Jump to content
Twins Daily
  • Create Account
  • Carlos Correa Doesn’t Deserve Boos at Home


    Melissa Berman

    On Tuesday night under a dark and dramatic sky, as Carlos Correa struck out for the second time in the game, a chorus of angry, frustrated boos rang out at Target Field. 

    Image courtesy of Melissa Berman

    Twins Video

    I was sitting along the third baseline at the game, and the boos caught me off guard. Correa has had an abysmal start to the season; he’s batting .185, and to sum things up, his Baseball Savant page stats are primarily in the blue (poor) range. I thought the boos were coming from the scores of rowdy Padres fans crowding the lower deck, but I quickly realized that they were coming from Twins fans. Later that evening, I saw what stood out to me as one of the saddest sports quotes I have seen in a while.

    “I’d boo myself, too, with the amount of money I’m making, and I’m playing like that,” Correa said after the game. 

    Despite his early season struggles, Correa does not deserve to get booed at home. Is it necessary to be hostile to our players, especially when they are holding themselves accountable? 

    Look, I’m a lifelong Minnesota sports fan. I’ve been at Timberwolves games where the Wolves have been down by 20 or 30 at halftime, and I booed. I was at that putrid 2018 Vikings home loss vs. the at-the-time bottom feeder Bills with the Pioneer Press headline “Boos bombard Vikings in 27-6 loss to Bills at U.S. Bank Stadium,” and I joined in. I’m not trying to take a “Holier than Thou” position.

    And I know someone making $33 million a season doesn’t need my defense; after all, he’s the one who made that Dior store comment. Correa needs to be better, but he knows that. One doesn’t get to where he is in his career without being the fiercest competitor imaginable. Players are frustrated enough when they are struggling; when others are on their case, it makes it even worse. Plus, Correa is far from the only Twins player batting poorly right now.

    Slumps are a part of baseball. They come and go, and everyone goes through them. Fans boo a slumping Correa. What is he supposed to do about it? Try harder? It’s the truth that even when players are paid tons of money, it doesn’t mean they are not allowed to go through slumps. Plus, I wonder how much Correa’s back is still affecting him; he already missed time for it this season, and he was wearing what possibly looked like a heating pad in the dugout Tuesday night.  

    I see a difference between booing the overall team based on a perceived lack of effort and booing a specific individual player who, by all accounts, is doing his best but is struggling. Twins fans might argue that because Correa is a team leader, criticism comes with the territory, and I do not deny that, and when you’re being paid that much, you probably should be subject to some extra scrutiny. Correa also gets his fair share of boos everywhere he goes because he was on the 2018 Astros. I don’t think we need to shed any tears for him. But what amount of money does a player need to be paid for him to be “justifiably” treated poorly?

    And when a fanbase turns against a player, it can get ugly. Those looking for an example need look no further than Joey Gallo’s time on the Yankees. Gallo said that he stopped going out in public in New York because of the ugly treatment he received from Yankees fans.

    “A bunch of [players on other teams reached out to offer support],” Gallo told Randy Miller. “It makes me feel like a piece of s--t, honestly. I remember playing here with the Rangers, watching guys get booed off the field and thinking, ‘Holy s--t! I feel bad for that guy.’ Now it’s me. I do appreciate people reaching out, but it makes me feel like I’m a problem,” Gallo said.

    After being traded to the Yankees in July 2021, Gallo hit .160 in 188 at-bats across 58 games. In 2022, he batted .159 in 233 at-bats over 82 games before being traded to the Dodgers at the trade deadline. Based on Gallo’s comments, suggesting that the hostility of the environment contributed to his extended slump is not outrageous.

    I’m not suggesting this is going to happen in Minnesota. If Correa went to the grocery store, even when he’s slumping, fans would crowd him in adoration and ask for a picture. But when I read Correa’s postgame quote, I couldn’t help but think: “What are we, Yankees fans?” Will booing make you feel better? Will booing motivate Correa more? Based on his full comments, Correa is already blaming no one but himself. He doesn't blame you for booing, but it doesn't mean you have to do it. 

    It’s still early in the season. Correa’s bat will heat up; it always does. He’s a proven star. And according to a piece by Dan Hayes, Carlos Correa’s recent metrics suggest his slump is close to over. 

     Correa will be with the Twins for years; the least fans can do is show him a little grace while he’s working through whatever he is battling.

    MORE FROM TWINS DAILY
    — Latest Twins coverage from our writers
    — Recent Twins discussion in our forums
    — Follow Twins Daily via Twitter, Facebook or email
    — Become a Twins Daily Caretaker

     Share


    User Feedback

    Recommended Comments



    Featured Comments

    Excellent post. 

    Count me as one who simply cannot understand people who find some joy in being mean.

    There is a saying, "Mean people suck." Why pull yourself down to a base level by booing the player who is currently the face of the team or really anyone for a physical error. Melissa writes a far better argument than me, but fans need to consider whether they are contributing to positive entertainment or attempting to make a strong negative statement of disagreement of a player as a member of the game.

    The booing at Yankee Stadium always bothered me. There may be a time for booing but it seems like most every athlete is harder on themselves than is necessary already. The piling on by fans at home does nothing to motivate or make one feel better. The booing and harassment of opposing players is simply a mirror of the character of the voice. I wish people would just enjoy the setting, the company of others, and the displays of expertise within competitions.

    Link to comment
    Share on other sites

    I would never boo a member of my family for a mistake, lack of success or failure.  I really do come to care for these Twins players and I want them to succeed. But they, like we, are human and they, like we, don't always succeed. However they are in a public arena, closely analyzed and viewed "in hindsight" and we are not. That is tough. I know  baseball is not life or death, like some of our military and law enforcement personnel experience, but most of us do not enjoy being criticized in crude, emotional ways. Your article was excellent Melissa. Thank you for writing it. It makes me re-think some of my critical posts here on TD.

    Link to comment
    Share on other sites

    I don't understand the need to vent ones frustration at a particular player. But it's their right. I know the player being booed by his home crowd knows that they're struggling.  I'm the opposite. Cross my fingers, promise to never do wrong ever. Sacrifice chickens. Whatever it takes to break that slump. 

    Link to comment
    Share on other sites

    Give me a break. 

    Twins fans are way too stoic, accommodating and easy-to-please.  Folks are happy to come to the ballpark and “support their team”, regardless of how they happen to play.  

    We are so far removed from being Yankees fans that even to raise that comparison is weak.  We need to have more of that competitive spirit, to actually provide some activity, rather than passively observe an event.  

    Correa has said that boos in Yankee Stadium are like “fuel for the Ferrari”.  If a grown man, marquee player hears the occasional outburst of discontent, I’d see it as evidence he’s playing for an engaged fanbase.  

    2-0, with two solid performances by Correa, since Tuesday night.  Carlito left the Little Leagues a long time ago. 

    Link to comment
    Share on other sites

    “Criticism, like rain, should be gentle enough to nourish a man’s growth without destroying his roots.”  Frank A Clark 

    I’m born and raised in North Dakota in the Norwegian bachelor farmer tradition as I’m sure many of you are familiar with.  I didn’t get a lot of guidance as a child but what I got was very memorable.  Got caught with beer at 16, dad picked me up from the sheriff.  I got left in the jail after getting a dui at 21. Called dad, he said remember what I told you last time?  Yes sir, was just letting you know where I was.  The feedback was delivered sparingly but with great effect.

    My theory is that the Minnesota booing is a lot like that. I wouldn’t expect it to continue but a message was sent. From his comments, he received the message.  He will probably get some additional feedback on not running out of the box. Hoping Buxton was part of delivering it.  Even leaders needs course correction and those two need to hold each other accountable. 

    It’s also the only feedback loop the fans have.  We are well aware that if this contract goes Chris Davis on us it will be potentially devastating to the franchise for years.  There’s a lot riding on it and it is appropriate to remind from time to time.

    Link to comment
    Share on other sites

    Correa doesn't get booed at Target for what he does deserve to like he does everywhere else (except Houston). That should be enough. After he doesn't even run out of the box even during the horrid slump? Wake up Carlos. The fans might find a breaking point, and bring up the past at home, too. 

    Link to comment
    Share on other sites

    I was glad to see the author's comment on his back.

    It would not surprise me to learn that Correa has been playing with this nagging at him. 

    Unfortunately there isn't much depth at SS, so he doesn't get much day to day relief. 

    Link to comment
    Share on other sites

    "Slumps are a part of baseball. They come and go, and everyone goes through them."

    What Carlos is going though isn't a normal slump, that is 10, 20 , maybe 30 at bats, he is at 147. So were people booing him 100 at bats ago? Not that I have heard, have the fans been booing Gordon or Gallo?

    As a fan what other way is there to tell a player we aren't happy with the way you are playing right now? I don't get to tell him I just dropped a half of my week's salary to bring my family to watch the game and you played like garbage and have been playing like garbage. This is what they signed up for when they decided to make a career out of a game that people have to pay to watch. With that said they didn't sign up for or deserve to be ridiculed out side of the playing field.

    Link to comment
    Share on other sites

    4 minutes ago, Squirrel said:

    I don’t boo my own because it changes nothing, imo. Just a waste of my energy. But to show my dislike, I don’t pay for it. Money speaks louder than boos. It’s ownership that needs to hear that.

    You were a huge advocate of signing him, correct?   The money is spent and the contract is guaranteed for the 1st 6 years.  What's the message for ownership?   

    Link to comment
    Share on other sites

    I almost never boo any player. Even a Yankee. I think almost every player tries hard to do the best he can. The only thing that I would consider booing is obvious intentional poor sportsmanship. Now, I realize that includes cheating like the Astros did but for me the statute of limitations on that has expired. I think Correa and most of the players and coaches involved in that now regret their actions, although I wish more of them would say so publicly.

    Link to comment
    Share on other sites

    54 minutes ago, Major League Ready said:

    You were a huge advocate of signing him, correct?   The money is spent and the contract is guaranteed for the 1st 6 years.  What's the message for ownership?   

    I don’t see how that has anything to do with it, really. Just suggesting to others who don’t like what’s going on on the field, don’t spend on it. Booing one player doesn’t solve anything. What does that do? Maybe it’s a motivation for Correa, but I still don’t think it does anything but maybe make the booer feel better. And it might be detrimental to a different player. It still won’t give us an unquestionable BP and offense. Team wins start by what ownership spends on and the FO purchases, imo. Players do know what they have to do, but no team is one individual.  I liked the Correa signings still do and I bought a Correa jersey to show my appreciation of that, something I’ve never done. But I’m hesitant to invest more into games until I see more over all. But I’ll spend more than last season because the pitching is worthy of my money. But … give me a WS contending team and maybe I’ll buy a season package. Money talks. Booing is wasted energy.

    Link to comment
    Share on other sites

    1 hour ago, h2oface said:

    Correa doesn't get booed at Target for what he does deserve to like he does everywhere else (except Houston). That should be enough. After he doesn't even run out of the box even during the horrid slump? Wake up Carlos. The fans might find a breaking point, and bring up the past at home, too. 

    I love joining in booing the opposing team. It is a way to rally around your team with other fans. The Yankees, the Dirty Sox, yeah baby fun times in the stands. Booing your own team? Now you are just that loud mouthed jerky guy in the stands. I'll admit sometimes it kinda funny, but not sure I want to be that guy. 

    Link to comment
    Share on other sites

    17 minutes ago, Squirrel said:

    I don’t see how that has anything to do with it, really. Just suggesting to others who don’t like what’s going on on the field, don’t spend on it. Booing one player doesn’t solve anything. What does that do? Maybe it’s a motivation for Correa, but I still don’t think it does anything but maybe make the booer feel better. it still won’t give us an unquestionable BP and offense. Team wins start by what ownership spends on and the FO purchases, imo. Players do know what they have to do, but no team is one individual.  I liked the Correa signings still do and I bought a Correa jersey to show my appreciation of that, something I’ve never done. But I’m hesitant to invest more into games until I see more over all. But I’ll spend more than last season because the pitching is worthy of my money. But … give me a WS contending team and maybe I’ll buy a season package. Money talks. Booing is wasted energy.

    I don't support booing either.  I was just confused because of your past support.  I thought you were speaking of your dollars and I guess you were coming from the angle others should voice their opinion through their wallets.  Of course, the net of that is we demand the team spends but we won't support the spending if it does not work out as well as we like.  That's just the reality with professional sports teams but we should acknowledge that we demand spending but only spend ourselves if not only that player but the whole teams does well.   That's the way it should be.  I am just saying we might not recognize that we expect their financial commitment while reserving the right to withhold ours if the plan we support even demand does not work out.

    Link to comment
    Share on other sites

    8 minutes ago, Major League Ready said:

    I don't support booing either.  I was just confused because of your past support.  I thought you were speaking of your dollars and I guess you were coming from the angle others should voice their opinion through their wallets.  Of course, the net of that is we demand the team spends but we won't support the spending if it does not work out as well as we like.  That's just the reality with professional sports teams but we should acknowledge that we demand spending but only spend ourselves if not only that player but the whole teams does well.   That's the way it should be.  I am just saying we might not recognize that we expect their financial commitment while reserving the right to withhold ours if the plan we support even demand does not work out.

    Yes and no … I’m willing to spend some based on current product. If that product tanks, they still have the money I already spent. I think they know what they spend on will impact what they get. There is and always will be risk on both sides

    Link to comment
    Share on other sites

    10 hours ago, Boswell said:

     

     

     

    2-0, with two solid performances by Correa, since Tuesday night.  Carlito left the Little Leagues a long time ago. 

    I'm not willing to credit the boos for Carlos Correa having 2 straight solid performances. Rather I would say Carlos is a habitually slow starter and he is steadily rising to his historically average hitting. 

    Link to comment
    Share on other sites

    I don't boo players for on field play, but I don't really cheer for them vocally either. I have no problem with fans booing home team players, though. If they can be cheered, they can be booed. It's also something they're well aware of when they sign their million dollar deals that are partly paid for by "average people" spending way too much to go watch these guys play a game.

    As some have mentioned, fans can "boo" louder with their money by not showing up, but a fan paying to attend a game comes with some "perks," and one of those "perks" is to be able to vocalize their feelings about both teams. Now there are definitely lines that should never be crossed, but I don't think booing is one of those lines. I don't recall any Twins players really asking for cheers or anything, but I know the Twolves have "called out" their fans before, and said they need to be louder. There's an expectation that fans are loud, and help provide the atmosphere that drives peak performance. Well if you want them to cheer, you better be willing to accept some boos.

    It's not fun, and I'm sure it's not easy. The vast majority of players work incredibly hard at their craft. But this is what they signed up for. They chose the entertainment industry. It comes with both good (millions of dollars, and playing a game for a living), and bad (boos).

    Link to comment
    Share on other sites

    I think everyone can agree that Correa is just not hitting as well as everyone expected. It is hard to cheer for a player that is performing poorly. Cheering for him would seem to mean we approve of his low batting average.  I can only hope this will help him play better.  Some fans are concerned that this could be a sign of things to come and are booing the signing of Correa to long term contract.

     

    Link to comment
    Share on other sites

    25 minutes ago, John Belinski said:

    I think everyone can agree that Correa is just not hitting as well as everyone expected. It is hard to cheer for a player that is performing poorly. Cheering for him would seem to mean we approve of his low batting average.  I can only hope this will help him play better.  Some fans are concerned that this could be a sign of things to come and are booing the signing of Correa to long term contract.

     

    Somehow I doubt he’d interpret support as approving of a low batting average.

    Link to comment
    Share on other sites

    Albert Belle had the right attitude about booing when he said, "I've been treated there (Camden Yards in Baltimore) just like everywhere else: you got everyone booing for you. I take that as a compliment."   

    While not a fan of booing, it does demonstrate that the fans care.  As they say the opposite of love is not hate, it is indifference. 

    Link to comment
    Share on other sites

    I don't think it's a big deal, you pay a ton of money to park your car, buy a ticket and eat a hot dog, then joining a boos chorus to show dissatisfaction for the entertainment shouldn't be controversial.  I don't think MN sports fans abuse this.

    Link to comment
    Share on other sites

    2 hours ago, tony&rodney said:

    Excellent post. 

    Count me as one who simply cannot understand people who find some joy in being mean.

    There is a saying, "Mean people suck." Why pull yourself down to a base level by booing the player who is currently the face of the team or really anyone for a physical error. Melissa writes a far better argument than me, but fans need to consider whether they are contributing to positive entertainment or attempting to make a strong negative statement of disagreement of a player as a member of the game.

    The booing at Yankee Stadium always bothered me. There may be a time for booing but it seems like most every athlete is harder on themselves than is necessary already. The piling on by fans at home does nothing to motivate or make one feel better. The booing and harassment of opposing players is simply a mirror of the character of the voice. I wish people would just enjoy the setting, the company of others, and the displays of expertise within competitions.

    Thanks so much for the kind compliment and taking the time to read + let me know your thoughts. Thankfully it seems like Correa is coming out of it- I wrote this a couple days ago now- so hopefully he continues that upward trend! 

    Link to comment
    Share on other sites

    15 hours ago, tarheeltwinsfan said:

    I would never boo a member of my family for a mistake, lack of success or failure.  I really do come to care for these Twins players and I want them to succeed. But they, like we, are human and they, like we, don't always succeed. However they are in a public arena, closely analyzed and viewed "in hindsight" and we are not. That is tough. I know  baseball is not life or death, like some of our military and law enforcement personnel experience, but most of us do not enjoy being criticized in crude, emotional ways. Your article was excellent Melissa. Thank you for writing it. It makes me re-think some of my critical posts here on TD.

    Thank you so much for the kind compliment + thoughtful observations. I really appreciate you taking the time to read + comment. Agree that I and many others care about the players as people outside of baseball- look at the warm reception Kyle Farmer just got with his return. Luckily it looks like Correa is on an upward trend (recent metrics plus clutch hits during Wed and Thursday games, so hopefully that eases the tension! Yesterday was a really great, fun win 

    Link to comment
    Share on other sites

    Of course he deserved boos.

    It is perfectly OK for fans to express their displeasure with his play in a harmless fashion.

    ...As for yelling disparaging personal comments or throwing things... that is of course NOT OK.

    Correa is a big boy, he can handle justified fan frustration... as he indeed told us himself. 

     

    Link to comment
    Share on other sites

    1 hour ago, MileHighTwinsFan said:

    Albert Belle had the right attitude about booing when he said, "I've been treated there (Camden Yards in Baltimore) just like everywhere else: you got everyone booing for you. I take that as a compliment."   

    While not a fan of booing, it does demonstrate that the fans care.  As they say the opposite of love is not hate, it is indifference. 

    I agree- there's nothing worse than indifference, which is something I see in White Sox fans right now, for example 

    Link to comment
    Share on other sites

    3 hours ago, chpettit19 said:

    I don't boo players for on field play, but I don't really cheer for them vocally either. I have no problem with fans booing home team players, though. If they can be cheered, they can be booed. It's also something they're well aware of when they sign their million dollar deals that are partly paid for by "average people" spending way too much to go watch these guys play a game.

    As some have mentioned, fans can "boo" louder with their money by not showing up, but a fan paying to attend a game comes with some "perks," and one of those "perks" is to be able to vocalize their feelings about both teams. Now there are definitely lines that should never be crossed, but I don't think booing is one of those lines. I don't recall any Twins fans really asking for cheers or anything, but I know the Twolves have "called out" their fans before, and said they need to be louder. There's an expectation that fans are loud, and help provide the atmosphere that drives peak performance. Well if you want them to cheer, you better be willing to accept some boos.

    It's not fun, and I'm sure it's not easy. The vast majority of players work incredibly hard at their craft. But this is what they signed up for. They chose the entertainment industry. It comes with both good (millions of dollars, and playing a game for a living), and bad (boos).

    Super good points and a really nice, thoughtful post- I thought your point about the "perks" of attending in person was rally interesting. The boos were much less prevalent on Wed and Thursday because Correa + the rest of the team got some clutch hits, so hopefully that trend continues. 

    Link to comment
    Share on other sites

    5 hours ago, wabene said:

    I love joining in booing the opposing team. It is a way to rally around your team with other fans. The Yankees, the Dirty Sox, yeah baby fun times in the stands. Booing your own team? Now you are just that loud mouthed jerky guy in the stands. I'll admit sometimes it kinda funny, but not sure I want to be that guy. 

    Yeah, I agree. The team looks to us in the stands for support at home. If we won't do it, who will? Are the guys at Yankees stadium gonna be in their corner? Not a chance. Super good points, thanks for reading 

    Link to comment
    Share on other sites




    Create an account or sign in to comment

    You need to be a member in order to leave a comment

    Create an account

    Sign up for a new account in our community. It's easy!

    Register a new account

    Sign in

    Already have an account? Sign in here.

    Sign In Now

×
×
  • Create New...