Jump to content
Twins Daily
  • Create Account

Recommended Posts

Posted
7 hours ago, Cory Engelhardt said:

See, the Twins are already in for 23.15 for one year. I HAVE to think they would easily go 2/22 on top of that. Which is why I HAVE to think another team goes 4 years minimum.

Exactly!

Posted
30 minutes ago, Cory Engelhardt said:

I get that, but free agency is almost always an overpay. And there is just no reason for him to reject the qualifying offer THIS early AND the Twins to not have signed him to 2/46 if that is the case.

I'm guessing it'll be at least 4/70. Less than that and the Twins have already signed him if it is 3 years. That makes too much sense. I mean, why would the Twins be willing to pay a shade over 23 million for one season if really they were wanting more like 11 million per for the following 2 seasons after that? I mean, the Twins gave 3/30 to Christian Vazquez, and Jeffers is world's better as a hitter than Vazquez ever was no?

Exactly. I don't think the Twins are interested in paying Jeffers what he will ultimately get.

Posted

No surprise. Jeffers is going for the gold and the team that signs him will be overpaying. He's not worth 23 million a year.

Posted
16 hours ago, MackMan said:

I think what Hawkeye is getting at is if we offer that much, a team is more than likely going to have to offer more in order to sign him, which give the Twins a fairly decent draft pick in the Supp A round. I mean, we've already shown we're willing to spend $23million for 1 year and if we add $27milliion over another 2 years, the AAV substantially comes down. 

Fair and this makes more sense.  

@Hawkeye Bean Counter, sorry if I misread your post.  

Posted
13 hours ago, Twins GFP said:

Exactly. I don't think the Twins are interested in paying Jeffers what he will ultimately get.

Yup. Their doing like an old auction. They have no intention of actually buying it, they just want to make sure that whomever does, overpays by A LOT so they can get the Supplemental pick in a good range right after the 1st round. It is actually a pretty smart move if you know you've got no shot at winning him over in FA.

Posted
18 hours ago, Woof Bronzer said:

I'd say there's very little upside.  He's getting older at a physically demanding position.  He is a poor defender and that will get worse with age.  He has a long injury history and actually plays less than Buxton.  His offense does not play at 1B or DH.  Catcher is the deepest position in the minors and if Jeffers is signed you can bet the organization will prioritize Jeffers over kids who might actually raise the ceiling.  We need more talent and spending limited FA dollars on Jeffers is going to make it harder to raise the ceiling.  

Ask yourself this:  would you feel there is zero downside to offering Buxton this same deal?  The risks are probably higher with Jeffers.  And the reward is a guy who has averaged 1.8 WAR/year as a starter.  We've got to dream bigger than this!

Getting a 2 WAR player for 15 million a year is a win every day of the week.  Who else are you getting for 15 million a year that gives you this production???   ie nobody.   

Posted
1 hour ago, Woof Bronzer said:

Fair and this makes more sense.  

@Hawkeye Bean Counter, sorry if I misread your post.  

Its correct.   I think the value on a 3 year deal to Jeffers is good and fair deal.   Ultimately though its to get the 1st round draft comp pick by having another team pay more than that.  Ive said since last year the math says he is getting 60 to 80 million - good catchers get paid handsomely there just haven't been any good comps recently because they are rare .   That was the only reason to not trade Jeffers at the deadline and still recoup some value.  

Posted
3 hours ago, Hawkeye Bean Counter said:

Getting a 2 WAR player for 15 million a year is a win every day of the week.  Who else are you getting for 15 million a year that gives you this production???   ie nobody.   

Vann Lackey, starting in 2028, is going to provide same or better production for far less after I sign him to a 6 year extension prior to his debut.  

Old-Timey Member
Posted
3 hours ago, Hawkeye Bean Counter said:

Getting a 2 WAR player for 15 million a year is a win every day of the week.  Who else are you getting for 15 million a year that gives you this production???   ie nobody.   

Arraez

Posted
On 11/13/2026 at 10:43 AM, Hawkeye Bean Counter said:

Getting a 2 WAR player for 15 million a year is a win every day of the week.  Who else are you getting for 15 million a year that gives you this production???   ie nobody.   

That's just slightly less that league average production per dollar spent.  That's just not effective enough to gain any real advantage.  That does not even consider the reality of being a team with less than average revenue.  A team with below average revenue must outperform the average.

Jake Bauers signed for $2.7M and produced 3.6 WAR.  The Twins spent almost exactly $15M in total on MAT / Harrison Bader and Carlos Santana.  They produced 6.8 WAR.  2 WAR for $15M is not an effective for a team with below average revenue.  I collected some data on low revenue teams that produced significant WAR from free agency and they across the board produced 1 WAR for every $2m-$3m  spent.

Posted
4 hours ago, Major League Ready said:

That's just slightly less that league average production per dollar spent.  That's just not effective enough to gain any real advantage.  That does not even consider the reality of being a team with less than average revenue.  A team with below average revenue must outperform the average.

Jake Bauers signed for $2.7M and produced 3.6 WAR.  The Twins spent almost exactly $15M in total on MAT / Harrison Bader and Carlos Santana.  They produced 6.8 WAR. 2 WAR for 15M.  2 WAR for $15M is not an effective for a team with below average revenue.  I collected some data on low revenue teams that produced significant WAR from free agency and they across the board produced 1 WAR for every $2m-$3m  spent.

Put another way, if the Twins spent $7.5m/WAR, even with a $140m payroll, that's about a 19 WAR team.  No chance at the playoffs.  With a $120m payroll, $7.5m/WAR gets you a 16 WAR team - same as the 26 Rockies.  Historically bad.  

The Brewers spent about $2.8m/WAR this year. 

Rays:  $2.3m/WAR

Guards:  $2,2m/WAR

That's how middle/small revenue teams compete against the big boys.  Develop, develop, develop.  Exploit the competitive advantage of developing enough talent that you don't have to pay $7.5m/WAR.  The Brewers got basically the same WAR as the Dodgers, for about $200m less.  They neutralized the Dodgers' revenue advantage, and they didn't do it through free agency.    

Posted
On 11/13/2026 at 4:10 PM, Major League Ready said:

That's just slightly less that league average production per dollar spent.  That's just not effective enough to gain any real advantage.  That does not even consider the reality of being a team with less than average revenue.  A team with below average revenue must outperform the average.

Jake Bauers signed for $2.7M and produced 3.6 WAR.  The Twins spent almost exactly $15M in total on MAT / Harrison Bader and Carlos Santana.  They produced 6.8 WAR.  2 WAR for $15M is not an effective for a team with below average revenue.  I collected some data on low revenue teams that produced significant WAR from free agency and they across the board produced 1 WAR for every $2m-$3m  spent.

So Jak Bauers is a player our fan base would have roasted for being a garbage bin pick up.   

The bigger question is who out of the bargain bin is going to give you that much production at the C position?   

Posted
25 minutes ago, Hawkeye Bean Counter said:

The bigger question is who out of the bargain bin is going to give you that much production at the C position?   

No one.  That's the point.  Don't force yourself to overpay for mediocre talent.  If the Twins rely on free agency they will never be able to compete with the big revenue teams.  It is by far the most expensive way to build a team.  Again, if the Twins pay $7.5m/WAR that's a 16 WAR team at a $120m payroll, a horrendously bad team.  

They need to develop players, period.  The Brewers have a whopping 2 players they signed via free agency.

Posted
8 minutes ago, Woof Bronzer said:

No one.  That's the point.  Don't force yourself to overpay for mediocre talent.  If the Twins rely on free agency they will never be able to compete with the big revenue teams.  It is by far the most expensive way to build a team.  Again, if the Twins pay $7.5m/WAR that's a 16 WAR team at a $120m payroll, a horrendously bad team.  

They need to develop players, period.  The Brewers have a whopping 2 players they signed via free agency.

We will be going into a new CBA where we will have to spend some money Woof.   If we can find someone that gives 3-4 WAR we can pair up with him so be it.   We will have ample other players to get cheap WAR from.  

Posted
3 minutes ago, Hawkeye Bean Counter said:

We will be going into a new CBA where we will have to spend some money Woof.   If we can find someone that gives 3-4 WAR we can pair up with him so be it.   We will have ample other players to get cheap WAR from.  

Building a roster through free agency as a middle revenue team simply doesn't work.  The Twins didn't have a single 3-4 WAR player last year, they don't grow on trees and by your math that player (who doesn't exist) would cost upwards of $30m/year

If the Twins want to spend money, buy the best front office in baseball.  Invest in your minor leagues, invest in development.  Hire better scouts and coaches.  Pry away a GM who has actually proven success in MLB.  

If the Twins want to spend money on players, sign Culpepper, Jenkins, and Bradley to long term extensions now.  

Spending money just to spend money in FA and overpay for 1-2 WAR talent is one of the worst things the team could do in my opinion.  

Create an account or sign in to comment

You need to be a member in order to leave a comment

Create an account

Sign up for a new account in our community. It's easy!

Register a new account

Sign in

Already have an account? Sign in here.

Sign In Now
The Twins Daily Caretaker Fund
The Twins Daily Caretaker Fund

You all care about this site. The next step is caring for it. We’re asking you to caretake this site so it can remain the premier Twins community on the internet.

×
×
  • Create New...