Jump to content
Twins Daily
  • Create Account

Recommended Posts

Posted

The Minnesota Twins have surprised the baseball world with two significant additions in a matter of days. First, Ryan Jeffers accepted the team's $23.15 million qualifying offer to return for the 2027 season. Then, Minnesota brought back a familiar face by signing right-hander Sonny Gray to a two-year, $55 million contract with an opt-out after the 2027 season. These moves represent a major investment from an organization that spent much of the previous offseason cutting payroll.

The additions are significant for different reasons. Jeffers gives Minnesota an established starting catcher who was one of its most productive hitters in 2026. Gray returns after finishing second in American League Cy Young voting during his previous season with the Twins in 2023. He is coming off another strong campaign with Boston, posting a 2.72 ERA across 169 innings in 2026.

Those two contracts change the financial picture considerably. So where does Minnesota stand financially, and does the team have enough room to make additional additions?

A Franchise-Record Payroll

According to FanGraphs, the Twins currently have an estimated $174 million payroll for the 2027 season. That would represent the largest payroll in franchise history, surpassing the previous record of approximately $164 million set in 2023.

That 2023 season was an important one for the organization. Minnesota won the American League Central before defeating the Toronto Blue Jays in the Wild Card Series for its first postseason series victory in 21 years. The front office will hope that a similar financial commitment can help the 2027 team return to the postseason.

From a league-wide perspective, this year's average MLB payroll was over $180 million. However, the $174 million figure is still an offseason projection. Minnesota has several decisions to make before its roster and payroll become finalized.

Arbitration Decisions Could Create Flexibility

The Twins have nine players eligible for arbitration, and the organization must decide which players will receive contracts by Friday, November 20. There are several interesting decisions among this group.

On the starting pitching side, Joe Ryan, Bailey Ober, Dean Kremer, and Taj Bradley are eligible. Ryan is projected to earn $9.6 million, followed by Ober at $6.9 million, Kremer at $6.5 million, and Bradley at $4.5 million. Ober is the biggest question mark in this group, as his projected salary and ongoing velocity concerns makes him a potential non-tender candidate.

Minnesota also has two arbitration-eligible relievers in Tommy Nance and Cole Sands. Nance is projected to earn $1.2 million, while Sands is projected at $1.3 million. Both could provide inexpensive bullpen depth if the organization decides to retain them.

The position-player group includes Trevor Larnach, Royce Lewis, and Kody Clemens. Larnach carries a projected salary of $6.3 million, Lewis is projected at $5.1 million, and Clemens comes in at $3.6 million. Larnach and Lewis are potential non-tender candidates. Both players have questions surrounding their respective roles, and the Twins must determine whether their projected salaries make sense for the production they provide.

Non-tendering Ober, Larnach, and Lewis would save Minnesota an estimated $18.3 million. That could create additional flexibility to address other areas of need. However, moving on from three players would also require the organization to find replacements or promote other options.

Where Should Minnesota Spend Next?

Even after the additions of Jeffers and Gray, the Twins have several areas they could address before Opening Day. The bullpen remains one of the most obvious needs, particularly from the left side. Kody Funderburk is currently the primary returning left-handed option, leaving Minnesota with an opportunity to add another experienced arm for the late innings.

A.J. Minter would make plenty of sense as a potential target. Minnesota acquired him during the 2026 season, and he pitched well after joining the organization. Bringing him back would give the bullpen another experienced option who is familiar with the coaching staff and organization. If Minter's asking price becomes too expensive, the Twins could look for someone with a similar track record. There is also a potential to move Kendry Rojas to a full-time relief role. 

There has also been discussion about adding another right-handed reliever. However, Minnesota might have enough starting pitching depth to address that need internally. Zebby Matthews and David Festa are two potential candidates to move into relief roles if the starting rotation stays healthy. The additions of Gray and Jeffers could allow the front office to prioritize other positions rather than spending additional money on a starting pitcher.

The position-player side presents another interesting question. Minnesota is losing Josh Bell at designated hitter after declining his mutual option. Bell was one of the team's more productive run producers in 2026, finishing with 21 home runs and a team-leading 96 RBI while posting a .738 OPS.

The Twins could look to replace that production by adding another established bat who can play first base, second base, or serve as a designated hitter. However, the recent spending spree might mean the organization is less willing to make another substantial financial commitment.

That could create an opportunity for Lewis. Rather than moving on from the former first-round pick, Minnesota could give him an opportunity to compete for a first-base role. Finding a position where Lewis can contribute offensively would give the Twins another option without requiring another significant free-agent investment.

Are the Twins Finished Spending?

The Twins have already made two moves that would have been difficult to envision a few months ago. Bringing back Jeffers and adding Gray gives the roster an immediate boost while pushing projected payroll to a franchise-record level. However, spending money and building a complete roster are two different things. Minnesota still needs another dependable left-handed reliever and could use additional production at first base or designated hitter.

The arbitration decisions will play an important role in determining what happens next. Non-tendering the three candidates mentioned above could create nearly $18.3 million in potential savings, giving the front office another opportunity to reinvest in the roster.

For now, the Twins have given fans a reason to be excited about the upcoming season. The organization has demonstrated a willingness to make significant financial commitments, something that was missing during much of the previous offseason. The next challenge will be turning those investments into a roster capable of competing for another AL Central title.

The additions of Jeffers and Gray have changed the conversation surrounding the Twins. The question is no longer whether ownership is willing to spend. It is whether the front office has enough resources and flexibility to finish building a playoff-caliber roster.


Where will the team’s payroll be on Opening Day? How else will the team spend this winter? Leave a comment and start the discussion.

Image courtesy of © Matt Blewett-Imagn Images

View full article

Posted

This is shaping up to be an interesting off season. I was of the opinion that Jeffers coming back was essentially it for a payroll bump so my opinion doesn’t mean much. It seems like there are a couple directions they could go. Non - tender everyone except Clemens to save money as a means to offset the Gray signing; doing the same as a way to add even more additions; or keeping most / all and still add more. Any of the three would be more than I was expecting. Of course trades could enter in as well. 

Posted

We are all guessing like crazy. The one point that seems to get regurgitated is that the Twins have overstepped their financial boundary. As such a slew of comments and this article point to reductions possible by dropping some combination of players. The date for offering arbitration approaches quickly, which will provide some knowns. Are the salaries of the players mentioned beyond the worth of the players?

Looking over the list, one can easily justify keeping all of the arbitration eligible players. Ryan, Bradley, and Kremer are easy calls. Ober gets forwarded plenty of times for a release but he has never produced less than 1 WAR; he earns his keep. Nance and Sands are easy keepers if they are healthy due to their minimum salaries. Clemens is a lock to be offered a contract. That leaves us with two controversial guys in Larnach and Lewis. It is hard to believe that neither has any value for a potential transaction, yet both are borderline calls due to their spotty production. 

The pst failures to find trading partners for players is a thing in these decisions. One would think that Arizona or San Diego, to name two clubs, would have an interest in a few of the listed players. Where the payroll sits is a pointless effort as shown by the past two days. I would tender all of the players but work on transactions for several. The returns only need to add some balance to the organization, it does not have to be for starting players.

Posted

Perhaps it would have been best to wait until tomorrow for this discussion as we will then know who was or wasn't offered arbitration.

 Don't have a clue whether or not Nance and Sands will be offered arbitration.  Looking at the pitchers on this team, it seems unlikely to me there will be a spot in the opening day bullpen for either.  Do either have options remaining?

Posted

The Twins are spending as if there will be a floor and they want to get ahead of the game.  Seems prudent.   Now can they move around some of the other salaries and add a bit more and end in the $170 to $180 million range and have a competent team?   I think its legitimately an option right now.   Friday will be a big day to see who is tendered.  

Ober, Kremer, Lewis and Larnach are the big names.  In total around $20 million total.  

Posted

Even with his velocity dip, I think Ober has value, especially for $6M, for a team needing a decent, experienced back of the rotation starter. So I think he can be moved for something.

The injury to Larnach sounds rather routine and shouldn't dampen his value, but it sure doesn't enhance it. If he was worth a rental bullpen arm at the deadline last season, I'd bet someone could really use a solid LH DH occasional OF for a decent AA prospect at least. But if not, PLEASE don't do the whole arbitration thing where we think we can trade him later. Just rip the bandaid off and go forward.

If they want to keep Lewis at $5M as a 3 position depth piece who should get about 300-350 AB...unless he suddenly figures something out and demands more playing time...I can live with that. Not sure Royce can. I'd move him and get another bench player. 

But regardless, if the plan is to give him a daily job I am out a this point. If the choice was Royce and his 2 1/2 years of frustration and poor performance at $5M, OR, someone like Nathaniel Lowe...decent glove, decent quad slash line, career OPS + of 115...I'm picking Lowe for roughly the same $, give or take.

If we can't get a big difference making bat this offseason for 1B, at least get a competent one.

Posted

From Google AI:

The $55 million figure reflects the total money under Sonny Gray’s control—not the absolute minimum the Twins will pay if he voluntarily walks away. In MLB contract reporting, a player option is counted as guaranteed money because the team cannot unilaterally decline it; only Gray can. [1, 2]
The math breaks down to $55 million through three components:
  • 2027 Base Salary ($20 million). Fully guaranteed for the first year. [1]
  • 2028 Player Option ($30 million). Because Gray holds the sole right to exercise this option (or opt out for a $5 million buyout), MLB accounting treats the full $30 million as guaranteed to him. [1, 2]
  • 2029 Mutual Option Buyout ($5 million). Mutual options require both sides to agree and are almost never exercised. Therefore, the $5 million buyout attached to the 2029 option is treated as guaranteed money owed to Gray at the end of his two-year stay. [1, 2, 3]
How the Payout Scenarios Work
Depending on what Gray decides after the 2027 season, his actual earnings from Minnesota will follow one of two paths:
Scenario 2027 Payout 2028 Payout 2029 Payout Total Paid
Stays Both Years (Exercises 2028 option, 2029 mutual option declined) $20M $30M $5M (buyout) $55M
Opts Out After 2027 (Declines 2028 option) $20M $5M (buyout) $0 (contract voided) $25M
(Note: In the unlikely event both Gray and the Twins agree to the $27.5 million mutual option for 2029, the deal maxes out at $77.5 million over three years.) [1]
Why Structure It This Way?
  • Team Payroll & Luxury Tax. For Competitive Balance Tax (luxury tax) purposes, the $55 million guarantee is averaged out to a $27.5 million hit per year across 2027 and 2028, even though his actual cash salary is lower in year one. [1]
  • Work Stoppage Protection. With MLB's Collective Bargaining Agreement expiring after the 2026 season, backloading the cash ($20M in 2027 vs. $30M+ in 2028) protects Gray from losing as much salary if games are missed during a potential 2027 lockout or strike. [1]
 

Create an account or sign in to comment

You need to be a member in order to leave a comment

Create an account

Sign up for a new account in our community. It's easy!

Register a new account

Sign in

Already have an account? Sign in here.

Sign In Now
The Twins Daily Caretaker Fund
The Twins Daily Caretaker Fund

You all care about this site. The next step is caring for it. We’re asking you to caretake this site so it can remain the premier Twins community on the internet.

×
×
  • Create New...