may not become a middle-of-the-order force. He may never produce the type of exit velocities that light up Statcast leaderboards. The home run totals will likely remain modest.

That doesn't mean he can't be an impact player. Minnesota's lineup already features hitters capable of changing a game with one swing. What it has often lacked is a player who consistently reaches base and keeps the line moving. Keaschall's recent surge suggests he can fill that role.

The comparison to Arraez should not be viewed as a disappointment. Twins fans spent years appreciating one of baseball's most unique offensive talents. If Keaschall develops into a player who reaches base at an elite clip, controls the strike zone, and frustrates opposing pitchers every night, Minnesota will gladly take those results.

The path may not look exactly like what many expected in March, but it is becoming increasingly clear that Keaschall has found a formula that works. And if that formula resembles the one Arraez used to become a batting champion, the Twins should have no complaints.

---

Are there other similarities between Keaschall and Arraez? Leave a comment and start the discussion.

View full article

[Twins_Fan_in_NJ]

Keaschall is 'officially fixed' - based on 164 plate appearances? 

[William K Johnson]

Let's wait until he wins three batting titles, then we can make a comparison.

[CRF]

You can't possibly be serious. 

[laloesch]

Luke Keaschall is no "officially" fixed?  Just like Royce Lewis is "officially" fixed?  Chuckles

[Bangkok Twins Fan]

Keaschall is unlikely to replicate Arraez's batting titles. Arraez routinely posted strikeout rates below 10% and possessed perhaps the most advanced contact skills in baseball. Keaschall's game includes more walks, more athleticism, and more speed on the bases. The comparison is less about identical production and more about the path to offensive value.

Okay, I can accept that as a better measurement, but as William posted, I don't think Luke is going to be a contender for any batting titles.

[thelanges5]

Keaschall has put up a 116 OPS+ since May 1st. That’ll play if he can keep it up. Ron Washington has helped Arraez become a serviceable 2B this year for SF. Maybe we can enlist his services in the offseason. 

[mluebker]

I’m glad to hear everyone in the lineup doesn’t need to be a power hitter. Now, if they just could decide to teach prospects to play one position well, instead of 3-4 adequately, the Twins might start looking like a team that can win, instead of a hodge-podge roster of good intentions and meager results.

[mrmaximoto]

his base stealing ability makes him a better version of Arraez even if he doesn't win batting titles.

[JD-TWINS]

3 minutes ago, thelanges5 said:

Keaschall has put up a 116 OPS+ since May 1st. That’ll play if he can keep it up. Ron Washington has helped Arraez become a serviceable 2B this year for SF. Maybe we can enlist his services in the offseason. 

They need to enlist somebody’s services!

I watched the L.A. game Tuesday night …… Keaschall fails to knock down ball up the middle, Dodgers score. He picks up a soft roller on the grass & as he comes in Lewis covers first ….. Keaschall flips the ball past the pitchers ear & not to 1B, awareness??? Later in game, ball up the middle (tough play) and he backhands it - off his glove and ends up in his throwing hand (running full speed toward left field) and he throws to Lewis with a throw that should NEVER be made - 2 -3 seconds, minimum, late and 15 feet left and short of 1B….. again, awareness??

His enthusiasm is appreciated & noted.

I’m usually a supporter of offense and “accepting” on some occasional defensive issues. Luke is terrible - no arm - no clues - no improvement! Need to play Arcia and let Luke go work with “whoever TWINS have” in St Paul for a few weeks.

Luis Arraez is playing Gold Glove defense at 2B this year (per MLB Network pundits)……. Luke can be fixed (technique), but about 60% of his problems are between his ears! He may need a mild sedative before games?

[shimrod]

Doesn't look like he's ok not being a power hitter. Swinging out of his shoes and missing badly last night. To be fair he wasn't the only culprit.

 

[bean5302]

Keaschall is generating results, but I'm not optimistic about him longer term. A recent hot streak pushed his numbers way up, but I'm not seeing what looks like a sustainable approach.

Comparing him to Arraez just because Arraez isn't a power hitter is nonsensical. Apart from his brutal rookie season, Arraez had solid defensive metrics at 2B by UZR or DRS. OAA hated him, but he's flipped that game on its head apparently learning how to exploit OAA.

Anyway, Arraez purposely hits the way he does. Keaschall tries to make harder contact and fails. Though, I do remember a time early in Arraez's career he started swinging for the fence and his numbers tanked as he had warning track power, not HR power.

[Linus]

I completely agree that Keaschalls offensive profile is badly needed in the Twins lineup. Keaschalls getting on base and stealing some bases would help reduce the boom or bust nature of our offense. There is only one way to know for sure so run him out there and let’s see what he can do. I won’t comment on the defense other than I think he needs to stick at second for the rest of this season. 

[tony&rodney]

Interesting. Does Luke Keaschall bring back Reid Detmers? I thought this was where the comparison was going.

[Bangkok Twins Fan]

1 hour ago, thelanges5 said:

Keaschall has put up a 116 OPS+ since May 1st. That’ll play if he can keep it up. Ron Washington has helped Arraez become a serviceable 2B this year for SF. Maybe we can enlist his services in the offseason. 

I'd love to have Wash on our team as a coach. Great baseball experience, I recall MANY years ago before a spring training game in Florida when Ron was with the Astros, and he was giving fielding tips to a young player who had been a catcher but was now trying his luck in the infield: a kid by the name of Craig Biggio. 

[JD-TWINS]

52 minutes ago, bean5302 said:

Keaschall is generating results, but I'm not optimistic about him longer term. A recent hot streak pushed his numbers way up, but I'm not seeing what looks like a sustainable approach.

Comparing him to Arraez just because Arraez isn't a power hitter is nonsensical. Apart from his brutal rookie season, Arraez had solid defensive metrics at 2B by UZR or DRS. OAA hated him, but he's flipped that game on its head apparently learning how to exploit OAA.

Anyway, Arraez purposely hits the way he does. Keaschall tries to make harder contact and fails. Though, I do remember a time early in Arraez's career he started swinging for the fence and his numbers tanked as he had warning track power, not HR power.

I agree on Luke’s approach and results (some are attributed to his speed) …… he swings to hit the ball in the gap but he often gets a base hit on a flare just on the grass - he has a few infield grounders & swinging bunts for hits, I know, make contact & put the ball in play, it’s a good thing. It’s a better thing if it’s intentional and not a poor result of the intention. Arraez is definitely intentional!

[karcherd]

We need to have some patience, not every player comes up and is a superstar.  Luke has 125 games and 500 plate appearances.  He is still figuring things out at this level like all players.  You need to give him this year at a minimum and see if he can be part of the future.  Or at least have someone better to replace him.  And no Arcia and or Kreidler are not going to be part of the long term solution so he should not be sitting for them.  The comments that want Arcia up here, I don't get.  No one in the league would even claim him and we want him to start for us.

As for his defense, he has had a few better games recently until last night.  He barely has played a season at second, he needs reps.  A comment above mention the throw he shouldn't have made behind second base last night, that can come with reps.  I was at the Rockies games last night and the Red Sox second baseman made a similar throw, should never have thrown it.  Point is these plays are made every night by everyone in the major leagues at some point.  He needs to learn, but these throws can still happen.

[LA Vikes Fan]

2 hours ago, tony&rodney said:

Interesting. Does Luke Keaschall bring back Reid Detmers? I thought this was where the comparison was going.

If it does, let's do it. 

[Mike Sixel]

Hahaha. 

[Brandon]

Anyone getting on base 38% + of the time is going to be value for the team.  Great base running and defense can make him a very valuable player.

[LA Vikes Fan]

37 minutes ago, karcherd said:

We need to have some patience, not every player comes up and is a superstar.  Luke has 125 games and 500 plate appearances.  He is still figuring things out at this level like all players.  You need to give him this year at a minimum and see if he can be part of the future.  Or at least have someone better to replace him.  And no Arcia and or Kreidler are not going to be part of the long term solution so he should not be sitting for them.  The comments that want Arcia up here, I don't get.  No one in the league would even claim him and we want him to start for us.

As for his defense, he has had a few better games recently until last night.  He barely has played a season at second, he needs reps.  A comment above mention the throw he shouldn't have made behind second base last night, that can come with reps.  I was at the Rockies games last night and the Red Sox second baseman made a similar throw, should never have thrown it.  Point is these plays are made every night by everyone in the major leagues at some point.  He needs to learn, but these throws can still happen.

Yeah, I think many here are being a little too impatient on Keaschall and assuming what he is today is what he'll always be. The much more likely result is improvement at the plate and in the field. The question is how much improvement and how fast. The idea that we should bench him and play Arcia, a 32 year old has been with a .657 OPS and no future (and that OPS is an improvement over his last 2 years), is beyond absurd. This year is about developing the core, not trying to patch together 78 wins instead of 75. We've got to play guys like Keaschall, Lee, Lewis, Martin, and Culpepper and Roden (both soon), and pitch Morris, Rojas, Prielipp, Gomez, Funderburk, and Paredes (Adams doesn't look like he has it). Later this year there may be chance for guys like Emma, GG, Ross, Klein, and/or Jenkins (I think Fedko's chance is slipping away; he may just not be good enough). We need to find out what we have and find out now, not next year or the year after that, or there will never be a good year. We will always be experimenting. Do it now and get it over with.    

I do disagree with you on Kreidler. He's only 28 so he has some runway (29 in December) and it looks to me like he already is an above average fielding SS.  The question is his bat but the guy stands at .282/.365/.506(.871) after 85 ABs this year. This marked improvement is after overhauling his swing and hitting well in AAA last year, especially in St. Paul. I know its a small sample size and may just be a never repeated hot streak and I know he was awful in his first 180 MLB ABs from 2022-05. Still, the bad batting is also a SSS. Frankly if Kreidler can field at an above average to elite level, and it looks like he can, I want him on the team as the starting SS even if his BA and OBP each drop 20 points and his SLG drops 50 so he's at .260/.345/.450 and on the team as a UTL even if his OPS drops to .700-.725.  He's one of the guys auditioning for a long(ish) term job for the Twins. He needs to play every day at SS. We can find a place for Culpepper by moving Keasch to the OF, Lee or Lewis to a UTL spot or by just having those 5 guys play 4 spots with one of them as the DH or getting the day off. We may have caught lightning in a bottle with Kreidler. Let's play it out and see if he can sustain this level of play or even something close to it.  

[1985Fan]

I’m for sending Luke down to AAA to learn how to play defense. His defense is costing the team and his offense doesn’t override the errors and bad plays in the field. 
I like his demeanor; the hustle, attitude, want to win, etc. He wants to help the team win and he wants it badly. If they can get his defense to a point where he’s not costing games, then he’d be valuable. Twins have to refocus on pitching and defense if they want to be serious about being competitive. You can’t kick the ball around and expect the pitching to bail you out all the time. Thats a recipe for losing against good teams like the Dodgers.

[karcherd]

11 minutes ago, LA Vikes Fan said:

Yeah, I think many here are being a little too impatient on Keaschall and assuming what he is today is what he'll always be. The much more likely result is improvement at the plate and in the field. The question is how much improvement and how fast. The idea that we should bench him and play Arcia, a 32 year old has been with a .657 OPS and no future (and that OPS is an improvement over his last 2 years), is beyond absurd. This year is about developing the core, not trying to patch together 78 wins instead of 75. We've got to play guys like Keaschall, Lee, Lewis, Martin, and Culpepper and Roden (both soon), and pitch Morris, Rojas, Prielipp, Gomez, Funderburk, and Paredes (Adams doesn't look like he has it). Later this year there may be chance for guys like Emma, GG, Ross, Klein, and/or Jenkins (I think Fedko's chance is slipping away; he may just not be good enough). We need to find out what we have and find out now, not next year or the year after that, or there will never be a good year. We will always be experimenting. Do it now and get it over with.    

I do disagree with you on Kreidler. He's only 28 so he has some runway (29 in December) and it looks to me like he already is an above average fielding SS.  The question is his bat but the guy stands at .282/.365/.506(.871) after 85 ABs this year. This marked improvement is after overhauling his swing and hitting well in AAA last year, especially in St. Paul. I know its a small sample size and may just be a never repeated hot streak and I know he was awful in his first 180 MLB ABs from 2022-05. Still, the bad batting is also a SSS. Frankly if Kreidler can field at an above average to elite level, and it looks like he can, I want him on the team as the starting SS even if his BA and OBP each drop 20 points and his SLG drops 50 so he's at .260/.345/.450 and on the team as a UTL even if his OPS drops to .700-.725.  He's one of the guys auditioning for a long(ish) term job for the Twins. He needs to play every day at SS. We can find a place for Culpepper by moving Keasch to the OF, Lee or Lewis to a UTL spot or by just having those 5 guys play 4 spots with one of them as the DH or getting the day off. We may have caught lightning in a bottle with Kreidler. Let's play it out and see if he can sustain this level of play or even something close to it.  

Kreidler has only played every day for less than a week.  Let's see what he can when he plays more.  I like his defense and don't mind him on the roster as a utility player.  But how many do we need.  Like you said we need to find what we have now this year.  Or we will be having the same debates next year at this time.  Ride with Luke at 2B this year, is there really room for him in the outfield if even a fraction of the guys coming up work out. I don't want to make room for Kreidler at this point as a starter.

[LA Vikes Fan]

1 minute ago, karcherd said:

Kreidler has only played every day for less than a week.  Let's see what he can when he plays more.  I like his defense and don't mind him on the roster as a utility player.  But how many do we need.  Like you said we need to find what we have now this year.  Or we will be having the same debates next year at this time.  Ride with Luke at 2B this year, is there really room for him in the outfield if even a fraction of the guys coming up work out. I don't want to make room for Kreidler at this point as a starter.

We don't have to make room for Kreidler to start at SS. We got nobody else. Culpeper is on the IL at AAA and he's at least a week or more before returning. Then, he ahs to have a week or two to knock the rust off before he'd even be ready for a call up. Lee is a lousy SS and Gray is even worse, something I didn't think was even possible.  Ross is a UTL who just got to AAA and Arcia is a 32 year old has been with no future. There just isn't anyone else right now to credibly put out there at SS and there won't be for a month so let's take the time now to find out if Kreidler can be the answer. If not, we haven't lost anything.  

I agree with your sentiments on Keaschall and would extend them to Lewis at 1B and Lee at 3B. Ride them this year and see if they can be the long term answer. You won't know unless you try.  

[Mike Sixel]

18 minutes ago, 1985Fan said:

I’m for sending Luke down to AAA to learn how to play defense. His defense is costing the team and his offense doesn’t override the errors and bad plays in the field. 
I like his demeanor; the hustle, attitude, want to win, etc. He wants to help the team win and he wants it badly. If they can get his defense to a point where he’s not costing games, then he’d be valuable. Twins have to refocus on pitching and defense if they want to be serious about being competitive. You can’t kick the ball around and expect the pitching to bail you out all the time. Thats a recipe for losing against good teams like the Dodgers.

What can he learn in AAA that he can't in Minnesota? Leave him up to continue learning to hit and field. 

Actually.... I'd see which pitcher Pittsburgh would deal for him, and consider it, and I'm a big fan. 

[twinzcynic]

This take is on the same level as the Twins' biggest problem right now is that they have too much starting pitching.

[1985Fan]

9 minutes ago, Mike Sixel said:

What can he learn in AAA that he can't in Minnesota? Leave him up to continue learning to hit and field. 

Actually.... I'd see which pitcher Pittsburgh would deal for him, and consider it, and I'm a big fan. 

He can learn outside the pressure of the big leagues, which is what MiLB is for. AAA is where learning on the fly is acceptable and shouldn’t damage a players confidence like the bright lights and scrutiny of MLB will. Once the confidence is gone, there isn't much hope. 
I agree with a possible trade, if the return is a usable arm. I don’t think Luke’s glove & arm can be fixed. 

[DJL44]

4 hours ago, JD-TWINS said:

Luis Arraez is playing Gold Glove defense at 2B this year (per MLB Network pundits)……. Luke can be fixed (technique), but about 60% of his problems are between his ears! He may need a mild sedative before games?

If he takes after Arraez, Luke will finally rate as a good second baseman in 2031.

[JD-TWINS]

1 hour ago, Brandon said:

Anyone getting on base 38% + of the time is going to be value for the team.  Great base running and defense can make him a very valuable player.

Not sure who you are referring to - maybe Larnach?

Keaschall was who most were referencing - his OBP is .332 and he was at a high of .310 until about 3 weeks ago. His base running is OK to Good. His defense is pretty brutal. Tough to get better “with practice” when you are in the line-up nearly every night. A lot of pressure at 23.

I wish Luke well and just want the Team to have best opportunity to Win “while guys develop”. One doesn’t have to exclude the other. Lewis went down for a short bit and it helped - hopefully it will continue. Wallner supposedly is doing better over a longer stretch in AAA - try Matt in right and have Luke take a break in St. Paul for 3-4 weeks to let him catch his breath. Clemens can play second OR Lewis can go to 2B and Clemens at 1B.

[Brandon]

8 minutes ago, JD-TWINS said:

Not sure who you are referring to - maybe Larnach?

Keaschall was who most were referencing - his OBP is .332 and he was at a high of .310 until about 3 weeks ago. His base running is OK to Good. His defense is pretty brutal. Tough to get better “with practice” when you are in the line-up nearly every night. A lot of pressure at 23.

I wish Luke well and just want the Team to have best opportunity to Win “while guys develop”. One doesn’t have to exclude the other. Lewis went down for a short bit and it helped - hopefully it will continue. Wallner supposedly is doing better over a longer stretch in AAA - try Matt in right and have Luke take a break in St. Paul for 3-4 weeks to let him catch his breath. Clemens can play second OR Lewis can go to 2B and Clemens at 1B.

The article referenced since May 1 across 164 plate appearances he hit .288/.390/.381.  I'm on my phone and read .390 as .380 but my comment is still valid.