"Line them up and choose for yourself. " TD poster tony&rodney posed this thought in the discussion on Austin Martin (concerning who else on the roster is a worse defensive outfielder). I have thoughts on that - don't we all? I doubt we'll reach full and complete consensus, but maybe some useful insights will develop.
Being the kind who likes to break down questions, I thought of 5 general attributes I want in a center fielder. It helps to define your terms, especially when each term is fuzzy at best.
Range. Not quite equivalent to foot-speed in all aspects of the game but close. Getting a quick start overlaps with routes.
Routes. Often range and routes are lumped together, because a lousy route reduces the range. I still feel like it's something that can be split into parts.
Arm. Unlike the above two, I lump together arm strength and arm accuracy, because, although arms are important in CF, they're still secondary to other skills.
At the Wall. Maybe there's a better term, but by this I mean long, difficult flies. Who do I trust to gather it in? Range is great, but you have to close the deal.
Judgment. Some of that overlaps with At the Wall, but I also mean knowing when to dive and when to play safe. Texas leaguers. Also, general game smarts. Throwing to the wrong base goes here, not under "arm."
I use a 1-5 rating scale, 5 high. Conceptually '3' is major league average. However, that would be for a corner outfielder, as 3's across the board might be someone's average left fielder, while the grading curve is steeper for center field, and all 3's would likely be a defensive liability. For whatever that's worth. Just to set a common frame of discussion.
I list the 8 outfielders, not just CF, who have played this season. (They're pretty much played everywhere - 4 in CF, 5 in RF, 6 in LF.) I also include Michael A Taylor, because I really enjoyed his defense last season, and between him and Byron Buxton they set the recent gold standard for Twins CF play that others need to aspire to
I'm sure there will be dissent. What do you see as the worst over-ratings or under-ratings, in the table below?
I'll confess that Martin's my whipping-boy, and I hate his arm, and his judgment coming in, and his technique on difficult long flies.
I also give Margot maybe more credit than he deserves, or has shown me, because he did have this reputation for quality. Maybe he lost it all.
The bottom line, for me, is that the discussion about CF backup behind Buxton is complex only because all the options are lousy.
You don't actually need these numbers or this breakdown to come to that conclusion. But I am me, and always will be. 😀
Buxton MAT Kepler Willi Martin Margot Kirill Larn Wallner
5 5 4 3 4 3 2 1 1 Range
5 5 5 3 2 3 2 2 2 Routes
4 4 4 2 1 2 3 2 4 Arm
4 5 5 3 1 3 2 2 2 At the Wall
5 4 5 3 2 2 2 2 2 Judgment