You aren’t wrong, but are missing the point. yes, quality of spend matters more than quantity, but quantity matters too, to a point.
The median payroll in 2025 was $172m, the target of $160m isn’t that the Twins have to magically hit that, it’s that the higher the payroll, the higher winning percentage in the regular season, and mid-range payrolls win the World Series 7 of the last 10 years.
There are exceptions, don’t mistake the Rays as the rule. Pittsburgh is the rule. When the Twins slashed payroll from 160m after 2023 the team got significantly worse, when they slashed it again after 2024, they didn’t get significantly worse. The truth is, 99% of prospects fail, good teams have a mix of veterans and youth. To have a mix of good veterans comprising half the team is to have a payroll above 130m, and average has been above 160m for years.
How they spend matters more than what, but what they spend matters a lot to the quality of the team relative to the league.
https://www.spotrac.com/mlb/payroll/
https://www.thesportsgeek.com/blog/mlb-big-spenders-performance/