jmlease1

Good for Travis. Be interesting to see how he does and if he can seize the opportunity the way some other young players have. I think his positional flexibility gives him a good chance to replace Marwin on the roster next year, and while he isn't the defender Marwin is, he could be a more productive bat.

Except it's simply not true regarding HRs. For home runs, the stat still represents fairly what the actions of the hitter were: they hit the ball over the fence. With RBIs it's not the same; arguably the most important information you get from RBIs is that the hitter had a lot of ABs with runners on base. What the context is for home runs isn't as important as the fact that someone actually hit the ball out.

The problem with RBIs is people use them to describe the wrong things. As an expression of a player's ability as a hitter...they're not very indicative. Other stats are far better and are more predictive of future success. RBIs simply don't do that. There's a fair theory that modern baseball is undervaluing contact as a skill, which plays to where the Twins were last night, at least a bit. Right now teams are valuing hitting the ball hard over hitting the ball (launch angle, hard-hit rate, etc) because what they're seeing is that having more players who do those things and get on base at a high rate leads to more big innings and more runs overall. But I think there's an argument that you can be even better off if those sluggers, those three true outcome artists are leavened with guys who get on base via a high batting average as part of a high on base percentage. Having guys with excellent contact skill does help...but having a bunch of guys who slap the ball a lot isn't going to help. you have to pick them carefully. And no matter what you do, sometimes a guy is going to have a bad day. Cruz is having an awesome season at the plate, he's exactly the guy you want up to bat with the bases loaded...and it didn't happen. But I take that matchup every single time. I'm a little concerned about Taylor Rogers. He's been much more hittable this year. But it's also only 16 innings. The k-rate is still excellent, he's not walking guys, his hr rate is right around the career average...so is he in trouble, or is this a fluke with small sample size? I'm a little worried, but it's not panic time.

I hope Blankenhorn gets a shot. His positional flexibility would be helpful with Arraez out since he could fill in at 2B or in one of the corner OF spots as needed (and even drop in at 3B if Donaldson needs a day off). Time to find out if he can hit MLB pitching, but I think his power will play. Not a great outing for Pineda, but he wasn't terrible either. I think he's still going to slot in as the 3rd starter for the Twin in the playoffs, behind Maeda & Berrios. Odd game: at one point the Twins had 4 hits...and all were home runs.

A real shame, he was settling in nicely and had some big hits. There's no question that his power production can play at the MLB level and he had done well in this short stint at controlling the strike zone (better than he had in the minors). I think he'll get an opportunity to compete for a role next season. Too bad it ended so quickly for him, he did a great job taking advantage of his opportunity and gave the team a nice boost.

That's a real shame about Rooker: he was off to a really nice start and was really taking advantage of his opportunity. He's got a serious power bat and if he's able to control the strike zone like this, he's going to be a nice player. Very unlucky. Very much felt like regular baseball to me today: players who have been taking a little heat busted out today, lol. Time for Blankenhorn? Marwin get a multi-hit game with a dinger. Ready to move on from Rosario? He clubs a dinger. I swear, that happens all the time in a normal season. Rich Hill pitched pretty well, but I still have more faith in other starters right now. Cleveland has a bad offense, it's just bad. So while I'm pleased to see the K's and happy he got through 5 innings, he's not looking like a top 3 starter on the staff. I hope the team signs Buxton to a long-term deal in the offseason. Even with the injuries, he's such a dynamic player and the team just works differently with him in the lineup. He's an energizer and he's producing.

If Gordon wasn't recovering from COVID, I'm pretty sure he would be the pick. But his bad luck continues, and we saw how with Sano & Astudillo there's a difference between being cleared to play again and being ready to play again after COVID. I'd give Blankenhorn a look. He's not going to impress defensively, but he can manage at several positions, including 2b, 3b, and corner OF. I think we'll be seeing him get a real chance next year. He's got some pop in his bat and with both Marwin and Adrianza struggling so badly at the plate, it's worth taking a peek at someone else.

I suppose of the question is whether Lindor said something or if someone else did and Romo thought it was Lindor? I found the whole thing a bit funny watching it live; it honestly felt like everyone just wanted to get out and move around on a crappy weather night, but Romo stayed hot in the dugout long enough that it seems hard to believe something didn't happen? It's definitely an issue without fans in the stands: guys are hearing everything anyone says and chirping that never got noticed before sure seems to be coming to the fore.

Maeda's starts are a must watch. So fun to watch him pitch. That trade is working out very nicely for the Twins, regardless of what Graterol does for the Dodgers. I like the fact that they are letting him go deeper into games now as well. I've been really impressed with his control this season but even if he regresses a bit on the walks he's still going to be excellent. Bieber is the obvious pick for the Cy this year, but Maeda deserves some votes and attention.

where is this idea that Eddie Rosario has somehow shown particular loyalty to the Twins? He's still an arbitration-eligible player. He hasn't taken any discounts, he hasn't passed up on anything to keep playing for the Twins. I'm amazed at your certainty that we will not be able to sign Buxton or Berrios, but if we aren't able to make it happen it won't be because of declining to offer another year of arbitration to Eddie Rosario. (Considering Buxton's injury history, we may have a better chance than ever to sign Buxton to a long-term deal that buys out 1-2 years of free agency) I was happy to keep Rosario for this season, because I wasn't sure the internal options were ready and the realistic FA options weren't significant upgrades in my mind. Plus, there was hope that recovery from the nagging injuries might improve Eddie's defense. But the reality is, the defense hasn't improved: his range and glove are not good. The arm is still excellent, but there are fewer opportunity to influence a game with your arm from LF than your glove. His bat is still fine, especially in this COVID season where hitting is down all over the place...but it's hardly elite. So when it comes to making the call next year you've got an increasingly expensive player with declining defensive skills that is not improving at the plate a track record of terrible base-running who plays one of the most replaceable positions in baseball. It's not about hating Rosario. It's about paycheck vs production. The more a player makes, the less you can ignore their flaws. The more a player makes, the fewer flaws you can accept. And as exciting as Eddie Rosario is, and as many big splash plays as he might make...he also has a lot of botches. I'm not going to pretend that Rooker or Kirilloff or Larnach is going to be able to replace Rosario's production right now (Rooker is doing better at the plate, but it's a very small sample); they might, but it's a much riskier bet. We know what we're going to get from Eddie, and it's not worth a 10-15% increase against a potential 50% decline in production when it's also not going to save you any money either. Roll with Eddie this season. Probably move along next year with thanks for his service. (The $13M he's made should help make him feel ok about his time here too)

I don't see Rosario as being part of the future, but other than making the people pulling their hair out over his baserunning mistakes, not really sure what we accomplish by trying to phase him out now, considering the injury status we have and this goofy short season. Rooker, Wade, and Cave are all contributing, but none of them are setting the world on fire. (Rooker is the only one out-hitting Rosario, and it's too small a sample to rely on yet and his defense is also...poor. Cave & Wade are better defensively than Rosario (better range, poorer arm) but neither is hitting well.) So there's no one that clearly deserves to take Rosario's place when Kepler gets back. Next season? I've always thought he was gone. The hitting has declined this year, the defense is just as bad as last year and he's going to get more expensive because MLB arbitration rewards experience over production. He's a great guy, been fun to watch, and is clearly MLB-calibre, but he's now at that point where his salary probably outstrips his skills. Cron is a fair comp in a lot of ways. TB made the decision previously on him that a) he wasn't worth the $5M he was gonna get, and they could replace his production with a younger, cheaper player. They weren't entirely wrong. Cron was a below average starter last year...is that worth $5M? maybe? Were they able to replace his production? Sure did. Choi was slightly better and made just under $1M. (I'm using bWAR btw) I think the run is over for the Twins for Eddie, because they're not going to want to pay him $8M+ next year for a guy that's going to project as a 2 bWAR player when they have a bunch of top hitting talent in the wings. There's no point to moving on now, but when the season ends, the Twins will reasonably move on.

I feel the most for Odorizzi, because he was looking at a very big payday if he could have turned in another good season and now he's kinda hanging out there. The injuries wouldn't impact his free agency nearly as hard in a normal year where things are spaced out a little more. But between the injuries, the ineffectiveness to date (he can't even do a normal rehab where he could go down and do a couple of minor league starts to get back in the groove before returning to the MLB roster) and the overall financial situation...hard to see him getting the 4-5 big money offer he was hoping for. Does he bet on himself for another year and try to make a run on a 1 year deal? He's not young any longer either. May is going to be hurt by this too, which probably works to the Twins advantage. I think they'll want to bring him back; yes, he's given up more hits this year to date, but how much of that is just SSS? The stuff plays and he's also getting tons of Ks without handing out free passes willy-nilly. But instead of getting a 3 or possibly 4 year deal, he's looking more likely at 2 years and for less money. I don't think anyone is going to hand him a closer job, and it's unlikely he'll get an offer for more than 3/4M AAV. I don't think Adrianza is significantly impacted. He is who he is, a solid utility guy. He might lose a little because the overall financial market will be down, but he was never likely to get an offer like he was a starter. I like him, he's been a useful player on the team, but he's not a player you're going to give a long-term deal to or commit a substantial amount of money to. But he'll still have a job, I think, even if it's not with the Twins. And that's always the way it is with a utility guy who just isn't good enough to take a starting job away from someone else.

what was so frustrating about this game was the Twins finally had a "crooked number" inning early in the game and had a nice lead. The offense had been struggling so much, even in the recent wins we weren't generating a lot of runs, so you see them start stringing together some hits and you start thinking "here we go!" and then everyone in the bullpen has a bad game at the same time. well, I guess that's baseball. Rosario had some kind of a game. A couple of significant mental errors. Nearly had two great defensive plays...and ended up with nothing. Big dinger. Can't say it was a great overall day for him, but he's a guy who makes things happen. You can have one of those guys on a team, but I wouldn't want two or three. Astudillo is a utility player. He's useful to have on a roster, especially with the bigger rosters because you can plus him into a lot of spots. But he's not a particularly good defender at any position, including catcher. As a 3rd catcher who can play a bunch of other spots and bench bat who is really good at making contact...he's a useful role player. I think he's exposed as a regular, and we saw that today. He looked pretty bad letting a pitch go to the backstop, and leaving the ball behind on the great throw hurt (even if the Tigers runner very likely didn't actually touch the plate and was probably out). He's just not a skilled defender back there. Jeffers/Avila/Garver all probably make that play. despite scoring 8 runs, the Twins left 22 runners on base. That's still not a winning formula even with the bullpen blowup. I'm still worried about Hill and his struggles with his control. Yes, he got into a groove eventually, but seeing him miss badly on so many first inning pitches...not sure he's going to be a starting option.

I like Rooker, feels like he could be an Adam Dunn kind of player: big power, lots of Ks, plenty of walks. But Rooker should be a better defensive player, and if he can be average-ish in the corners/1B and live in to his power potential, he's going to be a very nice player and a real asset. Finding playing time might be a bit of a problem for him, but as a RH bat there should be ABs available for him in the corners. Very solid start for the big guy. Love seeing him make that hard contact.

The reality is that relievers are among the fungible position in MLB, despite the increased importance of the bullpen in the age of 5-inning starters. There just aren't very many guys who are worth dropping large contracts on for things like a "proven closer". It's increasingly clear that you can do more and more with converting failed starters into quality relievers because often those starters have a plus pitch and have been trying to get by with 2-3 others that are average at best. As a reliever you can get away with throwing 60-70% 1 pitch; as a starter there aren't a lot of guys who can do that. It's tough as a starter to survive with only 2 pitches; as a reliever you're just fine throwing basically 2 pitches. The Twins are leaning into this concept and it's working for them. Grab guys with an elite pitch, ramp up that usage, and figure out which of their other pitches is the best off-set to that pitch and make that the secondary. They're going back to the idea of bullpens that respond to situations and lineups, rather than giving guys roles defined by innings and saves. It's smart and lets you have a stronger and more effective bullpen, while also keeping you from paying a premium for a role rather than a talent. If the Twins pay May or Rogers serious money it's going to be because they see them as guys who are firemen who can shut down the best parts of a lineup, not because they need them to pitch the 9th. They're going to give money to relievers who can be counted on to pitch a second inning at times. That's a better use of money than tossing cash at a guy to pitch the 9th in a "save" situation. Pay for talent, not a pre-determined role...which will also be better for the players too. More relievers will get paid if they're not just competing to be a "closer".

Congrats to Bert. I think it's probably time? He's seemed less and less interested in doing the games in recent years, which was a shame. Because when Bert was into it, he was flat-out outstanding, especially when talking about the art & science of pitching. I recall games where he would predict every pitch in a sequence and tell you why they were throwing it. he could spot flaws in a pitcher's mechanics and tell you what it meant and why. He really knows the game and it was fun to listen to him talk about it. At the same time, he knew how to have fun in the booth, which was really important with some of the truly awful teams. Sure, some of the bits got a little old/hokey (California math, pitchers being the best athletes on the team, etc) at times, but the dude did a lot of games and there were a lot of them in front of bad teams. I spent a lot of time with Dick 'n' Bert over the years, and I will miss having the man with the curveball that woke hitters up in the middle of the night in a cold sweat calling games. Happy retirement, to Bert "Be Home" Blyleven! And fortunately for the Twins, they have some fine in-house options to swing in after: Morneau (who could use a little more animation, but it otherwise excellent) or Hawkins (who reaches a little too hard at times for the comedy, but does a nice job dissecting the game, and has a very good voice. I know he works hard, but he sounds relaxed and comfortable. that's a skill.) are my top choices. Smalley is ok. Morris is a crank.

The team is in a huge funk right now. During a normal season, I'd be less concerned; these things happen during a long season and guys play their way out of it. The combo of injuries and slumps are really hammering the club right now and the losing is bleeding all over them. And unfortunately, there's almost not time to just "get through" something like this. I felt good in the early innings because sometimes the best slump-buster is the other team kicking the ball around the field...and then the Twins just fell apart. Again. This is still a good team, overall. But not right now. They're playing like they're a bad team.

It's very strange to see a team we were so confident in their offense and unsure about the pitching and defense going into the year to see the offense struggling so hard. Getting Donaldson back would certainly help; even if his his timing isn't there immediately, he's going to take good ABs and with him and Cruz together it'll cascade in the lineup.

The only problem with a catching duo of Garver & Jeffers is they both bat RH. It's one of the reasons why signing Avila was a really smart decision, being able to take advantage of a platoon split while resting your primary catcher. It's paid off fairly well: Avila might not be getting a lot of hits, but he's getting on base plenty. But Jeffers is a rising guy and it doesn't look like he's in over his head, even if he got called up earlier than planned. Man, I remember when I was super worried about catching for this franchise. Felt like there wasn't just a lack of options in MLB but no one coming along in the minors, and in three years we've got one of the best catching situations, franchise-wise in baseball. (I still think Rortvedt will make the majors, and as LH hitter could end up being a nice platoon partner in a few years)

I'm not going to give Taylor Rogers any grief about giving up a single to Lindor. That dude is fantastic and I really hope Cleveland is dumb enough to trade him. Watching him battle Maeda for a walk was a fantastic battle of a really smart pitcher against a really smart hitter and it was fun to watch even if the enemy drew the walk...because he freakin' earned it. How he managed to hold off on some of those splitters is just the sign of a great hitter. Lindor is a great, great player. Maeda continues to just pitch. Not many hitters ever look comfortable against him, and he's just fun to watch. Interesting decision on pulling him after the 5th; I think it was the right decision (and it panned out fine) but I guess I would have minded seeing him take another inning. I guess Rocco & Co didn't want to stress him the first start after throwing 115 pitches against a good team in a game you really want to win. I do think he can go 6, though and he should be allowed to throw more than 90 pitches. Sano keeps on mashing, and with all the injuries and struggles going on...we need it.

I love the clip on Sano's HR. He hits it and the announcer just says "uh-oh." LOL Sano is always going to have a ton of Ks, but as long as he's able to keep hitting the ball hard when he does make contact, be selective in what he swings at, and make enough contact, he'll be fine. You can live with the Ks when he has an OBP 100 pts higher than his BA. You can live with the Ks when he has a SLG well over .500 (currently sitting at .542) It's frustrating when he's got multiple runners on base and flails at a slider for strike three, but the trade-off is worth it. I think the other thing is, it's fine to have guys with Sano's approach in your lineup when they get these results, but it gets more problematic if everybody has that style and approach. And that's not what the Twins have: they have guys like Polanco and Arraez who do put the bat on the ball much more often as part of the mix, so it's not all boom or bust, K/HR/BB all the time. The mix helps.

Dobnak has been fantastic for the Twins this year and they've really needed him with their starting depth being tested. Sure hope Berrios' last start was indicative of where he really is right now so they can get a 3rd starter they can count on: Dobnak & Maeda have been the stalwarts. I've really grown to hate seeing Whit freakin' Merrifield at the plate. It just always seems like he's launching another hit. Would be perfectly happy for him to get a day off on Sunday. Interesting to see Cave getting more run in CF this year. Rocco must be more comfortable with him filling in there to leave Kepler in RF; nice advantage for us if Cave can hold up in CF defensively (and frankly great for Cave's career too; he's got a lot more value if he can legitimately play all 3 positions in the OF)

Congrats to Jeffers, who looks to have a bright future. He's doesn't a great job in working on his defense while showing a nice bat at a position where a lot of teams don't generate much offense, so it was nice to see him immediately grab a couple of hits. I'll admit I was surprised Astudillo wasn't the pick, but maybe the Twins learned a lesson from Sano's comeback from COVID and are going to give him a much longer recovery and ramp up time before dropping him back in MLB. Great start by Berrios. Hopefully this starts a roll for him. His stuff has been good all year, it's been his command that's been messed up. I think there's a good chance this was just what he needed to get locked in and start dominating.

a very small part of me wanted 1 more run from KC last night so the final score could have been 4-2...again. I mean, an entire 4 game series being 4-2 is some wackiness you can only get in baseball. But I'll take the win and smile. Rosario's assist was fantastic. Just perfectly played off the wall and a wonderful throw. Merrifield sure wasn't expecting that! Wisler has been better than I expected. Makes it easier to trust in the FO that they really do know how to scout pitching and know what they're doing. It looked like a low-leverage move, and instead it's turned into an excellent value-added play.

Dobnak has been great so far, but the 2 hrs make me a little nervous; he absolutely has to avoid those mistakes because elevating that sinker is going to get crushed much more often than not. This was the sort of regression I think was always a little likely. The trick will be keeping it from being too commonplace. I think he can do it, though. I don't favor additional playing time for Avila: you don't want to expose him and turn a strength (excellent production from your backup catcher) into a weakness. Let Avila do his thing, keep both catchers rested and healthy, and have patience that Garver will work himself out of his early slump. I hope the defensive improvement is real and consistent throughout the season. Marwin's always been a fine defensive player, so plugging him at 3B often isn't going to hurt, but it's Arraez that really seems to have shown serious improvement which is a real plus since he's going to be the guy at 2B for a while.