Cory Engelhardt

I don't hate this thinking. I do think the Padres would have to send a prospect WITH Peralta to make that work, but I'd be open to this. More moves would be coming, but something like this would definitely help the bullpen

👍 Agreed

The Padres don't have a starting or backup catcher on their roster right now. Ethan Salas is still probably at least a year away. But I wouldn't mind the Twins getting in on Cartaya here. Curious where he gets moved to

They don't have to trade Pablo.

Arenado will be 34 in April (Correa will be 31 at the end of September 2025) and statistically he really started to fall off last year in a few categories compared to his peak. He played about double the games that Correa did last year (152 to 86, which is good) but in those games he was worth only 3.1 fangraphs war, while Correa was worth 4.3 in only his 86 games. Arenado's batting line of 272/325/394 shows a pretty significant dropoff in power production too, and his wRC+ was only 2% above league average. According to steamer, he is projected to be a 3 win player. Correa's batting line of 310/388/517 is really pretty awesome, and is 55% above league average in terms of wRC+ (or 53% better than Arenado was.) He also projects to be a 3.7 war player this year according to steamer. And then really after that, you have the position change. Arenado is still a good defensive 3b, but not an amazing one. Correa is still a great defensive ss. The downgrade of Correa with Lee or Lewis at 3b to Arenado and Iglesias on the left side is noticeable at worst. The money being less would be ok if you could fill the gaps. But really, truly, the dropoff here would be a world class SS to a dumpster diving SS. And I don't want to downgrade our SS position that much. As far as value, Correa has positive value, and would bring back a different return if traded. I'm just not certain I want to trade him at all, especially for a older vet who isn't as good at a position that is then harder to fill. Good thing all of this is on the Pablo Lopez thread, right? :)

I get the feeling that could be the same with the Ishbia’s

Baltimore was said to be listening to offers to sell around January 1 of 2024. The sale was announced end of March 2024. That turnaround was only about 3 months give or take

Optimism is good to have

This is great news. Ryan is very good when he is on and healthy

As far as age/yearly salary/position/talent level go, Correa for Arenado would be pennies on the dollar

You said Arenado for Correa. I must have read that wrong.

Yeah, but then you have to get into why in the world the Twins would sell Correa for pennies on the dollar?

You had me until you said that he doesn't want to spend his career on a 65 win team. For everything that went right, and wrong, last year; the Twins aren't a 65 win team.

Most teams (even the Dodgers) use 10 or 11 different pitchers to start a game in a full season. That’s pretty normal

But then the question gets asked; is there upside to having Paddack ahead of Festa/SWR/Zebby/Morris in some capacity? I still think Paddack could be a decent back-end starter for a lot of teams. And I also agree you can never have enough pitching. But comparing how much is out there now in the trade market to what MIGHT be available at the deadline, assuming he stays healthy, is hard to comprehend for me. Plus, with the apparent payroll maximum the Pohlad family has decided on, it's hard for me to see why keeping Paddack past opening day makes sense.

Why? Just curious.

I'd argue their 2019 draft was actually really strong. Wallner, Spencer Steer, Sawyer Gibson-Long, Casey Legumina, Brent Headrick, Louie Varland and Edouard Julien all have made the majors so far. Some have been traded for other deals, but drafting them and having them make the majors IS an accomplishment. Also, taking a shot at NOW top 100 prospect Drew Gilbert was smart too, even though he wasn't going to sign.

I'll add to it, why would Correa accept a trade where he ISN'T getting an extension on his contract? And with that, why would a team be giving him an extension? It's not happening.

Hi Seth, I do agree that the cupboard isn't bare. They need some luck with health, but I think (if you compare this to an old house) the "bones" are good on this roster. That said, they've said specifically they want a right handed hitting outfielder and a true 1B. They also still have 2 open 40 man roster spots. I'm be beyond shocked if they don't fill their 40 man roster, and add the positions they say they are looking for. My guess is via trade, but still.

Sign me up. Every scouting report I've read says he is a solid defensive catcher, at least at this point in his career. If they can bring him in, and even have him at either AA or AAA to start, that's a good thing to have.

With how cheap he is and how much team control he has, I really have to think that SWR is entirely too low on this list. To compare, both Julien and Miranda could be traded this offseason for little, where I’d have to imagine trading SWR would bring back more than either, and by quite a bit no?

Always appreciate your writing. Thank you. Have a great day!

Yeah on the national level. Not locally. And if a team wants a player, and all of the rumored offers are trash (like they have been) how do you put any legitimacy to it. Its not happening

Oh wow, Diego Cartaya was designated to make room for Kim in LA. He was such a highly ranked prospect not that long ago. He hasn't hit a ton, but no doubt someone puts in a claim. Wonder if the Twins try to get him somehow?

I'll take that bet on Lopez getting moved. It's not happening I'll also argue that Festa and Matthews should rightfully be ahead of Paddack in the pecking order if he is moved or not.