Where did I say they outweigh the players or FO?
I just said that you are looking for an edge in the playoffs and Rocco so far has just been a wet noodle when it comes to managing playoff games. In fact, in games that mean anything this year(against teams with winning records and Cleveland, he has been horrible)
Also, all those guys you point to. Let's see their career playoff numbers.
I also believe Rocco CAN be a positive for us, but right now, I see him as a liability when it comes right down to it. Pulling starters that are cruising is whatever during the regular season because it can save bullets on guys arms, etc., but when you are in the playoffs and have a guy doing well and you yank him after 5 to go to a bullpen that isn't great, that's on him 100%.
I'll give an example Berrios cruising, game close. Put in Cody Stashak who is a bottom of the barrel guy then go to Taylor Rogers on back to back day. Dumb and exactly the kind of stuff a manager that HURTS, does.
Win a game. Any damn game in the postseason and I might change my mind. So far though, his teams have been killed in every game he's managed in October.