Joe Mauer, Byron Buxton, and Never-Ending Trade Speculation

[Cody Christie]

Image courtesy of ©Brad Rempel-Imagn Images

It has become one of baseball's most predictable conversations. Whenever the Minnesota Twins hit a rough patch, fall out of contention, or approach the trade deadline, Byron Buxton's name starts appearing in trade speculation. National analysts suggest contenders should call. Fans debate whether the organization should maximize his value. Pundits wonder if the star center fielder deserves a chance to play elsewhere.

The discussion has persisted for years, despite one important detail: Buxton has never shown much interest in leaving Minnesota. That's why Joe Mauer's recent comments were particularly noteworthy.

No one understands the unique position Buxton occupies better than Mauer. Before Buxton became the face of the franchise, Mauer spent more than a decade carrying that responsibility himself. He experienced the pressure of being a franchise cornerstone, heard the rumors about playing elsewhere, and ultimately chose to spend his entire career in a Twins uniform.

Speaking with reporters ahead of a celebrity golf tournament at the end of May, Mauer touched on several topics before the conversation turned to Buxton and his importance to the organization.

The parallels between the two stars are impossible to ignore. Both entered professional baseball with enormous expectations. Mauer was selected first overall by the Twins in the 2001 MLB Draft and eventually built a Hall of Fame career. Buxton was viewed as one of the sport's most exciting prospects before Minnesota selected him second overall in 2012 after the Houston Astros chose Carlos Correa with the first pick.

Their careers have unfolded differently, but each player became the centerpiece of the franchise during his era. When asked about Buxton's impact on the field, Mauer didn't hesitate.

“He’s one of the most exciting players in the game. He can do it all. He can impact the game in so many different ways — not just with the bat, but with his glove, with his base-running, and his tools. You don’t really have to know baseball to know that he just stands out a little bit from the other guys.”

Mauer's assessment reflects what Twins fans have seen for years. When healthy, Buxton remains one of the game's most dynamic talents. He can change a game with a home run, save runs in center field, or create havoc on the bases. There simply aren't many players capable of influencing every aspect of the game the way Buxton can.

Of course, the conversation around Buxton has never been solely about talent. Health has been the defining storyline of his career, and Mauer knows that reality better than most. His career was affected by multiple injuries, eventually forcing him to retire.

“That’s always been kind of his thing, that you’ve got to keep him on the field, and when he can stay healthy, he’s going to put up some good numbers. So happy that he’s staying healthy, and I always enjoy watching him play the game.”

Health concerns have often fueled trade discussions. Some outsiders see an injury history and wonder if Minnesota should move on. Others see an elite talent and believe a contender should make an aggressive offer.

Mauer understands those conversations because he lived through his own version of them. Before signing his long-term extension, there was speculation about whether the Twins could keep him. Later, as Minnesota endured losing seasons near the end of his career, some wondered if he would seek a better opportunity elsewhere. Instead, Mauer remained committed to the organization, choosing to finish his career where it started.

That history gives his perspective on Buxton additional significance. Naturally, trade rumors will continue to follow a player of Buxton's caliber. However, Mauer believes the center fielder has earned the right to determine what comes next.

“Buxton put himself in that position to have some input on it,” Mauer said. “He’s been around for a little while, and I believe he’s got a no-trade clause. Every decision is unique. Every player’s got their own things that they prioritize, and that go into a decision like that.”

Mauer also said, “I know Buxton wants to win more than anybody, and I think he wants to win in Minnesota, and that would be something that I would like to see. But I just wish the best for him. Such a good guy, was a great teammate, and I hope he gets that chance to win. And I really do hope it’s here in Minnesota.”

The trade speculation surrounding Buxton is unlikely to disappear anytime soon. That's the reality of being one of the most talented players in baseball. But Mauer's comments offer an important reminder that often gets lost in hypothetical trade proposals.

Players have a voice in these situations, and sometimes their priorities don't align with the outside noise. Mauer heard the rumors and stayed. Buxton has heard them for years and continues to express his desire to remain in Minnesota. For two franchise icons from different generations, that may be the strongest connection of all.

---

Will the Twins explore trade options with Buxton this year? Are there other connections between Buxton and Mauer? Leave a comment and start the discussion.

View full article

[Rosterman]

Ultimately any trade of Buxton means the Twins want to reduce (pocket) payroll rather than be competive in any way.

Then, again, you trade Buxton if he ain't gonna play in the field, or, at best, give you 120-130 appearances on the diamond. He will evntually be pushed out of center sooner rather than later, where will he end up, and do the Twins even think about extending him.

[mickster]

4 minutes ago, Rosterman said:

Ultimately any trade of Buxton means the Twins want to reduce (pocket) payroll rather than be competive in any way.

Then, again, you trade Buxton if he ain't gonna play in the field, or, at best, give you 120-130 appearances on the diamond. He will evntually be pushed out of center sooner rather than later, where will he end up, and do the Twins even think about extending him.

should have the opportunity to be a lifetime Twin if that is his desire.   If he wants out to get a ring, then you give him the Kevin Garnett treatment and award him that opportunity

[mikelink45]

Keep him, keep Ryan - build the bullpen.  Make us competitive again. 

[friedbrycenbeans]

I'll commit seppuku in the middle of target field if buxton ever plays for anyone other than the Twins

[Eris]

A good number of the trade speculation articles are also about writers hunting for clicks. 

[thelanges5]

I applaud and appreciate his loyalty to the Twins. With his no trade clause and service time, this will be a Buck decision. The front office and ownership sure aren’t doing anything to create optimism in this club.

[jkcarew]

I get why Mauer never wanted to be traded. And honestly, that speculation didn’t manifest until very late, when he was of middling value at first base. Buxton is more of a needle-mover than he’s ever been. The return for him right now would dwarf what the org would’ve received for Mauer those last couple of years.

Meanwhile, Buxton is in a completely different situation, with home-schooled kids, deep ties only in Georgia. It strikes me as completely odd that he wouldn’t ask for a trade to a contender at this point in his career, and given the state of the org. IMO, this goes beyond loyalty.

[mickster]

1 hour ago, mikelink45 said:

Keep him, keep Ryan - build the bullpen.  Make us competitive again. 

preach on!!!!!