But see, here’s the thing. 5 tool player is a term that only really applies to prospects. If all 5 tools fully develop they are known by a single name, Trout, Jr, Bonds, A-Rod etc. Almost like unicorns.
I flatly reject the premise that he’s only using one dimension of his game as a DH. Three of the five are still in play when on offense. If I read some of these posts correctly, we’ve figured out how to make 4.5 fully developed tools a bad thing? I would go so far as to say the hit for average tool is pretty solid when adjusted for changes to the game since the 5 tool thing was invented. Hitting approach might be a better metric but that’s a different discussion.
The 6th tool is availability. The names mentioned earlier had it. Buxton hasn’t had a healthy season yet which is why he was less than half price. So far, this is working brilliantly, especially considering how solid Taylor has been.
Careful reaching for too much cake, you knock it on the floor nobody gets any.