Jump to content
Twins Daily
  • Create Account

Shaitan

Old-Timey Member
 View Profile  See their activity

  • Posts

    2,908

  • Joined

  • Last visited

 Content Type 

Profiles

News

Minnesota Twins Videos

2026 Minnesota Twins Top Prospects Ranking

2022 Minnesota Twins Draft Picks

Minnesota Twins Free Agent & Trade Rumors, Notes, & Tidbits

Guides & Resources

2023 Minnesota Twins Draft Picks

The Minnesota Twins Players Project

2024 Minnesota Twins Draft Picks

2025 Minnesota Twins Draft Pick Tracker

2026 Minnesota Twins Draft Tracker: Picks & Bonuses

Forums

Blogs

Events

Store

Downloads

Gallery

Everything posted by Shaitan

  1. Shaitan
    I'd take any of them...on another 1-year deal.
  2. Shaitan
    Alternate take: Buxton is more valuable at DH than on the IL. My point here isn't to be contrarian. It's too say there are so, so very many variables to measure if one team is more "injury prone" than another. The data is interesting, for sure. But it doesn't tell a story. Is Paddack's (or even Maeda's) injury the Twins' fault? Is the team any worse off without Dobnak or Garlick? Do some players just have different genes that are more likely for certain injuries? Not of this is revealed in this data. It shows a comparison to other teams. It's absolutely interesting and I'm sure the FO is aware of it and trying to reduce numbers in future years. But it I find it hard to believe that it reveals the Twins are have poor conditioning or anything along those lines. (And how it the data collected? Because Maeda may be "on the IL" for 162 games, but he's only missing 35 he'd actually play in.)
  3. Shaitan

    Where's Wallner?

    Shaitan commented on Doc Munson's blog entry in Fantasy GM

    Teams rarely add prospects to the 40-roster for a Sept callup. If they think he'd be a difference maker in a pennant race I could see making an exception. And while I wish him success, I personally don't see him as that type of prospect.
  4. Shaitan
    It's sad on the human side of the game. But if the Twins actually pull it off this year, I believe he stills gets a ring. Is he also the union rep since the Rogers trade, or did I make that up?
  5. Shaitan
    While I'm well aware that a strong minor league system correlates with a strong major league team, I could care less how the minors "rank" if the major league team is winning. Prospect ratings are pure speculation. The results that matter at the the MLB level. But I also don't totally disagree with you. Of course I want the Twins to continually improve overall, majors and minors. But I don't think a side-by-side 2015-to-2022 list is a valid way to measure anything. What about the age of the roster in 2022 compared to 2016? What about long-term commitments and budget flexibility? What about the fact that there is a global pandemic that halted a year of development for most prospects? There are million variables that aren't addressed in this comparison.
  6. Shaitan
    This completely ignores that running a front office requires adjustment and responding to circumstances and only looks at rosters on paper. It ignores contract commitments, roster age, and other significant variables that affect how you build a system. Of course a winning team will respond (and draft) differently than a losing team.
  7. Shaitan
    Has anybody seen a recent update on Maeda?
  8. Shaitan
    Unless your name is Joe Smith. Why do they get 2 days to at Mahle to the roster? (Edit: Okay, otto answered this already.)
  9. Shaitan
    Few players, especially pitchers, perform at a high level for 5-6 years. There's a reason (besides Pohland cheapness) that teams are reluctant to commit to long-term deals. Considering Mahle just came off the IL with a shoulder ailment, I'd like to get through this season before even considering any kind of extension. If all works out, maybe try to buy out his final year of arbitration with a 2-3 year extension.
  10. Shaitan
    Remember when people on this board were saying the Twins should trade from their deep 6-man rotation in April? Let's not worry about next year's starting 5 yet...
  11. Shaitan
    Teams trade for players and let 'em go at the end of the year all the time. This trade confirms nothing about the future.
  12. Shaitan
    Was Hamilton on the 40? If so, good trade. If not, still a fine depth trade.
  13. Shaitan
    Better give him the 8th and not the 9th, then. **ducks** Sorry, but somebody had to make a "cheap Pohlands" comment.
  14. Shaitan
    Either Povich is very slow to develop, or there is a typo in his draft year.
  15. Shaitan
    Yes it's been a rough month. But if you think this is "rock bottom" then you weren't paying attention 5 of the last 10 years. They're in first place.
  16. Shaitan
    Ad three top 100 prospects and LAA might not hang up on you. After that: 1) Does Ohtani have a no trade clause? 2) Why would he promise to sign a new contract after the trade? 3) Why would he only sign for 3-5 years when he'd get more on the open market. 4) Let's not assume that all Japanese players want to play with each other. I understand the cultural issues, but it's inaccurate to assume that people will be bffs (or even friends) because they are from the same country.
  17. Shaitan
    An interesting stat/list, but it's only applicable to sellers, not buyers. A list of trade value for prospects would be far more relevant at the trade deadline. The only player on here who still has that title is Ryan, and the Twins are not trading a reliable MLB-ready arm at this point. Also, I'm amazed Arraez isn't even arbitration eligible yet. He seems like such a savvy vet at this point.
  18. Shaitan
    Self-respect = throwing things at players!?
  19. Shaitan
    Three for me (using the current roster): Buxton's health at postseason Gray's health at postseason Maeda's health at postseason
  20. Shaitan
    And this site has 30 discussions about trading Correa right now too (and probably a few about the Gray trade too). Some people just love to play front office simulator.
  21. Shaitan
    1991 was 31 years ago. A lot of things have changed.
  22. Shaitan
    But "some guy reading a boxscore on his computer" says so.
  23. Shaitan
    I'm in for almost any rental who will provide stable, average+ innings. Cheap (in trade capital) and no commitment, essentially. Cut losses if it doesn't work out.
  24. Shaitan
    I get your take and I love the effort this had to have taken. But I also think that there's a reason he's in AA on a losing ballclub. If he's ready to pitch leverage situations in MLB, why hasn't Miami rostered him? And what benefit do they gain in trading him?
  25. Shaitan
    Austin is a curious case. While I know there are always exceptions to any rule, I'd say (without watching him play) that he's yet another example of why you don't rush prospects as they acclimate to professional baseball. Still in awe the Happ trade happened.
×
×
  • Create New...