Tony O's OPS+ for his first eight full years (including his first knee injury) was 141. He lost almost all of the next year, then played 3 full seasons with an OPS+ of just over 100, playing on one leg. Then he played a half-year. Give the Twins, say, 5 more years of Tony with a normal decline and I think those early '70s teams go farther. Liriano's a good choice, but I don't think his arm injury could be chalked up to bad luck. More like inevitability. I would put Mauer's concussion second and Morneau's third, but both were pretty devastating to a team with some chances. Kirby's eye was tragic, but it wouldn't have mattered to the team's standings- that whole era was pretty tragic. I just wanted Kirby to have a shot at 3000 hits.