Jump to content
Twins Daily
  • Create Account
  • Twins News & Analysis

    3 Roster Moves the Twins Need to Make Right Now

    Three internal roster moves could provide a much-needed spark for a Twins offense that has gone quiet at the worst possible time.

    Matthew Taylor
    Image courtesy of Rob Thompson (photo of Matt Wallner)

    Twins Video

    The trade deadline has come and gone, and the Minnesota Twins have officially turned the page toward the final two months of the regular season. Jeremy Zoll added multiple pieces at the deadline, all of the new acquisitions are now on the active roster, and the focus shifts to making a run at a postseason berth.

    But just because the deadline has passed doesn't mean the Twins are done improving their roster. Some of the biggest upgrades available are already in the organization. With every game becoming more important, Minnesota can't afford to let roster spots go to players who aren't contributing while impact talent waits in St. Paul. If the Twins want to put themselves in the best position possible for the stretch run, there are three moves they should make immediately.

    1. Option Tristan Gray to Triple-A St. Paul and promote Kaelen Culpepper.
    Gray being called up when Byron Buxton landed on the injured list was a curious decision from the beginning, and it has only become more confusing over the last week. Since joining the Twins on July 29, Gray has received just two plate appearances, going 0-for-2 with two strikeouts. The lack of playing time says everything. The Twins simply don't trust him enough to put him in the lineup, meaning they've essentially been playing with one fewer roster spot.

    Instead of carrying a player who isn't going to play, the Twins should hand that opportunity to Kaelen Culpepper.

    The organization's top shortstop prospect has battled injuries throughout the season, but he has looked healthy since returning and continues to produce. Culpepper owns an .826 OPS at Triple-A this season and reminded everyone what he's capable of by going 3-for-5 with a triple on Tuesday night. He's a right-handed hitter, something Minnesota desperately needs, and he brings considerably more upside than Gray.

    Giving Culpepper regular opportunities at shortstop while Ryan Kreidler fills a reserve role would make the Twins younger, more athletic and with greater offensive upside. At some point, the organization has to find out what it has in one of its top prospects, and there may not be a better opportunity than right now.

    2. Designate Alex Jackson for assignment and recall Matt Wallner from Triple-A
    Carrying three catchers over the last month made perfect sense before the trade deadline. Ryan Jeffers was one of the biggest trade candidates on the roster, and keeping Jackson around gave the Twins insurance in case they decided to move Jeffers. They didn't end up moving him, however.

    Now that Jeffers is still in Minnesota, there isn't much reason to continue carrying three catchers. Jeffers and Victor Caratini form one of the better catching duos in baseball, and that extra roster spot could be much better utilized elsewhere.

    To Jackson's credit, he has been a pleasant surprise during his time with the Twins. Still, with a $1.35 million contract, there's a reasonable chance he could clear waivers and remain in the organization if another club isn't interested.

    Replacing him with Matt Wallner would immediately make the Twins' lineup more dangerous.

    Wallner's demotion in May was justified after his slow start to the season, but he has done everything the organization could have asked of him since arriving in St. Paul. He owns a .938 OPS with 20 home runs since being sent down, and he added another homer Tuesday night. He has forced his way back into the conversation.

    The Twins have been searching for offensive consistency for weeks, and Wallner's power gives them another legitimate threat in the middle of the lineup. That is simply more valuable than carrying a third catcher who has no clear role.

    3. Option Alan Roden to Triple-A and select the contract of Walker Jenkins
    When the Twins promoted Alan Roden in early July, the move was easy to understand. He was swinging the bat well at Triple-A, was healthy and deserved an opportunity to prove himself in the majors.

    Unfortunately, it hasn't happened.

    Roden has produced just a .514 OPS with no extra-base hits over his first 50 plate appearances with Minnesota. The Twins have also made it clear they aren't comfortable playing him in center field, limiting his versatility even further. Between his lack of production and limited defensive role, Roden simply hasn't established himself as someone who needs to remain on the roster.

    That opportunity should now belong to Walker Jenkins.

    Jenkins is one of the top prospects in baseball for a reason. He has posted an .818 OPS in Triple-A this season and has looked even better since returning from injury at the end of June. More importantly, he passes the eye test every time he steps on the field. He looks like a player who is ready for the next challenge.

    With Buxton sidelined, there are plenty of at-bats available. Jenkins can play either corner outfield spot and is capable of handling center field as well, giving manager Derek Shelton another athletic option while adding one of the organization's highest-upside bats. At some point, prospects stop benefiting from Triple-A and start benefiting from major league experience. Jenkins appears to have reached that point.

    The Twins have struggled to score runs over the last few weeks, and waiting around for the offense to suddenly improve isn't much of a strategy. The front office already addressed external needs before the deadline. Now it's time to maximize the talent that's already in the organization.

    Calling up Culpepper, Wallner and Jenkins would inject youth, upside and offensive potential into a lineup that desperately needs a spark. If the Twins are serious about making a run over the final two months, these are the kinds of aggressive roster decisions they should be making now instead of waiting until it's too late.

    What do you think? Are these the three roster moves the Twins should make immediately, or would you go in a different direction as they begin their postseason push? Leave a comment below and start the conversation!

     

    Follow Twins Daily For Minnesota Twins News & Analysis

    Recent Twins Articles

    Recent Twins Videos

    Twins Top Prospects

    Kaelen Culpepper

    St. Paul Saints - AAA, SS
    Culpepper was one of four Saints batters with three hits on Tuesday night in the team's 15-5 win over Louisville. He was 3-for-4 with a walk and his second triple.

    User Feedback

    Recommended Comments

    Featured Comments

    Performance expectations aside, where/when are you playing Wallner? Neither he nor Bell should see the field, and Bell is a switch hitter who's a little better against RHP. Playing time isn't really an issue for Wallner at this point, but if you're committed to getting him PAs then you're either sitting Bell (which is a massive waste of a roster spot) or you're putting one of them in the field where each is a liability. 

    4 minutes ago, strumdatjag said:

    Culpepper and Jenkins would then accumulate service time throughout all the lost part of the 2027 season (list time due to labor strife in negotiations of the new CBA).   Bad idea.   

    But yet every other team is doing exactly this, bringing up their top prospects in this environment.  I don't think Zoll is smarter than everyone else, but maybe he is and I am missing it.

    All interesting. I agree with Culpepper for Gray for sure for the reasons you stated. Jenkins for Roden also makes sense although I'm a little more hesitant. I think that we've given Roden a short but fair shot. The two nagging concerns are that Roden has hit the ball hard fairly regularly so you just think there may be more there and I question if Jenkins is quite ready.  This is Roden's last real shot with the Twins. Add to that the loss of rookie status if called up before 8/15 and I say we wait another 10 days for Jenkins and to give Roden a little more time. 

    Wallner is a very tough one. He is hitting now in AAA and has hit MLB pitching before. Still, two MAJOR issues with Wallner. The first is he had a huge hole in his swing the upper inside quadrant of the strike zone which made him an easy out. Has he solved that or is he just feasting on lesser pitching and likely to hit .150 in the Bigs again? The second is where do you play him? Bell is actually one of our better hitters right now so the DH spot is only available 1, maybe 2 games a week. There's no way to sugarcoat this, Wallner is a lousy OF. He lessens the defense every time he plays out there. It's even worse when out CF who covered for him is hurt and we really don't have another one, at least not yet. We are in that part of the year where pitching and defense tends to trump offense so Wallner is a big risk. He also doesn't hit LH pitching so he doesn't solve our primary weakness. Maybe platoon him in RF with Martin now, but what do we do when Buxton comes back? We certainly don't want to give Wallner playing time over Keaschall, since Keasch just had a .909 OPS in July and is off to an even hotter start in August (he is the best hitter on the team right now and should be hitting in the 2 hole, but I'll save that rant for another thread). Larnach has seized the LH corner OF spot on the team and squeezed Wallner out. I'd hate to be the starting pitcher and look out to the OF and see Larnach, Keaschall, and Wallner. Ground balls only that day.      

    So, on balance, I would call up Culpepper now for Gray and play him in a 60/40 SS platoon with Kriedler. I'd wait until 8/15 and if Roden hasn't gotten hot, switch him out for Jenkins. I just don't think there's a place for Wallner on this roster for this year absent another injury or maybe 2 since Jenkins is first OF up. He waits to try to win a DH job for 2027 or maybe an offseason trade. Sucks for Wallner, but he played himself into this position.  

    Jackson has much more organizational value than fans have.  He has shown he can hit at an mlb level (different ways over 2 season) and can provide good defense.  I am firmly of the belief the Twins are slotting him in as the backup catcher next year.   

    Granted Rushing has a UCL tear,  but the Dodgers traded for Rortvedt.  Having the depth is necessary.  Catchers had an immense premium this trade deadline and you still have a couple teams,  that would gladly make a claim on Jackson.  

    As to Gray be my guest.  

    As to Roden and Wallner - I am not sure.  I feel like Roden is starting to figure it out a bit at the MLB level.   Yes Wallner is on a heater,  so maybe.   I think Mendez would be an excellent hitter at extending at bats and putting the ball in play.   Jenkins has more upside than everyone.   

    Roden not passing muster in CF is a) a bummer, and b) limits his utility, and with him not hitting (it's a small sample and it's not like he's getting consistent time but still) it's not great. Possible he's a Quad A player.

    Bold move to recall Wallner, but I think it's the right one no matter how much some people around here despise him and his game. Why not see if he's able to ride a hot streak through the end of the season? Might actually give him some trade value in the offseason and they could use his thump in the lineup, especially with Buxton out.

    Tougher call on Jenkins, I think? Much as we all want to see him, it's not like he's destroyed AAA and adding him to the 40-man has a cost as well. If Rodriguez is going to be ready in a week or two I think I'd rather see him up in MLB, especially with him out of options next season. It's highly unlikely (absent another injury and/or Buxton out for much much longer) that we'll get both this season...especially if you want to bring Wallner back, which does make sense no matter if some people at Twins Daily start heating the tar, buying the feathers, lighting the torches, and sharpening the pitchforks...

    5 minutes ago, HarmonK03 said:

    But yet every other team is doing exactly this, bringing up their top prospects in this environment.  I don't think Zoll is smarter than everyone else, but maybe he is and I am missing it.

    Every other team?  I count  Lombard, Clark and thats it unless I am missing someone.  Red Sox came out and said they don't want to put the pressure on Arias.  Maybe a cup of coffee in late September.  

    2 minutes ago, HarmonK03 said:

    But yet every other team is doing exactly this, bringing up their top prospects in this environment.  I don't think Zoll is smarter than everyone else, but maybe he is and I am missing it.

    Agreed. I think the "risk" of losing significant control time due to an expected long term work stoppage next year is way overblown. The much more likely result is a lot of drama followed by either a shortened spring training and a roughly 140-150 game season, or a last-minute deal that saves the entire season. There is just too much money being made and too much other competition now to take the market risk of any sort of long-term disruption. MLB owners may not be as smart as NFL owners but they aren't that stupid. Next year's CBA negotiation should have little if any impact on whether to call up prospects, particularly after August 15 when they can come up and still retain their rookie status. The possibility of gain here is so much higher than the risk of loss that the risk of loss should be an afterthought at best.

    3 minutes ago, Hawkeye Bean Counter said:

    Every other team?  I count  Lombard, Clark and thats it unless I am missing someone.  Red Sox came out and said they don't want to put the pressure on Arias.  Maybe a cup of coffee in late September.  

    Maybe not every team, but there are others.  Cleveland and Cincy are two right off of the top.

    I dislike this article quite a bit.

    Culpepper is showing a blip of knocking the rust off, but 1 good game isn't enough to convince me he's ready for a massive competition leap.

    image.png.d84e4eedf5525937b34d050f4fee64e3.png

     

    Jenkins has been league average for over a month in AAA. Tons of pop ups, tons of grounders, low line drive rate, no power, average on the base paths and no real spot for him in the lineup.

     

    Jackson is an interesting case. His actual production has been good, but expected is terrible. He hits right handed and has 1300 career MiLB innings in the outfield. At $1MM and good defensively, does he pass through waivers? I'd say probably not, but if the Twins have seen enough, then I don't think it's the end of the world to watch him walk.

     

     

    5 minutes ago, jmlease1 said:

    Roden not passing muster in CF is a) a bummer, and b) limits his utility, and with him not hitting (it's a small sample and it's not like he's getting consistent time but still) it's not great. Possible he's a Quad A player.

    Bold move to recall Wallner, but I think it's the right one no matter how much some people around here despise him and his game. Why not see if he's able to ride a hot streak through the end of the season? Might actually give him some trade value in the offseason and they could use his thump in the lineup, especially with Buxton out.

    Tougher call on Jenkins, I think? Much as we all want to see him, it's not like he's destroyed AAA and adding him to the 40-man has a cost as well. If Rodriguez is going to be ready in a week or two I think I'd rather see him up in MLB, especially with him out of options next season. It's highly unlikely (absent another injury and/or Buxton out for much much longer) that we'll get both this season...especially if you want to bring Wallner back, which does make sense no matter if some people at Twins Daily start heating the tar, buying the feathers, lighting the torches, and sharpening the pitchforks...

    Quick point about Emma. I have read that it is "very likely" that he will get a 4th option year because he is accumulating used option years faster than "full professional seasons", which is defined as more than 90 days on an active roster. IL time does not count towards a "full professional season". Where a player uses up all three option years before he has accumulated five full professional seasons, that player is pretty much automatically granted a 4th option year. Emma has already met the criteria for that additional option year. The bottom line is that him being "out of options after this year" should not be a consideration whether or not to call him up over Jenkins.

    Lets just call it what this team is -  It is a tired mediocre team that added some ok talent but likely not enough to get to the playoffs.  I am fine with switching out Gray, I don't really care who you want to man one of the outfield spots Roden/Rodriguez/Martin/Wallner/Jenkins.    

    Keeping a 3rd catcher will not determine whether we make the playoff this year.  That will come down to starting pitching.  With Ryan struggling to get his fastball over 92 mph we are looking at his normal back half slide.  The hitters are not hitting as much nor hitting with RISP at the high clip they were doing before.  And Buxton is injured.  

    The bullpen is better.   Lewis is really starting to catch my eye.  Its a small sample,  but he is starting to figure it out.  Confidence going up and driving the ball the opposite direction.   

    We need 4-5 bats to catch fire.  So Jeffers, Larnach, Lewis, Keaschall and Bell all effectively need to get hot together.    I just don't see it.  

    At this point I am thinking I am back to hoping for a top 5-6 draft pick in the draft lottery if thats still a thing.  

    12 minutes ago, Hawkeye Bean Counter said:

    Jackson has much more organizational value than fans have.  He has shown he can hit at an mlb level (different ways over 2 season) and can provide good defense.  I am firmly of the belief the Twins are slotting him in as the backup catcher next year.   

    Granted Rushing has a UCL tear,  but the Dodgers traded for Rortvedt.  Having the depth is necessary.  Catchers had an immense premium this trade deadline and you still have a couple teams,  that would gladly make a claim on Jackson.  

    He has produced when called upon but if you are a contender you can't afford to roster a redshirt which is basically what they are making him.  In the offseason there will be other journeyman catchers similar that will be available that can be signed to be the backup.

    Regarding Roden, I think it helps to remember he started the season last year with Toronto and hit .188 with an OPS of .541.  He has three different stints and has not grabbed hold of any of these opportunities.  There may be something there, but we options with more upside that need AB's over him.

    Just now, HarmonK03 said:

    He has produced when called upon but if you are a contender you can't afford to roster a redshirt which is basically what they are making him.  In the offseason there will be other journeyman catchers similar that will be available that can be signed to be the backup.

    Is Jackson the reason the Twins lost yesterday?   No.   If you can get Ryan back to his early season form,  find another elite starting pitcher to pair with Bradley and Ryan -  Get 4-5 hitters to get on a heater and the bullpen to all meld together and those 15-20 at bats that a different bench bat would be the difference in a world series so be it.  Otherwise we will be paying 3+ million or another 20th+ prospect to get another catcher like Jackson.   

    I could see a Culpepper for Gray switch.  Still I'd want to make sure Culpepper's bat is in a good place before calling him up. The Twins would also need to play him in place of Kreidler to make sure he gets enough playing time.  We'll see how things look in a couple of weeks.

    I don't see the Twins trying to sneak Jackson through unless they firmly plan to somehow win the bidding war for Jeffers in the offseason.  His low salary and even with his flawed (low walk rate, high K rate) production with the bat (I think he has a 112 WRC+) would get him gobbled up right quick IMO.  . They barely played Outman as the 26th man so I think the Twins can work around Jackson if needed.

    It feels like Wallner is inevitable. I mean they appeared to feel comfortable moving Larnach with I assume Wallner as his replacement.  It didn't happen, but I'd think they might look for ways to see if they can work him in.  It will likely depend on how close or far this team is to competing for the last wild card spot as he doesn't provide much if any value defensively. An injury might be his best path back.

    I'm not sure how I feel about adding Jenkins early.  I guess it would depend on if Buxton can come back or not.  Otherwise Jenkins has to hit the ground running and likely replace Larnach or Keaschal's production at the plate.  Jenkins has a great approach so I think he is "ready" I just don't know if they want to put that much pressure on him to perform right away or not and he also hasn't been lighting up AAA IMO.  I'd think consistent at bats and playing time at AAA would still make sense for him unless Buxton is out and they give him his spot.

    The club house is in a good spot with all the players rooting for each other.  I'd be careful not to mess with that too much.  We'll see what they decide to do.  Certainly there are good reasons to get all three up right away but plenty of reasons to wait as well IMO.

    24 minutes ago, bean5302 said:

    I dislike this article quite a bit.

    Culpepper is showing a blip of knocking the rust off, but 1 good game isn't enough to convince me he's ready for a massive competition leap.

    image.png.d84e4eedf5525937b34d050f4fee64e3.png

     

    Jenkins has been league average for over a month in AAA. Tons of pop ups, tons of grounders, low line drive rate, no power, average on the base paths and no real spot for him…

     

     

    And yet, they still have a reasonable chance of outperforming the current alternatives. Jenkins has a higher OPS in the same AAA league than Max Clark, and Clark has a 228 OPS+ in his first 4 games with Detroit. It happens. And if it doesn’t…it’s not like they would be taking playing time from Cal Ripken and Mickey Mantle.

    29 minutes ago, Hawkeye Bean Counter said:

    Every other team?  I count  Lombard, Clark and thats it unless I am missing someone.  Red Sox came out and said they don't want to put the pressure on Arias.  Maybe a cup of coffee in late September.  

    Here is a few

    Max Clark 21 (Det)
    Colt Emerson 20 (Sea)
    George Lombard 21 (NYY)
    Kevin McGonigle 21 (Det)
    A.J. Ewing 21 (NYM)
    Cooper Pratt 21 (MIL)
    Konnor Griffin 21 (PIT)
    Didier Fuentes 21 (ATL)
    Samuel Basallo 21 (BAL)
    Bryce Eldridge 21 (SFG)
    Luis Lara 21 (MIL)

    40 minutes ago, strumdatjag said:

    Culpepper and Jenkins would then accumulate service time throughout all the lost part of the 2027 season (list time due to labor strife in negotiations of the new CBA).   Bad idea.   

    That's why they haven't been promoted yet.  I can understand the Twins perspective on that, but still it's frustrating.  And to be completely fair both Culpepper and Jenkins have missed significant time this season.  I think the Twins don't start the clock on either one of them this season which stinks because us fans want to see them.

    No to the Jackson move... I think the Twins see him as the backup next year. I can't see him passing through waivers with the way he has played this year.

    While there is no guarantee that players will accrue service time during the lockout, I can't see the Twins risking that on those two at this point.

    When Jenkins is called up, he needs to play every day. I don't think the Twins will do that for him right now. 

    Tristan Gray has turned into a pumpkin and then some. He's not playable right now. Same for Roden. Put me in the camp of, Culpepper and Jenkins can't be any worse but there may be some concerns about keeping them in the minors to maximize playing time.

    As for Jackson - Twins would probably lose him if they put him through waivers - and there's at least some universe where he has value backing-up Caratini in 2027 but...will there even be a 2027 season?

    35 minutes ago, Hawkeye Bean Counter said:

    Every other team?  I count  Lombard, Clark and thats it unless I am missing someone.  Red Sox came out and said they don't want to put the pressure on Arias.  Maybe a cup of coffee in late September.  

    Cleveland is calling up their SS prospect, and had around ten rookies....



    Create an account or sign in to comment

    You need to be a member in order to leave a comment

    Create an account

    Sign up for a new account in our community. It's easy!

    Register a new account

    Sign in

    Already have an account? Sign in here.

    Sign In Now

×
×
  • Create New...