Twins Video
It’s no secret that Minnesota sports fans have been conditioned for heartbreak. But heading into the 2025 season, pessimism surrounding the Twins might be reaching a fever pitch. According to The Athletic’s annual fan survey, just 52% of Twins fans reported feeling optimistic about the team’s chances this year. That number ranks 21st in Major League Baseball, sandwiched between the San Francisco Giants (20th) and the Oakland Athletics (23rd). It starkly contrasts the past two years, when Minnesota ranked in the top 10.
In 2024, 86.3% of fans expressed confidence in the team, placing them 10th in MLB. The previous year, the optimism was even higher, at 91.3%, again ranking 10th. Even in 2022, when there were still plenty of unanswered questions about the team’s long-term direction, the Twins ranked 17th with a 70.1% optimism rating. So what’s changed in just one year, to cause such a sharp decline?
Why Are Fans So Pessimistic?
There are several contributing factors at work. The most glaring issue is how the 2024 season ended. The Twins were in a prime position to claim a playoff spot, before an ugly late-season collapse left fans feeling burned. Adding another late-season meltdown to the record books was a gut punch for an organization that has historically struggled in October. It was clearly one of the most disappointing seasons in Twins history.
Adding to the unease is uncertainty regarding new ownership. The Pohlad family is expected to sell the team in 2025, leaving many questions about the franchise’s future direction. Justin Ishbia dropped out of a bid to buy the franchise that had reached advanced stages, forcing the team to pivot to other options. Will new ownership invest more aggressively in free agency? Will there be major front-office shake-ups? Fans have taken stability for granted under the Pohlads, and the unknown brings an extra level of uneasiness. At the same time, satisfaction with (and confidence in) the Pohlads themselves is lower than it has been since the family flirted with contracting the team over two decades ago.
Meanwhile, the rest of the AL Central is trending upward. The Cleveland Guardians, Kansas City Royals and Detroit Tigers made significant strides last season, each winning at least as many postseason games (3) as the Twins have won in the last 20 years. Many projection systems have the Twins as one of the favorites in the division, but fans want the team to prove it after 2024’s collapse. Minnesota can no longer assume divisional dominance, and fans feel uneasy about the team’s standing in the AL Central.
A Reason for Hope?
While the pessimism is understandable, there are still plenty of reasons to believe in this Twins team. The core roster remains strong, featuring a mix of young talent and proven veterans. Byron Buxton and Carlos Correa provide veteran stability, while the pitching staff should be among the league’s best, with a top starting trio of Pablo López, Bailey Ober, and Joe Ryan. There is also a solid group of pitching prospects in the high minors, who can provide depth when injuries arise.
Minnesota’s farm system is also in excellent shape, with several top prospects nearing their MLB debuts. Names like Luke Keaschall, Emmanuel Rodriguez, and Walker Jenkins give the organization a bright future. All three players could make their debuts in 2025 after finishing last season at Double- or Triple-A. The ability to develop and integrate young talent has been a strength for the Twins in recent years, and that trend looks likely to continue.
Lastly, while the uncertainty around new ownership is a concern, a fresh perspective could bring new opportunities. A more aggressive front office willing to spend on top-tier free agents or extend core players could elevate the team to the next level. If the sale goes through in 2025 as expected, it could provide a much-needed spark to reinvigorate the fan base.
The numbers from The Athletic’s fan survey don’t lie, because Twins fans are more skeptical than they’ve been in years. However, optimism can return just as quickly as it disappeared. Winning cures all and a strong start to 2025 could help change the narrative around the team. It’s on the Twins to prove the doubters wrong.
What makes you optimistic about the Twins this season? What are you pessimistic about? Leave a comment and start the discussion.
Follow Twins Daily For Minnesota Twins News & Analysis
- thelanges5, DannySD, Karbo and 2 others
-
5







Recommended Comments
Create an account or sign in to comment
You need to be a member in order to leave a comment
Create an account
Sign up for a new account in our community. It's easy!
Register a new accountSign in
Already have an account? Sign in here.
Sign In Now