I defended the Rogers for Paddack trade from a value stand point.
I now regret that stance, as others mentioned it weakened an already weak bullpen to bolster and already strong rotation with an injury risk. At the time with the unknowns, trading for another starter made sense, but not your best reliever, even on a one year deal.
The thing with reliever fungibility is you still need to invest in it. You can’t make relievers out of nothing and if you don’t continue to invest, you reap what you sew.