Derek Shelton Knows the Twins Must Be More “Defensive Minded.” How Does It Happen?

[Cody Christie]

Image courtesy of © Lon Horwedel-Imagn Images

The Minnesota Twins are going to have plenty of questions to answer this offseason. Who plays first base? What happens at shortstop? Will Royce Lewis be back? When will Byron Buxton return from injury? Which young players are ready to become everyday contributors?

There is another question that could have an impact on all of those decisions. How does Minnesota become a better defensive team?

Twins manager Derek Shelton was asked about the team's defense during a recent episode of Inside Twins. The conversation touched on Brooks Lee's transition to third base, the defensive development of several young players and what the Twins need to do moving forward. Shelton's answer was direct.

“I think that's really important as we move forward that, you know, we have to be more defensive minded.”

That sounds simple. It is not. The Twins have several young players who could help them get there. They also have several positions where the club could make significant improvements during the offseason.

Brooks Lee Changed the Defense

Lee's move from shortstop to third base was not an easy conversation. Lee had spent much of his professional career at shortstop. Like most players who grow up playing the position, he wanted to remain there. Shelton acknowledged that reality while explaining why the Twins ultimately made the decision to move him.

“If you look at a full season there, I think he wins a Gold Glove,” Shelton said. “I really do with, you know, if you want to talk about [defensive metrics], how it goes, I understand that he was frustrated when he moved. I mean, every player that plays centerfield or play shortstop, that's where they think they are.”

The important part of Shelton's explanation was that the move was not made simply because someone in the organization told him Lee should play third. Shelton wanted to see it himself.

“I do think in the conversations, going back to what we talked about earlier in terms of communication, and this is one of the things I told Brooksie when we talked about it, it's like, there had to be enough equity of me watching you play short, us having conversations to have the conversation about you moving to third,” Shelton said.

“If we come into spring training and I take someone else's opinion, someone else's thought process and just say, hey, we're moving there, I'm not developing a good relationship with the player.”

Lee's move has now become one of the more important defensive developments on the roster. Shelton believes it has changed the Twins.

“I think in the way he's played there, he's kind of changed how our defense has been. And we're going to trend towards being more defensive. We have to be. It's an area of growth for us going through.”

That last sentence is the one worth remembering. The Twins are not simply looking for a couple of players who can make highlight-reel plays. Shelton is describing a broader organizational direction. The roster needs to become more defensive.

The Young Players Are Already Helping

The timing of the Twins' defensive evolution could work in their favor. Some of the team's youngest players have shown encouraging signs since reaching the majors.

Emmanuel Rodriguez is a particularly interesting example. Rodriguez entered the organization with an offensive reputation, but Shelton has been impressed by what he has seen in the outfield.

“Really good. I mean, I was talking to Grady [Sizemore] about it last night. I don't remember the explosiveness that in spring training, the first step quickness, the ability to get after it,” Shelton said. “It's really been impressive.”

That athleticism gives the Twins another option as they build the next version of their outfield. Shelton also pointed toward Luke Keaschall, who has made progress defensively, as well as Walker Jenkins.

The Twins do not necessarily need nine Gold Glove-caliber defenders. They need to stop giving away outs and runs because the overall defensive structure is inadequate. There are several spots where that can happen. Here’s a look at each position and who will fit there for 2027.

Catcher: Victor Caratini

Catcher is an obvious place where Minnesota could look for improvement. Caratini has provided value as a blocker and has generally received positive marks for his overall receiving ability. His throwing game has been a different story.

His average pop time to second base has been around 2.04 seconds in 2026, placing him toward the bottom half of MLB catchers. That does not mean Caratini cannot be part of the roster. It does mean the Twins could look for a catcher who gives their pitching staff more defensive support, particularly when it comes to controlling the running game.

If Shelton wants the team to become more defensive minded, catcher is one position where an offseason addition could immediately help.

First Base: Still to Be Determined

First base is another position where defense could factor into the offseason decision. The Twins have room for an impact bat there, but whoever occupies the position also needs to provide competent defense. Lewis remains an option, particularly if Minnesota believes first base can help simplify his defensive responsibilities. 

But there is also a case for moving in a different direction after several difficult seasons for the former first-round pick. The first-base decision will likely be driven primarily by offense. It should not be made without considering defense.

Second Base: Kody Clemens or Royce Lewis

Second base could become a platoon situation involving Clemens and Lewis. Clemens has shown versatility by playing multiple positions, but his defensive work at second base has been inconsistent in 2026. His Statcast numbers currently show negative value at the position, including a -4 Outs Above Average mark at second. 

That does not necessarily eliminate him from consideration. It does, however, make second base another position where the Twins could improve if they find a player who can provide more consistent defense. If the organization is serious about becoming more defensive minded, those small decisions across the diamond will matter.

Third Base: Brooks Lee

Third base looks much more settled. Lee has made the position his own (6 OAA) after spending much of the season transitioning away from shortstop. Shelton went as far as saying Lee could win a Gold Glove with a full season at third base. That is a significant endorsement from a manager who watched Lee struggle through the transition before finding his footing.

It also gives the Twins something they have not always had in recent seasons: a young player who can potentially provide both offensive production and high-level defense at a premium position. If Lee continues progressing at third, the Twins can cross one defensive question off their offseason list.

Shortstop: Kaelen Culpepper

Shortstop may be the most interesting position on the entire roster. Culpepper should get the opportunity to open 2027 as the starting shortstop. That does not mean the organization has to make a permanent decision on him immediately. Culpepper can use the first half of next season to show whether he can handle the position every day.

Behind him is Marek Houston, who is moving closer to the major leagues and could eventually force another decision. If Culpepper sticks at shortstop, Minnesota's defensive alignment becomes much easier to construct. If he does not, the Twins may have to determine whether he belongs further down the defensive spectrum. That is one reason the next six months could be so important for him.

Outfield: Byron Buxton, Walker Jenkins, Emmanuel Rodriguez and Luke Keaschall

The outfield might provide Minnesota's clearest path toward becoming more athletic defensively. Shelton has made it clear that when Byron Buxton is healthy enough to play, he is going to play center field. That creates an important ripple effect.

Walker Jenkins has shown that he can handle center. Rodriguez has looked increasingly comfortable there as well. Keaschall can continue developing in a corner outfield position with more repetitions.

Jenkins and Rodriguez give the Twins additional options if Buxton is unavailable, while Keaschall's defensive development could determine how much flexibility the team has with its alignment. That is a pretty good starting point for an organization trying to change its defensive identity.

What Does "More Defensive Minded" Actually Mean?

This is where Shelton's comments become more interesting. The Twins do not need to suddenly turn into a team built exclusively around defense. They still need offense. They still need starting pitching. They still need bullpen depth.

But defense can no longer be an afterthought. Lee's move to third base is one example of the organization finding a better defensive fit. Rodriguez's athleticism gives the club another option in center field. Jenkins can cover ground. Culpepper has an opportunity to establish himself at shortstop. Those players could form the foundation of a better defensive club.

The front office will have to fill in the gaps. That means evaluating catcher. It means figuring out first base. It means determining whether Clemens and Lewis can handle second base well enough. It means continuing to develop Keaschall in the outfield.

And it means making sure the players brought in from outside the organization fit the same philosophy. Shelton is now saying the club needs to become more defensive minded. That cannot just be something said during a September podcast. It has to become part of how the roster is built.

The good news is that Minnesota may already have several pieces of that transition in place. Now the Twins have to figure out what comes next. If Shelton's vision becomes reality, the 2027 Twins should look noticeably different when they take the field.

---

How can the Twins improve defensively for 2027? Leave a comment and start the discussion.

 

View full article

[TCanWins]

I feel like Lee at third and Jenkins and Rodriguez in the outfield have all made noticeable defensive improvements to the team. Keaschall is getting comfortable in the corner and sticking catches he would have dropped earlier in the year.

Culpepper TBD with a number of errors as he settles in but his offense is encouraging. 

A catcher who can cut down some stolen bases would be huge. 

Overall I like the direction they're heading in.

[Riverbrian]

15 minutes ago, Cody Christie said:

“I think that's really important as we move forward that, you know, we have to be more defensive minded.”

Does this mean we rebuild the roster to become more defensive minded or does it mean we hope the players already in place become more defensive minded? 

 

 

[stringer bell]

6 minutes ago, Riverbrian said:

Does this mean we rebuild the roster to become more defensive minded or does it mean we hope the players already in place become more defensive minded? 

 

 

Culpepper, Jenkins and ERod have been here for a fraction of a season each, if you consider those guys as "already in place", yes that would be the answer. Getting an above-average defensive catcher to pair with Caratini should be a top priority. The wild card would be when and if Marek Houston is ready for MLB.

[MeleMouth]

11 minutes ago, Riverbrian said:

Does this mean we rebuild the roster to become more defensive minded or does it mean we hope the players already in place become more defensive minded? 

 

 

It would be difficult for Shelton to say he wants different players, but this may be as close to saying that as he'll go. Of course, if anyone picks up their game, he wouldn't be against that.

[FlyingFinn]

Generally, the more defensive minded a team is, the more team speed it has. We need that as well.

[Riverbrian]

10 minutes ago, MeleMouth said:

It would be difficult for Shelton to say he wants different players, but this may be as close to saying that as he'll go. Of course, if anyone picks up their game, he wouldn't be against that.

 

11 minutes ago, stringer bell said:

Culpepper, Jenkins and ERod have been here for a fraction of a season each, if you consider those guys as "already in place", yes that would be the answer. Getting an above-average defensive catcher to pair with Caratini should be a top priority. The wild card would be when and if Marek Houston is ready for MLB.

Twins Daily is going to subjectively take the quote both directions. 

String, I am the complete opposite... Catcher should be the last priority. Put Jackson back on the 40 man and roll with Caratini and Jackson and get your minor league catchers major league prepared. 

Despite the presence of Jeffers (who should have been traded). Caratini was apparently a priority last season. So we out bid the other teams and spent 14 million for a player who ended up being the worst hitter on the team (With at least 200 AB's). 

Just stop pouring money into the money pit. If you want a defensive catcher. You can pick one up off the waiver wire. 

If you want a catcher who can also hit. Caratini is supposed to be that guy.

We are already paying him more than other teams were willing to do. 

[Patzky]

26 minutes ago, Riverbrian said:

Does this mean we rebuild the roster to become more defensive minded or does it mean we hope the players already in place become more defensive minded? 

 

 

Eliminating the defensively suspect players like Matt Wallner and Josh Bell at 1B, and relocating the struggling ones like Lee from SS and Keaschall from 2B, says they're willing to work with what they have to some degree. The players coming from St Paul, like Roden and Ross, and Marek Houston, and ultimately Vahn, all are (at least not defensive liabilities) competent or better.

So, don't sign a Jazz Chisholm.  Do sign a Brandon Lowe. 

[Bangkok Twins Fan]

10 minutes ago, Riverbrian said:

Catcher should be the last priority. Put Jackson back on the 40 man and roll with Caratini and Jackson and get your minor league catchers major league prepared.

I'm okay with that strategy too. No need to go out and sign another free agent catcher for next season, at least not a veteran starter. Stick with what we have and wait for our new "catching pipeline" to deliver what we need in 2028. 

[stringer bell]

4 minutes ago, FlyingFinn said:

Generally, the more defensive minded a team is, the more team speed it has. We need that as well.

Agreed, and with a healthy Buxton, the Twins would have two guys (Keaschall and Buxton) with well-above average speed and five guys (Culpepper, Jenkins, Rodriguez, Clemens and Lewis) with above-average speed,  Brooks Lee's sprint speed has improved to the 24th percentile and almost all catchers not named Alex Jackson are slow. That would be the most speed the Twins have had on their roster since the Metrodome Days of the early 2000s.

Emmanuel Rodriguez has been astounding defensively so far. The Fielding Bible gives him +6 Defensive Runs Saved in 12 games. He's robbed two home runs and made every play. I doubt he can sustain that, but it would be huge to have a real elite defender manning the outfield. The numbers say that Buxton is no longer that guy.

[mikelink45]

Culpepper at 2B and Marek at SS - Clemens at 1B - improvement made.

[DJL44]

Catcher and second base would be great places to add players who can play good defense. Carson Kelly should be quite affordable. Any of Arraez, Lowe or Jazz would improve defense at 2B. Jazz is the youngest and the fastest.

[stringer bell]

13 minutes ago, Riverbrian said:

 

Twins Daily is going to subjectively take the quote both directions. 

String, I am the complete opposite... Catcher should be the last priority. Put Jackson back on the 40 man and roll with Caratini and Jackson and get your minor league catchers major league prepared. 

Despite the presence of Jeffers (who should have been traded). Caratini was apparently a priority last season. So we out bid the other teams and spent 14 million for a player who ended up being the worst hitter on the team (With at least 200 AB's). 

Just stop pouring money into the money pit. If you want a defensive catcher. You can pick one up off the waiver wire. 

If you want a catcher who can also hit. Caratini is supposed to be that guy.

We are already paying him more than other teams were willing to do. 

I don't disagree RB. The Jackson story is probably for a different thread, but I wish they had given him a little more run because his rep is a competent catcher who can slow down a running game and he was paid couch cushion money. It would appear that catching help from the system isn't that far away (midseason 2027?), 

Cleveland traded away a catcher with offensive potential and went with two defense-first pretty weak hitters and it looks like they will win the AL Central again. Finding a guy or two with defensive chops and options would be fine.

[Eris]

A nice write up. A return to the “Twins Way” from the Tom Kelly era of the decades past. It is about time. I have never understood the defense doesn’t matter philosophy that has defined the Twins for the past 15 years or more. 
 

The Twins are 140 DRS behind the Cubs, which equates to about 14 wins.  Most of this years playoff teams are in the top range of the DRS.  The Rays are second with 90 DRS and they will win the AL East.  Houston and Philadelphia have very negative DRS and are still in the playoff picture  

https://www.fangraphs.com/leaders/major-league?pos=all&stats=fld&lg=all&qual=y&type=1&season=2026&season1=2026&ind=0&team=0%2Cts&startdate=&enddate=&month=0&sortcol=11&sortdir=default&pagenum=1

 

Several other thoughts. 
On Caratini, certainly the Twins should have known of his slow pop time when they signed him. I thought I read on TD that Alex Jackson had the quickest pop time of any catcher in Twins history. 
 

A lot of this is on drafting and player development. If a team wants to improve their defense they need to draft athletic players who at least have the potential to be above average defensively at some position. 

[thelanges5]

Improved defense has been a talking point of emphasis the past few off-seasons. Easy to say hard to do. I agree with most of the posts that with the youth and some positional changes we seem to be headed in the right direction. 

[ewen21]

1 hour ago, Riverbrian said:

Does this mean we rebuild the roster to become more defensive minded or does it mean we hope the players already in place become more defensive minded? 

 

 

Simply put, the latter since the article and Shelton is assessing what we have.

[ewen21]

14 minutes ago, Eris said:

A nice write up. A return to the “Twins Way” from the Tom Kelly era of the decades past. It is about time.

Yes. wouldn't it be nice, but in today's game there is no way in the world a manager like Tom Kelly can exist.

[StiltedGopher]

Does he have a limited laundry budget?
 

Is this like a CPA firm saying they want their accountants to be a bit more accurate with their math.  Maybe like bakers wanting their products to be a little more aimed at tasting good? 
 

Defense is not a nice to have.  A manager better be able to have conversations with players about where they best fit, if at all, for the organizational goal which happens to be winning games.  
 

Maybe, Shelty can also kindly ask the players to get a little more competitive minded.  You know, if it doesn’t strain them too much worrying about the other team’s feelings.  

At some point, someone needs to be more accountable.  

Guess fans need a big thank you card for Shelty, too. Thanks for noticing that a little defense is nice to have.  You know, at times.  We fans could bring some laundry detergent, let the team know it is permissible to get their uniforms dirty.  
 

 

 

 

[Riverbrian]

16 minutes ago, stringer bell said:

I don't disagree RB. The Jackson story is probably for a different thread, but I wish they had given him a little more run because his rep is a competent catcher who can slow down a running game and he was paid couch cushion money. It would appear that catching help from the system isn't that far away (midseason 2027?), 

Cleveland traded away a catcher with offensive potential and went with two defense-first pretty weak hitters and it looks like they will win the AL Central again. Finding a guy or two with defensive chops and options would be fine.

Perfect

This mindset would allow the Twins to focus limited financial resources elsewhere. And we all need to realize that no matter what Tom Pohlad says. Our financial resources are limited and have always been limited... even if we increase payroll 70 million next season. 

I will continue to contend the same as last year that Bell and Caratini was a mistake. And I say that fully acknowledging that Bell did a decent enough job. 

 

[Twins 72]

The big question is when will Houston be ready. If it is 2028, Clemens plays 2B next year. Then you have Houston and Culpepper in the 2B and SS positions. That is pretty strong. It would be awesome to just start that next year. Then you can get both to the spot that they will play going forward. Lee is solid. OF will be solid with Buck, Jenkins, ERod, and yes Keashall. Lewis at 1B? I think he would be a very good full-time defensive 1B next year. He just needs to hit at a higher rate. I think they give him one more year and just play him at 1B. I would love to have Jeffers back on the QO. Then flow into the young guys at C. Overall, this group should be much more settled and solid defensively.