Jump to content
Twins Daily
  • Create Account
  • Twins News & Analysis

    The Twins New Shortstop for 2023?


    Ted Schwerzler

    Going into this offseason, the Minnesota Twins are going to face a serious decision at the shortstop position. Carlos Correa can, and will, opt out of his contract following the World Series. It is then on the organization to decide their next move, and they’ve provided some context as to what we should expect from there.

     

    Image courtesy of Brett Davis-USA TODAY Sports

    Twins Video

    Derek Falvey and Thad Levine made arguably the biggest splash of their tenure leading the Twins when they inked Carlos Correa to a deal last offseason. Ultimately, after pawning Josh Donaldson off on the New York Yankees, Correa fell in their laps. Minnesota had substantial money to spend, and a need that he could fill. This offseason, that same reality remains true, but Correa should have suitors willing to pay him Francisco Lindor money. It’s probably unlikely that the Twins are one of them.

    So, where does that leave a team waiting on Royce Lewis’ eventual return? It’s a big gamble to believe Lewis, coming off a second ACL surgery, will be the same player. However, his debut provided enough excitement to suggest he can hold down the position. Isiah Kiner-Falefa was who this front office targeted initially, before Correa, and that would have been a defense-only option that ultimately filled the void. Now facing a similar scenario, the front office will need to navigate a path forward.

    Despite the position being arguably one of the most important on the diamond, there are not a ton of options this winter. That is unless you want to play in the deep end of the pool. Trea Turner, Dansby Swanson, and Correa are going to be the top tier, but from there it’s quite a drop-off. Minnesota would seem an unlikely landing spot for Chicago White Sox Tim Anderson. He’s not a good defender, and a long-term deal there doesn’t make much sense. They could opt for an Ehire Adrianza reunion, but Jermaine Palacios would probably have been a better option before he was DFA’d and claimed by the Tigers.

    Both Elvis Andrus and Aledmys Diaz check the veteran box with some offensive upside, but it’s hard to envision either being an ideal fit for the Twins. Andrus provided production in just a limited sample, and Diaz hasn’t held down a single position in years. With external options waning and one name still yet to be discussed, things keep coming back to Jose Iglesias.

    The well-traveled veteran is coming off a one-year deal with the Colorado Rockies. He’s never been more than a league-average hitter, outside of the 2020 outlier with the Baltimore Orioles, but he does hit for a solid average. Defensively Iglesias has rated poorly from a Defensive Runs Saved standpoint, but has been roughly even when it comes to outs above average. As a whole, he’s the ideal type of player to operate in a stopgap role.

    There should be little reason Minnesota would need to pay handsomely for Iglesias. He made just $5 million last season in Colorado, and likely could be had for a similar amount in his age-33 season. Iglesias has been a reliably healthy option for years now, and could certainly hold down the fort until Lewis is ready to make his return.

    There’s no reason to suggest that Iglesias would be a big move for Minnesota, and if anything, it’d likely be received somewhat poorly. Coming off Correa though, the only way to lessen the blow is by re-upping on a new deal or swinging big on one of the other top two options. Going the stopgap route at shortstop could allow the Twins more funds to hand out elsewhere, however.

    Ultimately, there are not a ton of options on the free agent market. It doesn’t make much sense for Minnesota to swing a trade for a shortstop, and if they aren’t paying Correa, it’s odd to think they’d spend on someone else. Iglesias is where I’d put the highest odds at this point, especially considering the lack of internal options.

    -----------------------------------------------------------------------------

    See where Jose Iglesias ranks among free-agent shortstops according to Cody's article from yesterday. 

     

    Follow Twins Daily For Minnesota Twins News & Analysis

    Recent Twins Articles

    Recent Twins Videos

    Twins Top Prospects

    Gabriel Gonzalez

    Minnesota Twins - MLB, OF/1B
    Gabby, Wow! You're a big leaguer now! The 22-year-old has been called up while Tristan Gray is on the paternity list. The powerful right-handed hitter plays either corner outfield spots and a lot of first base lately too!

    User Feedback

    Recommended Comments



    Featured Comments

    45 minutes ago, USAFChief said:

    Signing Iglesias to play SS is roughly the equivalent of signing Matt Shoemaker to be in your rotation.

     

    It'll do nothing to help you win, but somebody has to stand out there.

    This is the worst comment in the thread. We never had pitching, we have Royce Lewis. Iglesias is league average, Shoemaker died on the mound for us. 

    10 minutes ago, JimPohlad1 said:

    There is literally no value or point in being in on a top SS options this off-season. Royce Lewis is the answer until further notice, so let’s save the money to use on an Ace like Rondon and snag Iglesias for cheap. 
     

    The only way we convince Correa to resign is if the market collapses and there isn’t enough interest for him, which I highly doubt. 

    Lewis had been hurt for three years.... You willing to bet he's going to stay healthy and not be Buxton?

    Similarly, Rodon was hurt each of the two years before this.... That's some serious risk for a pitcher.

    2 hours ago, JimPohlad1 said:

    This is the worst comment in the thread. We never had pitching, we have Royce Lewis. Iglesias is league average, Shoemaker died on the mound for us. 

    We don't have any version of Royce Lewis until midseason, at which point he's most likely not any kind of answer at SS.

     

    And Iglesias is only "league average" if we're talking the International League.

    The Twins not having a SS ready to at least Stan out there and play the position and then letting  Palacio go doesn't make much sense, but then neither did signing Correa.

    Lewis & Miranda should have been penciled in from the start & that 35M spent on pitching.

    Now Lewis is hurt because they played him out of position in their rush to keep his bat in the  lineup. Why did we trade for Martin if he can't play SS (hit apparently) again?

    Sign a Frontline starter, sign Fulmer and if Iglesias can back up SS & 3B until (hopefully) Lewis come back, then fine.

    Unless Urshela can do the same.

    Frankly they need Kiriloff at 1B and a power hitting OF with speed more than anything. Neither Larnarch & Walner fit that bill. If they can sign that "guy" for the corner OF, doesn't matter who plays SS.

    32 minutes ago, KBJ1 said:

    The Twins not having a SS ready to at least Stan out there and play the position and then letting  Palacio go doesn't make much sense, but then neither did signing Correa.

    Lewis & Miranda should have been penciled in from the start & that 35M spent on pitching.

    Now Lewis is hurt because they played him out of position in their rush to keep his bat in the  lineup. Why did we trade for Martin if he can't play SS (hit apparently) again?

    Sign a Frontline starter, sign Fulmer and if Iglesias can back up SS & 3B until (hopefully) Lewis come back, then fine.

    Unless Urshela can do the same.

    Frankly they need Kiriloff at 1B and a power hitting OF with speed more than anything. Neither Larnarch & Walner fit that bill. If they can sign that "guy" for the corner OF, doesn't matter who plays SS.

    Lewis played center in the AFL. He wasn't hurt from playing center. 

    I'm unenthusiastic about Iglesias. he's got zero power and I'm of the opinion that he's not exactly an elite defender at this stage in his career. I'd probably go for Elvis Andrus if you just wanted a bridge option to Royce Lewis or Brooks Lee.

    but I would definitely prefer they sign Correa to the 7 year deal (even 8?) we'd need to get it done. he's a terrific player, and outstanding defensive player whose skills are likely to age well at the position. (Correa makes the exceptional plays more through his powerful arm, tremendous wingspan, and intelligent positioning over footspeed and quickness, IMHO) he hits for a good average, he hits for good power as a SS, and he takes walks. he's a great teammate and a really smart player. I watched him on the broadcast the other night talking SS play with Jimmy Rollins and I'm on Team Correa.

    I love Royce Lewis, but unless you're going to get an elite starter (and the market is a bit dicey for that), I would be thrilled to lock down an all-star SS for the rest of the decade. I'm completely baffled that people seem to think Correa wasn't good this season, because to me he passes every single test.

    On 10/13/2022 at 9:57 AM, High heat said:

    Wonder what Alberto’s Mondesi  or Nicky Lopez would cost from the Royals?

    Dont want to pay Correa that 35 million for the next 7 8 + years. 

    Probably $6mil for Modesi as the talking head consensus seems to be that he will be non-tendered, especially with a new GM coming in.

    He seems a better option than Iglesias. Might be a good change of scenery candidate.

    Mondesi can't stay healthy (hello Mr. Buxton) but if I could sign him for $6 million I would in a heartbeat.  I just LOVE his talent and potential.  I'd rather gamble on youth and potential than throw money at old has-beens like Elvis Andrus or Jose Iglesias.  The Twins could sign a non-tendered Mondesi and STILL see Royce Lewis get healthy and become the SS of the future.  Having game breaking speed like Buxton, Lewis and Mondesi on our team could prove very interesting.  We'd need a new manager though.  Rocco consistently attempts fewer SB's than any team in the league.  His initial year, record setting HR team broke him.  He has no desire or ability to "create" runs.

    Nicky Lopez would require a trade, but that kid can pick it.  As long as the Royals have Bobby Witt Jr. there's not much need for Mondesi and Lopez unless K.C. plays Lopez at 2B.  

    My "preference" would be to resign Correa.  But if cost is "prohibitive" I wouldn't mind looking at Mondesi or Lopez.  I'd still like to have serious discussions with Miami for young SP'ing by dangling Larnach or Wallner or even Kirilloff or Kepler.  We have FOUR (4) !!  LH hitting OF'ers and at most can play 1 or two at a time.  I'd like to follow the Cleveland model and stockpile power arms.  I Rec'd a LOT of comments from a lot of different viewpoints because I believe there is not a simple answer, nor an unquestioned "correct" answer to this question.  We have Lewis and Brooks Lee who could very well be major league SS material.  We also have Miller who may be as well.  None of them can give the Twins an entire season at SS NEXT YEAR.  Something needs to give.  




    Create an account or sign in to comment

    You need to be a member in order to leave a comment

    Create an account

    Sign up for a new account in our community. It's easy!

    Register a new account

    Sign in

    Already have an account? Sign in here.

    Sign In Now

×
×
  • Create New...