So my general conclusion, regarding this season:
This team was built on the premise that upgrading the rotation was the key to success. But then they also assumed Buxton, Correa, Polanco, and Kepler would carry the team offensively.
First part, more or less successful. Second part, all four of those players have failed to meet even modest expectations. That’s actually pretty remarkable, that none of them has clicked.
But it does mean the ceiling for this team, this year, is winning the ALC. Barring a complete revival of those four players, it’ll be wait ‘til next year.