Matt Braun

Join us in argument as we count down the greatest Twins teams in history, as voted on by the Twins Daily writers. Today: the fourth-ranked team. Image courtesy of Thiéres Rabelo Overview Let’s get this out of the way now. There’s one man synonymous with this season: a certain Alfred Manuel Martin Jr., commonly known as “Billy.” Martin first earned his bread as the feisty second baseman on the Mickey Mantle Yankees of the 1950s. He didn’t hit particularly well, but his spark plug nature and wild card tendencies fed into a knack for World Series victories; Billy claimed five rings as a player. He was loud, chaotic, and—if such a thing exists in sports—Billy was simply a winner. His future managerial career resulted in a .553 winning percentage—a number made even more impressive considering the teams he took over typically stunk the prior season. In 1969, though, Martin was a new skipper looking to turn around the Twins following a rare forgettable season. Cal Ermer proved a feckless replacement for Sam Mele, the man who helmed the team during their glorious run in 1965. The squad still claimed classic talents like Harmon Killebrew and Jim Kaat, along with new stars like Rod Carew and Dean Chance, who both joined the team for the 1967 campaign, in addition to their usual deep cast of complimentary pieces and excellent bullpen options. For one reason or another, they never gelled. Owner Calvin Griffith sensed his dynamite group of athletes couldn’t wait around to figure something out under Ermer. His solution? The former 3rd base coach and one-time manager of the Denver Bears. Lineup Baserunning was one of the core tenets of Billy Martin’s strategy. He pounded aggression into his players, emphasizing stolen bases and special attention to taking the extra base whenever possible. Even Harmon Killebrew shed his adherence to stagnation to swipe eight bags, five more than his next-highest season. By season’s end, only the Seattle Pilots, Kansas City Royals, and New York Yankees stole more bases. Perhaps the flashiest steals came from Rod Carew, who stole home on seven separate occasions in 1969. Thom Henninger, in The Pride of Minnesota: The Twins in the Turbulent 1960s, writes that, in the spring, Martin "taught [Carew] to time a pitcher's delivery and start for home from a walking lead when he knew he could make it safely."* The resulting threat netted a handful of free runs and uneasy deliveries from pitchers privy to Carew's desire for theft. No one in the AL scored more runs than the Twins. Killebrew had his best season by OPS+, slashing .276/.427/.584 while leading the league in homers (49), RBIs (140), and walks (145). He took home the AL MVP award over a pair of Orioles thumpers, Boog Powell and Frank Robinson. Carew clocked the first of many (many, many, many) .300 seasons, hitting .332 as Minnesota’s top-of-the-order assassin. Tony Oliva—brilliant as always—led the league in hits and doubles. Yet there was one more major offensive contributor outside of the trio of future Hll-of-Famers: 27-year-old Rich Reese. The Ohioan had technically been around since 1964, but he barely registered as a name to know until 1967. Following a pair of decent seasons, Reese crushed in 1969, hitting .322 with a .513 slugging percent; he hit so well that Killebrew moved to 3rd base to accommodate the newfound force. With shortstop the year prior as the kind of unanswerable question teams loathe to endure, Minnesota made a move for veteran Leo Cárdenas, hoping that his tranquil glove could soothe the previous positional shortcomings. The fit was perfect. Cárdenas enjoyed one of his best seasons at the plate, slashing .280/.353/.388 over 160 games while playing his typical, sanguine defense. The addition also allowed super-utility man César Tovar to forget ever needing to play shortstop, freeing him up to focus most of his play at second base or in center field. A passing glance could render Tovar an easily missed background extra in Minnesota's packed lineup, but Martin saw Tovar as his "little leader," the kind of guy "who got everyone going" at the top of the lineup, and in the clubhouse, as the kind of energy jolt Martin was himself in his playing days.** Pitching That the Twins pitched well in 1969 wasn’t a surprise; exactly who led them that year was. Dean Chance served as the assumed ace, but he battled arm issues, only tossing 88 ⅓ frames after totaling nearly 600 innings between 1967 and 1968; his career soon wound down, with his last major league pitch coming in 1971. Lefty Jim Merritt had been a reliable rotation staple, but he departed to Cincinnati in the trade that brought Cárdenas to Minnesota. Two men stepped up in their wake: Jim Perry and Dave Boswell. Jim, brother of Gaylord, worked as a swingman since joining the Twins in 1963, but he always found himself on the staff outskirts. He started as many as 25 games in two separate seasons, but it took Martin pushing the veteran into a full-time role for Perry to blossom. So he did, eschewing the assumed drop-off from the lowered mound to win 20 games with a 2.82 ERA over 261 ⅔ innings. He earned Minnesota’s first Cy Young award the following season. What fueled the sudden breakout for the 33-year-old? Martin believed aggression was the culprit; he would go to the mound and rile up his hurler, forcing him to challenge hitters instead of pitching around the corners.** The next crucial figure was also a holdover from years past. Dave Boswell owned a terrific curveball and a mercurial spirit as volatile on the blisters that often plagued his right hand. He spent the first few seasons of his major league career as a swingman like Perry—although, starting in 1966, his swings favored the rotation. He dropped his ERA to 3.23 in 1969, won 20 games, gobbled a career-high 256 ⅓ innings, and infamously fought Billy Martin in a bar melee that left him with an inflamed eye. If you ask Billy, Boswell threw the first punch; if you ask Dave, Martin started the fight. In any case, Boswell left for two weeks, banished to his house as punishment. He actually pitched better following the incident, sporting a 2.79 ERA in 12 starts the rest of the way. Don’t look into what lesson this teaches. Outside of Perry and Boswell, Jim Kaat was his usual, reliable self, a young, thin lefty named Tom Hall expanded upon his impressive 1968 debut with an effective year, and Ron Perranoski put forth yet another tremendous season, leading the league with 31 saves; he finished 13th in the MVP vote. Postseason 1969 saw the debut of a new playoff round: the Championship Series. Teams no longer had to be the best in their league; they just had to be the best in their six-team division. Only the Reggie Jackson and Sal Bando A’s threatened Minnesota, but their 88 wins couldn’t touch Minnesota’s 97. The 109-win Orioles were their reward. Baltimore swept the Twins, just as they would do the next season, but the series was close, at least for a time. The Orioles took Game One in a 12-inning nerve-fest that ended when Minnesota spoiled a bases-loaded situation just to watch Paul Blair walk it off with a bunt single. Game Two was even closer: Boswell and Baltimore starter Dave McNally duked it out into the 11th before Perranoski entered to earn the final out of the frame, eventually surrendering his second game-winning hit of the series. Game Three slanted Minnesota’s way after a first-inning score, then turned into an 11-2 drumming, only notable for one crucial decision. Instead of giving Kaat the nod—like fans and Calvin Griffith expected—Martin placed his faith in Bob Miller, who produced all season as a Swiss army knife capable of starting and relieving. Miller’s subsequent implosion, when combined with Martin’s cavalier attitude towards his superior, caused Griffith to can his manager after just one season. It would not be the last time Martin was fired from a managerial position. It wouldn’t even be close to the last. Concluding Thoughts This was a genuinely fun and deep team. The lineup raked, and the pitching staff had plenty of juice even with essentially ⅓ of a season from Chance. They just ran into a buzzsaw. 1969 happened to be the first full year with Earl Weaver manning the helm in Baltimore—and their 109-win juggernaut was probably the best iteration of that team, even if they did fall to the Miracle Mets in the World Series. There’s an alternate future where Minnesota was a little luckier in games one and two, giving them a lead over the Orioles they probably would have kept. But they weren’t. That’s baseball. Anyways, Billy Ball was a tremendous success. This team may be a little overrated, given that Bill Rigney's team in 1970 put forth essentially the same season (which may mean that that team was actually underrated; who's to say), but it's hard to argue against such an iconic and memorable squad. I think this is the perfect placement for this team—it’s exactly where I ranked them—and I’m glad to see our writers agreed. “Carew, Killebrew, and Oliva. Peak Rich Reese. Perry, Kaat, Boswell in the rotation.” -Hans Birkeland “Harmon Killebrew had a career year and finally won MVP. Rod Carew won his first batting title. The Twins won 97 games this year, but were swept by Baltimore in the ALCS. Long before the Yankees, the Orioles were the postseason bully of the Twins.” -Tom Froemming Previous Entries: #10 - 2010 #9 - 2023 #8 - 2002 #7 - 1970 #6 - 2019 #5 - 2006 Honorable Mentions Sources: https://www.baseball-reference.com Henninger, Thom, The Pride of Minnesota: the Twins in the Turbulent 1960s, (Lincoln: University of Nebraska Press, 2021.) Martin, Peter and Golenbock, Peter, Number 1, (Dell Publishing Company, New York, 1980.) View full article

To me, the best system maximizes prime talent in a way that splits player movement in an equal way. Essentially: the A’s should have as much of a chance as anyone to sign Aaron Judge when he hit free agency. This doesn’t happen. About 2/3 of the league can be safely ignored when players of a high caliber hit free agency, and the teams in the middle have to be deathly worried about what happens at the back-end of the deals they hand out, rather than be excited for signing a great player. That’s the issue: if Montgomery’s whiff problem proves more fatal than previously estimated, whoops! There goes like four years.

What to do when the heroes are no longer heroic In a different era, Jordan Montgomery, Blake Snell, and Cody Bellinger would have been the crown jewels of a free-agent class. Montgomery, a recent playoff hero; Snell, a Cy Young honoree fresh off his second award; and Bellinger, a bounceback case who showed flashes of the dynamic, tantalizing athleticism that made him a superstar at just age 23. Any of these three players would bring tremendous joy to whatever organization signed them—likely leading their decision-makers to anoint them as saviors in whatever specific overtones they saw fit. But here we are halfway through January, listening to silence on whether any of these men will join a franchise soon. It’s simply a different time now. While those previous descriptions are accurate enough, each player owns an obvious downside. Montgomery strikes out fewer batters than you’d like; Snell’s relationship with the strike zone is often nebulous; and Bellinger’s under-the-hood numbers speak more towards mere goodness rather than greatness. The flaws matter more these days; we know—or think we know—the ideal production shape of a player at each man’s position, and that shape is mighty cruel. Good teams rarely risk acquiring a player outside of that mold. So: is this a good thing? I think a lot of sports are wrestling with the analytical revolution and its consequences. The NBA can’t contain its own offense, the NFL can’t start theirs, and you are probably already well-versed on the aesthetic downside of modern MLB games. Efficiency is not always in the best interest of the game or the fans who hold expectations on how that game should look and feel. Some trimmed fat is genuinely good—thank god head coaches realized that punting on 4th and short is for cowards—but this rapid movement towards playing the same style of the same variation of the same concept is… boring. It gets stale. A team of guys striking out at a 27% clip only reinforces the old stereotypes that block prospective fans from tuning in and enjoying a ballgame. I don’t think it's a death sentence for the sport that teams are holding reservations about a few players that are admittedly flawed. We don’t need to force the Mike Hampton contract on teams simply because we dislike their process. What would be nice, though, is if each team had the means to reasonably sign players of Snell’s caliber without needing to stare down the maw of a lengthy rebuild if he falters ever so slightly. Someone likely would have snatched up all these men long ago if the game wasn’t wholly focused on conservatism and skeptical analysis. I suppose I just don’t like what the stalemate says about the player-franchise relationship. Teams seem to assume the worst about each player, and while that may be the safe move, doing so is lame, to steal a term I used in my prior table setter. I don’t know what exactly would create a better system, but I know this one isn’t the best it could be. View full article

Join us in argument as we count down the greatest Twins teams in history, as voted on by the Twins Daily writers. Today: the fifth-ranked team. Image courtesy of Thiéres Rabelo Overview The 2005 Twins stick out in the team’s grand narrative. The 2000s were a broadly successful era for Minnesota: only six franchises won more regular season games over this period, and the elite talent gathered in the north flourished in a way unseen since the great teams of the 60s. But, blotting this canvas is 2005, standing with a modest 83 wins in a sea of success. The team pitched well enough, enjoying another excellent season from ace Johan Santana, who led Carlos Silva’s best season as a pro and Brad Radke’s final healthy year as perhaps the greatest innings eater to ever live to the league’s 7th-best ERA. The bats didn’t follow suit. Torii Hunter broke his ankle, limiting his playing time to just 98 games, while future lineup fixtures in Joe Mauer and Justin Morneau struggled to adapt to major league pitching. By OPS+, Matthew Lecroy was the team’s best hitter, and—with all respect to the current manager of the Rochester Red Wings, and a man who enjoys banana and mayo sandwiches—him leading the charge is usually not an ideal way to score runs. And, to make matters worse, the Chicago White Sox, of all teams, vaulted over the Twins in the AL Central, riding their hot pitching to the franchise's first World Series win since Woodrow Wilson was president. Fortunately, 2006 went a little better. Lineup A duo of “Js”—Joe Mauer and Justin Morneau—spearheaded the bats; the lefties had flashed promise in prior years, but consistency proved elusive before 2006. Mauer made history, proving his worth as a 1st overall pick by becoming the first AL catcher to win the batting title. But Morneau topped him, claiming the first MVP win for a Twin since Rod Carew won it in 1977. What really made this lineup fun, though, was the ancillary characters adding to the group’s identity. White Sox manager Ozzie Guillen—brilliant in his own special eccentricities—handed Minnesota’s offense a title that would carry on for years: the piranhas. It wasn’t Mauer you should be worried about—“the catcher,” he called him—rather, Guillen was impressed by guys like Jason Bartlett and Luis Castillo, smaller, contact-oriented players with tremendous batting averages who allowed the boppers behind them to run up incredible RBI totals. Advanced stats disagree with Guillen’s observation as Mauer and Morneau were unquestionably the team’s best hitters, but it gave the team a title, a myth to build themselves around. They were the piranhas, and fending them off would be exhausting. The 06’ Twins slashed .287/.347/.425, good for the highest batting average in the league. Michael Cuddyer enjoyed the 4th-highest OPS+ of his career, hitting for a 124 mark while covering right field almost exclusively; the man to his right, Torii Hunter, was typically adept, earning a 112 OPS+ with a Gold Glove for his efforts. Pitching It’s remarkably difficult to write this section without just gushing over Johan Santana. The Venezuelan was in his third year as a full-time starter, and it may have been his best: he led the AL in wins, ERA, games started, innings, strikeouts, ERA+, FIP, WHIP, H/9, and K/9. Batters knocked him around in April, so he started May with seven innings of one-run ball against the Mariners, totaling a 2.50 ERA the rest of the way. Minnesota went 25-4 in those starts. His Cy Young win was implied. When Santana was done, Joe Nathan usually entered to make it clear in no uncertain terms that the other team’s hitters probably should have just called out sick. Nathan’s ERA was a microscopic 1.58 as he finished off 61 games, fully establishing himself as the finest non-Rivera reliever in the game. He finished 5th in the Cy Young vote. Minnesota actually had a reliever with a lower ERA, though: journeyman lefty Dennys Reyes suddenly and shockingly shed his previous control problems to mow down hitters to the tune of a 0.89 ERA. Other dominating, young relievers in Jesse Crain, Matt Guerrier, Juan Rincón, and Pat Neshek helped give the Twins easily the best ERA in baseball (2.91). Future effective pitchers Matt Garza and Glen Perkins also debuted. There’s one more player we need to talk about. To this day, almost 20 years later, Twins fans will still lament his destiny, claiming that things would have gone differently had he enjoyed good fortune. We need to talk about Francisco Liriano. While Santana was the unquestioned ace of the team, Liriano—a 22-year-old rookie—made a serious run at dethroning him. He pitched brilliantly out of the bullpen until mid-May when his dominance forced Minnesota’s brass to insert him into the rotation. He didn’t stop. In fact, he actually got better. He allowed a .525 OPS as a starter the rest of the season—an unthinkably low total nearly .100 points lower than Santana’s already-impressive .618 mark on the season. It was like the baseball gods blessed Minnesota with a golden ticket to playoff success. One ace is tough to beat; two aces may as well be impossible. And, then, it was all gone. The team scratched him from a start at the beginning of August due to elbow inflammation that never quite went away. He made two more major league starts betwixt a rehab attempt, but the pain continued to flare. On November 6th, 2006, Liriano underwent Tommy John surgery. He would go on to have a lengthy, journeyman career that featured a no-hitter in 2011, a successful starting stint with the Pirates, and a World Series ring as a lefty specialist for the 2017 Astros, but his 2006 dominance and subsequent flameout remains one of the greatest “what ifs?” in Minnesota’s history. Playoffs The team won 96 games, which included a tense wait session after the final win, as the team huddled in the clubhouse to watch the outcome of the Tigers game. Minnesota had already secured a postseason spot, but Detroit’s match determined the exact shape of their October baseball—whether it be in division-winning or wild card form. The Tigers lost. Reveling in their home crowd hours after their game ended, Twins players re-rook the field and celebrated their fourth division championship in five years with their patient, grateful fans. Their opponent? The Oakland A’s. No problem; Minnesota stymied the same ballclub just four years prior. How hard could it be? Wait, when did Frank Thomas get here? And when did Dan Haren get so good? Game One tilted Oakland’s way when The Big Hurt punished two Santana offerings, just narrowly providing enough cover for Barry Zito to earn the win with eight brilliant innings. Game Two extended the lead 2-0 when Minnesota’s bullpen couldn’t support Boof Bonsor’s six quality frames; Mark Kotsay provided the back-breaking knock when his liner snuck past a diving Torii Hunter, leading to an inside-the-park homer and two inescapable runs. Game Three was a laugher. Concluding Thoughts Any team that can claim both the MVP and the Cy Young winner deserves to be in the upper echelon of historical squads. It’s clear this team was top-heavy, though. Rondell White and 2006 Jason Kubel were an uninspiring tag team at DH, and Lew Ford’s cratered performance pushed Jason Tyner into a role unbecoming of a player of his abilities, no disrespect. And then there was the rotation: once Liriano went down, Minnesota’s second-best starter was either Brad Radke on his last legs or Boof Bonser. Granted, it was the best of Boof Bonser, but still, a 96-win team needs a better complement for their regal ace. I wonder if the playoffs would have played out differently if the baseball meta at the time was more forgiving of bullpen games—the Twins could easily crack teams in half with their assortment of relief arms, and they may have given the team a better effort than a clearly broken down Radke in game three. It’s tough to see one of the best relievers in baseball, Nathan, pitch just ⅔ of an inning in an entire series. “That 2006 team was amazing. And MVP (Morneau). Mauer's first batting championship. Santana's second Cy. Hunter coming along. Cuddyer's breakout. Nathan. Radke holding on. And I'm convinced if Liriano wasn't hurt, no one was stopping them. Santana was on what should have been Cy #3, but Liriano for a 3-month stretch was even better than Johan.” -Seth Stohs “This club won 96 games and boasted the AL MVP (Justin Morneau), Cy Young (Johan Santana) and batting champ (Joe Mauer). Pretty impressive.” -Tom Froemming What do you think of the 2006 Twins? Were they ranked too high or too low? Do you have any special memories of them? Leave a comment below and start the discussion. Previous Entries: #10 - 2010 #9 - 2023 #8 - 2002 #7 - 1970 #6 - 2019 Honorable Mentions View full article

Join us for thoughts I think when there's nothing to analyze, and speculation on Trevor Larnach. Image courtesy of © Kirby Lee-USA TODAY Sports You know how people sometimes say, "What a time to be alive"? This is not one of those exciting times. What a time it isn't. Baseball Apathy This is the least I’ve thought about baseball in an offseason. I think some combination of classist team spending and Minnesota’s announced vow of abstemiousness has neutered my usual excitement. I’m not thrilled. Nor am I jazzed. I’m looking forward to the season’s start, but only because of a basic enjoyment of Twins baseball—not because they’ve done anything to spark an anxious anticipation. Football has most of my attention these days. I’m watching the college football national championship game while writing this—go Washington; please make this age well [Ed. note: Welp. What a time it isn't.]—while reading Fran Tarkenton’s autobiography, co-written by Jim Klobuchar. I know the Twins will do something before the season starts. They always do. And offseason splashiness is poorly correlated with actual, real success the following season; there’s just something so lame about the whole thing. Following up one of the most exciting seasons in recent history by losing the man who finished second in the AL Cy Young vote, while declaring that the already unimpressive payroll will decrease, sucks the life out of a fan. It’s a gut punch to those who care, even if the reasons are legitimate. I don’t know. Maybe it’s healthy to carry your mind elsewhere when the season is on hold. I do think, though, that people tend to underrate a lack of moves, equating them to actively going backward. This isn’t the case. The Twins are already set up well, with a solid all-around offense lacking a significant hole, and they have a starting rotation that is both experienced and still relatively young. Bailey Ober is the oldest starter at 28 years of age. (Who would have guessed he was the oldest?) They could use another starter, because I don’t trust Chris Paddack to last an entire season, but there are far, far worse pitching situations in MLB. So, yeah, here we are: I’m sad at the lack of moves, but I think the team is already set up pretty well. Hypocritical? Maybe. I guess that’s the difference between rationality and emotional thoughts. What to do with Trevor Larnach? After three years, I don’t think we are any closer to knowing whether Larnach is a long-term solution. He’s been perfectly okay, but okay doesn’t cut it for a guy of his prospect pedigree. He needed to prove something in 2023, and all we saw were variations of a similar mediocre theme. With Matt Wallner firmly established, have we seen the end of Larnach as a Twin? Wallner proved more in 200 at-bats than Larnach has in three seasons. I’d say to package him in a trade, but I don’t think he has much value now. Oh, and here’s a fun thing I found the other day: Player 1: .222/.315/.385 Player 2: .240/.303/.429 Player 1 is Larnach; player 2 is Oswaldo Arcia. Also, did you know Arcia is still only 32? Still, I have this nagging feeling that he’ll Luke Raley it and break out with a team like the Rays. I guess there’s no downside to keeping him around for one more year. It’s just a shame that it looks like he’s only an ancillary depth piece, not the potential middle-of-the-order thumper he should have been. Hunter McCall will have a good breakdown piece on Larnach on the site tomorrow, though, so check back then for some detailed looks at his key areas of needed improvement. And, those are my two thoughts of the day. How do you feel about Minnesota’s spending malaise? Do you think Larnach can still contribute to the Twins? Leave a comment and start the discussion, on these or other topics. View full article

Join us in argument as we count down the greatest Twins teams in history, as voted on by the Twins Daily writers. Today: the sixth-ranked team. Image courtesy of Thiéres Rabelo Not that many baseball teams get a nickname. The 2019 Twins weren't quite Murderer's Row or the Big Red Machine, but they were every bit as good as Harvey's Wallbangers and the South Side Hitmen. That earned them a their own sobriquet. Overview The Twins were at a critical juncture entering 2019. Their surprise 2017 Wild Card appearance was a happy incident—especially as it came in the first full season under new front office leadership—but 2018 turned sour, and Minnesota now seemed stuck in the middle, trapped between mediocrity and competency. Longtime second baseman Brian Dozier was dealt to the Dodgers. Fan favorite Eduardo Escobar traveled south to Arizona. Most daunting of all, to emphasize the end of an era, franchise icon Joe Mauer ended his career in 2018, donning his old catcher’s gear for one last pitch before a deeply appreciative Target Field home crowd. The season cost one more career: Manager Paul Molitor was shown the door, ending his Twins managerial career after four seasons. The new front office initially kept Molitor despite the turnover—an odd move only made because Twins owner Jim Pohlad promised Molitor’s safety. Now, they could choose their own decision-maker, and they selected Rocco Baldelli, a young Rays product in the modern analytical vein. Minnesota spent the offseason mostly quiet, choosing to acquire depth pieces over splashy names. C.J. Cron and Jonathan Schoop added right-handed pop to the lineup, Marwin González brought super-utility credentials from a winning organization in the Astros, and Blake Parker and Martín Pérez thickened a pitching staff looking to recover from a forgettable season the year prior. But the big bopper—the man who would symbolize and embody the team unlike any player since—was Nelson Cruz. Set to turn 38 in 2019, Cruz was a risky investment, even if he did claim over a decade of experience pummeling pitchers. Fortunately, the gamble paid off. Lineup Following an 11-4 bludgeoning of the White Sox on May 24th, left fielder Eddie Rosario told reporters that “[w]hen you’re hitting a lot of bombas, everybody’s hitting bombas, everybody’s happy.” He probably didn’t know it at the time, but his use of “bomba” would soon morph into a living, breathing title, transforming Minnesota from being “The Twins” to “The Bomba Squad.” And, well, it was fitting: the team blasted 307 homers in 2019, riding the juiced ball (more on that later) to an MLB record for home runs hit in a single season. Five different players (Cruz, Max Kepler, Miguel Sanó, Rosario, and Mitch Garver ) hit at least 30 bombas (also an MLB record). Cruz alone blasted 41. Garver—despite only taking 359 plate appearances—sent 31 balls over the wall. Their outfielders hit homers; their infielders hit homers; their catchers hit homers. Every player was fully capable of destroying a baseball on any given night, giving the team a deadly 1-9 that scored the second-most runs in MLB. But yeah, the ball was definitely juiced. Homers started to tick up starting in mid-2015, and they hit a cartoonish zenith in 2019. That year, the league hit 6,776 long balls, blowing way beyond the previous high set just two years prior. It reached a point where commissioner Rob Manfred admitted that MLB’s own scientists noticed the baseball had less drag than before. This isn’t to discredit the lineup, though. The ball was juiced for everyone; Minnesota just so happened to notice the trend and made the (correct) decision to focus on adding power bats in the offseason. One player bucked the trend, though, only hitting four homers in a tremendous rookie season defined by his almost magical contact abilities. Luis Arráez was called up in May for a cup of coffee, went back to Triple-A at the start of June, and re-joined the big league club in the middle of the month. His time in the minors quickly ended. His preferred playing style—spitting on pitches outside of the strike zone with an iconic head shake before smacking a line drive to the opposite field—fueled a .334/.399/.439 line that prompted predictions for a future batting title for the 22-year-old Venezuelan. Those predictions were wrong. He’s won two batting titles. Pitching Minnesota’s lineup stole the headlines, but this team could pitch well, too—although it took a while to come around. José Berríos became the unquestioned ace of the staff when injuries curtailed Ervin Santana’s career, and he was characteristically great, earning his second career All-Star nod in 200 ⅓ innings, with a 3.68 ERA. Jake Odorizzi was a hell of a No. 2, breaking out at 29 to make his only career All-Star team in a truncated (but nonetheless effective) season. His ERA was 3.51. And Taylor Rogers baffled hitters out of the bullpen, utilizing his slingshot delivery and new, sharp slider to earn the first 30-save season of his career. The rest is where things get messy. The bullpen’s first-half ERA was 4.30—actually not too bad in the context of 2019, but still an unpleasant sight, especially because the depth beyond Rogers was questionable. Thirty-year-old rookie Ryne Harper made the team after a dominant spring training, but his looping curveball schtick faltered, making him unreliable. Tyler Duffey spent the previous four seasons as a frustrating, inconsistent starter. Suddenly, he was throwing 95-MPH darts with a nasty breaking ball. Was it sustainable, though? Trevor May was much of the same, failing to establish himself since he debuted in 2014. The innings between the starter and Rogers were fraught with hazards and tripwires. Baldelli couldn’t find anyone to trust. Yet, after half a season, it clicked. The Twins made a move at the deadline, adding a feisty veteran of San Francisco’s trio of championships in Sergio Romo. Romo fit perfectly; his slider-or-nothing approach still earned plenty of whiffs, and his closing experience allowed Baldelli to play matchups with the lefty Rogers if he so chose. The new order propelled Minnesota's bullpen to the best in baseball by FIP in the second half (3.56). The rotation was more straightforward; Berríos, Odorizzi, Pérez, Kyle Gibson, and Michael Pineda made all but 16 of the team’s starts in 2019, gobbling innings that varied from great (Berríos, Odorizzi,) to good (Pineda), to meh (Gibson, Pérez). Playoffs The team won 101 games, the most since they won 102 in 1965, and fended off a hearty challenge from Cleveland to win the AL Central. Their reward? The Yankees. Woof. Game One tilted Minnesota’s way after Polanco and Cruz blasted solo homers, but New York piled on in the middle innings to make it a 10-4 laugher. Game Two was much of the same—but with a twist. Pineda, who was a reliable starter all season, was hit with a 60-game suspension at the beginning of September after he tested positive for hydrochlorothiazide, rendering him ineligible for postseason play. The Twins turned to rookie Randy Dobnak for the start, hoping his sharp sinker and solid regular-season showing would conjure some good fortune. It didn’t. A Yankees 7-spot in the third inning essentially ended the match. Game Three’s loss was inevitable. Concluding Thoughts This team was good--damn good. Their home run ability was surreal, and it seemed like their pitching should have been enough to win them, I don’t know, at least one playoff game. Two-and-a-half starters and a solid bullpen are enough for most teams; I guess luck never bothered to show up for them when it mattered most. Still, their consistency and outright domination in the regular season is a marvel to look back on. They lost three games in a row once, four games in a row once, and… that was it. They were healthily above .500 every month, with a 13-11 July serving as their worst showing. Obviously, postseason success matters too, but I think this team belongs up there with the likes of 1970—a team very similar in outcomes to this one. "The Bomba Squad was great. Maybe it was the juiced ball... But all those "piranhas" labels were out the window when they broke the single-season home-run mark. Cruz was a story. Kepler hit 36. Garver. Sano. Rosario. I mean, it didn't matter. Ryan LaMarre was acquired as an extra outfielder in mid-September from the Braves, whose AAA season was done. He happened to be in the Twins Cities with his wife and her family. He hit homers. Down 3-1 in the 8th... three-run homer from Marwin. It was just crazy. Also illustrated why maybe giving up some offense to add pitching was a good idea. 101 wins too." -Seth Stohs "Bombas and a decent rotation before injuries and suspensions. Kepler, Polanco, and Buxton were great until they got hurt. Nelson Cruz." -Hans Birkeland "The Bomba Squad! A 101-win season. The most home runs ever. The best run differential in team history (+185). It’s already slipping my mind that these guys also had two All-Star starting pitchers (José Berríos and Jake Odorizzi), went a ridiculous 55-26 on the road and were 23-12 in one-run games. I guess it's easy to forget some of the details when a team rips your heart out in the end." - Tom Froemming "The Bomba Squad was the most fun team to watch. Even if they were down by 4+ runs, it never felt like they were out of a game. The ending was brutal, but it was probably the most fun regular season of Twins baseball I have ever seen. Plus, Taylor Rogers was a driving force out of the bullpen." -Cody Schoenmann What do you think of the 2019 Twins? Were they ranked too high or too low? Do you have any special memories of them? Leave a comment below and start the discussion. Previous Entries: #10 - 2010 #9 - 2023 #8 - 2002 #7 - 1970 Honorable Mentions View full article

Join us in argument as we count down the greatest Twins teams in history, as voted on by the Twins Daily writers. Today: the seventh-ranked team. Image courtesy of Thiéres Rabelo Overview The 1970 Twins—the reason why we can’t broadly declare the decade to be pitiful and fruitless. That, and Rod Carew. And Bert Blyleven. The great mechanisms that built the Twins of the 1960s were still at play in 1970. Franchise icons like Harmon Killebrew, Tony Oliva, Jim Kaat, and César Tovar were still reasonably in their primes (Killebrew less so, at age 34, but still fresh off an MVP season). Billy Martin’s flash-in-the-pan success and immediate firing could have pushed them off course, but these Twins were sturdy. They simply replaced the eccentric Martin with another Billy—this one preferred to drop the “y”—and lurched forward with their leviathan of talent. No one knew it then, but this would be Minnesota’s final foray into playoff baseball until the 1987 team miraculously won it all. The rest of the '70s weren’t bad, really. Rather, the Twins fell into the kind of lull that causes franchises to atrophy, as mediocre talent begat more mediocre talent, with the whole thing crashing down in a disgusting 1982 campaign. They weren’t bad, but they were something worse than that: forgettable. That’s for the future, though. For now, we’ll enjoy and celebrate the final adventure of a legendary group of players. Lineup Killebrew, Oliva, and Tovar were the three stars at the top of Minnesota’s lineup. The man nicknamed “Killer” was still the leader of the bunch. He bashed 40 homers for the eighth time in his career, en route to a gorgeous .271/.411/.546 slash line, good enough to nab him a third-place finish in the AL MVP race. The man who finished second? His teammate, Oliva, who cracked a league-leading 36 doubles and 204 total hits, marking another tremendous season in a run of excellence that would (unfortunately) soon end. Tovar only finished 18th in voting, but his contributions were critical. Since Jimmie Hall’s shocking decline in the mid-1960s, center field had been in flux. Ted Uhlaender was a respectable replacement, with the height of his play coming in 1968, but the Baylor product wowed few—and his defense lagged behind expectations for such a critical position. Enter Tovar. The Venezuela native had played every position on the field, after brief looks at first base, catcher, and pitcher in 1968 during a promotional stunt in which he played all nine spots on the diamond in a meaningless game. He even struck out Reggie Jackson while on the mound. Why not make him the everyday center fielder? The fit was perfect. Tovar knocked 36 doubles and 13 triples, while playing good defense (if Total Zone is to be believed). The rest of the lineup was… well, there’s a reason three men garnered the lion’s share of focus. Longtime fixture Bob Allison barely played due to his failing knees; the young, brilliant Carew was limited to 51 games after an injured leg caused him to miss most of the season; and 1969 breakout star Rich Reese dimmed in 1970, losing nearly .200 points of OPS. Still, the team scored the seventh-most runs in MLB and played excellent defense to offset their hitting woes. Pitching This team could pitch. They’d beat you with their starting rotation, and then they’d beat you with their bullpen. Staff ace Jim Perry had served as a reliable swingman since the team acquired him from Cleveland in 1963, but he was never among the group who earned regular starting nods from managers. There was always more talent, more veteran options. Once those choices evaporated, Perry became a full-time starter in 1969, and reached new heights in 1970. He won 24 of his 40 starts, covering 278 ⅔ frames, turning in a 3.04 ERA in a season that earned him the AL Cy Young Award nod over solid challengers in Dave McNally, Sam McDowell, and Mike Cuellar. Filling in behind him was a 19-year-old Bert Blyleven, in his first taste of major-league ball, Kaat’s typical, steady effectiveness, and Luis Tiant—the one and only—in his often-forgotten stopover between Cleveland and Boston. But, because a 19-year-old and a legend with only 92 ⅔ innings in him isn’t a strong back-end, Dave Boswell, Bill Zepp, and Tom Hall stepped in to supply frames. Boswell—still recovering from his altercation with manager Martin the previous season—barely pitched, and didn’t get outs when he did. Zepp filled innings well, covering more than 150 of them before the season ended, but the story was focused solely on a man nicknamed “The Blade.” Hall had been around since 1968, earning the Twins quality outs whenever the team called upon him. His slim appearance—Baseball Reference lists him at 150 pounds—reminded those who tried to hit off him of the edge one might find on a knife. That terror was too much in 1970; Hall eviscerated batters, striking out 184 over just 155 ⅓ innings. He had a 2.55 ERA. Whether starting or relieving, Bill Rigney knew he could rely on his svelte lefty. In fact, relief pitching is really what defined this team: Ron Perranoski, Hall, and Stan Williams were terrors out of the bullpen. Perranoski’s greatness had been well-known since his time with the Dodgers—and his performance would earn him a seventh-place finish in the Cy Young vote—but Williams’s play was especially eye-opening. Once a Dodger bullpen arm himself, Williams bounced to New York before settling in as an ancillary arm with Cleveland. Losing 14 games in 1969 earned him the boot out. Now a Twin, Williams pitched in 68 games, crushed hitters with his 1.99 ERA, and gave the team crucial innings unable to be pitched by their starting rotation. Playoffs The previous season concluded with a 3-0 sweep at the hands of the Earl Weaver-led Orioles and 1970 ended with… a 3-0 sweep at the hands of the Earl Weaver-led Orioles. No game was particularly close; Minnesota came the closest in the opening contest, losing 10-6. Baltimore jumped on Perry. The rest of the series doesn’t deserve a mention. Concluding Thoughts I’m glad our writers knew their history on this one. It’s easy to write off or misremember what happened when the Martin era ended before it could really begin, but this was a genuinely fun, cool team that was maybe pretty modern. What do you do when you have two-and-a-half trustworthy starting pitchers? Rely on your bullpen. Of course, having career years from Hall and Williams doesn’t hurt. I think if Carew had stayed healthy and Tiant had made more of an impact, this team would stand out more in our collective memory. Carew was obviously a dynamo. Perhaps a Tiant start in Game Two evens the series and gives the team a fighting chance against the Orioles. We’ll never know. In any case, this was a deeply memorable team. They were Minnesota’s last breath of fresh air, before injuries and old age sapped what remained of the 1960s run, marking the start of a 16-year postseason drought. They had award winners and breakout relief arms. If Killebrew wasn’t bashing homers, Tovar was probably hitting a triple. Carew may have played in just 51 games, but Blyleven started his legendary MLB career pitching impressively well for any rookie—much less a 19-year-old. But there was a team better than them waiting in the playoffs. So it goes. "This team probably should be higher by as many as 4-5 spots. They actually won 98 games but are a bit overlooked because it was so similar to the 1969 season, just not with Billy..." -Seth Stohs "Peak Cesar Tovar, Carew, Killebrew. Perry, Kaat, baby Blyleven, and Luis freaking Tiant." -Hans Birkeland What do you think of the 1970 Twins? Were they ranked too high or too low? Do you have any special memories of them? Leave a comment below and start the discussion. Previous Entries: #10 - 2010 #9 - 2023 #8 - 2002 Honorable Mentions View full article

Join us in argument as we count down the greatest Twins teams in history, as voted on by the Twins Daily writers. Today: the eighth-ranked team. Image courtesy of Thiéres Rabelo Overview: The 90’s were not kind to Minnesota. The team enjoyed a great 1992—although one not good enough to overcome the division-winning Athletics—and promptly slid into the same pre-1987 quagmire that cursed most every season following their glorious 1960s run. The team kind of looked like the one that practiced so much magic before; Kent Hrbek, Kirby Puckett, and Kevin Tapani played out the rest of their memorable Twins careers, and newcomer Chuck Knobluach was an All-Star fixture, but the armor suffered chinks; the picture blurred. By the late 90s, the only ones around to remind fans of the good old days were Rick Aguilera—who himself would leave in 1999—and manager Tom Kelly. Kelly was synonymous with Minnesota baseball at this point; born in Graceville, he parlayed an anonymous stint in MLB into an eternity as the man steering the Twins. He oversaw their unlikely 1987 championship victory in his first full season before ushering the team to yet another win in 1991, marking the two first—and as of 2023, only—World Series wins since the team moved from Washington. But the glories of 1991 were long in the past. The team had dissipated into an unrecognizable mess, losing the stars that drove the team to past glories without developing the young talent necessary to halt the long dive into obscurity. Finally, following the first winning season in eight years, Kelly resigned, leaving the job to rookie manager Ron Gardenhire. Gardenhire would have more than just Kelly’s shadow to deal with: MLB’s owners voted to contract the Twins late in 2001, throwing the team’s future into uncertainty. The team stayed put—a Hennepin County judge named Harry Crump shot down the effort, forcing the team to honor their lease and play at least one more season in the Metrodome—but the vague promises given to Minnesota’s players and coaches loomed over 2002 like the Death Star, threatening them at all points with the idea that this could end at any moment. Lineup By wRC+, the Twins were a top-ten group. Jacque Jones put forth the best hitting season of his career, riding his aggressive hitting style to a .300/.333/.511 slashline, good for the third highest OPS+ on the team. Torii Hunter claimed the second spot, cracking a .289/.334/.524 line that earned him an All-Star nod and a 6th-place finish in the AL MVP vote, the highest placement of his career. But, the best hitter by OPS+ was Bobby Kielty, a one-year wonder who hit .291/.405/.484 in 2002, and never came close to replicating those numbers again. He was traded to Toronto the next year, then bounced to Oakland. In his final career at-bat, he blasted a homer in game 4 of the 2007 World Series, scoring the critical run in Boston’s series-winning victory. What a career. This was mainly a group effort on offense; five other hitters notched an OPS+ of at least 100; Luis Rivas and Cristian Guzmán were the only regulars to fall short of that mark. Both men made up for it with the glove—at least narratively; advanced stats frown upon Rivas’ alleged defensive acumen. It was the early 2000s! We were just getting used to this sort of stuff. Other players of note include Michael Cuddyer, who was in his first full season as a minor league yo-yo, Denny Hocking and Matt LeCroy, who both exemplify a type of Twin popular with the team in this era and Casey Blake, who was in his final season as a passed-around depth piece before his unusual breakout in 2003 and eventual solid MLB career. Pitching 37-year-old Rick Reed was the de facto ace of a group that… let’s say was more bullpen-inclined. The team finished with the 9th-lowest reliever ERA in the league, riding excellent seasons with J.C. Romero, Eddie Guardado, Tony Fiore, LaTroy Hawkins, and Michael Jackson—no, not that one—to a 3.68 ERA. Romero’s breakout was especially shocking; the lefty fell flat on his face as a swingman the prior two seasons before posting a microscopic 1.89 ERA in 2002. He won nine games, lost two, and was probably the best reliever in the game not serving as his team's closer. The rotation, however, was more a collection of interesting names, fascinating players who were special in other times, but not now. Kyle Lohse made his full-season debut and was passable. He put up a 106 ERA+. Better days were ahead in St. Louis. Brad Radke took a break from his typical, boring competence, pitching to his worst ERA+ since his rookie season over just 118 ⅓ innings—an impossibly low total for the workhorse. And then there was Johan. The former rule-5 pick hadn’t succeeded much over his first two years in the majors, but a special regiment of changeups offered by minor league pitching coach Bobby Cuellar turned Santana’s career around. He hopped between the rotation and bullpen in 2002, but—no matter what role the team placed him in—the young lefty dominated; he ended the season with a 2.99 ERA and would win the AL Cy Young for the first time in two short years. Playoffs They didn’t know it at the time, but the 2002 Twins would become infamous for their playoff run. Not because of themselves, mind you, but rather, who they beat: Minnesota bested the Moneyball A’s in a nail-biting five-game classic. The final game was a doozy: the game stood as a normal 2-1 pitching duel headed into the 9th before A.J. Pierzynski cracked a two-run homer and David Ortiz added on for good measure, driving an RBI double to the gap to give Minnesota a four-run lead. They needed it. Mark Ellis cut three runs off the lead with a homer off Guardado. The Twins closer buckled down to net the final two outs—the final immortalized as it fell softly into Denny Hocking’s glove. The Angels decidedly thrashed Minnesota in the next round in a 4-1 series win that was uncompetitive after game three. Concluding Thoughts This is a weird time to analyze. They’re fun, absolutely. But also weird. It’s cool to see the early stages of the names that would define the 2000s Twins—guys like Hunter and Santana—but… Bobby Kielty? An absurd relief season from J.C. Romero? It’s hard to digest. At the end of the day, though, they won 94 games and went to the ALCS—something no Twins team has done since. Narratively, I think this team being the one that “saved” baseball in Minnesota, as well as the team that kicked off an awesome stretch of dominance, helped its cause. I mean, the newest Twins manager since the Reagan administration took the team to the ALCS under a cloud of uncertainty? That’s a hell of a tale. Given the lack of a dominant rotation, though, I think going to the ALCS was probably the height of the team's potential. It was maybe Gardenhire’s finest managerial performance, and it all came during his rookie season. “[T]his was the Team that Saved Baseball in Minnesota. Fun group of young players who had struggled for a few years and then came together and won a lot of games, made it to the playoffs for the first time in 13 years and they beat the Moneyball A's and got to the ALCS.” -Seth Stohs “Beat the Moneyball A’s, Pierzynski Ortiz and Mientkiewicz providing an edge. Veteran rotation that could have been even better if they didn’t bury Johan.” -Hans Birkeland “A sentimental favorite of mine, these guys inspired a bunch of “bloggers” to pop up. Whatever happened to those guys? Anyway, as someone who started closely following the Twins in 1999, it was incredibly rewarding to see this group of guys develop into a 94-win team and advance to the LCS. Would have gone all the way if it wasn’t for that damn rally monkey.” -Tom Froemming What do you think of the 2002 Twins? Were they ranked too high or too low? Do you have any special memories of them? Leave a comment below and start the discussion. Previous Entries: #10 - 2010 #9 - 2023 Honorable Mentions View full article

Join us in argument as we count down the greatest Twins teams in history, as voted on by the Twins Daily writers. Today: the ninth-ranked team, which should be a familiar one. Image courtesy of Thiéres Rabelo Call them the Streak-Breakers, the Slump-Busters, or the Ponche Posse. The 2023 Twins were a fun bunch. Overview The glories of the 2019 season were far in the past. The team never put itself together in 2021 and completely fell apart at the end of 2022, and 2020 effectively never happened. All of that placed Minnesota’s top brass in a precarious position. Was this the core to push in on? Could the veterans from 2019 find it in them to break through again? To make things harder, Carlos Correa was no longer around: the All-Star shocked the world by signing a deal with the Twins before 2022. Every party knew his original pact was effectively a one-year deal, but perhaps playing in the Twin Cities—breathing in the culture—would convince him to stay. No dice. The shortstop signed with San Francisco for… hold up; it looks like that deal fell through. Never mind; the Mets are right here to snatch him up. With Francisco Lindor already set at shortstop, the altruistic Correa will simply move to 3rd… wait, it happened again? Shoot. May as well come home, then. Correa is back in town—and with Pablo López leading the rotation (following a bold trade of the 2022 AL batting champion, Luis Arraez)—the Twins are hoping their high-end talent can bring them back to the top of the AL Central. Lineup This was about as ensemble a cast as a team can build, while still finding success. Eleven players clocked in at a wRC+ over 100, with a trio of rookies—Edouard Julien, Matt Wallner, and Royce Lewis—at the top of the pack. Max Kepler effected a second breakout, slashing .260/.332/.484. Ryan Jeffers enjoyed his first full-fledged one, hitting .276/.369/.490. But spotlighting any one player misses the beauty of this team. As good as those previous hitters were, guys like Michael A. Taylor and Donovan Solano were just as important, filling in whenever needed and providing value when called upon. Taylor’s presence was especially critical, given that Byron Buxton never played an inning in center at the major-league level. And how about Willi Castro? Minnesota brought him on before the season, assuming he’d be nothing more than minor-league depth. He turned into a legitimate offensive weapon and baserunning leviathan, swiping 33 bags while playing every position except for first base and catcher. Well, maybe Lewis deserves a spotlight. After going first overall in 2017, the Aliso Viejo, Cal. native labored in the minors—with some thanks to the absent 2020 season—and only reached the majors in 2022. He played 12 brilliant games before tearing his ACL for the second time in his career. Returning in 2023, Lewis appeared to understand how precious playing time can be; he slashed .309/.372/.548 with—if you can believe it—four grand slams in a 20-game stretch. We’ll hear more from him soon. Pitching Much like the lineup, the September Twins rotation wasn’t quite the one they started with. López and Sonny Gray never missed a start, and were often brilliant when they pitched. Gray finished second in the AL Cy Young voting. However, the back half of the starting pack shuffled. What started as a Joe Ryan, Tyler Mahle, and Kenta Maeda trio quickly involved Bailey Ober, once Mahle went down with elbow issues. He underwent Tommy John surgery in May, and Ober was suddenly a rotation fixture. He was brilliant. Armed with a deceptively tricky fastball, the 6’9” righty gave the team 144 ⅓ innings of 3.43 ERA ball, leading him to the third-highest rWAR of any pitcher on the team after he started the year at Triple-A St. Paul. The bullpen was even more complicated (when isn't it?), as reliability was hard to find and consistency was non-existent. Jhoan Durán continued to be brilliant, although a little less so than in 2022, and Griffin Jax and Emilio Pagán were late-inning fixtures, but Jorge López’s implosion left the team looking for depth. Fireballer Brock Stewart mowed down hitters when called upon, but he was only available for 27 ⅔ frames. A handful of failed middle-inning arms amounted to little. Jordan Balazovics and José De Leóns came and went. This was easily the weakest part of the team. Playoffs This is, I suspect, the reason why this team ranked so highly. Following nearly 20 years and countless failed attempts at winning a single playoff game, the 2023 Twins not only notched a postseason victory on Oct. 3, but followed it up with two more wins to give the team a trio of victories—enough to call for a parade in downtown. That didn’t happen, but the wins were nice. Minnesota squeaked out two close victories against the Blue Jays—the first won by a pair of solo homers from Lewis, backing up excellent pitching from López and friends; the second from brilliant heads-up defense and Toronto manager John Schneider inexplicably yanking José Berríos in the fourth inning—before they reached the Big Bad Astros in the ALDS. Houston dispatched Minnesota in four games. The Twins made it a series after swiping Game Two on the Astros’ home turf, but Game Three was a laugher, and the team ran out of juice in a Game Four crier. Concluding Thoughts Is this a case of recency bias? Perhaps, but I think this team has a legitimate claim of being amongst the best Minnesota has seen. Their meager 87 wins belie a more impressive 93-69 Pythagorean win-loss total. They also went 37-36 against teams at or above .500, sixth-best in the league, and better than the eventual World Series champion Rangers. But, of course, this is about those playoff wins. You’d have to go back to 2002 to find a Twins team with more postseason victories in a single season, and they’re one of just 15 Twins teams even to play baseball beyond the regular season. Those three playoff wins tie them with the 1965 team for the fourth-most in team history (seriously!). Some of that is sleight of hand, given that the World Series served as the lone playoff series until 1969 and that the Division Series only came into being following the team’s two World Series wins, but that total certainly swayed voters. Ultimately, this team had two dominant starting pitchers, excellent depth, and enough power to flip games when needed. That recipe served them well in both the regular season and postseason, even if they lacked the star power that usually fuels great teams. "The end of the 0-18 narrative. The end of not winning a series. A true transition from a team that could always hit to a team focused on pitching... Gray. Lopez... Maeda... bullpen. Won the division handily and gives us excitement again." -Seth Stohs "Royce Lewis, Pablo Lopez, Carlos Correa, Ed Julien, Jhoan Durán, ended the streak and put a scare into the Astros." -Hans Birkeland "The team that ended the streak! Also, this was my first year writing for Twins Daily. This was the most enjoyable season of Twins baseball in my life, and it will always hold a special place in my heart." -Cody Schoenmann What do you think of the 2023 Twins? Were they ranked too high or too low? Do you have any special memories of them? Leave a comment below and start the discussion. Previous Entries: #10 - 2010 Honorable Mentions View full article

I don’t think they’re incompetent, but Keller only has two years of control left, and I don’t see the team being competitive that quickly. They could always extend him, of course, but now would be the most they’d ever get for him.

With no new Twins news in the papers or on the horizon, join Matt for yet another take on Ohtani, his confusion regarding Seth Lugo, and speculation on Minnesota's starter trade target. Image courtesy of © Jim Rassol-USA TODAY Sports Ohtani’s Deferrals I’ve spent a lot of time thinking about how I feel about Shohei Ohtani’s new deal. The emotion is something between frustration and annoyance. But why? Because of baseball’s inherent economic disparity? That’s nothing new to complain about; the sport has been unequal basically since its inception. I think, actually, I’m a little jealous--jealous that a team already healthy in its wealth is smart and attractive enough to pull off this deal. It’s somehow always the Dodgers, and never the Twins. Is it bad for baseball overall? It’s undoubtedly shady…ish. Deferrals have always been around—hello, Bobby Bonilla—but besides some mocking from internet folks, the real, tangible effects it has on the team seem to be nil (unless you’re the Orioles; well done, Chris Davis). Sixty-eight million dollars is certainly a new frontier, though. We shall see what comes of it. Also, Ohtani can opt out if Mark Walter loses his status as controlling owner or if Andrew Friedman leaves the team. Jack Harris on Twitter notes that Joe Maddon had a similar clause in his contract, which allowed him to opt out and eventually sign with the Cubs. That one was centered on Friedman, too. People love working with that guy. Maybe that's what I'm really jealous of. Lugo Blues It seems that Seth Lugo’s deal with the Royals caused some consternation amongst Twins fans, and I guess I don’t see why. Derek Falvey doesn’t pay for pitching, period. His method has always been to seek out tradeable projects, keeping the dough for extensions and position players. I’m perfectly confident he’ll find another starter for whom to trade. And Lugo himself? Is a 34-year-old with no history of being an effective starter the guy we will rue not having? I liked his potential five years ago. Now, I think he’s just a cromulent pitcher, overqualified as a reliever and moderately qualified as a starter. Good for the Royals, too. They haven’t had watchable baseball in years, and while Lugo’s arm won’t be the difference between the bottom of the barrel and the top of the division, it’ll be an improvement over their barren pitching pipeline. Who Will that Starter Be? Good question. I’m not sure. I’m confident it won’t be Corbin Burnes—Falvey never pays for the name brand—but it will undoubtedly be someone on the perimeter of our view. Pittsburgh’s Mitch Keller somewhat fits that criteria, but we are already hot on his trail, as seen by our writers’ trade suggestions earlier this off-season; the guy Falvey acquires will almost certainly be someone we’re not even considering. To throw a name out there, what about Trevor Rogers? He dominated in 2021 and commands an excellent fastball/changeup combo. Injuries erased almost all of his 2023 season—illustrating why teams might be scared of him—but the upside is apparent. What do you think of the specialized opt-out clauses in Ohtani's deal? What would you give up for Rogers? Are you worried about calling him Taylor by accident over and over, if the Twins did bring him in? Let's dig into it. View full article

Join us in argument as we count down the greatest Twins teams in history, as voted on by the Twins Daily writers. Today: the number 10 ranked team. Image courtesy of Thiéres Rabelo 2010 was much of the same for the Twins of this era: the team that won the 7th-most games of all franchises in the 2000s kicked off the 2010s with a new logo and yet another trip to the playoffs. Manager Ron Gardenhire won AL Manager of the Year. By wins, this was the team’s best performance since 2006—an impressive outcome considering this was now their third-straight Johan Santana-less season. They didn’t replace him—who could have—but they did shock the system with an impressive influx of young and old talent. Oh, and they had a new place to call home. Carl Pohlad had wanted out of the Metrodome since the 90s, but an extensive political battle kept the team grumpy yet covered by a roof. It’s not a good sign when the Wikipedia article for the stadium includes a history that starts 16 years before the field opened. The fight included an attempt by MLB to contract the Twins in 2001—a move that died a quick death when Hennepin County judge Harry Crump shot down the ploy just days following MLB’s decision hit the news. Then, less than nine years later, Minnesota opened the beautiful limestone-centric Target Field, bringing outdoor MLB back to the state. Lineup: While the Twins of the 2000s cloaked themselves in piranha vernacular, the 2010 team preferred to bop. Joe Mauer’s transcendent 2009 season gave the lineup two former MVPs and the best duo of lefties in the game. Neither of those was Mauer, though: Justin Morneau was the scariest batter in baseball that year, hitting a hilarious .345/.437/.618, and 39-year-old Jim Thome wasn’t far behind, topping the 1.000 mark himself over 340 plate appearances. Rookie Danny Valencia hit 300 in his first taste of the bigs. Six regulars hit above a 100 OPS+. The team finished 2nd in MLB in batting average, 2nd in OBP, and 7th in slugging. Perhaps the most significant positive development, though, was Delmon Young. The team made an uncharacteristically brash challenge trade for the former 1st overall pick just four years after he was drafted. He rewarded their boldness with two mediocre hitting seasons. Perhaps sensing that it was now seven years since he went number 1—and that goodwill in sports lasts about the same length of time as a House of Representative term, Young turned in a career year, posting a 124 OPS+ and 112 RBIs, netting him down-ballot MVP votes. A gaggle of veterans—two newcomers in Orlando Hudson and J.J. Hardy, two old-guard hitters in Michael Cuddyer and Denard Span, and Nick Punto—rounded out a supremely deep lineup. The bad news? Morneau’s story isn’t as simple as his outright dominance: the 29-year-old suffered a concussion against the Blue Jays on July 7th and never played another game the rest of the year. His play dropped in the following seasons. He led the NL with a .319 batting average in 2014 as a final show. Still, he never fully recovered from the concussion and subsequent injuries in the years following what could have been one of the greatest hitting seasons in Twins history. Pitching: 2010 was prime Rick Anderson’s Rick Anderson-ness. The longtime pitching coach famously preferred teaching a philosophy of limiting walks and pitching to contact—a strategy that worked for years until every pitcher became a nuclear flamethrower—and the 2010 Twins reflected his beliefs. Their rotation of Carl Pavano, Francisco Liriano, Scott Baker, Nick Blackburn, and Kevin Slowey struck out batters at the 10th-lowest rate, but their habit of seldom walking anyone (5.6% BB rate!) made them a roughly average group. The 2010 Twins were a bullpen team. Despite All-Star closer Joe Nathan missing the year with Tommy John surgery, Jon Rauch, Matt Guerrier, Jesse Crain, Jose Mijares, and swingman Brian Duensing, helped push the group to the 8th-best ERA in MLB (3.49). Adding Matt Capps at the deadline and Brian Fuentes on waivers in August only deepened the stable. Playoffs: Unfortunately, because this is a Twins team in the 21st century, their ultimate fate was a sweep at the hands of the Yankees. Games one and two were reasonably close. Game three wasn’t. That was it for the 2010 Twins. Concluding thoughts: This is a very worthy addition to the list. The 2010 team won the 7th-most games of any Twins team in history, and—considering some “luck” modifier—absolutely could have won even more had Nathan and Morneau enjoyed good health. The more I look at it, the more I see a team reminiscent of modern baseball. After acquiring Capps, the bullpen had six regulars with an ERA+ over 120, giving them a hearty amount of reliable relief arms; they could shut down games only needing four or five-inning starts. The rotation was missing a starter, though; the team axed Slowey, Blackburn, and Baker for the postseason, instead calling on Duensing to make the critical start in Yankee stadium down 2-0. It didn’t go well. If they had just one more sturdy starting pitcher, they could have moved Pavano to game three—a much better option than Duensing, who performed worse as a starter in 2010. Ultimately, this is the Jim Thome Season to me. His walk-off vs. the White Sox and absolute missile vs. the Royals are both singed deep into my memory banks, still crystal-clear over a decade later. Ironically, that this season came one year after Brett Favre led the Vikings to the NFC Championship game, considering Thome’s legendary run with Cleveland. “Jim Thome’s swan song with a 1.000 OPS, peak Mauer, Liriano was still good, Orlando Hudson, JJ Hardy, good Delmon. If only Morneau and Nathan had stayed intact.” -Hans Birkeland “The inaugural Target Field team won 94 games, but it’s easy to wonder how far these guys would have gone if Justin Morneau, who was having another MVP season, not suffered a career-altering concussion.” -Tom Froemming What do you think of the 2010 Twins? Were they ranked too high or too low? Do you have any special memories of them? Leave a comment below and start the discussion. View full article

A 2006 rule change narrowed an avenue once ripe with opportunity and talent. Image courtesy of © Jerry Lai-USA TODAY Sports Handed a chance to add a player to their major-league roster on Wednesday, the Twins—as they have done every year since 2017—passed. They weren’t solely driven by painful memories of Tyler Kinley and Justin Haley: The Rule 5 draft has, in recent years, devolved from a relatively consistent method of swiping talent to a largely barren, sure-let’s-shore-up-the-back-of-our-bullpen abstention fest. You can thank the 2006 CBA for this change. Before that year, players who signed at 18 or younger were eligible for the draft after four years; players signed at 19 or older needed just three years*. Emmanuel Rodriguez, for example, would have been eligible for last year’s Rule 5 process if the prior rules had still existed. The CBA pushed back the timeline a year for both age groups, allowing the Twins to wait until this offseason before ultimately deciding on Rodríguez. It’s just one year—seemingly innocuous stuff, really—but an extra season secretly cuts down on the talent available for selection. As Andrew Simon wrote for MLB.com: “relatively few players have stuck with a drafting team and made an impact [since 2006], though Josh Hamilton, R.A. Dickey, Darren O'Day, Brad Keller, Ender Inciarte and Mark Canha are among others who have been selected during that time.” Take Johan Santana. You know him. You love him! Santana was a 20-year-old fresh off a 4.66 ERA —a few ticks higher than the average hurler for the Midwest league that year. Needing to decide on his talents, the Astros gambled on leaving their $10,000 pitcher open for other teams to select, and the rest is well-documented history. Had it been after 2006, Houston would have enjoyed a bonus year of evaluation. Perhaps Santana flashes enough in his extra season to convince Astros decision-makers of his worth. In fact, it seems almost certain that he would have. -------------------- The last time a Rule 5 pick turned into an All-Star was in 2018, when the White Sox selected Jordan Romano… who only became an All-Star once he returned to his previous franchise. The only time before that was in 2017, when the Orioles selected Nestor Cortes… who only became an All-Star once he returned to his previous franchise. Other selections have turned into ancillary contributors or one- or two-year wonders. The last time a player turned into an All-Star for the team that drafted him was Odúbel Herrera, nearly a decade ago. The bonus year is grinding the already lengthy evaluation process to the point where no one misses. If a player hasn’t become a desirable prospect by the point at which he becomes eligible under the current rules, he likely never will be. In thinking about the Rule 5 draft and the changes made in 2006, I initially believed the new rules to be anti-player but pro-team. The talented must wait, laboring under the watch of a franchise safe in their evaluations. The team knows they have time; what’s the rush in ensuring they have someone of value? But, really, this process is only a boon to conservative teams. The swashbucklers of the league—the franchises who dare to bet on talent—have a worse chance at swiping a George Bell or a Shane Victorino, because it’s more evident to the original franchise whether they have a Victorino worth keeping. The cement is dried and set. Your best hope these days is to get a Brad Keller or maybe a Victor Reyes. It’s a bit of a travesty, just another minor alteration that makes the sport slightly worse for the fan. Given baseball’s place as the game most rooted in entropy—with Willi Castros popping up every season like clockwork—making it harder for teams to potentially hit the jackpot on talent creates a lesser product. Santana was an outlier, but can you imagine the mid-2000s Twins without him? What potential Santanas never wowed their fanbase because they never received the chance? *The specific wording is “professional seasons,” with occasional loopholes for players assigned to a team whose season has already ended. See J.J. Cooper’s article on Baseball America for more details. https://www.baseballamerica.com/stories/explaining-the-rule-5-draft/ What's your reaction? Is this change hurting the fan and player experience of baseball? Should it be revisited in future CBA negotiations? Join the conversation in the comments. View full article

Join us in argument as we count down the greatest Twins teams in history, as voted on by the Twinsdaily writers. Image courtesy of Thiéres Rabelo Starting today and going until the weekend before pitchers and catchers report, you’ll find a weekly post highlighting a team we considered among the best in Twins history, Senators not included. (Sorry, Walter Johnson .) The methodology was simple: I asked our writers to rank the ten greatest teams in Twins history, with potential notes or comments on their selections as they saw fit. From there, points were awarded in reverse order (e.g., 1st place was worth 10 points, 10th place was worth 1 point). I double, triple, then, finally, quadruple-checked to ensure my elementary arithmetic was still intact before the final list—and accompanying honorable mentions—took shape. What defines “greatest?” I let our voters decide; no boundary or guideline came from me. Perhaps some writers valued regular season performance, playoff success, individual accomplishments, run differential, or just how much fun it was to watch said team in their consideration. Individual ballots reflected their personality to a degree, but I think the consensus represents a solid, well-rounded group touching on numerous critical eras for the team. No more yapping. Let’s get on to the honorable mentions: 2004 Twins Our first list-misser was a top-heavy team in transition. A kid named Joe Mauer made an outstanding first impression- and suffered his first injury - with the squad, slashing .308/.369/.570 with nearly as many walks as strikeouts, providing a glimpse as to why the Twins selected the hometown prospect first overall in 2001. Johan Santana won his first Cy Young award with a dominant campaign; he led the league in ERA, strikeouts, ERA+, FIP, WHIP, H/9, and K/9. Throw in the usual excellence from Brad Radke and Torii Hunter, mix in surprise breakouts in Lew Ford and Joe Nathan (only one would stick, take a guess), and it’s not shocking that this team won 92 games, enough to claim the AL Central crown. This was a 21st-century Twins team, though, which meant their ultimate fate was falling to the New York Yankees in the playoffs. 2009 Twins It’s rare for one image to symbolize an entire team, but the one for Twins this year is clear and defined: Carlos Gomez streaking around 3rd, dashing home in a hopeful sprint as his teammates explode with exuberance and cheers. He would be safe, they knew, and his successful score capped off one of the greatest games of Twins history, the final regular season game Minnesota would play in the Metrodome. The AL Central was now the Twins’ to own. The rest of the season went pretty well, too. Nathan, Matt Guerrier, and Jose Mijares headlined a top 10 bullpen by ERA, while an ensemble lineup plated the 5th-most runs of any team in MLB. Orchestrating that offense was a 26-year-old Mauer, who led the league in all three triple-slash categories—as a catcher, mind you—carrying him to an easy MVP despite “only” playing in 138 games. But, hey, wouldn’t you know it, the Yankees were pretty good this year, too, and they romped the Twins on their way to winning the World Series. So it goes. 1962 Twins This one may be a surprise even for those well-versed in Twins history: the 1960s teams are usually considered monolithically good, with 1965 as the crowning club. What, then, is there to make of the other teams? Considering 1962 was only the second season the team played in Minneapolis, the importance of this team may actually be understated. “[F]or them to be really good already in 1962 was huge,” wrote Seth Stohs when voting for them. Indeed, a familiar cast of Camilo Pascual, Jim Kaat, Earl Battey, Bob Allison, Zoilo Versalles, and Harmon Killebrew led Minnesota’s first foray into winning baseball in 1962. Mickey Mantle’s Yankees halted them from going to the World Series—they were pretty good, also, if you didn’t know—but 1962 remained a solid stepping stone for the franchise, one that would lead them into a profoundly successful decade of dominance. 1967 Twins Hey, it’s the 60s again! This team featured some new stars—mainly a young Rod Carew, a reborn Dean Chance, and arguably the best years of Jim Merrit and Dave Boswell’s careers—but this was still the Killebrew/Allison/Tony Oliva show; Oliva claimed the worst OPS+ of the trio with a 130 mark. This was also the final season for manager Sam Mele. The Queens native was Minnesota’s skipper since Cookie Lavagetto received the boot partway through the team’s inaugural season. What went around came back to Mele; owner Calvin Griffith pulled the plug on him after the team stood at .500 50 games into the season. Cal Ermer took over, and the team won 20 more games than they lost the rest of the way. Entering a critical final two-game set against the Red Sox—whom they tussled with in the standings—Minnesota stood at the edge of the playoffs. They blew it, losing both games to send Carl Yastrzemski and the “Impossible Dream” Boston squad to the World Series in their place. Two more measly wins may have reversed history and raised this team’s placement on the rankings, but those excruciating losses knocked them down to honorable mention status. 1963 Twins This is the final mention of the 60s in this article, I swear. It may seem strange to consider a team that only finished in 3rd place, but—as Tom Froemming wrote—“[t]he 1963 Twins only won 91 games, but had the fourth-best run differential in Twins history (+165). They had a Pythagorean record of 98-63. A lot of franchise icons were on this roster, they went on to do bigger and better things, but this was still a really strong Twins squad.” Indeed, Allison, Pascual, and rookie sensation Jimmie Hall spearheaded a team that led MLB in runs scored and pitched to the 3rd-best ERA in the AL. Future nerds might call this team “unlucky,” but there’s no reward for poor fortune; all this team could do was watch the Yankees win the World Series again. 2017 Twins This was a fun Twins team. They weren’t a great one, but they were certainly fun. Fresh off a disastrous 103-loss season, the team cleaned house—but kept manager Paul Molitor—and rebounded to win 85 games, just enough to nab a playoff spot for the first time in seven seasons. A personal favorite of writer Cody Schoenmann, he writes that having “young players in Byron Buxton, Max Kepler, Jorge Polanco, Eddie Rosario, and Miguel Sano emerge” amongst veteran leaders in Ervin Santana and Brian Dozier was fun to watch. It may reveal a lot about the actual quality of this squad that “fun” is the consistent adjective used by those who remember the team. Santana, Dozier, and Buxton were excellent players—and Mauer had his best post-injuries season—but depth was thin, and the team couldn’t escape themselves in the postseason, blowing a 4-0 lead in their matchup against… the Yankees. Good lord, 2023 couldn’t happen soon enough. 1988 Twins Our final team of the day is the often-forgotten follow-up to the famous 1987 squad. The same heroes of before were here—Kirby Puckett, Frank Viola, Kent Hrbek, and more—but their fortune was left in the past; a 104-win Oakland team boasting some bashing brothers flew by the Twins in the division. This was still a formidable group of players: Puckett finished 3rd in MVP voting, while Viola took home the Cy Young, and an otherwise non-descript lefty named Allan Anderson shocked the league by winning the ERA title, becoming the first Twins pitcher to accomplish the feat (how about that for bar trivia!) But, still, there’s no ring to show for this team, which stuffs them into the “honorable mentions” compartment. That concludes our honorable mentions. Join us next week to learn who ranked 10th in our Greatest Twins Teams list. View full article