Rays Could Be Perfect Trade Deadline Partner for Two Veteran Twins

[Cody Christie]

Image courtesy of © Mark J. Rebilas-Imagn Images

The Minnesota Twins enter the trade deadline in an unusual position. They're still trying to compete in 2026, but that doesn't necessarily mean every veteran on the roster is untouchable. Multiple reports suggest the Twins could remain active sellers around the margins, even if they don't launch another deadline fire sale. Dan Hayes of The Athletic noted that the Tampa Bay Rays have been scouting Minnesota heavily in recent weeks, making them one of the more intriguing potential trade partners.

If the Rays are looking to add offense for a postseason push, two Twins stand out as logical fits: Ryan Jeffers and Trevor Larnach. Rather than weakening Minnesota's roster, moving either (or even both) could allow the organization to lean into areas of organizational strength while addressing bigger needs.

The Rays Need More Middle-of-the-Order Production

Tampa Bay has rarely been afraid to make creative deadline moves, especially when they can acquire controllable hitters at reasonable salaries. Larnach checks nearly every box.

The 29-year-old is putting together the best offensive season of his career, hitting .293/.381/.457 (.842) with eight home runs, 19 doubles, and a career-high 135 OPS+. His improved approach has been just as impressive as the production. He's walking 11.4% of the time while cutting his strikeout rate to a career-low 17.4%.

Like most left-handed hitters, Larnach has struggled against southpaws, batting just .167/.268/.333 in 42 plate appearances. However, his production against right-handed pitching has been elite. His .313/.398/.475 line versus righties would immediately lengthen Tampa Bay's lineup and give the Rays another middle-of-the-order bat capable of getting on base consistently.

Just as importantly, Larnach remains affordable. He's earning $4.475 million this season and remains under team control through arbitration next year, making him attractive for a club that consistently looks for value.

Minnesota Has Plenty of Internal Replacements

Trading Larnach becomes much easier because of the Twins' depth. Matt Wallner looked overmatched during his early-season stint, hitting just .167/.259/.292 before being optioned to Triple-A in May. Since returning to St. Paul, however, he's looked much more like the player Minnesota expected. Over 243 plate appearances, Wallner owns a .284/.374/.602 line with 19 home runs.

Alan Roden has also forced his way into the conversation. Acquired in last year's Louis Varland trade, Roden hit .272/.397/.512 at Triple-A before earning another opportunity with Minnesota. Despite posting those numbers, he's received only 37 plate appearances since being promoted to the Twins in early July.

Then there's Walker Jenkins. The former No. 5 overall pick has quickly reminded everyone why he's considered one of baseball's premier prospects. Jenkins has touched Triple-A pitching with a .267/.371/.432 line and looks increasingly ready for an extended opportunity in the major leagues.

With three legitimate corner outfield options waiting behind Larnach, the Twins are in a position where dealing from depth could improve other parts of the roster without sacrificing offensive production.

Jeffers Could Bring Back Significant Value

Jeffers presents a different but equally compelling trade case. Bobby Nightengale recently reported there's a growing belief around baseball that Jeffers could be available even if Minnesota doesn't fully commit to selling. That makes sense.

Jeffers is an impending free agent who has elevated his offensive game this season. Across 186 plate appearances, he's hitting .293/.395/.535, with nine home runs. His elite plate discipline stands out even more than the power, as his 14.4% walk rate nearly matches a career-low 16.6% strikeout rate. His offensive production has been 64% better than league average, according to wRC+.

This year's breakout only strengthens what has already been an impressive offensive résumé. Dating back to the start of 2023, Jeffers owns a .259/.346/.446 line for a 122 wRC+, making him one of baseball's better offensive catchers over that span. For comparison, major-league catchers are hitting just .229/.304/.380 this season. Few contenders have enough offense behind the plate, and Jeffers would instantly become one of the better bats available at the position.

Caratini Gives Minnesota Flexibility

Trading Jeffers would have been much more difficult earlier in the season. Victor Caratini has changed that equation. After a slow start, the veteran took advantage of increased playing time while Jeffers recovered from a hamate fracture. Since May 20, Caratini has hit .273/.342/.460, with six home runs, eight doubles, a 8.9% walk rate, and an 19.6% strikeout rate over 158 plate appearances.

Minnesota also has Alex Jackson on the roster to provide quality defense as a backup catcher, giving the Twins a capable tandem if Jeffers is moved. Caratini is signed through 2027, making him more than just a short-term stopgap. That contract provides the Twins with the flexibility to maximize Jeffers's trade value while maintaining stability behind the plate.

Why Tampa Bay Makes Sense

The Rays have consistently targeted hitters who control the strike zone, possess positional flexibility, and remain affordable through arbitration or short-term contracts. Both Larnach and Jeffers fit that profile.

For Minnesota, Tampa Bay has one thing the Twins desperately need: bullpen depth. The Rays have built a reputation for developing power arms and routinely possess relievers who become attractive trade chips at the deadline. Even if bullpen help isn't the centerpiece of a deal, the Rays also have one of baseball's deeper farm systems, giving Minnesota multiple avenues to improve its long-term outlook.

The fit is obvious from both sides. Moving Jeffers or Larnach wouldn't necessarily signal that the Twins are giving up on 2026. Instead, it would represent a front office willing to capitalize on organizational depth. Minnesota has viable replacements waiting at both catcher and corner outfield. Caratini has shown he can handle a larger workload behind the plate, while Wallner, Roden, and Jenkins all deserve opportunities to establish themselves in the outfield.

If Tampa Bay is indeed one of the clubs most interested in adding offense, the Rays could offer exactly what Minnesota needs in return. The result could be one of the rare deadline trades where both teams improve their present while the Twins also look to strengthen their future.

---

Can the Twins and Rays align on a trade before the deadline? Can Minnesota trade Jeffers and stay competitive? Leave a comment and start the discussion.

 

View full article

[tony&rodney]

Agree that the Tampa Bay Rays may be a good trade partner. The targets are Brody Hopkins, Michael Forret, Ty Johnson, and Tre' Morgan as a throw in.

Can the Twins find a better deal elsewhere for Jeffers and Larnach.

Also, remember that Wallner is a DH only. Bell and Buxton have that nailed down for now.

[LambchoP]

I think Jeffers and Larnach should be enough for a top 100 pitching prospect who hopefully is AA/AAA level or higher. We should be planning for contention next year.

[Dman]

I've been looking for teams with pitching to trade with and I don't think there is a better system than Tampa's if you are looking for arms.

I don't know if there is way to pry Michael Forret from them but that would be my target.  He's at AAA could maybe be used in the Majors this year. Plenty of other power relievery arms in their system as well.  I really hope the Rays like our guys as I feel like they have what we need most.

Only other system would maybe be Atlanta.  Not sure if they match up as well for Larnach and Jeffers though.

Only arm I really like from the Yankee's is Elmer Rodriguez but he is a top 100 guy so pretty steep to get for just Jeffers or Larnach.  Maybe the Twins could add something to get there?

At any rate I agree with the OP. Tampa makes the most sense as a trade partner as they need what we have. It will come down to cost for them as they don't like to spend on rentals and like the Twins I don't think they can sign Jeffers in the offseason. 

Here's my pitch to Tampa.  If you don't want the Yankee's to grab the best hitting catcher on the market with an elite .900 OPS even if you over pay for him you are keeping him out of the Yankee's hands and adding him to your team.  That could be a pretty large difference as those teams battle for first place.  Keeping the Yankee's devoid of good bats should be part of their strategy IMO.  If I were them I'd over pay, but they are looking to add a big arm and that might deplete things too much for what the Twins would want back.  We'll see what happens but that would be my pitch. And for the record I'd rather Tampa get him than the Yankee's.

[DJL44]

I feel increasingly confident that the Twins will get an offer they can’t refuse for Jeffers. Demand is too high for catchers and supply is too low.

[Dman]

3 minutes ago, DJL44 said:

I feel increasingly confident that the Twins will get an offer they can’t refuse for Jeffers. Demand is too high for catchers and supply is too low.

He's also a right handed bat which the market is low on.  I'd say he is doubly valuable. Tough to pay a ton for a rental but he fills a lot of needs.  I'd think if you are ever gonna overpay big time for a rental he would be it.

[Dman]

14 minutes ago, tony&rodney said:

Agree that the Tampa Bay Rays may be a good trade partner. The targets are Brody Hopkins, Michael Forret, Ty Johnson, and Tre' Morgan as a throw in.

Can the Twins find a better deal elsewhere for Jeffers and Larnach.

Also, remember that Wallner is a DH only. Bell and Buxton have that nailed down for now.

Hopkins would be the better get than Forret, but I'm assuming Tampa might want to use him this year or next in their rotation.  Seems a little too much to give in a Jeffers or Larnach trade, but perhaps the Twins could add something to get there.  Hard to say.  Hopkins has some great stuff just sounds like control is an issue.

[JD-TWINS]

Trade Jeffers and Wallner in a package. Excellent short term help at Catcher and a potential DH with excellent upside power …… like Larnach, a platoon guy v. RH pitching. Both are just occasional corner outfielders. Wallner is almost $ free.

Larnach has value this year and going forward for Twins!

Trade Bell and young arm for some value. Larnach shifts to DH and line-up has better consistency……..allows Jenkins a role in OF, if Team thinks this makes sense.

Clemens - Buxton - Keaschall in OF (w/Roden or Jenkins)…… Larnach & Martin (OF) at DH ……. Caratini/Jackson ……… Lee -  Kreidler - Arraez or Culpepper - Lewis.

Go big w/prospects to Giants for Luis!!!

[Rigby]

2 minutes ago, Dman said:

Hopkins would be the better get than Forret, but I'm assuming Tampa might want to use him this year or next in their rotation.  Seems a little too much to give in a Jeffers or Larnach trade, but perhaps the Twins could add something to get there.  Hard to say.  Hopkins has some great stuff just sounds like control is an issue.

Yep, 77 BB in 82 IP may be a bit of an issue.

[JD-TWINS]

14 minutes ago, DJL44 said:

I feel increasingly confident that the Twins will get an offer they can’t refuse for Jeffers. Demand is too high for catchers and supply is too low.

Experienced, competent, switch hitting Catcher /1B ………..with another year of control. Am not sure that Caratini isn’t as attractive or more attractive than Jeffers for a few of the Clubs in the hunt?

[rdehring]

Add me to the list of those who believe the Twins must trade Jeffers.  That's assuming they get a reasonable offer.  Hopefully, better than reasonable.

As for Larnach, more 50/50.  Should be moved if they get a very good offer.  Add Wallner and maybe another prospect for some help for the pen and it will be an excellent deadline for the Twins.  Most important, some of the return must be a pitcher who will help the Twins this year. 

[tony&rodney]

2 minutes ago, JD-TWINS said:

Experienced, competent, switch hitting Catcher /1B ………..with another year of control. Am not sure that Caratini isn’t as attractive or more attractive than Jeffers for a few of the Clubs in the hunt?

Personally, I prefer Caratini as my catcher. However, Jeffers is easily he better bat and He also provides a fair amount of power. Jeffers has improved as a hitter and is a tough opponent for pitchers. My guess is that Jeffers has more value, even if he will be a free agent after two more months.

[MikeNC]

Hmmm, Jeffers is an established, elite hitting Catcher who at age 29 should have a number of good years ahead.  In a current market where competing available Catchers of his calibre are non-existant. All we get is a prospect?  Not a top 100 even?  Yeah, if we can't get a decent MLB or a AAA-MLB ready bullpen arm then pass, keep him for the rest of the season.  Yankees have the WORST production at Catcher in all of MLB, pony up dudes or watch Jeffers beat you down the stretch run.

[hitterscount]

Wallner is not a legit corner outfielder.... period. No explanation needed.... trading Larnach and replacing him with Wallner is a terrible plan. I don't have an issue of moving either player because of the reasons listed , there are current options to stay competitive, but Wallner isn't one of them. 

[DJL44]

16 minutes ago, JD-TWINS said:

Experienced, competent, switch hitting Catcher /1B ………..with another year of control. Am not sure that Caratini isn’t as attractive or more attractive than Jeffers for a few of the Clubs in the hunt?

I would sell both if I got a stupid offer for each of them. I don’t think being slightly out of the playoff race should keep them from making a good baseball trade.

[Mike Sixel]

Tampa or Seattle are my hopes..... Tampa had the best farm system by far. I'm not sure what you need to include to get Forret, but he's the target there. Some combo of players for Hancock from Seattle. 

Id happily deal larnach if they are calling up Jenkins. If not, I'd rather deal or DFA Bell, and make Larnach the primary DH. 

[DJL44]

I am as confident as I can be that the Twins won’t have 3 catchers on the 26-man roster on August 5th.

[Twins GFP]

Contrary to what the article says, trading away two of your best hitters for prospects does constitute waving a white flag on the season.

That being said, if the Twins believe there is a zero chance of a Jeffers re-sign/extension, and the Caratini/Jackson pairing looking solid, I can understand why they would trade him.

The Larnach situation is a little different. With another year of arbitration control, and the Twins not willing to call up a high-end prospect with the strike looming, I don't know if the return would be so high that trading him right now makes sense. Yes, they would be selling high on him, but it sends a bad message to the clubhouse if they trade him for prospects while in the playoff hunt.

[UK Twin]

TBH Tampa Bay will probably refuse to trade any pitchers to us as they are sick and tired of watching them flourish for the Twins. 😁

[Patzky]

1 hour ago, Dman said:

I've been looking for teams with pitching to trade with and I don't think there is a better system than Tampa's if you are looking for arms.

I don't know if there is way to pry Michael Forret from them but that would be my target.  He's at AAA could maybe be used in the Majors this year. Plenty of other power relievery arms in their system as well.  I really hope the Rays like our guys as I feel like they have what we need most.

Only other system would maybe be Atlanta.  Not sure if they match up as well for Larnach and Jeffers though.

Only arm I really like from the Yankee's is Elmer Rodriguez but he is a top 100 guy so pretty steep to get for just Jeffers or Larnach.  Maybe the Twins could add something to get there?

At any rate I agree with the OP. Tampa makes the most sense as a trade partner as they need what we have. It will come down to cost for them as they don't like to spend on rentals and like the Twins I don't think they can sign Jeffers in the offseason. 

Here's my pitch to Tampa.  If you don't want the Yankee's to grab the best hitting catcher on the market with an elite .900 OPS even if you over pay for him you are keeping him out of the Yankee's hands and adding him to your team.  That could be a pretty large difference as those teams battle for first place.  Keeping the Yankee's devoid of good bats should be part of their strategy IMO.  If I were them I'd over pay, but they are looking to add a big arm and that might deplete things too much for what the Twins would want back.  We'll see what happens but that would be my pitch. And for the record I'd rather Tampa get him than the Yankee's.

Wonder if Tampa would take the cheap route and inquire about Caratini, also effectively keeping Jeffers out of the Yankees' hands.

[terrydactyls]

You are promoting Jeffers and Larnach as prime targets for Tampa Bay.  But then you say that Tampa Bay consistently looks for players with "positional flexibility".  Jeffers is primarily a catcher with occasional time at 1B.  Larnach is a questionable LF, but should be a DH.  Neither offer Tampa Bay positional flexibility.

[UK Twin]

2 minutes ago, Patzky said:

Wonder if Tampa would take the cheap route and inquire about Caratini, also effectively keeping Jeffers out of the Yankees' hands.

I think that would end up backfiring for them as I do think we'll get an offer for Jeffers that we can't refuse, quite possibly from the Yankees in that situation. And then we won't be trading Caratini.

[Mike Sixel]

4 minutes ago, terrydactyls said:

You are promoting Jeffers and Larnach as prime targets for Tampa Bay.  But then you say that Tampa Bay consistently looks for players with "positional flexibility".  Jeffers is primarily a catcher with occasional time at 1B.  Larnach is a questionable LF, but should be a DH.  Neither offer Tampa Bay positional flexibility.

Jeffers is a rental. They can use him at catcher and DH. I don't think it matters he's not flexible for two months. Ymmv, of course. 

[Patzky]

Just now, UK Twin said:

I think that would end up backfiring for them as I do think we'll get an offer for Jeffers that we can't refuse, quite possibly from the Yankees in that situation. And then we won't be trading Caratini.

One is likely gone, barring last minute injury (See Langeliers, Shea) 

It had better be a door buster deal for Jeffers. Don't forget the qualifying offer vs work stoppage concern in 27. If it's not a great deal, like my dad used to say, don't get taken to the cleaners.

[Dman]

29 minutes ago, Patzky said:

Wonder if Tampa would take the cheap route and inquire about Caratini, also effectively keeping Jeffers out of the Yankees' hands.

That is one way to get back down to two catchers. Not sure Caratini would have the same steam Jeffers does so not sure they'd do that deal.  Also not sure if the Twins wouldn't trade both catchers if the prices were right.   If they could get close to ready starting pitching from each of them that would go a long way toward building the pitching depth they need for next year and beyond.  They'd still have Jackson left and would have to find a more straight up defensive catcher, but with Lackey on the way they could make that work for the right price.

Still I think the solid play is to just move Jeffers.  I don't know how Tampa feels about Bodine but he is hitting nearly .900 OPS at AA.  If they think he will be ready by next year then one year of Jeffers bridges that gap for them and his big righty bat would really help them in the playoffs. I'd think its Jeffers or bust for them.

[mnfireman]

Tampa has Yandy Diaz as its primary DH, he's having a as good a season (maybe better) as Larnach. Larnach would be an upgrade over De Luca in RF however.

[mike8791]

As Twins GPF stated, you are recommending trading 2 of the top 3 hitters(and maybe your 2 best w/Bux slow return) in a lineup that already has some very streaky hitters.  Trading a player like Jeffers who is almost certainly lost after this season is a no-brainer.  If Zoll fails to get this done with a nice return then he is not the GM who should be responsible for leading this club back to contention. A return like Hancock or a top 100 pitching prospect should be attainable, maybe with a #10-20 prospect added as a sweetener.

Trading Larnach would be a fool's errand.  I realize Jenkins is in the wings but his 2026 stats would indicate he needs more time in AAA. The other OF prospects are either too injury prone(E Rod) or have defensive limitations(Gonzales/Mendez) to count on them to replace Larnach any time soon. With a combo of Keuchel/Roden as corner OFs,  loss of Larnach, in addition to Jeffers, would severely dampen any fan enthusiasm remaining, kill player morale, and, if possible, further lower any credibility in ownership. 

[HarmonK03]

11 minutes ago, mike8791 said:

As Twins GPF stated, you are recommending trading 2 of the top 3 hitters(and maybe your 2 best w/Bux slow return) in a lineup that already has some very streaky hitters.  Trading a player like Jeffers who is almost certainly lost after this season is a no-brainer.  If Zoll fails to get this done with a nice return then he is not the GM who should be responsible for leading this club back to contention. A return like Hancock or a top 100 pitching prospect should be attainable, maybe with a #10-20 prospect added as a sweetener.

Trading Larnach would be a fool's errand.  I realize Jenkins is in the wings but his 2026 stats would indicate he needs more time in AAA. The other OF prospects are either too injury prone(E Rod) or have defensive limitations(Gonzales/Mendez) to count on them to replace Larnach any time soon. With a combo of Keuchel/Roden as corner OFs,  loss of Larnach, in addition to Jeffers, would severely dampen any fan enthusiasm remaining, kill player morale, and, if possible, further lower any credibility in ownership. 

Roden is not a replacement for Larnach, if he is traded it needs to be to clear room for Jenkins.

[DataNerd]

50 minutes ago, Patzky said:

Wonder if Tampa would take the cheap route and inquire about Caratini, also effectively keeping Jeffers out of the Yankees' hands.

That would require them to have Caratini under contract for next year, which isn't their style.  They currently only have 1 player (Steven Matz) under contract for 27.

[DataNerd]

1 hour ago, JD-TWINS said:

Experienced, competent, switch hitting Catcher /1B ………..with another year of control. Am not sure that Caratini isn’t as attractive or more attractive than Jeffers for a few of the Clubs in the hunt?

We signed Caratini as a FA in the offseason because the league wasn't giving him the contract we thought he was worth.  I'm not sure that a team is all of a sudden more excited about Caratini now when he looks to be pretty much the same player he was the last 2 years.