I like your thought process on the value of calling a game. I don’t have much to add, except the pace of the game is a contributing factor too. That might be an indication of trust/alignment on the game plan between pitcher and catcher. Communication additional to the hand signals seems like a very important skill that I don’t have any statistical data to back up, but my observation of pitchers who work fast and control the game tend to have batters that call a lot of timeouts.
I think framing is an important stat until automated zones get deployed. There are 140+ pitches thrown in the average ballgame and meatballs down the middle get hammered, so a catcher’s receiving skills can impact 100+ outcomes per game (positive or negative). That is realistically 3-4 outs per game, maybe more.
all the talk about how good or bad a catcher’s arm is, in 2021 there were 2214 bases stolen in 2430 games or .911 per game. 1980 there were 3294 stolen.
season to date Jeffers has had 24 stolen bases against in 39 games .62 per game. He’s 30% better than league average.
yes, his bat lacks at 74 wRC+. Hopefully the leading indicators are accurate and the best is yet to come.
He’s still a very good defensive catcher where it counts.