Jump to content
Twins Daily
  • Create Account

Recommended Posts

Old-Timey Member
Posted

I mean i get it.  Spring hope is eternal.  Don't get me wrong, I always want the Twins to do well, win the division and get to the big game.  To me that is the hope every season.  But I'm reading articles about Royce Lewis being done, Ryan Jeffers, trading Ryan and all of the arguments are legit from one side or the other.  

However, now I'm looking at the Twins competition within their division and I'm thinking the Twins maybe should go for a reset??  If you look at Cleveland, Chicago and Detroit; the Twins main competition next season and those teams are all younger as a team than the Twins.  So always hoping for a young core to take another step forward and improve some more on last season and then bang next thing you know they are contenders.  But the teams most likely to improve on their numbers from last season because of their youth and gaining more experience is Cleveland, Chicago and Detroit as they are all younger than the Twins.  So now for the Twins to out perform those squads they would need to sign some big free agents, one for the rotation one for the bullpen and probably a couple of big hitters that can play 1st base or somewhere that's important.  But we know the Twins are not going to go that route.  So at that point, why not just trade some of these older young guys and get some new young talent in??  I know its not a popular idea, but the Twins are older than the teams they will probably finish behind.

Posted
40 minutes ago, Twodogs said:

I mean i get it.  Spring hope is eternal.  Don't get me wrong, I always want the Twins to do well, win the division and get to the big game.  To me that is the hope every season.  But I'm reading articles about Royce Lewis being done, Ryan Jeffers, trading Ryan and all of the arguments are legit from one side or the other.  

However, now I'm looking at the Twins competition within their division and I'm thinking the Twins maybe should go for a reset??  If you look at Cleveland, Chicago and Detroit; the Twins main competition next season and those teams are all younger as a team than the Twins.  So always hoping for a young core to take another step forward and improve some more on last season and then bang next thing you know they are contenders.  But the teams most likely to improve on their numbers from last season because of their youth and gaining more experience is Cleveland, Chicago and Detroit as they are all younger than the Twins.  So now for the Twins to out perform those squads they would need to sign some big free agents, one for the rotation one for the bullpen and probably a couple of big hitters that can play 1st base or somewhere that's important.  But we know the Twins are not going to go that route.  So at that point, why not just trade some of these older young guys and get some new young talent in??  I know its not a popular idea, but the Twins are older than the teams they will probably finish behind.

I think you answered your own question.

The Twins do have some talent on short term/1 year deals in the rotation that they absolutely should be open to trade to add/supplement the young core that they most likely are planning on building around.

I mean, if the Twins already in the lineup are going to plan around Culpepper and Jenkins and Rodriguez and Lee and Keaschall taking the reins, are you counting those among those you want to do a reset with? Or ride with? And with that, Marek Houston and Vahn Lackey both theorhetically should be ready at some point in the next 12-18 months as well. Those are all good things, and there MIGHT be others too.

 

So yeah, I think riding with these guys being lead along with bringing in some outside help, especially in the bullpen, that SHOULD be the expectation no?

Posted

When the Twins made the decision to trade Duran, Jax, and Varland, it signaled a rebuild. However, even as those guys were being shipped out there was a turn, regret or whatever because the Twins did not close on a deal with the Red Sox. July of 2025 was followed up by holding all of Wallner, Larnach, Ober, Ryan, Lewis, and Jeffers. One can never know, but it sure looked like there was great potential in a rebuild.

Now the Twins are stuck on the refrain of contending even as they are missing critical pieces needed to rise to a .500 record. Because the Twins were within view of a playoff wild card spot, despite being below .500, the front office feels they did their job by providing "meaningful" September baseball. The only clear path to contention is a $160M roster, which would be surprising and perhaps also difficult to complete if certain players choose to go elsewhere.

The Twins do have some hope for the prospects and their unproven players. How the front office and ownership responds in the next two weeks will be telling.

Posted
On 11/11/2026 at 6:18 PM, Twodogs said:

I mean i get it.  Spring hope is eternal.  Don't get me wrong, I always want the Twins to do well, win the division and get to the big game.  To me that is the hope every season.  But I'm reading articles about Royce Lewis being done, Ryan Jeffers, trading Ryan and all of the arguments are legit from one side or the other.  

However, now I'm looking at the Twins competition within their division and I'm thinking the Twins maybe should go for a reset??  If you look at Cleveland, Chicago and Detroit; the Twins main competition next season and those teams are all younger as a team than the Twins.  So always hoping for a young core to take another step forward and improve some more on last season and then bang next thing you know they are contenders.  But the teams most likely to improve on their numbers from last season because of their youth and gaining more experience is Cleveland, Chicago and Detroit as they are all younger than the Twins.  So now for the Twins to out perform those squads they would need to sign some big free agents, one for the rotation one for the bullpen and probably a couple of big hitters that can play 1st base or somewhere that's important.  But we know the Twins are not going to go that route.  So at that point, why not just trade some of these older young guys and get some new young talent in??  I know its not a popular idea, but the Twins are older than the teams they will probably finish behind.

New young guys have not been a plus for the Twins for some time.

Better to get some truly GOOD veterans to assist the Culpepper, Jenkins, etc. as they find out how tough the Big League can be.

IF the rookies are as good as hoped, time will fill in gaps as the season/s, go bye.

Posted
On 11/11/2026 at 6:18 PM, Twodogs said:

I mean i get it.  Spring hope is eternal.  Don't get me wrong, I always want the Twins to do well, win the division and get to the big game.  To me that is the hope every season.  But I'm reading articles about Royce Lewis being done, Ryan Jeffers, trading Ryan and all of the arguments are legit from one side or the other.  

However, now I'm looking at the Twins competition within their division and I'm thinking the Twins maybe should go for a reset??  If you look at Cleveland, Chicago and Detroit; the Twins main competition next season and those teams are all younger as a team than the Twins.  So always hoping for a young core to take another step forward and improve some more on last season and then bang next thing you know they are contenders.  But the teams most likely to improve on their numbers from last season because of their youth and gaining more experience is Cleveland, Chicago and Detroit as they are all younger than the Twins.  So now for the Twins to out perform those squads they would need to sign some big free agents, one for the rotation one for the bullpen and probably a couple of big hitters that can play 1st base or somewhere that's important.  But we know the Twins are not going to go that route.  So at that point, why not just trade some of these older young guys and get some new young talent in??  I know its not a popular idea, but the Twins are older than the teams they will probably finish behind.

The primary benefit of a reset is trading off a couple players of value to help build a future team.  It's basically the flip-side of trading prospects to find the last piece or two for a contender.  The White Sox are one example.  Much of their starting position players came from trading Kopek and Crochett.    Not only did the Twins have valuable assets to trade but they had a lot of talent that was ready or nearly ready. 

They did not lose any of the young talent.  They lost an opportunity to give them more playing time at the MLB level.  More importantly, they lost the boost that could have / should have come from moving Joe Ryan / Ryan Jeffers / Pablo Lopez and perhaps even Buxton.  The Twins missed their opportunity.  It no longer makes sense to "reset" because they don't have older players taking up playing time although the case could be made with some SPs.   It also does not make sense because they don't have any value to trade now to help build the future.     

Posted
2 hours ago, Major League Ready said:

The primary benefit of a reset is trading off a couple players of value to help build a future team.  It's basically the flip-side of trading prospects to find the last piece or two for a contender.  The White Sox are one example.  Much of their starting position players came from trading Kopek and Crochett.    Not only did the Twins have valuable assets to trade but they had a lot of talent that was ready or nearly ready. 

They did not lose any of the young talent.  They lost an opportunity to give them more playing time at the MLB level.  More importantly, they lost the boost that could have / should have come from moving Joe Ryan / Ryan Jeffers / Pablo Lopez and perhaps even Buxton.  The Twins missed their opportunity.  It no longer makes sense to "reset" because they don't have older players taking up playing time although the case could be made with some SPs.   It also does not make sense because they don't have any value to trade now to help build the future.     

I wasn't even suggesting a full teardown. Ryan Jeffers was a pretty straightforward situation. He was entering the final year of his contract, and the Twins had an opportunity to turn him into a decent young player with six years of control. That's pure asset management. Letting that opportunity pass was value lost.

The bigger mistake, in my opinion, was Joe Ryan. He had enormous trade value last offseason and I'm a huge Joe Ryan fan. But sometimes you have to separate how much you like a player from what that player represents as an organizational asset.

And here's where I think the Twins really missed an opportunity.

I look at Ryan's trade value last offseason and think it was the equivalent of adding another Walker Jenkins-type prospect to the organization. Maybe even two players with the potential of a Culpepper. That's an awful lot of young talent to leave on the table. And it's not just about acquiring prospects. It's about acquiring players who could potentially become major contributors for six or seven years while making very little money. 

Even the Tolle/Arias deal that reportedly could have happened doesn't bother me as much. I assume the reason it didn't happen was that Boston's package simply wasn't valued highly enough at the time. And I think that would have been a reasonable position for Falvey to take.

BTV had Payton Tolle at approximately $20 million and Franklin Arias at $22 million around the trade deadline. That's a combined value of $42 million. Joe Ryan was around $70 million.

There was a pretty substantial difference.

But look at what happened afterward.

Today, using those same BTV valuations, Tolle is worth approximately $81 million and Arias is worth $57 million. That's $138 million combined. Joe Ryan has fallen to approximately $22 million.

Think about that for a minute.

The potential Boston package went from being worth $42 million to $138 million, while Ryan went from approximately $70 million to $22 million.

That's a massive swing. Obviously, nobody could have predicted those exact numbers, and we don't know everything that happened in those negotiations. But that's precisely the risk of holding onto valuable assets. Sometimes the window to maximize their value is much smaller than you think.

And this is where I think the Twins made their biggest organizational mistake.

The teardown had already started with the dismantling of the bullpen. Once you make that decision, you have to follow through with a coherent plan. You don't necessarily have to trade everybody, but you need to be honest about where your organization stands and what direction gives you the best chance of sustained success.

Trying to remain competitive while simultaneously dismantling the roster can put you in a terrible middle ground. You're not rebuilding aggressively enough to accumulate elite young talent, and you're not putting together a roster capable of seriously competing.

Going for it was incredibly risky.

And I think the Twins need to start looking at young talent differently.

The most valuable players in baseball from a trade standpoint are often the young, highly talented players who make very little money and have six or more years of control. That's the sweet spot. You're getting production, upside, financial flexibility, and years of team control all in one package.

Once those players get older, become more expensive, and accumulate fewer years of control, their surplus trade value can decline dramatically. That doesn't mean established stars have no trade value. It means the economics of young talent are incredibly difficult to duplicate.

Look at what the Nationals demonstrated with their young offensive talent last year. When you have an organization overflowing with young players, you have options. You can build around them, trade some of them for established major leaguers, or use that depth to keep replenishing the roster.

That's organizational flexibility. And it's incredibly valuable.

The Twins need to stop thinking so much about how good a player is today and start thinking about what that player represents over the next three to six years.

I don't want a perpetual rebuild. I want an organization that understands when to sell high, when to buy low, and how to turn one generation of talent into the next.

You don't build sustained contenders by holding onto every good player. Sometimes the smartest thing you can do is trade a very good player before his value declines and turn him into two or three players who could be part of your next great team.

That's how you build something that lasts

 

Posted

The last couple of comments, while accurate and ones that mirror comments i have made, are kind of depressing in a way. The front office Sh@t the bed.

Those failures to be proactive are a reason to make a few trades and sign a few players now. Add talent.

Posted
50 minutes ago, Riverbrian said:

I don't want a perpetual rebuild. I want an organization that understands when to sell high, when to buy low, and how to turn one generation of talent into the next.

You don't build sustained contenders by holding onto every good player. Sometimes the smartest thing you can do is trade a very good player before his value declines and turn him into two or three players who could be part of your next great team.

That's how you build something that lasts

 

It may, sadly, be the way things are done, now, but rather than having a - Team - with players fans love and come to see succeed, year after year, as it was, mostly, from 1982-91  this is far more like cattle futures, buy low , sell high. 🤢

Posted
9 hours ago, RpR said:

It may, sadly, be the way things are done, now, but rather than having a - Team - with players fans love and come to see succeed, year after year, as it was, mostly, from 1982-91  this is far more like cattle futures, buy low , sell high. 🤢

It's exactly like cattle. 

Rip Wheeler GIFs - Find & Share on GIPHY

 

Posted
13 hours ago, Riverbrian said:

I wasn't even suggesting a full teardown. Ryan Jeffers was a pretty straightforward situation. He was entering the final year of his contract, and the Twins had an opportunity to turn him into a decent young player with six years of control. That's pure asset management. Letting that opportunity pass was value lost.

The bigger mistake, in my opinion, was Joe Ryan. He had enormous trade value last offseason and I'm a huge Joe Ryan fan. But sometimes you have to separate how much you like a player from what that player represents as an organizational asset.

And here's where I think the Twins really missed an opportunity.

I look at Ryan's trade value last offseason and think it was the equivalent of adding another Walker Jenkins-type prospect to the organization. Maybe even two players with the potential of a Culpepper. That's an awful lot of young talent to leave on the table. And it's not just about acquiring prospects. It's about acquiring players who could potentially become major contributors for six or seven years while making very little money. 

Even the Tolle/Arias deal that reportedly could have happened doesn't bother me as much. I assume the reason it didn't happen was that Boston's package simply wasn't valued highly enough at the time. And I think that would have been a reasonable position for Falvey to take.

BTV had Payton Tolle at approximately $20 million and Franklin Arias at $22 million around the trade deadline. That's a combined value of $42 million. Joe Ryan was around $70 million.

There was a pretty substantial difference.

But look at what happened afterward.

Today, using those same BTV valuations, Tolle is worth approximately $81 million and Arias is worth $57 million. That's $138 million combined. Joe Ryan has fallen to approximately $22 million.

Think about that for a minute.

The potential Boston package went from being worth $42 million to $138 million, while Ryan went from approximately $70 million to $22 million.

That's a massive swing. Obviously, nobody could have predicted those exact numbers, and we don't know everything that happened in those negotiations. But that's precisely the risk of holding onto valuable assets. Sometimes the window to maximize their value is much smaller than you think.

And this is where I think the Twins made their biggest organizational mistake.

The teardown had already started with the dismantling of the bullpen. Once you make that decision, you have to follow through with a coherent plan. You don't necessarily have to trade everybody, but you need to be honest about where your organization stands and what direction gives you the best chance of sustained success.

Trying to remain competitive while simultaneously dismantling the roster can put you in a terrible middle ground. You're not rebuilding aggressively enough to accumulate elite young talent, and you're not putting together a roster capable of seriously competing.

Going for it was incredibly risky.

And I think the Twins need to start looking at young talent differently.

The most valuable players in baseball from a trade standpoint are often the young, highly talented players who make very little money and have six or more years of control. That's the sweet spot. You're getting production, upside, financial flexibility, and years of team control all in one package.

Once those players get older, become more expensive, and accumulate fewer years of control, their surplus trade value can decline dramatically. That doesn't mean established stars have no trade value. It means the economics of young talent are incredibly difficult to duplicate.

Look at what the Nationals demonstrated with their young offensive talent last year. When you have an organization overflowing with young players, you have options. You can build around them, trade some of them for established major leaguers, or use that depth to keep replenishing the roster.

That's organizational flexibility. And it's incredibly valuable.

The Twins need to stop thinking so much about how good a player is today and start thinking about what that player represents over the next three to six years.

I don't want a perpetual rebuild. I want an organization that understands when to sell high, when to buy low, and how to turn one generation of talent into the next.

You don't build sustained contenders by holding onto every good player. Sometimes the smartest thing you can do is trade a very good player before his value declines and turn him into two or three players who could be part of your next great team.

That's how you build something that lasts

 

I agree and there is a fine line where if a team decides to say they are going to compete, if you are one of those top 5 or 6 teams in the league and actually have a shot at winning the World Series then keeping those higher priced veterans totally makes sense.  But if you are trying to compete to be a .500 squad and back into the post season that probably isn't a good reason.  Should probably try to make some deals at that point in time.

Posted

In my opinion, making the playoffs is worth it. If you can get in... get in. A 13-9 record in the playoffs could win you a World Series. The margins are too tight in baseball to dismiss any team that gets there.

Over 162 games, the difference between the best and worst playoff teams can look enormous. But when you break it down, it's not quite as significant as it seems.

The Brewers had 103 wins. The Astros had 81. That's a 22-win difference, which is huge over the course of a season. But that's essentially one additional win every seven games. The Brewers win about 6.4 games every 10. The Astros win 5.

That's a meaningful difference over 162 games. But in a short playoff series? Anything can happen. Get hot at the right time and you can win it all.

However... getting to the playoffs doesn't have to mean relying on veterans.

Again, in my opinion, the big-market teams have an advantage because money improves their chances of surviving 162 games and making the playoffs. They have deeper rosters. They can survive when Kyle Tucker has a crappy year. They can absorb injuries, bad contracts and underperforming players without completely derailing their season.

That's the advantage of money. It gives you more room for error. It's an unfair advantage that hopefully gets addressed with this CBA.

The top payroll teams typically make the playoffs. Last year, 8 of the 12 playoff teams were among the top 10 in payroll. That's a 2-to-1 advantage for big-money teams in terms of playoff representation. These are teams spending over $200 million.

When you have twice as many big-money teams as smaller-market teams making the playoffs, you naturally increase the likelihood that a big-money team wins it all. Not necessarily because they're twice as good, but because they have twice as many representatives competing for the championship.

However... those big-money teams still get knocked out early.

Four of the top 10 payroll teams were eliminated in the Wild Card round. Another three were eliminated in the next round. They were knocked out by teams with considerably less money.

Some people will point to that and say money doesn't matter.

That's not the point.

Money matters, but it primarily matters when it comes to getting through 162 games and making the playoffs. Once you're there, the playing field gets a whole lot tighter.

And that's where I think the Twins have a problem.

The Twins are formatted like a big-market team without having big-market money. They're trying to build a roster that competes with the big boys, but they don't have the financial resources to survive the same mistakes.

They need to be incredibly lucky to win consistently playing that game.

They need to approach things differently.

They need to develop not only players with major league talent, but players that other organizations want. They need to create trade value. They need to continually replenish their system and give themselves multiple ways to improve the major league team.

Look at Joe Ryan.

They developed trade value with Joe Ryan. If they had traded him at the right time, a big-market team likely would have been willing to provide the prospect return necessary to acquire him. Teams like the Brewers would be more inclined to trade Joe Ryan for additional prospect capital rather than give up that kind of capital to acquire him.

The Twins didn't capitalize on that opportunity. Instead, they chose to go for it with a team that wasn't built to survive 162 games.

And that's the problem.

You can't operate like a big-market team without the resources of a big-market team. You have to recognize where your advantages need to come from.

The Twins need to develop players who outperform their contracts. They need to identify undervalued talent. They need to know when to keep a player and when to turn that player into multiple future assets.

They can't afford to let valuable players walk away without getting the most out of their value.

And they can't continually fill holes with the low-level free agents the big boys don't want. They need to develop the players the big boys do want.

The Brewers have shown that you can compete without spending like the Dodgers. It takes a commitment to development, smart roster management and continually replenishing your talent.

The Twins don't need to build the best team in baseball. They need to build a team capable of making the playoffs. Once they're there, anything can happen.

But they have to build that team in a way that gives them a chance to get there year after year. Unless the CBA changes everything. The Twins don't have a sustainable model. They have a get lucky every once in awhile model. 

Develop or die.

That's the reality for a team like the Twins. 

Posted
6 minutes ago, Riverbrian said:

Develop or die.

That is your mantra. Most teams try to develop. A few teams spend more money on it than others, but all could do the same. Agree with your thinking.

Where the Twins have fallen is in their willingness to take chances. The trades of Duran and Jax may have seemed crazy but they did bring back talent. The trade of Varland was easy to question because Roden is redundant and Rojas was such a wild card added to Varland being traded with four years of control still remaining. Even that trade can still work if Rojas develops. The July 2025 moves signaled a movement that never happened. Players like Wallner, Larnach, Ober, and Jeffers lost all value while Ryan and Lewis saw their worth crater. It is possible that the 2027 Twins roster only Ryan while all of the five others are gone without returning a single player. The decision was made to "compete"? The Twins beat the Vegas odds with 76 wins last season at the expense of their future. The way I see it now, the club has to spend and make whatever gamble trades they are able to in order to add talent. It is going to be difficult. I guess we will know plenty in two weeks. Hope.

Posted
16 hours ago, Riverbrian said:

I wasn't even suggesting a full teardown. Ryan Jeffers was a pretty straightforward situation. He was entering the final year of his contract, and the Twins had an opportunity to turn him into a decent young player with six years of control. That's pure asset management. Letting that opportunity pass was value lost.

The bigger mistake, in my opinion, was Joe Ryan. He had enormous trade value last offseason and I'm a huge Joe Ryan fan. But sometimes you have to separate how much you like a player from what that player represents as an organizational asset.

And here's where I think the Twins really missed an opportunity.

I look at Ryan's trade value last offseason and think it was the equivalent of adding another Walker Jenkins-type prospect to the organization. Maybe even two players with the potential of a Culpepper. That's an awful lot of young talent to leave on the table. And it's not just about acquiring prospects. It's about acquiring players who could potentially become major contributors for six or seven years while making very little money. 

Even the Tolle/Arias deal that reportedly could have happened doesn't bother me as much. I assume the reason it didn't happen was that Boston's package simply wasn't valued highly enough at the time. And I think that would have been a reasonable position for Falvey to take.

BTV had Payton Tolle at approximately $20 million and Franklin Arias at $22 million around the trade deadline. That's a combined value of $42 million. Joe Ryan was around $70 million.

There was a pretty substantial difference.

But look at what happened afterward.

Today, using those same BTV valuations, Tolle is worth approximately $81 million and Arias is worth $57 million. That's $138 million combined. Joe Ryan has fallen to approximately $22 million.

Think about that for a minute.

The potential Boston package went from being worth $42 million to $138 million, while Ryan went from approximately $70 million to $22 million.

That's a massive swing. Obviously, nobody could have predicted those exact numbers, and we don't know everything that happened in those negotiations. But that's precisely the risk of holding onto valuable assets. Sometimes the window to maximize their value is much smaller than you think.

And this is where I think the Twins made their biggest organizational mistake.

The teardown had already started with the dismantling of the bullpen. Once you make that decision, you have to follow through with a coherent plan. You don't necessarily have to trade everybody, but you need to be honest about where your organization stands and what direction gives you the best chance of sustained success.

Trying to remain competitive while simultaneously dismantling the roster can put you in a terrible middle ground. You're not rebuilding aggressively enough to accumulate elite young talent, and you're not putting together a roster capable of seriously competing.

Going for it was incredibly risky.

And I think the Twins need to start looking at young talent differently.

The most valuable players in baseball from a trade standpoint are often the young, highly talented players who make very little money and have six or more years of control. That's the sweet spot. You're getting production, upside, financial flexibility, and years of team control all in one package.

Once those players get older, become more expensive, and accumulate fewer years of control, their surplus trade value can decline dramatically. That doesn't mean established stars have no trade value. It means the economics of young talent are incredibly difficult to duplicate.

Look at what the Nationals demonstrated with their young offensive talent last year. When you have an organization overflowing with young players, you have options. You can build around them, trade some of them for established major leaguers, or use that depth to keep replenishing the roster.

That's organizational flexibility. And it's incredibly valuable.

The Twins need to stop thinking so much about how good a player is today and start thinking about what that player represents over the next three to six years.

I don't want a perpetual rebuild. I want an organization that understands when to sell high, when to buy low, and how to turn one generation of talent into the next.

You don't build sustained contenders by holding onto every good player. Sometimes the smartest thing you can do is trade a very good player before his value declines and turn him into two or three players who could be part of your next great team.

That's how you build something that lasts

 

Btv under rated those two. Fangraphs had them both very highly rated .

Look, this is all the past. At some point, we need to stop litigating that, and talk about the future. 

But if we want to learn a lesson.... They should trade Buxton. That's the lesson here. He's the only veteran with lots of excess value right now. And yes, I know he has a no trade......

At this point, they either need to truly tear it down, or invest in this last year of pitcher control, without giving up legit prospects, other than potentially tait and any OF.....

 

Also, Tommy boy wouldn't let them deal veterans last year......

Posted
1 hour ago, tony&rodney said:

That is your mantra. Most teams try to develop. A few teams spend more money on it than others, but all could do the same. Agree with your thinking.

Where the Twins have fallen is in their willingness to take chances. The trades of Duran and Jax may have seemed crazy but they did bring back talent. The trade of Varland was easy to question because Roden is redundant and Rojas was such a wild card added to Varland being traded with four years of control still remaining. Even that trade can still work if Rojas develops. The July 2025 moves signaled a movement that never happened. Players like Wallner, Larnach, Ober, and Jeffers lost all value while Ryan and Lewis saw their worth crater. It is possible that the 2027 Twins roster only Ryan while all of the five others are gone without returning a single player. The decision was made to "compete"? The Twins beat the Vegas odds with 76 wins last season at the expense of their future. The way I see it now, the club has to spend and make whatever gamble trades they are able to in order to add talent. It is going to be difficult. I guess we will know plenty in two weeks. Hope.

Yeah... I've been using the catchphrases over and over again, hoping they'll eventually catch on. Develop or Die, Strip Mining for Parts, and Buyers Buy, Sellers Sell are things I find myself repeating.

In regard to that last one, I never want to be hypocritical. I know how I felt at the time. Sometimes I'm right, sometimes I'm wrong, but that doesn't change how I felt when it happened. I'm not going to rewrite my position just because I know how things turned out.

I wasn't one of those who was overly upset about the Varland trade. Sellers Sell... I'm consistent.

I remember that day unfolding as we watched a very good bullpen get completely torn apart. My reaction was basically, OK... that's what sellers do. The Varland trade coming in late was a surprise, but I wasn't upset about it. I had to trust that the Twins really, really liked the return.

A good left-handed starting pitcher has more potential value than a relief pitcher. The difference in innings alone makes that pretty obvious. But there's a catch. You have to develop that pitcher. You have to make the trade work.

Rojas and Roden have to turn into something. That's what selling is supposed to accomplish. You acquire players with potential, develop them, and ultimately create more value than what you gave up.

You have to win the trade by making your acquisitions better.

That brings me to the bigger issue.

Not finishing what you started... making a sharp reversal in direction and suddenly deciding to go for it in 2026 was just crazy.

Forget about the Joe Ryan value lost for a moment. That bothers me, and I've said so repeatedly and it's been discussed plenty. But there's another part of this that deserves attention.

Going for it was questionable enough, but the enhanced nightmare scenario was always sitting there. Going for it... followed by being in contention... followed by buying at the deadline... followed by not making it. That's how you enhance the original mistake. 

That's the worst possible outcome. You've given up assets as a seller, spent additional resources trying to compete, and ultimately accomplished neither objective.

Again... I'm not a hypocrite. I was against the approach they took in the off-season. I said so, and I stand by it.

I repeatedly said they should trade Joe Ryan and Ryan Jeffers. I repeatedly asked for a first baseman and a young, athletic shortstop. The very things that we need this off-season I was asking for last season. I believed Ryan and Jeffers could help provide the resources to make that happen.

But once the decision was made to go for it, and the Twins actually played well enough to put themselves in contention, my thinking changed with the circumstances. Who am I to not support somewhat over achieving ball players. 

Buyers Buy

I was OK with trying to add some bullpen pieces. I said so. I also understood why others wanted them to pack it in. That's a perfectly reasonable position when you consider how they got there.

But here's what the decision to reverse course ultimately did. With the benefit of full hindsight. 

We traded away a bullpen piece and then had to turn around and trade for a bullpen piece. We gave back the gains rather fully completely. 

And when you combine the Varland trade with the Hoffman deal, here's what the final picture looks like:

  • The Twins get Rojas but lose Hill. Rojas is closer to the big leagues, but did we actually gain talent in that exchange?
  • The Twins get Hoffman but lose Varland. Now we're talking about $10.5 million versus a minimum-salary player, not to mention the difference in years of team control.
  • The Twins get Roden but lose Klein and Pena.

Put it all together, and it sure looks like we lost this trade.

I'm not saying that's the final verdict. There is still a way to win it. But that way depends on something very specific and something the Twins haven't been terrific at. 

Rojas and Roden have to become productive major league players. They have to develop into something that makes the entire sequence of transactions worthwhile.

That's the responsibility that comes with selling.

You can't just acquire prospects and call it a successful rebuild. You can't just accumulate young players and assume you've created value.

You have to develop them.

Develop or Die.

 

Posted
2 hours ago, Mike Sixel said:

Btv under rated those two. Fangraphs had them both very highly rated .

Look, this is all the past. At some point, we need to stop litigating that, and talk about the future. 

But if we want to learn a lesson.... They should trade Buxton. That's the lesson here. He's the only veteran with lots of excess value right now. And yes, I know he has a no trade......

At this point, they either need to truly tear it down, or invest in this last year of pitcher control, without giving up legit prospects, other than potentially tait and any OF.....

 

Also, Tommy boy wouldn't let them deal veterans last year......

Buxton... I'm keeping him... Twin for life. I advocate surrounding him with Talent. Not Bit Pieces of partial talent. It can be young inexperienced talent... but I want to surround him with talent. I ain't trading him. Surround him with talent. Make his absences less significant. But, take his pluses when he's playing like Buxton can. Let's his play be part of something bigger, better... More athletic. 

I bring up the past to point out the future. It cost us time and value. You are correct... it's the future that matters now. I want them to stop repeating past mistakes.

The next wave is here... we have to handle them differently. If they do this right... they could win today and tomorrow. 

Posted
12 minutes ago, Riverbrian said:

Buxton... I'm keeping him... Twin for life. I advocate surrounding him with Talent. Not Bit Pieces of partial talent. It can be young inexperienced talent... but I want to surround him with talent. I ain't trading him. Surround him with talent. Make his absences less significant. But, take his pluses when he's playing like Buxton can. Let's his play be part of something bigger, better... More athletic. 

I bring up the past to point out the future. It cost us time and value. You are correct... it's the future that matters now. I want them to stop repeating past mistakes.

The next wave is here... we have to handle them differently. If they do this right... they could win today and tomorrow. 

I'm ok if they go big. If they go ten million dollar hitters or starting pitchers.... I'm not. 

Posted
9 minutes ago, Mike Sixel said:

I'm ok if they go big. If they go ten million dollar hitters or starting pitchers.... I'm not. 

That's exactly where I am. If I hear they are looking for a right handed anything... I'll know that once again... They are not serious about it. If they sign a bunch of low value one year deals... I'll know that once again... they are not serous about it. 

Buxton, Keaschall, Jenkins, Emma and Roden. That's 5 outfielders with talent... right there. All of them will be back next year to take any gains they make this year into the future. They have enough talent to be better than the Twins were last year. There is a bunch of athleticism in that group. That's talent. You can surround Buxton with talent. If Buxton gets hurt... you've got talent to replace him, If any of them get hurt... you've got talent to replace him. If any of them fail... You've got talent to replace them. 5 talented players on the same roster. Either realized talent or unrealized talent. It's talent... it's either good right now or it's good in the future. Whatever happens you are prepared... whatever direction the player takes... you are prepared.

If all 5 turn out to be home runs.... That's the greatest thing that could ever happen. It's not a problem. It's a good thing. A great thing. 

The worst thing they could do is what you suggest. Just hand us fans more Low value one year deals. Same Ol Same Ol.

Posted
On 11/14/2026 at 6:51 PM, Riverbrian said:

I wasn't even suggesting a full teardown. Ryan Jeffers was a pretty straightforward situation. He was entering the final year of his contract, and the Twins had an opportunity to turn him into a decent young player with six years of control. That's pure asset management. Letting that opportunity pass was value lost.

The bigger mistake, in my opinion, was Joe Ryan. He had enormous trade value last offseason and I'm a huge Joe Ryan fan. But sometimes you have to separate how much you like a player from what that player represents as an organizational asset.

And here's where I think the Twins really missed an opportunity.

I look at Ryan's trade value last offseason and think it was the equivalent of adding another Walker Jenkins-type prospect to the organization. Maybe even two players with the potential of a Culpepper. That's an awful lot of young talent to leave on the table. And it's not just about acquiring prospects. It's about acquiring players who could potentially become major contributors for six or seven years while making very little money. 

Even the Tolle/Arias deal that reportedly could have happened doesn't bother me as much. I assume the reason it didn't happen was that Boston's package simply wasn't valued highly enough at the time. And I think that would have been a reasonable position for Falvey to take.

BTV had Payton Tolle at approximately $20 million and Franklin Arias at $22 million around the trade deadline. That's a combined value of $42 million. Joe Ryan was around $70 million.

There was a pretty substantial difference.

But look at what happened afterward.

Today, using those same BTV valuations, Tolle is worth approximately $81 million and Arias is worth $57 million. That's $138 million combined. Joe Ryan has fallen to approximately $22 million.

Think about that for a minute.

The potential Boston package went from being worth $42 million to $138 million, while Ryan went from approximately $70 million to $22 million.

That's a massive swing. Obviously, nobody could have predicted those exact numbers, and we don't know everything that happened in those negotiations. But that's precisely the risk of holding onto valuable assets. Sometimes the window to maximize their value is much smaller than you think.

And this is where I think the Twins made their biggest organizational mistake.

The teardown had already started with the dismantling of the bullpen. Once you make that decision, you have to follow through with a coherent plan. You don't necessarily have to trade everybody, but you need to be honest about where your organization stands and what direction gives you the best chance of sustained success.

Trying to remain competitive while simultaneously dismantling the roster can put you in a terrible middle ground. You're not rebuilding aggressively enough to accumulate elite young talent, and you're not putting together a roster capable of seriously competing.

Going for it was incredibly risky.

And I think the Twins need to start looking at young talent differently.

The most valuable players in baseball from a trade standpoint are often the young, highly talented players who make very little money and have six or more years of control. That's the sweet spot. You're getting production, upside, financial flexibility, and years of team control all in one package.

Once those players get older, become more expensive, and accumulate fewer years of control, their surplus trade value can decline dramatically. That doesn't mean established stars have no trade value. It means the economics of young talent are incredibly difficult to duplicate.

Look at what the Nationals demonstrated with their young offensive talent last year. When you have an organization overflowing with young players, you have options. You can build around them, trade some of them for established major leaguers, or use that depth to keep replenishing the roster.

That's organizational flexibility. And it's incredibly valuable.

The Twins need to stop thinking so much about how good a player is today and start thinking about what that player represents over the next three to six years.

I don't want a perpetual rebuild. I want an organization that understands when to sell high, when to buy low, and how to turn one generation of talent into the next.

You don't build sustained contenders by holding onto every good player. Sometimes the smartest thing you can do is trade a very good player before his value declines and turn him into two or three players who could be part of your next great team.

That's how you build something that lasts

 

The 2 or 3 players need to have one work out as a player worthy of trading later for 2 or 3 players, or be good enough prospects to trade for a decent player.  

People seem to love to bring out the Tolle for Ryan bit that came out long after the trade. At the time of the hoped for trade, the Athletic said that the Twins wanted one of Duran or Abreu. Boston countered with Arias, their highest rated outfield prospect Jhostynxon Garcia, and other assets.  The Twins turned that down. Tolle was drafted the year before from college. They would have scouted him. 96 MPH fastball, 7 feet of extension and a high spin slider was what was said he possessed. That is a description of what the Twins look for.. Boston in his first minor league season had him in AA by the traded deadline. I really doubt that the Twins did not know about him, would pass up an opportunity to get him, or Boston would have given him up. The reason I bring this up is that it really highlights how teams get better. Accurately identify the skill level of your prospects. Keep the good (Tolle), offer up the highly rated ones that you are fairly sure will not be high level mlb players  up in trade (Garcia, who Boston later traded for more prospects)

Posted
2 hours ago, old nurse said:

The 2 or 3 players need to have one work out as a player worthy of trading later for 2 or 3 players, or be good enough prospects to trade for a decent player.  

People seem to love to bring out the Tolle for Ryan bit that came out long after the trade. At the time of the hoped for trade, the Athletic said that the Twins wanted one of Duran or Abreu. Boston countered with Arias, their highest rated outfield prospect Jhostynxon Garcia, and other assets.  The Twins turned that down. Tolle was drafted the year before from college. They would have scouted him. 96 MPH fastball, 7 feet of extension and a high spin slider was what was said he possessed. That is a description of what the Twins look for.. Boston in his first minor league season had him in AA by the traded deadline. I really doubt that the Twins did not know about him, would pass up an opportunity to get him, or Boston would have given him up. The reason I bring this up is that it really highlights how teams get better. Accurately identify the skill level of your prospects. Keep the good (Tolle), offer up the highly rated ones that you are fairly sure will not be high level mlb players  up in trade (Garcia, who Boston later traded for more prospects)

I don't know what they offered.

This is the first time I'm hearing of the password being part of the conversation. I'm trying not to treat rumors as gospel, I try not to hang front offices on rumor. I hate mentioning individual players but conceptual conversations seem to fail without dragging specific players into it. I just wanted people to see the Ryan - Tolle - Arias value crossroads. 

My larger point was money and years of control drop value like a stone and young prospects rule the value world. There was a window. 

If someone goes from 20 to 120 in value in a short period of time. They will be young players. 

I can only imagine in my head what a trade conversation sounds like. Especially a conversation with the deadline.

What I imagine is this. The Red Sox know who they don't mind parting with and who they mind parting with and they are hopeful that someone will take what they don't mind parting with. 

BTW... If Duran and Abreu were deal breakers of some sort. That's interesting because both left handed hitting Outfielders? Both with significant platoon split deficits vs. lefty pitching. At the time of the potential trade of course.

At that time Abreu was a strip mined young outfielder at that point. He required a Refsnyder to get 300 AB's.

Abreu is also a great example of confounding the prospect rankings. He was never a top 100 prospect. He was the 21st ranked Astro prospect.

Boston got him for the 2 month rental of Christian Vazquez. 

Value is a funny thing. 

Posted
21 hours ago, Riverbrian said:

In my opinion, making the playoffs is worth it. If you can get in... get in. A 13-9 record in the playoffs could win you a World Series. The margins are too tight in baseball to dismiss any team that gets there.

Over 162 games, the difference between the best and worst playoff teams can look enormous. But when you break it down, it's not quite as significant as it seems.

The Brewers had 103 wins. The Astros had 81. That's a 22-win difference, which is huge over the course of a season. But that's essentially one additional win every seven games. The Brewers win about 6.4 games every 10. The Astros win 5.

That's a meaningful difference over 162 games. But in a short playoff series? Anything can happen. Get hot at the right time and you can win it all.

The Dipoto Plan.

Posted
12 minutes ago, MeleMouth said:

The Dipoto Plan.

Dipoto is not wrong about the playoff side of things. We have heard fans say that Brewers were not good enough to win the world series for 4 straight years until they won it in the 4th year and now those same people call them an outlier.  

I believe Dipoto went off the rails a bit when he gave a specific number... such as win 54% of games. Fans are going to light that comment up like it was an endorsement for mediocrity. I believe that it's awfully egotistical to think you keep a team in that specific range. He used the 54% number coming off a year that they were exactly 54% and didn't qualify for the playoffs. The Mariners didn't qualify in two years out of the next three years since the comment. Last year... they didn't even reach the range of 54%.    

My statement is a little more fluid and reactionary to the conditions that exist. Buyers Buy Seller Sell.

Even though I felt the Twins shouldn't have gone for it in the off-season leading up to 2026 and therefore possibly not been in the position to buy or maybe be in position to buy with a different context such as youth contributing. They were in contention and you support them... because getting into the playoffs is getting in. 

They did what I thought they should do and it didn't work out. It actually gave back the Varland trade gains. 

Posted
28 minutes ago, Riverbrian said:

Dipoto is not wrong about the playoff side of things. We have heard fans say that Brewers were not good enough to win the world series for 4 straight years until they won it in the 4th year and now those same people call them an outlier.  

I believe Dipoto went off the rails a bit when he gave a specific number... such as win 54% of games. Fans are going to light that comment up like it was an endorsement for mediocrity. I believe that it's awfully egotistical to think you keep a team in that specific range. He used the 54% number coming off a year that they were exactly 54% and didn't qualify for the playoffs. The Mariners didn't qualify in two years out of the next three years since the comment. Last year... they didn't even reach the range of 54%.    

My statement is a little more fluid and reactionary to the conditions that exist. Buyers Buy Seller Sell.

Even though I felt the Twins shouldn't have gone for it in the off-season leading up to 2026 and therefore possibly not been in the position to buy or maybe be in position to buy with a different context such as youth contributing. They were in contention and you support them... because getting into the playoffs is getting in. 

They did what I thought they should do and it didn't work out. It actually gave back the Varland trade gains. 

MIL is not an example of just make the playoffs and anything can happen. They had the most wins in MLB in 2025 and 2026 and well more than 90 in 2021, 2023, and 2024, with "only" 86 in 2022. They were consistently trying to put together excellent teams. Just because there was a meme that they were unable to win the big one, they consistently had one of the top win totals in the majors, and it's pretty clear that teams as good as they have been have a better chance of winning it all. 

The goal of just getting into the playoffs implies a win target in the 86-88 range, under your theory that once you're in you only need to go 13-9 to win it all. I'm sure you'll agree that there is a lot more to it than that. Further, as we've seen, teams that target that kind of win total, especially when they go all in or even sort-of, kinda partially in, to achieve it like the Twins did last year, aren't taking steps to build a sustainable winner that could become a regular 90+ winner like the Brewers. 

Of course, teams with less than 90 wins can and do win the World Series. For Twins fans, the most famous example was the 1987 team. ATL won it with 88 wins in 2021. after losing Ronald Acuna. But look at that team, it still had stars in Freddie Freeman and Austin Riley, very good players in Ozzie Albies and Dansby Swanson (each of whom, I would argue, performed better in 2021 than any Twin is likely to do in 2027), and two front line starters in Charlie Morton and Max Fried who were better than any of the pitchers on the Twins have shown themselves to be. All six of those players were playing to standards they had already established, instead of having career years, with the exception of Swanson, who had been a 1-1 pick and was just playing up to the expectations for him and who since that time has consistently been at that level. ATL also had tremendous luck before the playoffs happened, winning the lottery three times in a row with their trade deadline acquisitions.

It's very hard to see how the Twins could replicate Atlanta's success this year. With the exception of the unreliable Buxton, they don't have any position players who have played to the standards that even Ozzie Albies was at, nor, with the exception of Lopez, who is returning from his second TJ, do they have any pitchers whose best year was close to the level Morton and Fried were consistently at. Further, TP's big boy talk aside, they don't have the assets to get them, even if players were available.

Posted
On 11/11/2026 at 7:01 PM, Cory Engelhardt said:

The Twins do have some talent on short term/1 year deals in the rotation that they absolutely should be open to trade to add/supplement the young core that they most likely are planning on building around.

If this is your main point, I agree 100%.

Posted

.  Tolle shows the limitations of the baseball trade values. He came out of college with superior credentials BTV says he is worth this much now. Tolle has a very high FB rate. Boston has superior outfield defense.  How much less value would he have with the Twins? Fielding run value says that Boston’s outfield  was 33 runs better, OAA says 22, DRS says 81 runs better. Tolle might have vastly different numbers pitching for a different team. 

 

Please see riverbrian’s earlier comment. His comment seems to have disappeared. 

Posted

Yes there is a lot more to it than that. 13-9 is simply the bare minimum requirement to barely win it all. However... every playoff we learn that having superstars doesn't mean they will play like superstars in a short playoff sample. In your Atlanta example. Max Fried was 2-2 with a 4 plus ERA in the playoffs. It was Ian Anderson who was lights out. Freeman was great. Albies and Swanson didn't provide very much to the offense but I'm sure they were solid defensively. It was Eddie Rosario that led the way. 

Atlanta actually serves as an example of what I'm talking about in regards to contention and support.

Rosario, Duvall and Soler were all acquired at the 2021 deadline because of the injuries that you mentioned. They got Rosario for basically free after Cleveland basically got Rosario for free after we non-tendered him. Soler cost them their 26th prospect and Duvall cost them their 16th rated prospect. That 16th rated prospect was someone we all know and love. Catcher Alex Jackson.  The Braves were 51-52 at the trade deadline and 4 games in back in the NL east. That rebuild outfield on the fly due to the current context of an injured outfield. All produced over .800 OPS over for Atlanta after they were acquired for the total of a 16th and 26th rated prospect.  

Just so there is no confusion. I think a team shouldn't simply declare an 88 win target goal. I think they should  win as many games as they possibly can. Get a bye in the first round... home field advantage but I will never look down on a playoff participant.

Get in. It's hubris to think you can identify that Rosario would go nuts in the playoffs. 

Posted
16 minutes ago, old nurse said:

.  Tolle shows the limitations of the baseball trade values. He came out of college with superior credentials BTV says he is worth this much now. Tolle has a very high FB rate. Boston has superior outfield defense.  How much less value would he have with the Twins? Fielding run value says that Boston’s outfield  was 33 runs better, OAA says 22, DRS says 81 runs better. Tolle might have vastly different numbers pitching for a different team. 

 

Please see riverbrian’s earlier comment. His comment seems to have disappeared. 

I'm not sure if it was something I rewrote. 

I agree with what you are saying. Context matters. Would Tolle be as successful with us? No way of telling.

Would Abreu have been as good with us? I doubt it. He would have continued to be strip mined for parts is my best guess. 

BBTV can't be perfect... it has severe limitations but it's about as close a guide as our mere mortal souls can come up with. 

  

 

Posted
1 hour ago, Riverbrian said:

I'm not sure if it was something I rewrote. 

I agree with what you are saying. Context matters. Would Tolle be as successful with us? No way of telling.

Would Abreu have been as good with us? I doubt it. He would have continued to be strip mined for parts is my best guess. 

BBTV can't be perfect... it has severe limitations but it's about as close a guide as our mere mortal souls can come up with. 

  

 

Actually fangraphs has literal values on every minor league player. You can figure out the value of a major league player relatively easily. 

 

Create an account or sign in to comment

You need to be a member in order to leave a comment

Create an account

Sign up for a new account in our community. It's easy!

Register a new account

Sign in

Already have an account? Sign in here.

Sign In Now
The Twins Daily Caretaker Fund
The Twins Daily Caretaker Fund

You all care about this site. The next step is caring for it. We’re asking you to caretake this site so it can remain the premier Twins community on the internet.

×
×
  • Create New...