Brock Beauchamp Site Manager Posted February 10, 2020 Posted February 10, 2020 Oh my! I would absolutely love Gardenhire in the booth! Someone make this happen when he's done managing!Noooooooooooo. I want some of the players from those relatively outdated teams, not the manager that was an important factor in them being so outdated. We need current analysis, not more folksy baseball wisdom. Stories are fine; literally every person who played or managed has stories. What we don't need to do is try to revert a broadcast into hearing people talk about how baseball worked 20 years ago.
David HK Verified Member Posted February 10, 2020 Posted February 10, 2020 Am I a mean person? It's just that the less I hear of Bert, the better I like it. One of my all-time fave Twins, but his broadcasting schtick was getting really, really old...
mini_tb Verified Member Posted February 10, 2020 Posted February 10, 2020 I had gotten more and more tired of listening to both Bremer and Blyleven drone on game after game through the years to the point that it made the broadcasts less enjoyable. The discussion all just seemed predictable, shallow, and repetitive. Bremer would get excited about home runs. Blyleven would make non sequitur comments and circle people. There would be cringeworthy attempts at jokes, and that's about it. For me, replacing Blyleven with Morneau was the missing piece. Morneau is well spoken, humble, and provides useful insight into various scenarios throughout the game. I want to hear what he has to say as I watch the game. He and Bremer have great chemistry together, especially as Morneau has become increasingly more comfortable in the booth. Sorry, Bert, you are the weakest link.
ScottN Provisional Member Posted February 10, 2020 Posted February 10, 2020 Smalley is by far the best "color" guy paired with Bremer (who is great, imo).
IndianaTwin Verified Member Posted February 10, 2020 Posted February 10, 2020 Depends. Is there a groupon available? Between groupon and the senior citizen discount, you should be faring well.
DocBauer Old-Timey Member Posted February 11, 2020 Posted February 11, 2020 Noooooooooooo. I want some of the players from those relatively outdated teams, not the manager that was an important factor in them being so outdated. We need current analysis, not more folksy baseball wisdom. Stories are fine; literally every person who played or managed has stories. What we don't need to do is try to revert a broadcast into hearing people talk about how baseball worked 20 years ago.I greatly enjoy the players who fill the booth. But come on, as a guest color guy, or part of a 3man booth, you wouldn't want to hear some Gardy insight and story telling here and there? Not necessarily a steady gig, but I sure would.
Yoke Verified Member Posted February 11, 2020 Posted February 11, 2020 I greatly enjoy the players who fill the booth. But come on, as a guest color guy, or part of a 3man booth, you wouldn't want to hear some Gardy insight and story telling here and there? Not necessarily a steady gig, but I sure would.I'd like to have some of the older guys get together and have half hour shows that run throughout the season where they tell old stories. Just three or four guys around a table shooting the ****. Put out a new one couple weeks. Then, we get cool old timer stories, and we also don't have to weed through a 3.5 hour game to get that one that will make us laugh.
USAFChief Twins Daily Contributor Posted February 11, 2020 Posted February 11, 2020 Between groupon and the senior citizen discount, you should be faring well. Across the street, a neon signAll you can eat for a dollar ninety nineAww, that old stew is the baddest in the landBut a one dollar's worth was all that I could stand
Greglw3 Verified Member Posted February 11, 2020 Posted February 11, 2020 So with Seth confirming Morneau calling 60 games this year, how do the rest of the games break down?Morneau - 60Bert - 20?Smalley - 25?Will Torii Hunter be back? Who else am I missing?Jack Morris, LaTroy Hawkins, off the top of my head. Smalley is my favorite, Morneau was quite good I thought.
Greglw3 Verified Member Posted February 11, 2020 Posted February 11, 2020 I don't dislike Morneau, but I understand where you're coming from. He's a cool guy, would be a great next door neighbor, and is a Twins legend. But he's about as vanilla as they come when it comes to color guys. I'm sure he'll improve. Frankly I think Smalley and Kaat are both fantastic. Kitty realistically isn't going to do a ton of ballgames, I'd like to see Roy become the full-time guy. I do like Bert as well, and I do like both Hawkins and Hunter too. Morris is more-or-less the full-time color man in Detroit now, which to me seems kinda weird, like there's a conflict of interest when he's doing Twins games.Smalley is my favorite fill-in analyst, too! I feel like I’m getting a doctorate baseball education when he’s on. Plus I have a soft spot in my heart, having followed his career. He must have gotten some of that amazing knowledge from talking to Gene Mauch as he’s Mauch’s nephew. I thought Mauch was a tactical genius!
Squirrel Community Moderator Posted February 11, 2020 Posted February 11, 2020 Across the street, a neon signAll you can eat for a dollar ninety nineAww, that old stew is the baddest in the landBut a one dollar's worth was all that I could standThe ‘Dad jokes’ thread is in the Sports Bar forum ...
Whammy Verified Member Posted February 11, 2020 Posted February 11, 2020 I think we've learned one uncontroverted fact in this thread. No matter what happens, about half of us will be happy and half unhappy.
Richie the Rally Goat Community Moderator Posted February 12, 2020 Posted February 12, 2020 I think we've learned one uncontroverted fact in this thread. No matter what happens, about half of us will be happy and half unhappy. you just learned that now?
h2oface Old-Timey Member Posted February 12, 2020 Posted February 12, 2020 Bring on A.J.!!!! Now that would be fun!
Bomba2026 Verified Member Posted February 12, 2020 Posted February 12, 2020 I would like an announcer that is Funny and knowledgeable with an occasional good story. I like Dick B. and LaTroy a lot though. Change is not always good...
Nine of twelve Verified Member Posted February 13, 2020 Posted February 13, 2020 Across the street, a neon signAll you can eat for a dollar ninety nineAww, that old stew is the baddest in the landBut a one dollar's worth was all that I could standThe Dave Edmunds version, not the Huey Lewis version.
strumdatjaguar Verified Member Posted February 13, 2020 Posted February 13, 2020 Some here proposing Gardy after his retirement from managing. How about pairing him with Ozzie Guillen? You may ask who would do the play by play - who cares. Couldn’t get a more entertaining duo. However, it would be necessary to air their games with a 7 second delay.
TouchEmAllGuy Verified Member Posted March 9, 2020 Posted March 9, 2020 Morneau - 57 GamesBlyleven - 30 GamesSmalley - 26 GamesMorris - 23 GamesHawkins - 17 GamesKaat - 10 Games Looks like Sid's report of Morneau doing 80 games was inaccurate.
lecroy24fan Verified Member Posted March 9, 2020 Posted March 9, 2020 Morneau - 57 GamesBlyleven - 30 GamesSmalley - 26 GamesMorris - 23 GamesHawkins - 17 GamesKaat - 10 Games Looks like Sid's report of Morneau doing 80 games was inaccurate.Just give him Morris' 23 games please. I'll even be okay with suffering through Smalley if Morris is gone.
Vanimal46 Old-Timey Member Posted March 9, 2020 Author Posted March 9, 2020 Morneau - 57 GamesBlyleven - 30 GamesSmalley - 26 GamesMorris - 23 GamesHawkins - 17 GamesKaat - 10 Games Looks like Sid's report of Morneau doing 80 games was inaccurate.Interesting distribution of games... Bert getting 30 games feels like too much. I’d rather have Hawkins for 30 games and Bert for 17.
SF Twins Fan Verified Member Posted March 9, 2020 Posted March 9, 2020 Interesting distribution of games... Bert getting 30 games feels like too much. I’d rather have Hawkins for 30 games and Bert for 17. I wonder if this is Bert trying to take a step back or if he's being push out by the new Twins front office. Either way, I'm glad he's getting less and less games each season. I wouldn't mind Smalley getting some of his games as well.
Monkeypaws Verified Member Posted March 9, 2020 Posted March 9, 2020 Sorry, not gonna read 6 pages, so repetition going down. Justin is eloquent compared to most, and had all the cred you could possibly want. Bert, Kitty Kat, Hawkins and Morris have the pitcher's pov, completely different read on the game, and some of them be in the HOF, or deserve too be. Bert has been great all these years, f bombs and all. Dude has personality. I like the former Twins in the booth. Wild are a train wreck compared to the Twins, though Ryan Carter is good.
Nine of twelve Verified Member Posted March 9, 2020 Posted March 9, 2020 Morneau - 57 GamesBlyleven - 30 GamesSmalley - 26 GamesMorris - 23 GamesHawkins - 17 GamesKaat - 10 Games Looks like Sid's report of Morneau doing 80 games was inaccurate.Total of 163. Must mean there's some doubling up somewhere, especially if not all 162 games are broadcast.
notoriousgod71 Verified Member Posted March 10, 2020 Posted March 10, 2020 Total of 163. Must mean there's some doubling up somewhere, especially if not all 162 games are broadcast.Last year Kaat teamed up with Bert for at least some of the games. I'd imagine Kaat will do the games on the East Coast unless there is something special going on at Target Field that he'll need to attend.
jctwins Verified Member Posted March 11, 2020 Posted March 11, 2020 I wonder if this is Bert trying to take a step back or if he's being push out by the new Twins front office. Either way, I'm glad he's getting less and less games each season. I wouldn't mind Smalley getting some of his games as well. He is being pushed out. They want a new look. He doesn't like it, and is working it into conversations whenever he gets the chance. Typical Blyleven.
olerud Verified Member Posted March 11, 2020 Posted March 11, 2020 Time for Bremer to go away too... Morneau is great. Maybe they can move Cory Provus from the radio booth over.I agree bremer needs to go, but instead of provus id rather see Gladden!
Minfidel Verified Member Posted March 12, 2020 Posted March 12, 2020 Never liked Morneau. He shows almost zero emotions.Maybe not a lot of emotion, but a lot of insight. I find I learn something every game - and I thought I knew it all!
DocBauer Old-Timey Member Posted March 12, 2020 Posted March 12, 2020 Morneau - 57 GamesBlyleven - 30 GamesSmalley - 26 GamesMorris - 23 GamesHawkins - 17 GamesKaat - 10 Games Looks like Sid's report of Morneau doing 80 games was inaccurate.Wish Kaat was doing more than 10 games. Is there any posting as to which 10 games? I'd really like to tune in to those. Like him or not, sort of feels like Bert is being a bit un-ceremoniously dropped. Not sure that is fair. Seems they are really struggling to find a consistent 2nd voice in the booth. Seems strange to me since they have a lot of options. Is 2020 an audition season? No matter who, or how many games, I state again that I really enjoy the 3 man booth on a semi-regular basis. Find it insightful and entertaining.
Ebby Calvin Laloosh Provisional Member Posted March 12, 2020 Posted March 12, 2020 It's amazing the difference in opinion. Personally, I can't stand Smalley and Bert. Both have clung onto a single turn of phrase or two that I just can't stand hearing anymore. Bert: "Downward Plane" and "Bend your back" Roy: "Big end of the bat, big end of the bat big end of the bat..." (seriously, try to keep track of how many times he says that this year). The points made about Bert not preparing are spot on. Anyone one of us could sit next to Dick and read the Media Guide and the broadcast wouldn't lose a thing. Roy needs to figure out how to end a sentence. Occasionally he has a wee nugget of wisdom, but then three batters later he finishes up rambling about it. Marney and Morneau are the answer in this fan's opinoion.
Thegrin Verified Member Posted March 12, 2020 Posted March 12, 2020 Women have higher pitched voices than men. As we grow older that higher pitch gets more difficult to hear. If Older Men are the majority of the current audience, a woman announcer will drive them away, because they won't be able to understand much of what is being said by the woman announcer. When women say, "He doesn't listen to me any more." what they should be saying is, "He doesn't hear me anymore."
Marek Houston Wichita Wind Surge - AA SS On Saturday, Houston went 3-for-5 and scored two runs. After a short slump, he is now back over .290 on the season. Explore Marek Houston News >
Recommended Posts
Archived
This topic is now archived and is closed to further replies.