Jump to content
Twins Daily
  • Create Account

Recommended Posts

Posted
1 hour ago, Twodogs said:

It would be interesting to see what Royce can do in a different organization?

Let's hope he gets the opportunity. Royce finding success elsewhere would never bother me. It hasn't happened for him as a Twin.

Verified Member
Posted
1 hour ago, darin617 said:

What free agent are they going to find for the same money?

They will gain two things:

1. $5+ million to improve the roster

2. The absence of Royce Lewis going forward

 

Posted
9 hours ago, Eris said:

According to FanGraphs Lewis’ 2026 salary was 2.85 million. He projected to get a 2.3 million dollar raise in arbitration for being 20% below league average. Not sure if arbitration is really helping Lewis as a likely outcome is DFA. 

Which makes me wonder how accurate the $5.1M is. I get that MLBTR is often pretty good and we don’t have a better reference point, but I’m struck with how many people are treating this salary as gospel. 

I’m also struck with how similar this was to a year ago when the discussion was about Larnach, who was coming off a 0.2 bWAR year. The TD braintrust seemed to be about 90 percent on non-tendering.

Now much of the discussion seems to be trending that way on a guy with a 0.8 bWAR and who has always been considered more talented. 

Verified Member
Posted
13 hours ago, JADBP said:

OR.....Bring up Houston ASAP.  Maybe by June?  He is a superb defender and if he can hit MLB pitching, watch out!  Move Pepper to 2B.  That frees up Clemens to platoon 1B with Royce--actually both become decent bench pieces. 

This highlights the only real downside of spending money on a FA second baseman - it’s hopefully Culpepper’s spot by mid-season. A platoon of Clemens and Lewis at 1B could work and they both provide at some flexibility to move around the diamond. 

Once Houston is up we shouldn’t have to worry about having bench players for CF or SS - they can move Jenkins/ERod and Culpepper over when injury strikes or the starters need a rest.

All that said, we may have just seen the best year (by far) Clemens will ever have and Lewis clearly can’t be counted on. If Jeffers doesn’t resign they will definitely need someone more dependable to hit in the middle of the lineup, which means 1B.

 

Posted
3 hours ago, MackMan said:

Lewis is a AAAA player similar to Rooker a few years ago.....

He has shown us who he is. He's a below average hitter who is a ball player from the neck up. 

Not sure what you mean by "from the neck up".  Did you mean the opposite?

As far as being compared to Rooker, well the athleticism and the ability to be acceptable in the field aren't comparable. 

Posted
15 hours ago, Greggory Masterson said:

I outlined how many teams do have a player like that on their bench—one who doesn't necessarily do one thing well but is only a half-step behind your average regular. The Twins have had guys very recently like Willi Castro and even Kyle Farmer (2023's version who could play shortstop and hit at a league-average level). The thing is that Lewis has no shown himself to be 2023 Kyle Farmer, and other than hoping they find the switch to get him to consistently play at a passable level, it's difficult to see how he becomes that.

No one would be salivating over adding 2023 Kyle Farmer to this team, but his OPS that year was 60 points higher than Lewis's last year, and he could play a premium defensive position passably well. He had twice the bWAR in about a third of the plate appearances. I would love a good fifth infielder being added to the mix. The issue is that that player is not Royce Lewis. Or at least it hasn't been in 30 months.

Just wanted to comment that the OP was a good, easy to understand, breakdown of Lewis' performance and value. 

Posted
13 hours ago, Twodogs said:

Rooker hit 109 bombs in 4 years in Oakland.  Last year he only hit 10 in an injury plagued season where he only played 48 games.  But if you extrapolate that over 150 games and he hits 30 homeruns again.  Before last year Rooker hit 99 homeruns in 3 seasons.  He ended up being a lot better than  a AAAA player.  That makes me wonder do the Twins cause these guys to be AAAA players??  It would be interesting to see what Royce can do in a different organization?

I don't disagree with you. Clearly Rooker bouncing from the Padres to the Royals to A's opened something up to where he was finally able to tap into that power we were always told he had. 

I really do think it is something with our development at minor league level. I mean, they absolutely messed up Auston Martin's swing by trying to make him a power hitter. Then when he finally broke camp with the big league team, he was doing more of his stuff and it was playing...for a while. 

Posted
On 11/11/2026 at 7:27 AM, DJL44 said:

His bat hasn’t been good enough for Double-A yet.

Look at what he is doing in the fall league, absolutely ripping the cover off the ball 

Posted

If they are determined to keep Keaschal in the OF, Lewis should be their 1Bman. He has been disappointing but it looked like he figured it out before he ran out of gas. He's got the talent to be a pretty good MLBer. The only other option we have is to trade him & get nothing in return & then pay for an expensive broken down 2Bman. I'm not crazy about Clemens at 2B, but I have a different solution.

Posted

Another thing to keep in mind. Prior to his being sent down to AAA. Royce had an OPS of .539. This number was influenced by a horrible May of .318 OPS. 

That is going to weight down his final 2026 number. 

When he returned... his OPS was .704 for the rest of the season. Creating the final .667

.704 still wasn't great but the .539 was improved upon when he came back. 

However... That .704 was strongly influenced by a real nice June. He produced a .841 OPS that month. 

He then watched that thing walk back straight down to a .559 in September. 

When he said... he doesn't do slumps. What he meant to say is... I do slumps.  

 

Old-Timey Member
Posted
6 hours ago, Riverbrian said:

He then watched that thing walk back straight down to a .559 in September. 

When he said... he doesn't do slumps. What he meant to say is... I do slumps.  

 

Maybe he meant I'm a .195 hitter who does do the very occasional hot streak. 

Posted
7 hours ago, Riverbrian said:

Another thing to keep in mind. Prior to his being sent down to AAA. Royce had an OPS of .539. This number was influenced by a horrible May of .318 OPS. 

That is going to weight down his final 2026 number. 

When he returned... his OPS was .704 for the rest of the season. Creating the final .667

.704 still wasn't great but the .539 was improved upon when he came back. 

However... That .704 was strongly influenced by a real nice June. He produced a .841 OPS that month. 

He then watched that thing walk back straight down to a .559 in September. 

When he said... he doesn't do slumps. What he meant to say is... I do slumps.  

 

Or slumps I am.

Verified Member
Posted

Sad to say, but it is hard to disagree with this assessment. That said, $5.1M isnt going to buy a replacement if note either. Where do you put Keaschall?

He doesnt have the arm.for RF.

I always thought Lewis should be in LF.

Right handed bat, 5 tool guy. Seems he lost a couple 10mm wrenches along the way. See what spring training brings. Maybe the magic reappears, then if not, assess. They need a big bat at 1B.

Verified Member
Posted
16 hours ago, TL said:

This highlights the only real downside of spending money on a FA second baseman - it’s hopefully Culpepper’s spot by mid-season. A platoon of Clemens and Lewis at 1B could work and they both provide at some flexibility to move around the diamond. 

Once Houston is up we shouldn’t have to worry about having bench players for CF or SS - they can move Jenkins/ERod and Culpepper over when injury strikes or the starters need a rest.

All that said, we may have just seen the best year (by far) Clemens will ever have and Lewis clearly can’t be counted on. If Jeffers doesn’t resign they will definitely need someone more dependable to hit in the middle of the lineup, which means 1B.

 

I agree with everything you said and I too am looking forward to the slick play of Houston at SS.  I just hope he hits well enough to stick there.  

The really does leave a hole in the middle of the line up for a power-hitting infielder.  We are not going to ever get 25-30 HRs out of Lee, Houston or Culpepper.  And, we just don't have anyone that looks like they can get us there (why we stuck with the Royce).  We can't replace 25 HRs with HOPE.  So, let's see what we can package to get a good 1Bman.  I'd honestly trade Ryan for a 1Bman right now, especially one that we can ride for 3-5 years. 

But who knows...we just can't seem to trade anyone anymore!  This team seems just totally spooked with trading!  And, this is not a new Pohlad thing...we didn't trade Ryan for Boston's #1 and #2 prospects, one of which is now their Ace!  And, I don't trust Zoll as far as I can throw him.....so....wow.....

Posted
On 11/11/2026 at 6:19 AM, stringer bell said:

Starters aren't written in stone. Check out the March/April lineups the Twins produced in 2026. I'm fine with Lewis being carried as a non-starter to start the season and it is pretty likely that he would get his last chance as a regular player due to injury or ineffectiveness of a player who is thought to be a "starter".

To what end? He's been awful for 2.5 years. Why can't people move on?

Posted
On 11/11/2026 at 12:27 PM, stringer bell said:

Two points, probably contradictory. 1) Royce Lewis is a 1-1 draft choice and looked extraordinary in cameos between injuries. It can't help but change the narrative about his career. There is a small amount of hope in most of us that he can somehow be that guy again. 2) Lewis' performance in the past two and a half seasons is barely utility infielder worthy. If that is all there is in the tank, he isn't worth all of the conversation.

I find it interesting that in some people's minds future performance is written in stone. Two first base free agents are proof that isn't so--both Ty France and Jake Bauers looked like their careers were about done two years ago, now they are probably the two most sought-after first basemen in the market. 

Royce Lewis is my favorite player. Hands down. He's got the skill. Last year, his flop down the stretch was clearly him expanding the zone and hacking away. That said, he simply cannot be "expected" to contribute as a starting position player.

Old-Timey Member
Posted
11 hours ago, JADBP said:

We are not going to ever get 25-30 HRs out of Lee, Houston or Culpepper. 

They got 24 HR from Lee last year and he's only 25. Culpepper hit 14 in only 74 games in AAA last year and 11 in 59 games at AA the year before. You may not get 30, but at least these two are not black holes. 

Posted
11 hours ago, JADBP said:

I agree with everything you said and I too am looking forward to the slick play of Houston at SS.  I just hope he hits well enough to stick there.  

The really does leave a hole in the middle of the line up for a power-hitting infielder.  We are not going to ever get 25-30 HRs out of Lee, Houston or Culpepper.  And, we just don't have anyone that looks like they can get us there (why we stuck with the Royce).  We can't replace 25 HRs with HOPE.  So, let's see what we can package to get a good 1Bman.  I'd honestly trade Ryan for a 1Bman right now, especially one that we can ride for 3-5 years. 

But who knows...we just can't seem to trade anyone anymore!  This team seems just totally spooked with trading!  And, this is not a new Pohlad thing...we didn't trade Ryan for Boston's #1 and #2 prospects, one of which is now their Ace!  And, I don't trust Zoll as far as I can throw him.....so....wow.....

And we don't need to get 30HR's out all of our players. This thought and sentiment is exactly has gotten the Twins into the position their in. Trying to make everyone a power hitter isn't going to work. What should be done is focus on that particular players strengths and refine them. If some power comes with, awesome. If not, let that player play. Trying to make Austin Martin a power hitter is what screwed him up for years. Same thing with Larnach. If they had just let Larnach use his power to be a doubles hitter instead of trying to build him up to be the next Killer, we'd be advocating to keep on in the team in the middle or back half of the order because he hits the ball. 

If Culpepper hits 15-20 a season that is fine. But with that he needs to put 35-40 doubles and 20-30 steals in the stat book to off-set the "lower" power numbers. Not every player is going to be Mike Trout where they're going to put up a consistent 35-40 HR's/season with 25-35 steals AND 40+ doubles. 

Lee has already shown he has power. He was just shy of 25. Another season of refining his swing from both sides and he is going to be more dangerous. He has the defense, now he just needs to work on selective pitch swinging. 

Houston was and is a glove-first SS. If he hits less than 10-15/season I'm down for that. If he can keep his average around .300 and play stellar defense, we've got a SS who will play for a long time. Heck, if he can even be a resemblance of Ozzie Smith, I would take that in a heartbeat. Probably the best fielding SS the game has ever seen, and was an okay bat. 

Posted
13 hours ago, Mike Sixel said:

To what end? He's been awful for 2.5 years. Why can't people move on?

Jake Bauers OPS '21-'24  .572, .693, .662

Ty France OPS '23-'25   .703, .670, .681

Past performance does not guarantee future results, both positive and negative.

Posted
15 minutes ago, stringer bell said:

Jake Bauers OPS '21-'24  .572, .693, .662

Ty France OPS '23-'25   .703, .670, .681

Past performance does not guarantee future results, both positive and negative.

How many years does he have to be bad? There are zero, zero, guarantees in life, but you have to make decisions anyway. That's the nature of life. 

Posted
18 minutes ago, Mike Sixel said:

How many years does he have to be bad? There are zero, zero, guarantees in life, but you have to make decisions anyway. That's the nature of life. 

He's still under team control and still has options remaining. He's 27 and has had some great success in small sample sizes before. I want the Twins to give him one more chance, but have someone around so that he isn't in the lineup by default.

Posted
48 minutes ago, stringer bell said:

He's still under team control and still has options remaining. He's 27 and has had some great success in small sample sizes before. I want the Twins to give him one more chance, but have someone around so that he isn't in the lineup by default.

So two guys that can realistically start at first? 

Posted
8 minutes ago, Mike Sixel said:

So two guys that can realistically start at first? 

Yeah, Lewis plus one. Clemens is certainly an option at first and perhaps Keaschall or Roden. If Clemens is at first, they would have to find someone to play second base, so I'm saying they need to add a starting level infielder at either first or second base. As I said upthread, who starts the season at a position isn't necessarily the guy who will get the playing time over the course of the season. Lewis offers a chance to end the season as a starter at first, second or third. Of course, he will have to hit much better than he has and after two years it is folly to count on it, but holding out the possibility when under team control is a gamble I would take as a GM. 

Posted

Honestly just trade him and move on . No reason to force a role for a bad player he probably even needs a change so the top pick expectations are gone and he can just play. It's obvious the pre injury form is gone . Biggest reason I say move on is twins won't demote him to bench bat they will continue trying to start him hoping he figured it out even tho it's been years since he's even been average . I mean he's eventually getting replaced once Houston is really why not do it now and sign a replacement you can trust to move you quality production instead of being twins worst everyday players. 

Posted
14 hours ago, stringer bell said:

Yeah, Lewis plus one. Clemens is certainly an option at first and perhaps Keaschall or Roden. If Clemens is at first, they would have to find someone to play second base, so I'm saying they need to add a starting level infielder at either first or second base. As I said upthread, who starts the season at a position isn't necessarily the guy who will get the playing time over the course of the season. Lewis offers a chance to end the season as a starter at first, second or third. Of course, he will have to hit much better than he has and after two years it is folly to count on it, but holding out the possibility when under team control is a gamble I would take as a GM. 

Perfectly said. 

I don't understand how people don't understand this. 

Old-Timey Member
Posted
11 hours ago, Sampson5 said:

Honestly just trade him and move on . No reason to force a role for a bad player he probably even needs a change so the top pick expectations are gone and he can just play. It's obvious the pre injury form is gone . Biggest reason I say move on is twins won't demote him to bench bat they will continue trying to start him hoping he figured it out even tho it's been years since he's even been average . I mean he's eventually getting replaced once Houston is really why not do it now and sign a replacement you can trust to move you quality production instead of being twins worst everyday players. 

The Twins LIKE to gamble on players, so you may get your wish.

Create an account or sign in to comment

You need to be a member in order to leave a comment

Create an account

Sign up for a new account in our community. It's easy!

Register a new account

Sign in

Already have an account? Sign in here.

Sign In Now
The Twins Daily Caretaker Fund
The Twins Daily Caretaker Fund

You all care about this site. The next step is caring for it. We’re asking you to caretake this site so it can remain the premier Twins community on the internet.

×
×
  • Create New...