Jump to content
Twins Daily
  • Create Account

Recommended Posts

Posted

 

You want to DFA someone who just turned 24?  

 

Of course, why not? Again, give me a name who has negative WAR two consecutive years under 24 then become a first-division player in the future.

Posted

 

Of course, why not? Again, give me a name who has negative WAR two consecutive years under 24 then become a first-division player in the future.

 

Well, it's only his second season, and his WAR is only -0.1, so a little hot stretch will get him out of negative territory.  Last year he was also -0.1, despite a wRC+ of 101.  He's not an awful player, and to pretend he can't possibly get better is ludicrous.

Posted

 

You do realize that this isn't football, and the players on offense also have to play on defense, right?

 

It would be amusing to see Colon in CF (if I weren't a Twins fan).

Posted

 

Well, it's only his second season, and his WAR is only -0.1, so a little hot stretch will get him out of negative territory.  Last year he was also -0.1, despite a wRC+ of 101.  He's not an awful player, and to pretend he can't possibly get better is ludicrous.

Ludicurous? Cameron Maybin had huge physical upside and loud tools in his young career. At 24, Maybin produced 4.3 WAR and Padres just thought what you said. But you knew, he never got better. In MLB history, there were many players like Maybin.

 

Yes, -0.1 vs 0.1 or -0.1 vs 0.5, getting better WAR. But if Twins want to win champ, Polanco need to become 3~4 WAR player, that's huge jump and no one had done that in MLB history.

Posted (edited)

 

Ludicurous? Cameron Maybin had huge physical upside and loud tools in his young career. At 24, Maybin produced 4.3 WAR and Padres just thought what you said. But you knew, he never got better. In MLB history, there were many players like Maybin.

 

Yes, -0.1 vs 0.1 or -0.1 vs 0.5, getting better WAR. But if Twins want to win champ, Polanco need to become 3~4 WAR player, that's huge jump and no one had done that in MLB history.

 

how sure are you of that last sentence? That no one in history has become a 3-4 win player after this type of start? I'm asking, because I have no idea.

 

edit: you can find A LOT of players that had much more negative WAR in year 1 that became elite....

Edited by Mike Sixel
The Twins Daily Caretaker Fund
The Twins Daily Caretaker Fund

You all care about this site. The next step is caring for it. We’re asking you to caretake this site so it can remain the premier Twins community on the internet.

×
×
  • Create New...