Jump to content
Twins Daily
  • Create Account
  • I Was Skeptical of Joey Gallo. Now I'm Relieved to Have Him Aboard.


    Lou Hennessy

    "Man, I'm glad I called that guy. . ." - Billy Madison

    The Twins' signing of Joey Gallo was a head-scratcher when it was announced in late-December. Now, it’s one of the more essential transactions that the club made this off-season. So what changed?

    Image courtesy of William Parmeter

    Twins Video

    The Twins went into the off-season with some clear needs on their roster. A left-handed corner outfielder was not one of them. In fact, that mold of player was one of the only assets that the club seemingly had in excess. Their surplus consisted of Max Kepler, Alex Kirilloff, Nick Gordon, Trevor Larnach, and Matt Wallner

    Then it was announced that two-time all star Joey Gallo would be joining that group, warts and all. This left many Twins followers, myself included, befuddled as to how this game of musical chairs would turn out. The move played into the notion that this front office likes a good contract more than it likes a good player, and it gave the team’s critics a fresh slab of red meat to feast upon.

    As a prototypical three-true-outcome player, Gallo would surely require ample playing time for the $11 million investment to be worth it. How might this impact the development of the young talent such as Kirilloff, Larnach and Wallner? Where would Gallo play defensively for it all to make sense? Would this make a trade of one of the incumbent lefty bats all but certain? 

    Clearly, Gallo’s signing created more questions than answers, and that tends to turn a lot of people off when molding a contending roster. 
    But now, Gallo is one of the most vital cogs in the Twins’ 2023 blueprint. That begs one last question - did he change, or did we?

    When his signing became official in late-December, many griped about Gallo’s high-strikeout, boom-or-bust approach. That criticism is certainly valid. Gallo has a career strikeout rate of 37.3%, which is the highest among qualified active players. Not only that, but Gallo has only put 25% of his swings in play over the last two seasons, which is by far the lowest in the major leagues in that time. 

    About a month later, the Twins shipped fan-favorite Luis Arraez to the Miami Marlins in return for Pablo López and two prospects. This sent fans into even more of a tizzy, as Arraez is one of the premier contact hitters in the game. This magnified the bitter aftertaste that many were experiencing, whether that was fair to Gallo or not.

    But now, his fit on the roster makes more sense, especially given the injury concerns that are once again emerging in the lineup. Kirilloff was the on-paper starting first baseman for most of the off-season, but is now pegged to miss the beginning of the regular season as his recovery from last season’s wrist surgery is taking longer than expected. Second baseman and lineup stalwart Jorge Polanco missed the entirety of the Grapefruit League slate with knee soreness, and will once again hit the dreaded injury list. Even superstar Byron Buxton will be limited to designated hitter duties as he continues to recover from his many leg and hip ailments. 

    This gives Gallo plenty of opportunity for playing time. That could mean sliding in as the regular first baseman until Kirilloff returns. It could mean more of an opening for him in the outfield, with Gordon shifting to second base. It could mean more starts in center field until Buxton is back out there. It could even mean increased time back at third base while Jose Miranda slides over to first. No matter where it happens, Gallo will get plenty of looks all across the diamond. 

    The bigger question surrounds which version of Gallo’s bat comes north to Target Field. Will he be the behemoth that slugged 38 home runs in three different seasons? Or will he be the heir-apparent to Miguel Sano’s throne of punch outs?

    The good news is that Gallo did extensive training with hitting coach David Popkins over the off-season in an effort to make more contact. The Twins’ coach has been lauded by Gordon and Carlos Correa for the in-season work that paid dividends in the second half of last season. Hopefully Popkins’ tutelage will continue to be effective as he continues to work with Gallo, who is likely his biggest challenge yet. 


    What do you think? Are you happy to have Gallo aboard as the Twins begin their 2023 campaign? Where do you think he will get most of his playing time? Do you think Popkins will be able to help Gallo as he did with Correa and Gordon in 2022? Let us know in the comment section below. 

    MORE FROM TWINS DAILY
    — Latest Twins coverage from our writers
    — Recent Twins discussion in our forums
    — Follow Twins Daily via Twitter, Facebook or email
    — Become a Twins Daily Caretaker

     Share


    User Feedback

    Recommended Comments



    Featured Comments

    An absolute butcher who seems to be in terminal decline?  All for $11M?  Skeptical?  No.  Torqued?  Yep.

    Worse than the combined signings of Archer and Bundy the previous off-season. 

    If Rocco ever hands the umps a lineup card with him at leadoff, he should be fired on the spot - not after the game!

    Link to comment
    Share on other sites

    I did not like the pickup and still do not.  The only reason he is of value right now defensively is due to injuries.  I still to not like the strikeout rate and when he strikes out with RISP people will wince.  Once those players heal he will be holding back Larnach when they send him down to add Kirilloff and Polanco.

    Link to comment
    Share on other sites

    The Twins are not going to release Joey Gallo before June, which is a long time from now. So it then becomes important how he is used if he is the 2022 Gallo, someone who should not be in the lineup. The hope is that Gallo can be a rebound player and that is quite a gamble. He will get 100 at bats before any serious evaluation. There is value in a guy playing good defense and hitting the long ball, even at a .210 BA. While I was not in favor of the signing, I'm more interested now in how he does combined with how Baldelli uses him. It was interesting that he was pinch hit for in the first game. We need to be patient and hope for the best.

    Link to comment
    Share on other sites

    6 minutes ago, chinmusic said:

    As a tactical move, I think Gallo's acquisition makes sense.

    Seems as if there is a contingency plan.

    He's only 29. You never know.

    There are multiple exit paths that can be good for the Twins.  Popkins is working as much for building up to play well this season but also to make him a valuable trade or QO candidate.  If this lottery ticket hits, he hits 35-40 home runs and the Twins get another high draft pick when he declines the QO.  That's significant upside for 11m bucks.

    Its not like they are hitching the whole wagon to him for multiple years, its part of the push for depth and being able to play all over makes him worth the flyer.  If he's completely washed, Lee or Lewis or Julien or Wallner or Kirriloff or Martin will take his roster spot.  They will probably still be able to trade him for a low level prospect if they take on some salary. 

    Link to comment
    Share on other sites

    He will have to prove himself before I can say he is worth 11 mil. The positions he plays are well fortified with Miranda, Farmer and Solano, at a much more reasonable price. I hope I'm wrong, but it looks like another poor investment into a possible strikeout king.

    Link to comment
    Share on other sites

    I have been hopeful lately that he'd turn things around hitting but it seems that teams are trying to get around the shift to hinder his comeback. So we'll have to see. 

    He plays a good corner OF & 1B but it's not that we don't have anyone who can't play there. Fortunately we have plenty of CF subs where don't need to count on him there. I'd prefer to see Gordon in the OF than 2B.

    So far it's been 1 game, He saved P Lopez w/ decisive DP. Hopefully we don't arrive to a point where we're desperate for his glove and hopefully he can start hitting where it justifies for him to be on the team.

    Link to comment
    Share on other sites

    Boy of Boy is this one going to get a range of responses...You may as well post something positive about Pagan next.

    1st off if Popkins can turn Gallo into a .240 average hitter with an under 30% k rate guy, he should be the manager!

    2nd I hated this signing BUT can see why they did it..I don't agree with it..But I get it.

    Also, I think it creates roadblocks for both Larnach and Julien. For those who say Julien hasn't played above AA. If I remember correctly neither did Kepler.

    One final thought. A contending team IMO signs Gallo. A team in limbo doesn't..

    I don't have to like everything the FO does, to still support the players.

    Link to comment
    Share on other sites

    3 hours ago, MABB1959 said:

    Seems too early to decide.  His average after one game is .000.    Hopefully it is one of biggest surprise this season!

     

    11 minutes ago, Ricky Vaughn said:

    It's way to early to make any pronouncements about him. I was puzzled by the signing and generally hate three true outcome hitters. But I'm willing to give him a chance. I just hope if he's only hitting .160 in June the FO is willing to eat the money and move on.

     

    2 hours ago, Tibs said:

    After 1 game?

    Look, I'm not saying he'll be a surefire MVP or anything. I'm just relieved to have him now given the injuries to the current roster. Lack of depth killed this team in the last six weeks of last season. I'm glad there's higher-upside backup plan in place this year. 

     

    I'm not calling for the team to hand him an extension after one game. There's no need to start building a statue for him. But my perspective on his addition has changed since he was signed. That's all.

    Link to comment
    Share on other sites

    Gallo is 1B until either he shows his bat is a flop, and / or Miranda proves he's an unacceptably bad fielder at 3B. I thought Miranda looked pretty good at 1B last season...he could do that again. Gallo with a good bat would still be valuable in the OF. I hear he has a very strong throwing arm. 

    Link to comment
    Share on other sites

    1 hour ago, Alex Wilde said:

    Bunch of bozos. Give the guy a shot before you sit here shitting on him after spring training. He played for two of the toughest teams last year in the largest markets in the country. Baseball is a grind and it can be hard to make adjustments when you are playing every single day for 6 months. If he doesn’t work out, who cares? It was a one year flyer on a guy who a couple years ago was in the running for MVP. He can play all across the diamond and is an above average fielder at any position he slots in at. And leading off is bad because  what…? We had Kepler lead off against a right handed starter on opening day. Who else should lead off against a righty? Gallo has a great OBP and a solid OPS against RHP. I would rather have him than free swinging Nick Gordon or any right handed bat at the bottom of the lineup lead off. He sees a lot of pitches and there’s something to that aspect of a lead off hitter as well. I think Gallo should slot in at lead off until Julien, Lee, or Martin are up in the bigs to take over for him. And if we didn’t have Gallo, who would be starting at first base on opening day? 35 year old Donavan Solano? Never played above AA Julien? Or some other journeyman first baseman like Luke Voit or Tyler White? Give me a break and sit down and stop being keyboard GMs.

    As a native Chicagoan, your post stirred up some nostalgia for me. Thanks for that!

     

    images.jpeg.bd7017ae4f68484eff0f3127594f514b.jpeg

     

    Link to comment
    Share on other sites

    This was a bad signing to begin with & I don't think anything has changed. He's on our team & is going to get playing time so I hope the unrealistic turnaround happens, but just don't see it. 

    As I said he is going to play so I hope provides good D and at least some offensive production.

    Link to comment
    Share on other sites

    Until Kirilloff is ready, Gallo's the main option at 1B. Doesn't mean we have to like it or even that it is the best option. One thing is for sure, the Twins don't give a guy $11M to sit on the bench and Gallo won't be an exception. If he isn't at 1B he'll be in the outfield. I doubt we will ever see him at 3B with Miranda, Farmer and Solano on the roster. Besides all 3 of them hit much better than Gallo. So, if/when Kirilloff comes back and if/when he starts hitting with reckless abandon, Gallo will take playing time away from an outfielder or two, and if that is Kepler who is just as inept at hitting, then nothing will be lost. If it is Larnach, Gordon, Lewis, or Martin then someone will need to have their head examined. 

    The Gallo/Kepler watch line is 0-7 with 2-K's, 0-BB, 0-HR, 0-RBI and 5-LOB. 

    Link to comment
    Share on other sites

    8 hours ago, theBOMisthebomb said:

    No thank you, still a hard pass on Gallo. The one game I've seen him in a Twins uniform is one game too many. I do hope he hits 38+ home runs and I'm wrong with egg on my face.  

    I hope we’re both wrong! ….after 2 games now though….,,,,he looks like a 10th grade kid playing on the Varsity and he’s way over matched. Pathetic. When a guy only puts the ball in play 25% of the time, I guess we gotta wait 8-10 games to see if he can get 4 hits in that time period. Right now he looks like he might get A HIT per week…..maybe?? Maybe 2 walks in a week because he doesn’t swing!

    We gotta get Kiriloff back or be prepared to bring up Julien to play 1B by April 15!

    Will need Polanco as well so we can get Gordon freed up to get Taylor out of CF v. RH pitching …….he doesn’t look much better than Gallo.

    Both are more than competent on defense but we need some more juice on offense!!

    Two & 0 and haven’t yielded a run…….some good situational pitching & we’re playing the hapless Royals.

    Need more “O” in a hurry.

    Link to comment
    Share on other sites

    3 hours ago, rv78 said:

    Until Kirilloff is ready, Gallo's the main option at 1B. Doesn't mean we have to like it or even that it is the best option. One thing is for sure, the Twins don't give a guy $11M to sit on the bench and Gallo won't be an exception. If he isn't at 1B he'll be in the outfield. I doubt we will ever see him at 3B with Miranda, Farmer and Solano on the roster. Besides all 3 of them hit much better than Gallo. So, if/when Kirilloff comes back and if/when he starts hitting with reckless abandon, Gallo will take playing time away from an outfielder or two, and if that is Kepler who is just as inept at hitting, then nothing will be lost. If it is Larnach, Gordon, Lewis, or Martin then someone will need to have their head examined. 

    The Gallo/Kepler watch line is 0-7 with 2-K's, 0-BB, 0-HR, 0-RBI and 5-LOB. 

    Taylor v. RH pitching - Kepler - Gallo….it’s as ugly as we thought it might be.

    Gordon in CF v. RH pitching - Gallo/Kepler rotating in RF since neither should play in front of Larnach - Kiriloff at 1B - Polanco at 2B and our line-up is Waaay better. Hopefully, by the 20th of the month - fingers crossed!

    Can we DFA a $9M or better yet, an $11M salary in May?

    Link to comment
    Share on other sites

    Timing of this article seems odd. The smart/good play in the opener is something that we might have expected from Gallo. He has a reputation for being solid defensively.

    Offensively, it's been every bit the nightmare that many predicted...or worse. He's a left-handed power bat in theory only for now. It's early, and I remain firmly in the TBD camp.

    Link to comment
    Share on other sites

    Just now, jkcarew said:

    Timing of this article seems odd. The smart/good play in the opener is something that we might have expected from Gallo. He has a reputation for being solid defensively.

    Offensively, it's been every bit the nightmare that many predicted...or worse. He's a left-handed power bat in theory only for now. It's early, and I remain firmly in the TBD camp.

    We’ve played two games. While I’m not exactly not skeptical of this and have been since he was signed, let’s give it more than two games.

    Link to comment
    Share on other sites




    Join the conversation

    You can post now and register later. If you have an account, sign in now to post with your account.
    Note: Your post will require moderator approval before it will be visible.

    Guest
    Add a comment...

    ×   Pasted as rich text.   Paste as plain text instead

      Only 75 emoji are allowed.

    ×   Your link has been automatically embedded.   Display as a link instead

    ×   Your previous content has been restored.   Clear editor

    ×   You cannot paste images directly. Upload or insert images from URL.

    Loading...

×
×
  • Create New...