Well, their number 5 pitchers have put up negative WAR. Had they added a 2 WAR SP in FA, that would be worth 4-6 wins over this season. 4 more wins right now puts them near the WC. Add 1 good RP, and you added 1-2 more wins this year over Breslow and others that should not have been here. So, we'll just disagree that counting on Hughes, May, Santiago, Gibson was a good idea. To say they could sign 1 SP is unrealistic is an exaggeration at best.