Sano Going To Let It Eat

This is just a point of discussion now. It will become more important when arbitration comes around and the Twins use the lack of availability as an argument for lower pay.  Even a bigger issue when the discussion of a long term contract starts. Sano is really hurting himself in terms of his future.  It isn't the positional issue (I have always viewed him as a first baseman) as much as durability and longevity. The Hrbek analogy is very appropriate. A very good player who could have been so much more for so much longer.

Let he who is without fat cast the first Oreo.

Just kidding. I’ll take that Oreo if you’re just going to cast it away.

mlbtv just did a quick thing with Peter Gammons this morning and they showed Sano hitting. He doesn't look fat by any means.

He looks great for a DH and maybe a 1B. I have long maintained that he is going to be playing less and less 3B each year. I would put the over/under on his games started at 3B at 50% of his total game played.

But I don't really care. IF he produces like most expect him to produce then those will be great numbers even at DH.

Aaron Judge is 290 lbs.  Guess the Yankees should put him on a diet because he is not good enough.

Judge is actually about 280... and he's at least 3 inches taller than Sano

Let he who is without fat cast the first Oreo.

 

Just kidding. I’ll take that Oreo if you’re just going to cast it away.

FTW!

You're moving the goalposts.

 

Are we really going to pretend like he was going to be a long term fixture at 3B? The guy has had documented issues fielding the ball almost since MN signed him.

 

That wasn't the point though. The point was that you're professing to know what a healthy baseline for Sano is, and then you're using that to forecast the future. That is pure conjecture but it's being thrown around this thread as if it's fact.

There aren’t a lot of 300 pounders in MLB playing any position. Mo Vaughn in his last few years. But really no one has carried that kind of weight through an entire successful career. I personally don’t consider Sandoval to have had a successful career. One season of 80 RBI. Injuries and mediocrity since the age of 24.

Ortiz wasn’t in the 300 range for most of his career. Maybe the last 4-5 years of it.

Yes, Vargas is there now, but he really hasn’t had much of a career either.

I think the concern about the weight stems from the team's concern. If his bosses weren't concerned we wouldn't be either. At least not to the same extent. The team actually talks to the kid. So public concern from the fo is a thing. Probably not a big thing. But it's there. Way behind the k's but still there.

You're moving the goalposts.

 

Are we really going to pretend like he was  going to be a long term fixture at 3B? The guy has had documented issues fielding the ball almost since MN signed him. 

 

That wasn't the point though. The point was that you're professing to know what a healthy baseline for Sano is, and then you're using that to forecast the future. That is pure conjecture but it's being thrown around this thread as if it's fact. 

No, I'm not. I'm deferring to the people in charge of the Twins -- who clearly have an issue with it.

He looks great for a DH and maybe a 1B. I have long maintained that he is going to be playing less and less 3B each year. I would put the over/under on his games started at 3B at 50% of his total game played.

 

But I don't really care. IF he produces like most expect him to produce then those will be great numbers even at DH.

Will you care if he averages 115 games per year for his career at $25 mil plus?

The character assassination here is getting pretty thick. There are plenty of people reacting to the character assassination, which makes it hard to have any sort of reasonable discussion on the matter. Sano very well may deserve some of it, but I don't think many of us are without sin either... so let's stop casting stones. 

This is the crux of it for me. I don't care for the obsession with his weight, especially when numbers are thrown around with no basis. That in and of itself is irksome, but I think you touched on the larger issue, which is that those assumptions about his weight are then used to question character.  

Why the hell do we have to have a bi-monthly rip fest about his weight?  What makes people want to conjure up those criticisms with little or no evidence to back them up?

The timing is very convenient.

It's curious that the criticism is often heightened when he is most vulnerable, i.e. unable to defend himself with his performance on the field.

No, I'm not. I'm deferring to the people in charge of the Twins -- who clearly have an issue with it.

If you're talking about the FO making comments about Sano needing to get back to game shape this ST following offseason leg surgery then we're in agreement. The Twins and Sano should be focused on that. There was no way he was going to be able to show up to camp in the condition either side would have liked. 

This FO hasn't made any comments about what a healthy weight for Sano is, and they certainly haven't touched on whether he'll be able to continue producing into his late 20s and early 30s. That was your addition to thread, and that was what I objected to. 

My concern isn't necessarily that he's coming in "overweight". It's been pointed out multiple times that each person has a different ideal weight because of height and body type. My concern is that if he's being given a weight goal going into an offseason of what the team wants him to weigh coming into the spring, and he's missing it, that's a huge problem. He's basically telling his bosses that he doesn't feel the need to do what they ask of him. That shows a lack of discipline and accountability on his part. I get why people are saying, "but he's still good". Great. Awesome. My response is why stop at "good" when with a little discipline he could be "great"?

My concern is that if he's being given a weight goal going into an offseason of what the team wants him to weigh coming into the spring, and he's missing it, that's a huge problem. He's basically telling his bosses that he doesn't feel the need to do what they ask of him. That shows a lack of discipline and accountability on his part.

Has he, though? Is there any evidence that suggests the team told him to hit a specific number, and he chose to ignore his bosses? Maybe there is, but I don't think anyone here has come across it.

Generally, I don't understand the need to invent realities simply to argue against those realities. By all available photo and video evidence, Sano is about the same size he was last year. I buy that he's not quite in playing shape, but that's a far cry from what a few people here have described in spite of documented visual evidence. But why believe that when someone on Twins Daily says Sano is lazy and obese? I don't know. Maybe you and others can explain it to me.

 

That doesn't seem to be uncommon with 24-year-olds. I've been saying for a couple of years that hopefully he sees the light if he struggles, fails and finds that life isn't going to be quite as easy as it appeared with youthful eyes. I took awhile to learn that lesson, I'm guessing many other young folks have too. I was hoping this off season would be the year for him, but with the off field stuff and the injury, it may not be.

Finally.

Kid's 24. Not all players are going to develop at the same rate.

He works hard, by my eyeball test. Several ST worth.

And he was in FM training prior to reporting.

Some of this is simply over the top conjecture.

It's rather mind boggling to me to see so many posters posit that being overweight doesn't negatively affect a baseball player.

 

That just doesn't make sense.

 

Not rendering him useless is not the same as not negatively affecting his performance.  At the very LEAST, it slows a baseball player down.  It almost certainly HAS to negatively affect ankle, knee, and hip joints.  And I'm just not buying the idea that a 3rd baseman isn't negatively affected defensively if he's carrying extra pounds.

 

C'mon people.  

Well said, couldn't agree more.

There seems to be a relief among some that Sano has been mashing in BP.  Not sure why anyone would expect anything different from him.  It's what he does.  But he's capable of so much more, even in the field.  He's selling himself, and therefore his team and fans, short by not staying fit enough to be an asset at third base.  And I cannot fathom why so many are willing to give him a pass for that.

Sano's face looked noticeably bigger in the main pic on the startrib article, but in the video he doesn't look much bigger than last year so maybe it's just the angle or he just gained 10 pounds in the face.

He was 290 when diagnosed with the stress fracture last year per another article written about a week ago. I know he wasn't destined for 3B for much longer but I was hoping another 2-3 years at 260 lbs or so would be possible.

From this article by the Pioneer Press' Brian Murphy:

*Meanwhile, manager Paul Molitor is still trying to establish a deeper relationship with Sano to help the talented but enigmatic cleanup hitter reach his full potential as a reliable run-producer and professional.

"Talented, but..." speaks volumes here.  

*Molitor said he has enlisted teammates to help Sano focus and hone his craft, but that has produced mixed results.

If a player was doing just fine on his own, it wouldn't be necessary for the manager to round up other players to babysit Sano to 'focus'.    

*“I think the trend has been he’s figuring some things out; some things have been a little harder to get through to him,” Molitor said. “At times I’ve tried to involve people that might be able to provide a voice that will penetrate. We’re just trying to get him to see the bigger picture.

“He loves to play. It’s all in front of him. He, as much as anyone in that clubhouse, wants what’s in front of him, but I’m not sure he understands what is required to reap those rewards — of competing, winning, financial security, taking care of his family. We’re trying.”

"Some things have been a little harder to get through to him"?  To me that's coachspeak for 'No matter what we say, this is someone who has to figure it out for himself, and he either can't or won't do that on his own to this point...'  The underlined statements above come across to me as general statements that may as well be red flags.  Big ones.

Sano has the potential to be a generational big leaguer.  These types of talents don't grow on trees, especially for the Twins.  I cannot understand why so many people are willing to give him a pass on his lack of conditioning and / or devotion to his craft.  The Twins are going to have to decide fairly soon if Sano is someone they want to hitch their wagon to long term.  Sano himself is making what should be a no-brainer of a choice for the Twins front office a real head-scratcher.

Has he, though? Is there any evidence that suggests the team told him to hit a specific number, and he chose to ignore his bosses? Maybe there is, but I don't think anyone here has come across it.

 

Generally, I don't understand the need to invent realities simply to argue against those realities. By all available photo and video evidence, Sano is about the same size he was last year. I buy that he's not quite in playing shape, but that's a far cry from what a few people here have described in spite of documented visual evidence. But why believe that when someone on Twins Daily says Sano is lazy and obese? I don't know. Maybe you and others can explain it to me.

What reality has been invented? The only reality that is being discussed is that Sano has come into camp overweight enough that our front office has had to field questions on whether his size will affect his performance. I doubt very much that there is any sort of "weight goal" in writing, however it is not difficult to deduce from their concern that an general outline of where they would like him to be exists and has been discussed with him. If it hasn't, that is negligence on the part of management. If they are viewing it as an issue, why shouldn't we? Also, don't recall seeing a single comment on here calling Miguel obese and lazy. Lamenting that he seems to have such a hard time being disciplined with his fitness, yes. Obese and lazy, no.