Trading for a Young Starter: Sandy Alcantara

Good article about the kind of player the Twins need to deal for. Young player with potential.

Let’s be realistic. He is worth mid prospects at best. Not top 10 players in one of the deepest farm systems in the majors

 

Yeah let’s trade all of our studs for a below average player and give away all of our MLB studs for nothing. This site is a joke and working against the best interest of the Twins and Twins fans

I love this site.  The writers have differing views on most subjects.  Don't go away mad........

 

Let’s be realistic. He is worth mid prospects at best. Not top 10 players in one of the deepest farm systems in the majors

No, Alcantrata is genuine. Young and talented. The FO needs to wisely move some of our prospects. There isn't room at the ML level for all of them. 

Edited November 16, 2019 by sweetmusicviola16

 

Sure but let’s at least get a fair price for our deep system. Give them mid range guys who would be top guys in their organization. No need to overpay just because an Td admin did an article. Guy is very average. We have a lot of them in our system. I wouldn’t mind him but no need to pay the farm for a guy that projects as a #4 starter

The Twins are free to pay whatever they would want, I was just making a loose estimation. I'm pretty sure Falvey and Lavine won't be calling me for advice anytime soon, so I think you're safe! For what it's worth I'm also not TD Admin, just a contributor. But yeah, I'm not at all an expert on trade costs and am generally protective of prospects, but I do think a young starter like Alcantara would be a wise investment.

It is interesting that both Gallen and Alcantara were both in the Cardinal system. If either were going to be front of rotation pitchers, the Cards would not have traded both for Ozuna.. They may have traded the prospects at peak value. History has shown the Cardinals to be a much better judge of pitching talent than most. 

There are  people who think that not getting a back of the rotation starter when they come available is a bad thing. It does promote discussion

 

The Twins are free to pay whatever they would want, I was just making a loose estimation. I'm pretty sure Falvey and Lavine won't be calling me for advice anytime soon, so I think you're safe! For what it's worth I'm also not TD Admin, just a contributor. But yeah, I'm not at all an expert on trade costs and am generally protective of prospects, but I do think a young starter like Alcantara would be a wise investment.

for a back end starter Javier or Servino or Celestino and a couple of prospects out of Elizabethton or the GCL would be a better loose framework.   Alcantar would have to improve a lot to be league average in K%

 

for a back end starter Javier or Servino or Celestino and a couple of prospects out of Elizabethton or the GCL would be a better loose framework.   Alcantar would have to improve a lot to be league average in K%

Javier is actually who I chose to headline the trade I am proposing for Alcantara in my Offseason blueprint - it will be up on Tuesday.

Interesting article. Can the Marlins really be so down on their chances that they will trade away most of their good pitching.If that is true, I wonder what Captain Jeter is smoking.

 

Javier is actually who I chose to headline the trade I am proposing for Alcantara in my Offseason blueprint - it will be up on Tuesday.

Yes to this. A deal somewhere along the lines of Javier and Cellestino. 

 

I get that we don't want to give up the Kiriloff's and Larnach's for a Alcantara. But just once it'd be nice to get back a talented potential like this instead of just ending up releasing our prospects after they fizzle. Think Gonsalves. Alcantara has the physical talent to be really good. Whether he has the mental makeup is the question.

This trade intrigued me.

 

I think it is going to take Balazovic to headline the deal. I don’t know how reliable the trade simulator is at Baseball Trade Vaues but it took a package of Balazovic, Rooker and Severino to get the deal done.

 

It could be that the Marlins value Javier much higher than Baseball Trade Values.

This trade intrigued me.

 

I think it is going to take Balazovic to headline the deal. I don’t know how reliable the trade simulator is at Baseball Trade Vaues but it took a package of Balazovic, Rooker and Severino to get the deal done.

 

It could be that the Marlins value Javier much higher than Baseball Trade Values.

I wouldn’t trade Balazovic for him straight up

Let’s be realistic here. Just because he’s young doesn’t mean he is going to project that well and he is having a lot of the same issues striking people out. I would say he is more of a regression candidate than a breakout candidate. Sandy’s ceiling is a #3 or #4 starter but more than likely will be sent to the bullpen. That’s worth prospects but certainly not worth anyone in the top 10 or even 20 for that matter given how deep and talented the Twins minors is

The Twins will have to make some deals this year. It can't be done through FA alone.

 

Although, I wonder if the Marlins are sellers?

 

They have been rumored to be considering Castellanos and Ozuna. They have young talent on the mound and if they are considering adding some higher end bats. That doesn't sound like a team looking to move Alcantara.

 

If the Marlins fail to sign either (which is likely), there’s atleast a possibility of them going down this route and I think the Twins are right team for them to pair up with given all the quality depth that’s present in the upper levels of our minor league system.

 

Like they’ve shown with the Gallen/Chisholm and Richards/Sanchez trades, it’s clear that they’re not afraid of giving up young ML talent (like Alcantara) if they believe it’s in the best interests of their future plans.

 

While I’m sure he wouldn’t be the centerpiece (either Larnach or Duran), I could see Miami having a lot of interest in Gordon. And since they’re in search of competent bats, Cave and Rooker could be targets as well.

I have a great deal of confidence Falvey will get this offseason right. I like the type of thinking this post represents. Whether Alcantara is the guy or not, I do believe we'll see a mixture of moves, both signings and trades. I think we'll be bold. 

Good god man. Just because someone is young and in the leauge does not make them good.

His peripherals are bad and he would be a JAG on the AAAA shuttle for the twins.

Good god man. Just because someone is young and in the leauge does not make them good.

His peripherals are bad and he would be a JAG on the AAAA shuttle for the twins.

This is correct. Could see him develop as a bullpen guy in the future. But not someone you give top 20 prospects for

If he'd make the team I'm all for it. Based on the original post, I'm not sold he's an improvement or has that high of a ceiling.

 

That said, the arguments I'm reading here that say "trade our prospects for a prospect...because we have too many prospects..." has me scratching my head.

 

 

Just being honest, I know nothing about the Marlins. I just don't pay attention to them. So I know pretty much nothing about Alcantara either. But this is the kind of thinking they should be employing. While peripherals may be poor, he showed improvement, is young, controllable and high velocity is always good. Im betting Johnson would love to work with all of that. But there remains real questions here. I'm thinking 1 top 10 guy and 1 in the second 10 and maybe a toss in. Fair? Too high?

Sounds about right to me. Javier and Cellestino or maybe Alcala.

 

We have a strong farm. But we also have a team that is close to WS competitive. We have a young team. I'd just like to see us not waste the strength of the farm by allowing them to be mired in the minors. Now is the time to utilize to add some of the pieces on the ML level that we need. I see what you are describing in Alcantrara and if you get him w/o giving up major pieces then why not? If not him then who?

It is interesting that both Gallen and Alcantara were both in the Cardinal system. If either were going to be front of rotation pitchers, the Cards would not have traded both for Ozuna.. They may have traded the prospects at peak value. History has shown the Cardinals to be a much better judge of pitching talent than most.

There are people who think that not getting a back of the rotation starter when they come available is a bad thing. It does promote discussion

Zach Gallen was not yet I don't think a top prospect when traded. He probably would have stayed in the minors last season. Same with Alcantra. Hope the Cards didn't make a mistake since they expected more from Ozuna.

Anything is possible. Your post is just as legit as mine. 

 

I was shocked to see Syndergaard on the trading block followed by an acquisition of Stroman by the Mets. Things like that demonstrate that the road to be traveled is not always clear and defined. 

 

If I was the GM of the Marlins, I wouldn't be trying to acquire expensive FA bats yet (like is being rumored) but I'm not sure that I would give up young pitching yet either because those young pitchers should have helium to inflate to higher value or at least still be in place when it is time to acquire expensive FA bats. 

 

In other words... If I was to part with one of my young pitchers... the return would have to be high enough to be worth the possible deviation in the plan.

 

A package of Gordon, Duran, and Rooker sounds like a decent starting point. Marlins get a younger replacement for Alcantara, that probably fits better with their timeline of contention, and two potential everyday players for the right side of their infield. Probably could add a lottery ticket like Sands to the deal, but maybe they’d want more certainty in a young bullpen arm like Littell.

I think the point of the article is that the Twins should be looking for young arms on the come. If we cleared out a half dozen mid level prospects plus a Cave or Gordon, it doesn't hurt us because we have a surplus in the OF and IF 

 

This is exactly what I think Falvey will do. 

 

Remember, his trade for Odoorizzi now looks like the work of a genius

 

 

IMHO

One more from baseball trade values...

 

Larnach straight up for Alcantara.

 

With Kirilloff and Larnach this might be the winter to trade one of those corner pieces for a controllable starting pitcher. Kirilloff would bring a better pitcher if one is available.