I agree with every other clause in your post, but quibble with this. Why do you hold Buxton accountable for his bat, then make it an either/or statement? What makes the guy so tantalizing is the potential for both. He can hit AND field. He needs his hit tool to become more consistent. Agreed, staying on the field is a critical component to this equation. I for one feel that this whole team is much better with him roaming CF than without, regardless of his hitting. True there are too many holes in the lineup, and if he can get back on track from the end of ‘17, it’s one fewer. I agree with you that he needs to hit. He’s shown the ability, he’s coming up on 1000 ABs, it’s time. I think he can do it, but even if he can’t, he’s still extremely valuable.