I think Mauer will probably be pretty polarizing - as he was while he was playing. The problem, in my opinion, is that there wasn't a Game 6 or single great moment for Mauer like there have been for others. Even Santana had 17 strike out night against Texas, a great duel against Schilling on ESPN etc Mauer's single most memorable play is (arguably) this play where he tags out Gardner at home by leaping at him. https://www.mlb.com/video/mauers-amazing-play/c-4608765 It's amazing. That was in his MVP year. I remember the old ESPN forums were full of condescending Yankee fans telling us that Mauer was going to be in pinstripes b/c we couldn't afford him. But as good as that play was, we still lost that game. I have my Rushmore and he misses the cut but by talent, he might deserve to be on it.