That's fine too, but I don't think we should ever just give a prospect a job. Development takes time and based on Hicks and Buxton as examples where there wasn't competition it seems like most players need that extra push. Even Morneau had to display Dougie.
I don't get the extension talk throughout this whole thread. Has a single rental player signed an extension IN SEASON in recent years? It happens with trades, but those are almost always in Nov-Jan.
Rentals are different though. Think of what the Twins got for Morneau. I'm hopeful that a package more comparable to last year's Dozier trade could get it done. But I ain't no GM.
I think he's in toast but why not? It's a minor league deal. Even if they call him up, it's hard to imagine a worse performance out of the bottom-ranking bullpen arm at this point.
Cave has been awful but...you need a pure OF for the 4th OF spot. Maybe Wade (who is already on the 40 man). But if Buxton heals fast, I'd keep Cave on the MLB roster through this injury, knowing he might not return.
I'm definitely not a pitching coach, but to me it seems like his control is either on or off. When he was in the bullpen in April it was off and there weren't results. If he's throwing 60-70% strikes he gets results. Though that's probably the case for any pitcher, to a point.
This may be selective memory, but I feel like he was never a top prospect. Instead, he was a "Twins top prospect" during a dry spell in the farm system. In other words, he rated highly but against lesser competition than, say, the present.
I get it but...he couldn't even get an out in a blowout. They'd have been better off just keeping Eades on the roster and waiting it out (in retrospect).
I don't see SD trading controllable talent after their free agent investments. Pending free agents, sure. But they're also playing for next year. But who knows. The trade game is unpredictable.