Jump to content
Twins Daily
  • Create Account

Eris

Verified Member
 View Profile  See their activity

  • Posts

    990

  • Joined

  • Last visited

  • Days Won

    1

 Content Type 

Profiles

Minnesota Twins News, Rumors & Analysis

Minnesota Twins Videos

2026 Minnesota Twins Top Prospect Rankings

2022 Minnesota Twins Draft Picks & Signing Bonuses

Minnesota Twins Trade & Free Agent Rumors

Minnesota Twins Fan Guides & Resources

2023 Minnesota Twins Draft Picks & Signing Bonuses

The Minnesota Twins Players Project

2024 Minnesota Twins Draft Picks & Signing Bonuses

2025 Minnesota Twins Draft Picks & Signing Bonuses

2026 Minnesota Twins Draft Picks & Signing Bonuses

Forums

Blogs

Events

Store

Downloads

Gallery

Everything posted by Eris

  1. Eris
    What we have here is a total system failure that predates Falvey. Since approximately 2010, Byron Buxton is the only player drafted in the Twins organization who has produced at above average to elite level of performance (when he is not hurt). Berrios might belong on this list. There is a real development gap regarding many of Twins high level draft picks. There were others like Dozier, Kepler and Polanco with short periods of sustained success.
  2. Eris
    This is very true. Much has been written about the defensive shortcomings of Lee, but for the 2025 season Lee’s defensive run value was equal to Correa’s.
  3. Eris
    Tyler Mahle trade —-very bad Jorge Lopez trade —horrible, maybe the worst. Releasing Brent Rooker ( not a trade but in hindsight huge lost opportunity). Since 2023, Rooker has put up 9.6 fWAR for Oakland. The Twins best player over this period is Byron Buxton who has 9.2 fWAR Missing on many first round picks is why the Twins are in their current predicament Sonny Gray trade was a good trade.
  4. Eris
    The problem with a total rebuild is the Twins position players are so bad that trading Ryan and Lopez—even if they were to hit a home run on both trades would not make the Twins a competitive team. To be playoff competitive, a team needs to have about 25-30 WAR from their position players (the Blue Jays had about 34 fWAR for the 2025 season). On the Twins only Buxton had more than 3 fWAR. Jeffers was second with 2.1 fWAR. When you start doing the math it hard to get to 25 fWAR unless Lewis, Keaschall, Wallner, Martin and Lee average about 3 WAR. From that perspective it seems reasonable to give fans something to excited about which is tuning in watch Ryan and Lopez pitch.
  5. Eris
    I think the challenge is there are too many holes to fill mostly due to under development of prospects. Trading Ryan or Lopez or both for top 20 MLB prospects which seems like a reach will not make the team substantially better as there 5 + positions that need serious upgrading and most of these position players from last year are still on the team. Several of these players are best suited for DH and describing them as position players is being generous.
  6. Eris
    Does anyone know where Law ranked the Twins farm system last year.
  7. Eris
    As there were about 6 underperforming positions players mostly responsible for the 2025 season results, upgrading most of these positions without waiting for prospects was always almost impossible. In fact all of these underperforming players (except Vasquez) are still on the team. So the 2026 season becomes trying the same thing over again (minus a good bullpen foundation) and expecting a different outcome.
  8. Eris
    What was the purpose of this article as it does not seem to be to discuss a fair trade proposal. In a normal trade, a team would trade current value (Jeffers) for the probability of greater value in the future. Or trade current value from a position of excess (maybe catcher) to a team that has excess at different position of need (e.g. the Twins would benefit from acquiring a 3WAR SS). The proposed Jeffers for Wong trade as discussed accomplishes neither of these as it involves the Twins trading current value for even less future value. No front office would ever make such a trade.
  9. Eris
    The Twins did not do a total selloff last year because Lewis, Lee, Larnach, Julien and Wallner did not have a lot of value. I understand the point of the article which is that starting pitchers and Jeffers have a lot of value. Literally there would be no position players to build around except Buxton and possibly Keaschall. Everyone else is just “hope”. You think a team 5 or 6 player who can not hit and whose best position is DH is bad, try a team full of non-hitting DH types with no starting pitching. At some level they need to sell tickets. There is hope the Lewis, Wallner, Martin, Keaschall and Jeffers can approach a 3 WAR season in which case the Twins will have a decent team. Also, to have an impact on the Twins outlook, they would have needed to trade each SP for Walker Jenkins type prospect as the Twins are many position players away from having a competitive post season team.
  10. Eris
    On Culpepper. College players selected in the first round are expected to rise quickly in the minors. Those who do not (see Aaron Sabato) likely will not have a successful MLB career. On E. Rodriguez. I’m estimating that he will have a strikeout rate in the mid 30s when he gets to the big leagues. I expect the first several years in the big leagues to be brutal. Call me old school but I don’t see how this is going to work unless he can get his strike out rate down to about 25%. (Miguel Sano’s K rate was 36% with BB of 12%)
  11. Eris
    The challenge in putting together a roster is that providing value is not the most meaningful metric. The goal is to make it into the postseason. Which means a roster of position players who averaged about 2 WAR each. Signing a player who provides 0.5 WAR at near league minimum may provide real value but it is unlikely to get the team closer to a playoff berth.
  12. Eris
    It is hard to judge a pitcher when they are hurt, especially if it is a hip. If the hip is or becomes chronic then this is who Ober is as a pitcher.
  13. Eris
    Larnach is not the only player whose roster spot should be in question. Every player who underperformed last season should available for a trade. (Lewis, Lee, Larnach, Wallner, Julien). It is hard to win when half of the position players are below average and don’t play good defense. On Outman, the Twins need a backup CF who is about average defensively. Can (especially) Martin or possibly Rodon improve enough to not be a liability in CF.
  14. Eris
    While this is true, the Dodgers only won game 7 because an ex-Twin didn’t get an appropriate lead off of third in a critical situation. (Referring to Isiah Kiner-Falefa as an ex-Twin is probably pushing the boundaries of what it means to be an ex-Twin, but this is TD)
  15. Eris
    There are several scenarios where it makes sense. 1). The Twins solution to needing more right handed power is to maximize Jeffers at bats from 1B or DH. To this they need another catcher to distribute the catching duties. 2). Maybe Jeffers still has concussion like symptoms from his Sept 2025 concussion. 3). Possible trade of Jeffers is in the works (I think this is unlikely as it seems this would be done by now).
  16. Eris
    Moving Ryan Jeffers to first base and getting him in 140 games a year would make a lot of sense. He likely will be above average defensively at 1B and one of the Twins best right handed power bats increases playing time. But the Twins have Julien, Bell, Clemens, maybe Keaschall and a bunch of other players to pencil in there. Ryan Jeffers experienced concussion like symptoms in early September 2025, but he did catch 2 games towards the end of the season. Maybe there are some health concerns here. (I have no information that supports this other than he missed about 3 weeks towards the end of the 2025 season).
  17. Eris
    I agree with you. The problem is that the Twins have 5 ish positions that are below average with no expectations of upgrades until prospects arrive or “hope “ that the current players (Lee, Lewis, Larnach, Wallner, whose ever at 1B) can turn it around.
  18. Eris
    If a focus is on starting pitching then pairing that with quality catchers who call a good game makes sense. Not sure if our catcher quality meets that criteria.
  19. Eris
    I realize this article is about RP, but it doesn’t make much sense to focus on value when the team has two or three position players who average or above average. This is not a competitive team based on last year’s performance. We are left hoping that the once promising position players turn it around.
  20. Eris
    From FanGraphs. WRC+ of 75. Below average both offensively and defensively. A utility play who can’t hit should at least be able to play defense. Not sure I understand this move at all.
  21. Eris
    I think this is unfair to Kody Clemens. Clemens produced 1.4 fWAR last season with average to slightly above average defense. Garlick's best season was 0.4 fWAR. As an added note, 6 Twins position players with at least 100 plate appearances had an fWAR below Garlick's best season. So maybe Kyle Garlick is the appropriate benchmark as painful as that may be to think about. Major League Leaderboards - 2025 - Batting | FanGraphs Baseball
  22. Eris
    Do we know when he tested positive.
  23. Eris
    I don’t understand the appeal the Twins have for seriously underperforming veterans who have been passed over by multiple teams. I would much rather watch their prospects play. At least the youth provide hope for the future.
  24. Eris
    Not sure I really understand everything that was written. I don’t need to. A MLB player who is unable to catch up to a fastball will generally have a very short and unsuccessful career.
  25. Eris
    There is also Mickey Gasper. Although much derided on TD, he made a number of nice throws from behind the plate. His throws to nab Clement and Judge at 3rd were exceptional In reality he probably grades out as a well below average catcher https://www.mlb.com/video/ernie-clement-caught-stealing-2nd-base-catcher-mickey-gasper-to-second-ba https://www.mlb.com/stories/player/681508
×
×
  • Create New...