Suppose Arraez were not in the picture.
If the Marlins still had Pablo Lopez, and decided to wave the white flag this early in the season, and traded him to the Padres for these four players, a pitcher who looks to be not very consequential and three bats who are outside the top-100 across MLB but are highly enough regarded to be around top-10 in either the Padres or Marlins organizations, would this be seen as a good trade for Miami? Usually I want more young pitching than this in return for an established starter, but the Marlins are perennially short on bats, so all in all it looks like a reasonable return.
If so, then this recent trade doesn't change my view of last year's MIN-MIA trade, namely a good move by MIN but a win-win for the two teams.