I knew you were joking with the screen grab. But the discussion got me thinking about the fact that you see more and more out calls being made to throws to the body as opposed to the hands right at the base—including on pick-off throws to first. I think the advent of replay has had a big impact on these calls and by extension, throw and tag placement. Before replay, those *close* body tags rarely got an out call, even if they were, in fact out. Very hard for an ump to see a body tag and the hands touching the base at the same time, and thus the default on those close plays was typically “safe.”
And that’s the point, really. We are talking about REALLY close plays, essentially how to optimize nabbing a runner when he is two inches from touching second base. The ball is obviously moving way faster than the runner, but if the ball has to travel a foot less reach him, that could provide the (replay reviewable) difference. Not to mention the fact that the runner can avoid the tag at the bag by moving his hands, whereas it’s much harder to avoid the tag by shifting his body.